• Ohio
  • Pickerington
  • The Old Bag Of Nails

The Old Bag Of Nails

(614) 283-4392
  • 797 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • $$$$$
(614) 283-4392
  • Menu
  • Our Desserts
    • Famous House-Made Carrot Cake $2.99

      Treat yourself to the best carrot cake you will ever eat. House-made and sliced to order

    • Bread Pudding $3.99

      Steve says, it's the best he's ever had and that's good enough for us

    • Fried Snickers $4.99

      Serves 2

    • Pecan Ball $3.99

  • Starters
    • Mussels and Shrimp $9.99

      Over a pound of mussels with jumbo shrimp, steamed in white wine, butter, spices and served with garlic bread

    • Chicken Nachos $8.99

      Crisp tortilla chips smothered with melted cheese, scallions, jalapenos, black beans, salsa, sour cream and topped with grilled chicken

    • Loaded Skins $7.99

      Potato skins loaded with chopped bacon, melted cheddar cheese, scallions and served with sour cream. You say potato, i say potato too

    • Chicken Wings $8.99

      One pound of tender wings & drums, tossed in your choice of buffalo, garlic parmesan, garlic sesame, sweet baby ray's BBQ, or kamikaze sauce

    • Boneless Chicken Wings $8.99

      Tender white meat chicken served breaded or grilled, tossed in your choice of buffalo, garlic parmesan, garlic sesame, sweet baby ray's BBQ, or kamikaze sauce

    • Onion Ring Basket $6.99

      Hand-cut and battered, crispy rings served with a horseradish dipping sauce

    • Beer Battered Pickles $6.99

      Dill spears hand-battered, deep-fried and served with a ranch dipping sauce

    • Black Bean Dip $7.99

      Home cooked black beans and fresh salsa mixed together then topped with shredded cheese and served with crispy flour tortilla chips

    • Hand Battered Mushrooms $7.99

      Fresh button mushrooms battered, deep-fried and served with a horseradish dipping sauce

    • Jumbo Soft Pretzels $5.99

      Buttered, salted then baked fresh. served with a jalapeno cheese dipping sauce

  • House Salads
    Salad dressings: house sweet & sour, ranch, blue cheese, hot bacon vinaigrette, italian, balsamic vinaigrette, french, honey mustard, 1000 island. Add blackened or grilled items to any salad: salmon or tuna $7.99, shrimp or scallops $6.99, chicken $ 3.99
    • Pub House Salad $3.99

      Fresh greens with tomato, bacon, red onion, blue cheese and croutons

    • Caesar Salad $3.99

      Chopped romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan cheese, caesar dressing and croutons

    • Spinach Salad $3.99

      Fresh spinach, mushrooms, egg, red onion, hot bacon vinaigrette and croutons

    • The Pride of the Pub Spinach Salad $10.99

      Fresh spinach topped with grilled marinated portobello mushrooms, chunky blue cheese, crispy onion straws, blackened scallops or shrimp and finished with a hot bacon vinaigrette

    • The Wedge Salad $6.99

      An iceberg wedge with blue cheese dressing, bacon, tomato, egg, red onion and croutons

    • Chicken Cobb Salad $9.99

      A large bed of lettuce topped with charbroiled chicken, tomato, diced eggs, feta cheese, bacon and marinated onions

    • Greek Salad $7.99

      Fresh greens tossed and topped with marinated onions, tomatoes, feta cheese, kalamata olives and banana peppers. Served with greek dressing on the side

  • House Soups
    • House-Made New England Clam Chowder $4.49

    • French Onion Soup $4.49

    • Tomato Basil Soup $4.49

    • Soup of the Day $4.49

  • Our Burgers
    All burgers are cooked to order and served with your choice of side. Sub potato cakes, tater tots or onion rings for $0.99, add a bowl of soup or salad for $1.99
    • Double Cheeseburger $7.99

      Our signature double cheeseburger topped with american cheese, pickles and red onion. Served with a side of mayo mustard mix

    • Gaylord's Favorite Burger $8.99

      Smothered in BBQ. Sauce and topped with crisp bacon and cheddar cheese

    • Pauly Burger $8.99

      Topped with grilled salami, provolone, white american cheese, banana peppers, italian dressing, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo on a hoagie bun

    • Rustic Burger $8.99

      Covered with melted blue cheese, smoked bacon and crisp onion straws

    • Your Way Burger $8.99

      Have it any way you want white american, swiss, cheddar, pepper jack, blue cheese, sautéed onions, mushrooms, bacon, or jalapenos peppers

    • Gaylord's Mini Cheeseburgers $7.99

      Served with white american cheese, mustard, red onion and pickle

    • Mini Hot Cheeseburgers $7.99

      Pepper jack cheese, jalapenos and mushrooms

  • Our Sandwiches
    All sandwiches are served with your choice of side. Sub potato cakes, tater tots or onion rings for $0.99, add a bowl of soup or salad for $1.99
    • Philly Cheese Steak $8.99

      Sauteed onions, mushrooms and peppers topped with melted white american cheese

    • Pub Famous Reuben $8.99

      Corned beef on marble rye with sauerkraut, 1000 island and melted swiss cheese

    • Your Way Chicken Sandwich $8.99

      An 8 oz. chicken breast prepared your way. BBQ, buffalo, grilled, blackened or battered and fried. I like mine fried with buffalo sauce, don't you

    • French Dip $8.99

      Tender sirloin sliced and topped with sautéed onions and melted swiss cheese on a hoagie served with hot au jus

    • Turkey Reuben $8.99

      Sliced smoked turkey on marble rye with 1000 island dressing, melted swiss cheese and coleslaw

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $8.99

      Crispy buffalo chicken tenders wrapped with shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion, and blue cheese dressing in a soft flour tortilla

    • Chicken Caesar Wrap $8.99

      Grilled chicken breast, parmesan cheese, lettuce, and caesar dressing all wrapped up in a flour tortilla

    • Chicken Tenders Basket $8.99

      Fried chicken tenders served with crisp onion rings and honey mustard

    • Grilled Portobello Mushroom Sandwich $8.99

      Marinated grilled portobello mushroom topped with pepper jack cheese, provolone cheese, sun dried tomato mayonnaise on a ciabatta

    • New England Reuben $8.99

      Our famous golden fried fish topped with coleslaw, melted swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing between two slices of crisp marble rye

    • OBON Club Sandwich $8.99

      Sliced ham, smoked turkey, bacon, swiss, cheddar, white american cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo on two slices of wheat toast

    • Spicy Chicken Quesadilla $7.99

      A crisp flour tortilla filled with grilled chicken, salsa, monterey jack and cheddar cheese

  • House Specialties
    Add a bowl of soup or salad to any entree for $1.99
    • 12 oz. New York Strip $17.99

      Once you try this new york strip, you'll never order a filet again, it's that good! simple and to the point, char-grilled steak topped with burnt butter, served with hand-battered onion rings and choice of soup or salad

    • Gaylord's Fish Dinner $12.99

      Our famous cold water cod broiled or blackened, topped with garlic butter and served with wild rice and a side of your choice

    • Atlantic Salmon $14.99

      Atlantic salmon char-grilled or blackened. served with wild rice, a choice of side and dill cream sauce

    • Clam Basket $11.99

      Clams, hand-battered and fried to golden brown. served with coleslaw and steak fries

    • Fish Tacos $8.99

      Thin slices of our hand-battered fish, topped with spicy shredded lettuce slaw and salsa. served with tortilla chips and sour cream

    • Fish Sandwich $8.99

      Our famous cold water cod, broiled, blackened or hand battered and fried; served on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato and onion, and choice of side

    • The Hob Nob $8.99

      Our famous cold water cod, hand-battered and fried. topped with american cheese and served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and onion, and choice of side

    • Blackened Tuna Steak $10.99

      A blackened tuna steak topped with sun dried tomato mayonnaise, onion straws, lettuce and tomato. Served on ciabatta, with a side of your choice

    • Shrimp Po' Boy $8.99

      Crispy fried shrimp, tossed with shredded lettuce, tomato, onion and cajun mayo. Stuffed in a fresh-baked hoagie, and served with a side of your choice

    • Crab Cake Sandwich $9.99

      Homemade crab cake, pan seared and topped with our cajun mayonnaise. Served on ciabatta with lettuce, tomato and onion, and a side of your choice

    • Fisherman's Platter $14.99

      A hearty combination of our famous fish, along with our handbattered scallops & shrimp, served with coleslaw and steak fries

    • Shrimp & Chips $13.99

      Jumbo shrimp, hand- battered and fried, served with coleslaw and steak fries

    • Scallops & Chips $14.99

      Plump scallops, hand-battered and fried, served with coleslaw and steak fries

    • Our Famous British Style Fish & Chips $12.99

  • Sides
    • French Fries

    • Steak Fries

    • Potato Chips

    • Coleslaw

    • Veggie Kabobs

    • Veggie of the Day

    • Applesauce

    • Cup of Soup

    • Fried Corn

    • Fruit

    • Rice

  • Kids Menu
    All kids meals include choice of juice, milk or coca cola products
    • Kids Fish & Chips $4.79

    • Kids Shrimp & Chips $4.79

    • Kids Caesar Salad $4.79

      With two fried chicken tenders

    • Kids Mac & Cheese $4.79

    • Kids Monster Grilled Cheese Sandwich $4.79

    • Kids Hamburger or Cheeseburger $4.79

      With lettuce, tomato & onion and choice of side

    • Kids Chicken Tenders $4.79

      With BBQ sauce or ranch dressing and choice of side

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.