Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Bay Shore
  • AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop

What is Grubhub

Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.

Next

Why use Grubhub

Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.

Previous
Start your order

AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop

(631) 647-9292

We make ordering easy. Learn more

Google map
  • 182 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Restaurant website
  • No cuisines specified

  • Grubhub.com
  • AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop

  • (631) 647-9292

    We make ordering easy.

  • Menu
  • Grilled Cheese
    • Traditional Grilled Cheese $8.50

      American cheese melted between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Southern Pork Grilled Cheese $12.50

      Pulled pork smothered in BBQ sauce with melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Pairs well with our homemade coleslaw. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Southern Chicken Grilled Cheese $12.50

      Pulled chicken smothered in BBQ sauce with melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Pairs well with our homemade coleslaw. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese $12.00

      Our crispy chicken smothered in BBQ or Buffalo sauce with melted mozzarella, American, or pepper jack cheese between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • BBQ Style Chicken Grilled Cheese $12.00

      Our crispy chicken smothered in BBQ or Buffalo sauce with melted mozzarella, American, or pepper jack cheese between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Veggie Melt $11.50

      Sauteed broccoli, onions, red and green peppers all between 2 slices of whole wheat or sourdough with melted pepper jack. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • Mac N' Cheese Melt $12.00

      For the real cheese lovers. This grilled cheese features our homemade mac with extra cheddar melted on top, all between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Philly Melt $12.50

      Thinly sliced steak sauteed with peppers and onions, topped with melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • Apple Bacon Grilled Cheese $12.00

      Sliced apples, bacon and melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Hawaiian Grilled Cheese $12.00

      Grilled honey maple ham and grilled pineapple with melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Crispy Jalapeno Grilled Cheese $11.25

      Our homemade potato chips, sliced jalapenos and pepper jack melted between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • The Big T Grilled Cheese $8.50

      Sliced honey maple turkey with melted cheddar cheese between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • Lobster Seafood Grilled Cheese $14.00

      A blend of lobster, crab and seafood with melted cheddar between 2 slices of sourdough. Served with a pickle and our homemade potato chips.

    • Lobster Seafood Grilled Cheese $9.95

      A blend of lobster, crab, and seafood with melted cheddar between two slices of sourdough.

    • The Chicken Bacon Bomber $12.50

      Crispy chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon, and AJ's chip dip, sourdough bread.

    • Truffle grilled cheese $7.95

      Perhaps our most "gourmet/sophisticated" grilled cheese yet!! This grilled cheese features Muenster cheese, with white truffle oil on sourdough.

    • AJ's burger melt $12.75

      Our seasoned 5oz. burger patty with AJ's sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, red onion and American cheese!! all on sourdough bread PLEASE NOTE: Let., Tom, onion all melted between the cheese unless requested on the SIDE!

    • Truffle grilled cheese $13.50

      Perhaps our most "gourmet/sophisticated" grilled cheese yet!! This grilled cheese features Muenster cheese, with white truffle oil on sourdough.

    • The Summer Delight $8.75

      This grilled cheese is a perfect summer special with an Asian cuisine twist on it. Featuring grilled chicken tossed in our house-made teriyaki sauce and topped with our own Asian slaw made from scratch; all of this between two slices of sourdough bread with melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese!!

    • Grilled Chicken Caprese $12.00

      Straight out of Capri Italy; this grilled cheese features diced tomatoes, diced basil and diced red onion all tossed in oil & salt served on top of grilled chicken and melted between mozzarella cheese between two slices of sourdough bread.

    • The Gameday $7.95

      Just in time for football season: A loaded grilled cheese! This sandwich Features our homemade potato chips topped with diced tomato, red onion, and jalapeno drizzled with cheese sauce with melted pepper jack cheese between two slices of sourdough bread.

    • The Smoke Out $13.25

      Back by popular demand for a limited time only!! Smoked Gouda cheese, Pulled BBQ pork, fried pickles and our homemade coleslaw all piled in between two slices of sourdough bread. Receive 20% off a beer or milkshake with the purchase this one sandwich!!

    • Half sandwich $5.00

      Try a half grilled cheese "Traditional" ONLY OR add bacon or tomatoes and change the cheese or bread!!!! With a side salad or soup...call for soups of the day

    • The Gobbler $11.75

      This is our November special every year!!! Featuring turkey, our very own cranberry sauce, and stuffing!! All on sourdough bread with melted Muenster cheese

    • The Roast Beast $12.50

      Just in time for the holidays this December special features slow cooked beef, homemade crispy onion straws, horseradish spread and Muenster cheese all on sourdough bread.

    • The New Years Resolution $9.50

      Our very own BLT sandwich!! Lettuce, Tomato, bacon and cheddar cheese melted between two slices of sourdough bread. On the lighter side for those looking to be healthy at the beginning of the new year!!

    • Donut go bacon my heart $5.60

      A GLAZED DONUT GRILLED CHEESE! this grilled cheese is a first for us, a glazed donut from our neighbor The Rolling Pin Bakery, cheddar cheese, and candied bacon. Add sweet tots or sweet fries as a side for an added treat.

    • The O'Malley Melt $11.00

      Just in time for St patty's day this one is a tradition for us!! This grilled cheese is on rye bread with Swiss cheese, option of sauerkraut or cabbage, and our very own corned beef simmered in some Guiness served with a side of spicy golden mustard.

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip Grilled Cheese $10.50

      Homemade spinach and artichoke dip between two slices of sourdough bread with melted mozzarella cheese.

    • The Fiesta Melt $11.00

      Seasoned ground beef mixed with diced tomatoes, onions and mild jalapenos (not spicy) with shredded Monetery jack cheese all on sourdough bread served with a side of sour cream for dipping.

    • The Habanero Hottie $9.50

      Sauteed steak, pickled jalapenos, onion rings, AJ sauce all melted between two slices of sourdough bread with SPICY Habanaro cheese

    • AJs Kickin Chicken Salad $8.75

      Our very own chicken salad with a twist! On whole wheat toast with lettuce and Muenster cheese. The chicken salad features chicken, jalapeño,red onion, candied walnuts, dried cranberries and bacon bits!

    • The Cuban $10.50

      Our version of the classic "Cuban sandwich", Sourdough bread with grilled ham, pulled pork, pickles, and golden mustard all melted with Swiss cheese.

    • The Mac Attack $10.00

      Our famous "Mac Melt" has found its better half! This monster grilled cheese features sourdough bread, Mozzarella cheese, and our mac n cheese breaded and deep fried!

    • The Zesty Bean Burger $12.00

      A Bean patty, sauteed mushrooms, fresh jalapenos, and A red pepper aoili sauce all on whole wheat bread with melted pepper jack cheese.

    • Grilled cheese sampler -4 selections $10.00

      Cant decide which of our most popular grilled cheese you want? Or want a bit of multiple types to share with friends? Don't worry it is now all possible with this sampler platter of mini grilled cheese selections of your choice!

    • Grilled cheese sampler- 6 selections $15.00

      Cant decide which of our most popular grilled cheese you want? Or want a bit of multiple types to share with friends? Don't worry it is now all possible with this sampler platter of mini grilled cheese selections of your choice!

    • Oh Kale Yeah $9.50

      consists of a homemade kale slaw; featuring kale, red onion, apples, and a honey mustard based sauce with grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese.

    • South of the Border $10.00

      Sourdough bread, crispy onion pedals, coleslaw and pulled pork sauteed in lime juice all melted between cheddar cheese.

    • Pretzel bun grilled cheese $8.50

      A fresh pretzel bun stuffed with Swiss cheese, thick cut bacon, and a spicy brown mustard spread then grilled to perfection!

    • The Mistletoe $9.50

      Sourdough bread, melted Asiago cheese, baby Arugula, and Prosciutto!

  • Mac N' Cheese
    • Small mac n' cheese $7.50

    • Large mac n' cheese $9.50

    • Western Mac n Cheese

      Our famous homemade mac n cheese topped with our crispy bbq chicken, diced jalapenos and a drizzle of ranch dressing

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip Mac n Cheese - Small $5.95

      Our very own spinach and artichoke dip cheese sauce sauteed with cavatappi pasta. Pairs perfectly with some grilled chicken at an additional charge

    • Spinach and Artichoke Mac n Cheese-Large $8.95

      Our very own spinach and artichoke dip cheese sauce sauteed with cavatappi pasta. Pairs perfectly with some grilled chicken at an additional charge

  • Quesadillas
    Check out our new delicious quesadilla menu!
    • The healthy grilled chicken wrap $10.00

      Grilled chicken, Sauteed peppers & Onions, diced tomato, lite honey mustard sauce all on choice of Spinach Herb wrap or White wrap. This wrap comes with grilled Broccoli and has an option for sweet potato fries as an upcharge!

    • Cheese Quesadilla $9.25

      Classic cheese quesadilla!

    • Chicken Bacon Bomber Quesadilla $13.25

      Crispy chicken,bacon all coated with our homemade chipotle ranch sauce!

    • Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese $12.50

      Crispy chicken smothered in buffalo sauce!

    • BBQ Chicken Quesadilla $12.50

      Crispy BBQ chicken smothered in BBQ sauce! Add crispy bacon for an extra flavor!

    • Pulled Pork Quesadilla $13.75

      Pulled pork with BBQ sauce!

    • Mac N Cheese Quesadilla with Bacon $13.25

      Mac N Cheese stuffed into a quesadilla with crispy bacon!

    • Veggie Quesadilla $12.40

      Sauteed peppers, onions, and broccoli tossed in balsamic vinegar!

    • Build Your Own Quesadilla $9.25

      Starting off with a plain cheese quesadilla, get creative and build your own!

    • Philly quesadilla $13.75

      Sauteed steak, peppers, and onions!

    • Lobster quesadilla $15.00

  • Sides
    • A.J.'s Homemade Potato Chips $4.50

      With dipping sauce.

    • Tater Tots $6.00

      With homemade dipping sauce.

    • French Fries $6.00

    • Sweet Potato Tots $7.00

      With homemade dipping sauce.

    • Dill Pickle $2.00

    • Sweet Potato Fries $6.50

    • Corn Dog Nuggets $7.00

    • Fresh Coleslaw $5.00

    • Fried pickles $7.00

    • Chips on a stick $3.50

      A whole potato cut into a spiral on a wooden skewer then deep fried and salted. We offer a wide variety of additional toppings to really get creative with it!

    • Mozzarella sticks $7.00

      Italian style breaded mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara dipping sauce. 5 sticks per order

    • Fried cheddar cheese curds $4.95

    • Soft Pretzel bite w/cheese sauce $7.00

      Warm soft pretzel bites with a side of our homemade cheese sauce for dipping!

    • Fried Mac n Cheese bites $8.00

      Homemade mac n cheese bites, 4 large mac bites per order!

  • Alcoholic Beverages (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    Cheers!
    • Bud Light Bottle $3.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Sam Adams Winter Lager $4.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Brooklyn Winter Lager Bottle $4.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Athletic Brewing Non Alcoholic IPA $3.00

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Athletic Brewing Non Alcoholic Ale $3.00

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Bud Light Seltzer Mango $3.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Bud Light Seltzer Black Cherry $3.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Blue Point Pin Stripe Pilsner $4.00

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Dubco IPA $4.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Dubco Mellow Mood Ale $4.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Dubco Dublight $4.00

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Montauk Session $3.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Montauk Summer $3.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Blue Point The IPA $4.00

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Brooklyn Lager Pint (on Tap) $5.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Blue Point the Ipa Pint (on Tap) $5.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Spider Bite Straight C's Ipa Pint (on Tap) $5.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Blue Point Rasta Fa Rye Ale Pint (on Tap) $5.50

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • Beverages
    • Bottled Soda $4.50

    • Bottled Iced Tea $4.50

    • Bottled Water $3.00

    • Fountain soda - 16oz $5.25

    • Fountain soda - 24 oz $6.50

    • Milkshake- 24 oz $9.50

  • Soups
    • Tomato Bisque

      Homemade tomato bisque soup!

    • Grilled Cheese Sticks $7.95

    • Broccoli and Cheddar Soup

    • Manhattan Clam Chowder

    • Shrimp Corn Chowder

    • French Onion Soup

    • Lobster bisque

    • Chicken noodle soup

      Fresh homemade chicken noodle soup with nothing but white meat.

    • Buffalo chicken soup

    • New England Clam Chowder

    • Tomato and vegetable soup

    • Crab Corn chowder

    • Pumpkin bisque

    • Chipotle sweet potato

      Vegan, vegetarian, dairy free, gluten free

    • Ajs Irish soup

      Using our broth from our corned beef we add split peas, carrots, potatoes and a little bit of corned beef!

  • Dessert
    • Original Milkshake $9.50

      Classic Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry milkshake!

    • Oreo Churro $5.25

    • Original Churro $4.50

    • Baked S'mores dessert $6.50

      This dessert is a graham cracker pouch stuffed with chocolate and marshmallow and then baked! It comes with 2 per order.

    • Peanut butter cake $7.00

      An individual sized round chocolate cakes filled with peanut Butter and topped with chocolate!

    • Brioche Ice Cream Sandwich $5.00

      Warm pressed brioche bun filled with your choice of vanilla, strawberry or chocolate ice cream, topped with strawberry, chocolate or caramel syrup.

    • Upside Down Oreo Cheesecake $4.50

    • Upside Down Original Cheesecake $4.75

    • Cookie dough milkshake $11.00

    • Rainbow cookie milkshake $11.00

    • Birthday Cake milkshake $11.00

    • Oreo churro milkshake $11.00

    • Oreo milkshake $10.00

    • Cotton Candy Shake $11.50

    • The chocolate dipped banana milkshake $10.50

      Vanilla milkshake blended with chocolate syrup and a banana!

  • Salads
    • A.J.'s Grilled Cheese Salad $10.50

      Chopped romaine tossed with shredded cheddar, red onion, tomatoes and shaved carrots topped off with our very own grilled cheese crouton bites.

    • Walnut and Cranberry Salad $11.00

      Mixed greens, caramelized walnuts, feta cheese and dried cranberries served with raspberry vinaigrette.

    • Caesar Salad $10.50

      Romaine lettuce, shredded Parmesan cheese and crispy croutons with a creamy Caesar dressing.

    • Chicken Cobb Salad $11.50

      Romaine lettuce, crispy chicken, bacon, onions and sliced hard boiled eggs served with our famous AJ's dipping sauce as a dressing

    • Crispy Buffalo Chicken Salad $12.00

      Romaine lettuce, choice of grilled or crispy buffalo style chicken, shredded carrots, blue cheese crumbles and sliced red onion served with a ranch dressing.

    • Grilled chicken & Pineapple Salad $11.00

      Mixed greens, grilled chicken, and grilled pineapples served with a ranch dressing.

    • Build your own salad $6.00

      This option puts the customer at the steering wheel!! Choose your greens (mixed greens or romaine lettuce) then choose your toppings, proteins if desired, and then your dressing!!!

  • Kids Menu
    • Kids Grilled Cheese $7.50

      White bread with melted American cheese.

    • Small Mac N' Cheese $7.50

    • Kids Crispy Chicken Tenders and Fries $11.00

    • Kids Grilled Cheese Sticks $8.50

      Our traditional grilled cheese cut into kid size strips.

    • Mozzarella sticks $7.00

      Italian style breaded mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara dipping sauce. 5 sticks per order

  • Special of the month
    We like to keep our menu fun and always interesting for those who like to try new combinations!!!
    • Western Mac n Cheese

      Our famous homemade mac n cheese topped with our crispy bbq chicken, diced jalapenos and a drizzle of ranch dressing

    • The O'Malley Melt $11.00

      Just in time for St patty's day this one is a tradition for us!! This grilled cheese is on rye bread with Swiss cheese, option of sauerkraut or cabbage, and our very own corned beef simmered in some Guiness served with a side of spicy golden mustard.

    • The Fiesta Melt $11.00

      Seasoned ground beef mixed with diced tomatoes, onions and mild jalapenos (not spicy) with shredded Monetery jack cheese all on sourdough bread served with a side of sour cream for dipping.

    • The Summer Delight $8.75

      This grilled cheese is a perfect summer special with an Asian cuisine twist on it. Featuring grilled chicken tossed in our house-made teriyaki sauce and topped with our own Asian slaw made from scratch; all of this between two slices of sourdough bread with melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese!!

    • The Cheesy Frank $7.00

      This grilled cheese is perfect for the month of July and fits right in with Barbecue season! Featuring white bread, American cheese, onions in sauce and hot dog!!

    • Grilled Chicken Caprese $8.75

      Straight out of Capri Italy; this grilled cheese features diced tomatoes, diced basil and diced red onion all tossed in oil & salt served on top of grilled chicken and melted between mozzarella cheese between two slices of sourdough bread.

    • The Gameday $7.95

      Just in time for football season: A loaded grilled cheese! This sandwich Features our homemade potato chips topped with diced tomato, red onion, and jalapeno drizzled with cheese sauce with melted pepper jack cheese between two slices of sourdough bread.

    • The Smoke Out $12.50

      Back by popular demand for a limited time only!! Smoked Gouda cheese, Pulled BBQ pork, fried pickles and our homemade coleslaw all piled in between two slices of sourdough bread. Receive 20% off a beer or milkshake with the purchase this one sandwich!!

    • The Gobbler $11.75

      This is our November special every year!!! Featuring turkey, our very own cranberry sauce, and stuffing!! All on sourdough bread with melted Muenster cheese

    • The Roast Beast $12.50

      Just in time for the holidays this December special features slow cooked beef, homemade crispy onion straws, horseradish spread and Muenster cheese all on sourdough bread.

    • The New Years Resolution $9.50

      Our very own BLT sandwich!! Lettuce, Tomato, bacon and cheddar cheese melted between two slices of sourdough bread. On the lighter side for those looking to be healthy at the beginning of the new year!!

    • Donut go bacon my heart $5.50

      A GLAZED DONUT GRILLED CHEESE! this grilled cheese is a first for us, a glazed donut from our neighbor The Rolling Pin Bakery, cheddar cheese, and candied bacon. Add sweet tots or sweet fries as a side for an added treat.

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip Grilled Cheese $8.95

      Homemade spinach and artichoke dip between two slices of sourdough bread with melted mozzarella cheese.

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip Mac n Cheese - Small $5.95

      Our very own spinach and artichoke dip cheese sauce sauteed with cavatappi pasta. Pairs perfectly with some grilled chicken at an additional charge

    • Spinach and Artichoke Mac n Cheese-Large $8.95

      Our very own spinach and artichoke dip cheese sauce sauteed with cavatappi pasta. Pairs perfectly with some grilled chicken at an additional charge

    • The Habanero Hottie $9.50

      Sauteed steak, pickled jalapenos, onion rings, AJ sauce all melted between two slices of sourdough bread with SPICY Habanaro cheese

    • The Habanaro Hottie $9.50

      Sauteed steak, pickled jalapenos, onion rings, AJ sauce all melted between two slices of sourdough bread with SPICY Habanaro cheese

    • AJs Kickin Chicken Salad $8.75

      Our very own chicken salad with a twist! On whole wheat toast with lettuce and Muenster cheese. The chicken salad features chicken, jalapeño,red onion, candied walnuts, dried cranberries and bacon bits!

    • The Cuban $10.50

      Our version of the classic "Cuban sandwich", Sourdough bread with grilled ham, pulled pork, pickles, and golden mustard all melted with Swiss cheese.

    • The Mac Attack $10.00

      Our famous "Mac Melt" has found its better half! This monster grilled cheese features sourdough bread, Mozzarella cheese, and our mac n cheese breaded and deep fried!

    • The Zesty Bean Burger $12.00

      A Bean patty, sauteed mushrooms, fresh jalapenos, and A red pepper aoili sauce all on whole wheat bread with melted pepper jack cheese.

    • Oh Kale Yeah $9.50

      consists of a homemade kale slaw; featuring kale, red onion, apples, and a honey mustard based sauce with grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese.

    • South of the Border $10.00

      Sourdough bread, crispy onion pedals, coleslaw and pulled pork sauteed in lime juice all melted between cheddar cheese.

    • Pretzel bun grilled cheese $8.50

      A fresh pretzel bun stuffed with Swiss cheese, thick cut bacon, and a spicy brown mustard spread then grilled to perfection!

    • The Mistletoe $9.50

      Sourdough bread, melted Asiago cheese, baby Arugula, and Prosciutto!

Menu for AJ's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.