Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Bay Shore
  • Paul's Pizza

Paul's Pizza

(631) 254-4240

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 3 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Pizza
  • $$$$$
  • Paul's Pizza

  • (631) 254-4240
  • Menu
  • Salads
    Choice of dressing: French, ranch, creamy italian, oil & vinegar, balsamic, blue cheese, russian or caesar
    • Caesar $3.95

    • Garden $3.95

    • Chicken $5.95

    • Greek $5.95

    • Antipasto $6.50

      Add chicken $1.95, turkey $1.95, ham $1.95, mushrooms $0.75, cheese $0.95, anchovies $0.75

  • Pizza Pies
    • Pizza Pies $6.45+

  • Pizza Slices
    • Pizza Slices $1.90+

      Slice with topping: $2.50, white $2.75, chicken $2.95

    • Chicken or Eggplant $1.95+

  • Specialty Pizza - Whole Pie
    • Everything Pizza $9.95+

      Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, peppers, onion and fresh garlic

    • Veggie Pizza $9.75+

      Onion, peppers, olives, broccoli, garlic, mushroom

  • Specialty Pizza - Half Pie
    • Everything Pizza $9.95+

      Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, peppers, onion and fresh garlic

    • Veggie Pizza $8.75+

      Onion, peppers, olives, broccoli, garlic, mushroom

  • Specialty Pizza
    • White Pizza $8.95+

      Ricotta cheese & fresh garlic

    • Meat Lover's Pizza $9.95+

      Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, ham

    • Baked Ziti Pizza $18.95

      Ziti, ricotta, mozzarella cheese

    • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $19.95

      Chicken cutlet, ricotta, mozzarella & sauce

    • BBQ Chicken Pizza $19.95

      Fried chicken breast, BBQ sauce, mozzarella cheese

    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $19.95

      Spicy chicken breast, mozzarella & blue cheese

    • Hawaiian Pizza $19.95

      Ham & pineapple

    • Chicken & Tomato Pizza $19.95

    • Eggplant Rollatini Pizza $18.50

      Eggplant, tomato sauce, ricotta & mozzarella cheese

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $19.95

      Chicken cutlet, bacon, mozzarella & ranch

  • Pasta Dishes
    Choice of ziti or spaghetti. Served with italian bread or garlic knots
    • Marinara Sauce $6.50

    • Butter Sauce $6.50

    • Butter & Garlic Sauce $6.75

    • Garlic & Oil $6.50

    • Tomato Mushroom Sauce $7.50

    • Meat Sauce $7.50

    • Pasta & Meatballs $7.95

    • Pasta & Sausage $7.95

    • Penne Ala Vodka $7.95

  • Italian Dinners
    Choice of ziti or spaghetti. Served with italian bread or garlic knots. Can substitute a salad for pasta. Parmigiana add $.95 extra
    • Chicken $8.75

    • Chicken & Mushroom $9.25

    • Sausage & Peppers $8.75

    • Sausage & Mushrooms $9.25

    • Eggplant $8.75

    • Eggplant & Ricotta $9.50

    • Veal Cutlet $9.95

  • Baked Dishes
    Served with italian bread or garlic knots
    • Baked Stuffed Shells $7.75

    • Baked Ziti $7.75

    • Baked Ravioli $7.75

    • Baked Lasagna $8.00

    • Baked Manicotti $7.70

  • Stuffed Breads
    • Sausage, Pepper, Onion & Cheese $5.95

    • Pepperoni and Cheese $5.95

    • Broccoli and Cheese $5.95

    • Chicken Roll $5.95

    • Spinach and Pepperoni $5.95

      Ricotta, mozzarella, touch of fresh garlic

  • Calzones
    Stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella cheese, choice of topping
    • Calzones $5.95+

  • Hot Heros
    Parmigiana add $0.75 extra
    • Meatball $6.25

    • Sausage $6.25

    • Eggplant $6.25

    • Chicken $6.25

    • Veal $7.95

  • Cold Heros
    All served with the works: Lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar. add cheese $0.95, peppers $0.50, bacon 0.95, olives $0.50, mushroom $0.50
    • Chicken $6.50

    • Ham $6.50

    • Italian $6.95

    • Chicken Ranch $6.95

  • Side Orders
    • Meatball or Sausage $3.95

    • Garlic Bread $2.95

    • Garlic Bread with Mozzarella $3.75

    • 1/2 Dozen Knots $1.95

    • 1 Dozen Knots $3.50

    • Mini Rolls $1.50

      Pepperoni or sausage 3 for

    • Side Sampler $3.50

      Includes 2 sausage mini rolls, 2 pepperoni mini rolls, 3 garlic knots

    • Eggplant Platter $6.25

    • Chicken Cutlet Platter $6.25

      Add garden salad to any platter $1.95, add parmigiana to any side order $0.95 extra

    • Chicken Wings Buffalo or Honey BBQ $5.49+

Menu for Paul's Pizza provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.