• Wisconsin
  • Madison
  • Gotham New York Bagels & Eats

Gotham New York Bagels & Eats

(608) 467-7642
  • 112 E Mifflin St, Madison, WI 53703
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Bagels ,  Deli Food ,  Sandwiches
  • $$$$$
(608) 467-7642
  • Menu
  • Breakfast
    Served all day. Your choice of a bagel or bread.
    • Butter $1.25

    • One Egg $2.75

    • Two Eggs $3.75

    • Plain Cream Cheese Or Tofu $2.5

    • Flavored Cream Cheese Or Tofu $3

    • Egg & Cheddar $3.25

    • Pastrami & Egg $4.75

    • Sausage, Egg & Cheddar $5

    • Thick Cut Bacon, Egg & Cheddar $4.25

    • Cold Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese $6.75

    • The "G" $4

      your choice of bagel with hot capocollo, egg and cheddar

    • Double Your "G" $6

    • The "V" $4.75

      scallion tofu, roasted poblano peppers, tomato, arugula and avocado on a bagel

  • Gotham Signature Sandwiches
    • Long-Guy-Land $7.75

      house roasted turkey breast, roth kase fontina, arugula, tomato and mayo

    • Brighton Beach $9.25

      smoked alaskan salmon, caper cream cheese, watercress, red onion and tomato

    • Spanish Harlem $7.75

      shredded, roasted pork shoulder, hot capocollo ham, melted baby swiss, pickles and dijon mustard

    • Massapequa $8

      roasted chicken breast, roasted red pepper, arugula, fontina & pesto

  • Gotham Signature Sandwiches 1
    Served on rye bread with deli mustard, coleslaw and a pickle.
    • Williamsburg $9.75

      piled-high pastrami

    • Dyker Heights $9.75

      piled-high corned beef

  • Build Your Own Sandwich
    Includes bagel or bread with butter, mayo, dijon, or deli mustard. Arugula, baby spinach, tomato, roasted poblanos, or roasted red bell peppers $1.00, onions, cucumbers, pickles, pesto or jelly $0.75.
    • Hot Smoked Salmon Or Whitefish Salad $7.25

    • Turkey Breast $5.75

      chicken cutlet, tuna, chicken or egg salad, eggplant, genoa salami

    • Flavored Cream Cheese Or Tofu $2.25

      add a topping.

    • Capocollo, Egg, Plain Cream Cheese Or Tofu $1.75

    • Fontina, Swiss, Provolone, Cheddar, Avocado, Watercress Or Bacon $1.5

    • Peanut Butter $1.25

  • Salads
    Per pound.
    • Whitefish Salad $15

    • Chicken Salad $10.75

    • Egg Salad $8

    • Deli Salad $7

    • Tuna Salad $10.75

      olive oil/lemon-based or mayonnaise-based

  • Gotham To Go
    • New York Dozen $11

      13 bagels in a brown bag

    • Hell's Kitchen $19.75

      new york dozen with two 8 oz. spreads serves 12-15 people pick-up only

    • Riverside Park $60

      cold smoked salmon and cream cheese platter with a new york dozen, two 8 oz. spreads, watercress, red onion, tomato and capers serves 12-15 people

    • Midtown $60

      build your ownnew york dozen, three 1 lb. portions of: turkey, chicken salad, tuna salad, egg salad, eggplant crisps or genoa salami (3 lbs. total), arugula, tomato, red onion, pickles, mayo and deli mustard serves 12-15 people

    • Park Avenue $8.5

      signature half sandwiches, with deli salad, kettle chips, and can soda or bottled water (10 person minimum)

  • Meats
    Per pound.
    • Gotham Signature Pastrami $18

    • Gotham Signature Corned Beef $18

    • Cold Smoked Salmon $25

    • Turkey Breast $10.75

      roasted in the house

  • ...
    • Single Bagel Or Bialy $1

    • Cream Cheese 8 Oz $5.5

    • Cream Cheese $11

      per pound

    • Kosher Dill Pickle $1

    • Deli Salad $1.75

    • Kettle Chips $1.25

    • Protein Soup Of The Day $4.5

    • Vegetarian Soup Of The Day $4.5

    • Fruit Salad $3.25

    • Fruit Tray $25

  • Beverages & Bagels
    • Hand Rolled Bagels

      plain, whole wheat honey, cinnamon raisin, salt, sesame, everything, onion, garlic, poppy, egg, super egg everything, pumpernickel, bialy.

    • Bread Options

      sourdough, whole wheat, multi-grain, rye, hero roll.

    • Cream Cheese & Tofu

      plain, smoked salmon, olive, chimichurri, caper, walnut raisin, scallion, vegetable, plain tofu, scallion tofu, vegetable tofu

    • Coffee Hot Or Iced $1.75

    • Tea $1.5

    • Coffee To Go $15

      3 qt./serves 15

    • Milk $1.5

    • Snapple $1.75

    • Vitamin Water $2

    • Soda $1.25

      12 oz. cans

    • Poland Spring Bottled Water $1.25

    • Freshly squeezed orange or grapefruit $3

    • Cranberry/Lavender Or Spicy Pineapple/Mint $3

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.