Allmenus.com
  • Pennsylvania
  • New Cumberland
  • Coakley's Irish Pub

Coakley's Irish Pub

(717) 774-5556

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 305 Bridge St, New Cumberland, PA 17070
  • Restaurant website
  • No cuisines specified

  • $$$$$
  • Coakley's Irish Pub

  • (717) 774-5556
  • Main
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Coakley's Tavern Faire
    • Cheesy Crab Pretzel $11.99

      A delicious philly soft pretzel topped with a decadent blend of crab meat and cheese baked to a golden brown.

    • Hot Crab Dip $12.99

      A creamy blend of lump crab meat, cheese and spices, baked 'til bubbly and served with pita points and homemade chips

    • Pittsburgh Steak Salad $12.99

      Sirloin steak, tomatoes, cucumbers, steak fries and onion straws

    • Tavern Pretzel $4.50

      Coakley's philadelphia style soft pretzel baked and served with our homemade beer mustard or spicy cheddar cheese

  • Irish Nachos
    • Original Irish Nacho $7.99

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with spicy cheddar cheese, bacon, tomatoes, red onions, scallions and jalapenos.

    • Black n Bleu Chip $7.99

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with blackened tender fillet medallions melted with bleu and cheddar cheeses

    • Chesapeake Chip $7.99

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with crab, cheddar and old bay

    • The Buffalo Nacho $7.99

      House made potato chips dusted with fire and topped with grilled all natural chicken breast and rolled in a tangy buffalo sauce and cooled in Stella bleu cheese crumbles

    • Mozz Stix $7.99

      Homemade grande mozzarella, sliced into sticks, rolled in panko and fried golden

    • Boom Boom Onion Straws $7.99

      Lightly breaded spanish onions, touched with chipoltle and deep fried to golden and served with our boom boom sauce

    • Irish Potato Skins $7.99

      Skins stuffed with Wisconsin cheddar, applewood smoked bacon and served with sour cream

    • Chicken Fingers and Fries $7.99

    • Coakley's Pot o'Gold $12.99

      Mozz stix, onion straws, potato skins

    • Boom Boom Shrimp $8.99

      Jumbo shrimp, lightly breaded and rolled in a creamy thai boom boom sauce

    • The Lambert $7.99

      A juicy half pound sausage grilled and topped with sauteed onion, peppers and cheese wizz served on an Italian roll with side of french fries

    • Wings Wings Wings $9.49

      Served with bleu cheese and celery, choice of sauces: hot, mild, medium, regular, old bay, teriyaki, honey bbq, bbq, jalapeno mango bbq, 5 alarm, suicide, cajun, garlic butter, old bay and mike's sauce hot and butter garlic served regular or boneless

  • Coakley's is a Byob Place
    • Build your own Burger $8.99

      Choose your burger: all natural boneless breast of chicken, vegan veggie burger, turkey burger, or 50% steak, 50%ground chuck, 100% angus burger. Choose your toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, jalapenos, grilled onions, american, cheddar, swiss or provolone cheese and/or schmiggitty. add extra kick ($.50 ea) fresh california avocados, bleu cheese, fried ham, bacon or grilled mushrooms, fried egg

    • Fillet, Egg n Cheese Threeway $8.99

      Sandwich, wrap it or on a bed of toast, any way u want it! served with fries

    • Jameson Fillet $14.99

      Petite hand cut usda choice filet medallions, pan seared in jameson herb butter, served with fries and cole slaw

    • Chicken Fingers and Fries $7.99

    • Wings $9.49

      Served with bleu cheese and celery, choice of sauces: hot, mild, medium, regular, old bay, teriyaki, honey bbq, bbq, jalapeno mango bbq, 5 alarm, suicide, cajun, garlic butter, old bay and mike's sauce hot and butter garlic served regular or boneless

  • Irish Nachos_a
    • Irish Nachos $8.99

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with spicy cheddar cheese, bacon, tomatoes, red onions, scallions and jalapenos.

    • Calypso Caprese Tower $7.99

      Garden fresh sliced tomatoes, hand streatched wet buffalo mozzarella and california haas avocado stacked and doused with balsamic vinaigrette

    • Tavern Pretzel $4.50

      Coakleys famous footlong soft pretzel baked and served with our homemade beer mustard or spicy cheddar cheese. Add grilled chicken $4.00, shrimp skewers $6.00, salmon $6.00, fillet tips $6.00 to any salad

    • Gluten Free Wrap $1.00

    • Avocado Cobb Salad $9.99

      Grilled all natural chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, hard-boiled egg, fresh california haas avocados, wisconsin cheddar cheese, grape tomatoes, and paired with our avocado ranch dressing

  • For 10
    Served with the following sides:cole slaw, side salad, Caesar salad, French fries, veg of the day, mashed potatoes and chefs choice dessert
    • Chicken Bruschetta $10.00

      All natural steroid free chicken breast cooked on an open flame and topped with our house recipe grape tomato bruchetta and asiago cheese and served with choice of two sides

    • Powerhouse Chicken Breast $10.00

      All natural steroid free chicken breast topped with applewood smoked bacon and Wisconsin cheddar and served with choice of two sides

    • Chicken O'Malleyo $10.00

      Pan seared boneless breasted chicken blended with four cheese alfredo, tossed with chef's choice pasta and served with a side salad

    • The Chopper $10.00

      A half pound of our ground steak rubbed with spices, grilled to your desired temperature and topped with grilled mushrooms, onions and drizzled with guinness gravy and served with your choice of two sides

    • Lemon Crumb Haddock $10.00

      Broiled wild caught haddock topped with lemon crumb panko, served with your choice of two sides

    • Beer Battered Cod $10.00

      Smithwicks tempura battered cod filet, deep fried to a golden brown and served with your choice of two sides.

    • The Scamp $10.00

      Tilapia seared, sauteed and topped in scampi garlic butter and served with choice of two sides and a dinner mint

    • English Cut Prime Rib $10.00

      Our own coakley's golden herb crusted prime rib, slow roasted to perfection, carved into an english cut and served with au jus and your choice of two sides

    • Jameson Whiskey Chop $10.00

      A thick cut boneless pork chop pan seared in Jameson whiskey butter and served with your choice of two sides.

    • Petite Fillet Medallions $10.00

      Hand cut usda choice fillet rubbed with spices cooked in butter to your specifications and served with choice of two sides

  • Kids Menu
    All of the kids selections come with your choice of one side: french fries, coleslaw, applesauce, mashed potatoes, vegetable dujour, carrots and cucumbers with ranch, fruit salad or chips
    • Kids Burger $5.99

    • Kids Fish and Chips $6.99

    • Kids Steak $9.99

    • Kids Grilled Cheese $3.99

    • Kids Crab Cake $9.99

    • Kids Spaghetti $3.99

    • Kids Chicken Strips $5.99

    • Kids Pizza $5.99

  • Starters and Wee Bites
    • Guinness Draught $5.50

      Age-old, world famous stout. Our Idea of the perfect starter

    • Cheesy Crab Pretzel $11.99

      A delicious foot long soft pretzel braid topped with a decadent blend of crab meat and cheese baked to a golden brown.

    • Hot Crab Dip $12.99

      A creamy blend of lump crab meat, cheese and spices, baked til bubbly and served with pita points and homemade chips

    • Calypso Caprese Tower $7.99

      Garden fresh sliced tomatoes, hand streatched wet buffalo mozzarella and california haas avocado stacked and doused with balsamic vinaigrette

    • Prime Time $8.99

      Coakley's own golden herb encrusted, slow roasted shaved prime rib stuffed in a portabella with smoked provolone and caramelized onions served with coakley's marinara

    • Wings Wings Wings $9.49

      Served with bleu cheese and celery, choice of sauces: hot, mild, medium, regular, old bay, teriyaki, honey bbq, bbq, jalapeno mango bbq, 5 alarm, suicide, cajun, garlic butter, old bay and mike's sauce hot and butter garlic. Served regular or boneless

  • Coakley's Greens
    Add grilled chicken $4.00, shrimp skewers $6.00, salmon $6.00, crab cake $7.00, fillet tips $6.00 to any salad or any salad can be rolled into a wrap, served with chips and a pickle $0.00. Gluten free wrap?$1.00
    • Pittsburgh Steak Salad $12.99

      Fillet, tomatoes, cucumbers, steak fries and onion rings

    • Coakley's Cali Salad $8.99

      Chicken, granny smith apples, raisins, sundried tomatoes, bacon, eggs and feta cheese, served deconstructed and choice of dressing

    • Buffalo Chicken $8.99

      Fried buffalo chicken, celery, cucumbers, grape tomatoes and bleu cheese crumbles and choice of dressing

    • Spinach Salad $8.99

      Bacon, egg, mushroom, grape tomato and hot bacon dressing

    • Avocado Cobb Salad $9.99

      Grilled all natural chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, hard-boiled egg, fresh california haas avocados, wisconsin cheddar cheese, grape tomatoes, and paired with our avocado ranch dressing

    • Surf and Turf Salad $12.99

      1/2 head of romaine, flame kissed and topped with filet tenders and a shrimp skewer, drizzled with key lime caesar dressing and sprinkled with asiago

    • Coakely's Signature Prime Rib Salad $12.99

      Coakley's own golden herb encrusted prime rib cuts, served over a bed of mixed greens with grape tomatoes, purple onions, bleu cheese crumbles, roasted red peppers and paired with our own hot beefy balsamic vinaigrette

    • Topping Selection

      Salad dressings parmesan peppercorn, thousand island, raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, balsamic vinaigrette. our own homemade bleu cheese, beefy basalmic vinaigrette

  • Soups
    • Guinness Baked Onion Soup $3.99+

    • fgfdh

    • Coakley's Irish Potato Soup $3.49+

      Creamy homemade potato soup topped with cheddar cheese, sour cream and chives

    • Award Winning Chili $3.99+

  • Wings Wings Wings
    • Wings Wings Wings $9.49

      Served with bleu cheese and celery, choice of sauces: hot, mild, medium, regular, old bay, teriyaki, honey bbq, bbq, jalapeno mango bbq, 5 alarm, suicide, cajun, garlic butter, old bay and mike's sauce hot and butter garlic. Served regular or boneless

  • Coakley's Cold Deli Board
    Choose from cottage white, wheatberry or marbled rye bread, all served with lettuce, tomato, homemade chips and a pickle.
    • Turkey and Provolone $5.99

      Turkey and Provolone

    • Ham and American $5.99

    • Corned Beef and Swiss $5.99

    • Ham and American $5.99

    • BLT $5.99

    • Soup, Salad or 1/2 1 or 2 Sandwich $6.99

  • Coakley's Irish Specialties
    • Guinness Braised Pie $14.50

      Tender guinness braised fillet tips with caramelized onions, provolone cheese and puffed pastry baked to a golden brown

    • Shepherd's Pie $13.99

      This is our own special twist on an old irish favorite. Juicy braised fillet tips, sauteed with turnips, parsnips and carrots, folded into our guinness gravy and topped with mashed potatoes and finally baked to a golden brown.

    • Bangers and Mashed $15.99

      Irish bangers served over seasoned mashed potatoes and topped with a whiskey and caramelized onion gravy.

    • Fish and Chips $13.99

      A generous portion of our own handmade beer battered haddock filet and crispy steak fries served with tartar sauce.

    • Homemade Chicken Pot Pie $13.99

      Tender shredded chicken and mixed vegetables in a savory chicken gravy, topped with puff pastry, and baked to a golden brown.

    • Salmon Boxty $17.99

      A fresh grilled filet of salmon placed on two Irish potato cakes, drizzled with a mustard cream sauce and fresh vegetables, serves with your choice of one side.

    • Ala Carte Sides $2.99

      Garden salad, caesar salad, french fries, sweet potato fries, cole slaw, green apple walnut slaw.

  • Melts and Hot Sandwiches
    All sandwiches are served with coakley's homemade potato chips or mix and match: substitute any of our side choices for chips $1.49
    • Coakleys Reuben $5.49+

      Our own home-roasted corned beef piled high with aged Swiss cheese, thousand island dressing and your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw on grilled marble rye bread.

    • Coakley's Rachel $5.49+

      Sliced turkey piled high with aged swiss cheese, thousand island dressing and your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw on grilled marble rye bread.

    • Coakleys Melt $7.99

      Sliced turkey, applewood smoked bacon, tomato and american cheese piled high on thick cut sourdough bread and grilled until golden brown

    • The Lambert $7.99

      A juicy half pound sausage grilled and topped with sauteed onion, peppers and cheese wizz served on an italian roll with side of onion rings

    • Open Faced Fillet $11.95

      Tender fillet topped with caramelized onions, smoked provolone cheese on a half pretzel braid

    • Schmiggitty Pulled Pork Sandwich $7.95

      Roasted hand pulled-pork doused in schmiggitty sauce and served on a kaiser. if you haven't tried it, you're in for a unique experience

    • Crab Cake Sandwich $13.99

      Our homemade lump crab cake served on a kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and a side of tartar sauce.

    • Pittsburgh Pretzel Sandwich $8.49

      Grilled ham and swiss piled high primanti brothers style with fries and coleslaw all packed onto a pretzel roll.

  • Leprechaun's Dream
    • Fillet Bowl $9.99

      Tender fillet medallions topped with coakley's own guinness gravy, fresh vegetables and wisconsin cheddar cheese

    • Fried Chicken Bowl $9.99

      Fried chicken strips topped with roasted chicken gravy, fresh vegetables and Wisconsin cheddar

  • Coakley's is a Byob Place
    • Build your own Burger $8.95

      Choose your burger: all natural boneless breast of chicken, vegan veggie burger, turkey burger, or 50% steak, 50% ground chuck, 100% angus burger. Choose your toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, jalapenos, grilled onions, american, cheddar, swiss, provolone cheese or smiggitty. Add extra kick $0.50 ea fresh california avocados, bleu cheese, fried ham, bacon, or grilled mushrooms

    • The Tully Burger $9.99

      A juicy, 1/2 lb, hand pattied burger, grilled to your specification, topped with our Schmiggitty Sauce, Irish cheddar and aged Swiss cheeses, applewood smoked bacon, fried onion straws, lettuce and tomato on a kaiser roll.

    • Cheesy Crab Burger $10.49

      Our own hand-pattied 1/2 lb ground beef char grilled to your specification and topped with our creamy blend of lump crab meat, cheddar cheese and spices.

    • Burger Stuffers $8.99

  • Starters and Wee Bites
    • Guinness Draught $5.50

      Age-old, world famous stout. Our Idea of the perfect starter

    • Cheesy Crab Pretzel $11.99

      A delicious foot long soft pretzel braid topped with a decadent blend of crab meat and cheese baked to a golden brown.

    • Hot Crab Dip $12.99

      A creamy blend of lump crab meat, cheese and spices, baked 'til bubbly and served with pita points and homemade chips

    • Fried Calamari $8.99

      Lightly dusted calamari, flash fried and served with our bay remoulade dipping sauce

    • Euro Platter $6.99

      House made hummas accompanied by calamato olives, pepperoncini, crumbled feta, roasted red peppers and served with pita points and our homemade chips.

    • Calypso Caprese Tower $7.99

      Garden fresh sliced tomatoes, hand streatched wet buffalo mozzarella and california haas avocado stacked and doused with balsamic vinaigrette

    • Prime Time $8.99

  • Coakley's Soups
    • Guinness Baked Onion Soup $3.99

    • Coakley's Irish Potato Soup $3.49+

      Creamy homemade potato soup topped with cheddar cheese, sour cream and chives

    • Award Winning Chili $3.99+

      Our special recipe with a kick

    • Chip off the Old Block $7.99

  • Irish Nachos
    Our famous homemade potato chips topped with spicy cheddar cheese, bacon, tomatoes, red onions, scallions and jalapenos.
    • Black n Bleu Chip

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with blackened tender fillet medallions melted with bleu and cheddar cheeses

    • Chesapeake Chip

      Our famous homemade potato chips topped with crab, cheddar and old bay

    • The Buffalo Nacho

      House made potato chips dusted with fire and topped with grilled all natural chicken breast and rolled in a tangy buffalo sauce and cooled in stella bleu cheese crumbles

  • Hot Sandwiches
    • Coakley's Reuben $8.99

      Our own home roasted corned beef piled high with aged swiss cheese, thousand island dressing and your choice of saurkraut or coleslaw on grilled marble rye bread. Coakley's most popular sandwich.

    • Coakley's Rachel $8.99

      Sliced turkey piled high with aged swiss cheese, thousand island dressing and your choice of saurkraut or cole slaw on grilled marble rye bread.

    • Open Faced Filet $11.95

      Tender fillet topped with caramelized onions smoked provolone cheese on a half pretzel braid

    • Wings Wings Wings $9.49

      Served with bleu cheese and celery, choice of sauces: hot, mild, medium, regular, old bay, teriyaki, honey bbq, jalapeno mango bbq, 5 alarm, suicide, cajun, garlic butter, old bay and mike's sauce hot and butter garlic served regular or boneless

  • Coakley's Greens
    Salad dressings parmesan peppercorn, thousand island, raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, balsamic vinaigrette. our own homemade bleu cheese, beefy basalmic vinaigrette, key lime caesar
    • Pittsburgh Steak Salad $12.99

      Fillet, tomatoes, cucumbers, steak fries and onion straws

    • Coakley's Cali Salad $8.99

      Chicken, granny smith apples, raisins, sundried tomatoes, bacon, eggs and feta cheese, served deconstructed and choice of dressing

    • Buffalo Chicken $8.99

      Fried buffalo chicken, celery, cucumbers, grape tomatoes and bleu cheese crumbles and choice of dressing

    • Spinach Salad $8.99

      Bacon, egg, mushroom, grape tomato and hot bacon dressing

    • Avocado Cobb Salad $9.99

      Grilled all natural chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, hard-boiled egg, fresh california haas avocados, wisconsin cheddar cheese, grape tomatoes, and paired with our avocado ranch dressing

    • Surf and Turf Salad $12.99

      1/2 head of romaine, flame kissed and topped with filet tenders and a shrimp skewer, drizzled with key lime caesar dressing and sprinkled with asiago

    • Coakely's Signature Prime Rib Salad $12.99

      Coakley's own golden herb encrusted prime rib cuts, served over a bed of mixed greens with grape tomatoes, purple onions, bleu cheese crumbles, roasted red peppers and paired with our own hot beefy balsamic vinaigrette

  • Coakley's Irish Specialties
    • Guinness Braised Pie $14.50

      Tender guinness braised fillet tips with caramelized onions, provolone cheese and puffed pastry baked to a golden brown

    • Shepherd's Pie $13.99

      Juicy braised fillet tips, sauteed with turnips, parsnips and carrots, folded into our guinness gravy and topped with mashed potatoes and finally baked to a golden brown.

    • Bangers and Mashed $15.99

      Irish bangers served over seasoned mashed potatoes and topped with a jameson and caramelized onion gravy.

    • Fish and Chips $13.99

      A generous portion of our own handmade beer battered haddock filet and crispy steak fries served with tartar sauce.

    • Homemade Chicken Pot Pie $13.99

      Tender shredded chicken and mixed vegetables in a savory chicken gravy, topped with puff pastry and baked to a golden brown.

    • Salmon Boxty $17.99

      A fresh grilled filet of salmon placed on two irish potato cakes, drizzled with a mustard cream sauce and fresh vegetables, served with your choice of one side

  • Coakley's Specialty Burgers
    Choose from all natural chicken breast, vegan portabella, turkey, or 100% angus beef, with lettuce, tomato, pickle and chips
    • The Tully Burger $9.99

      Schmiggitty sauce, cheddar, Swiss, bacon, onion straws

    • Cheesy Crab Burger $10.99

      Topped with blend of lump crab, cheddar and spices

    • All American Burger $8.99

      Topped with your choice of cheese

  • From the Sea
    Coakley's supports efforts for sustainable seafood, simply sustainable, simply responsible.
    • From the Sea

      Choose your fish: tilapia, haddock or cod choose your way of cooking: smithwicks batter dipped, blackened with chef jeff's fat man's fire cajun spice blend, or broiled with chardonnay, fresh lemon and butter choose two sides

    • Drunken Irish Sailors $17.99

      Shrimp, crab cake and scallops, after having imbibed in chardonnay, slathered in fresh lemon and butter are broiled and served with two sides

    • The Jersey Shore $16.99

      Fried shrimp, scallops, cod and a crab cake served with boardwalk french fries and homemade slaw

    • The OCMD $17.99

      Haddock, shrimp, scallops and a crab cake buoyed with the flavors of chardonnay, lemon and butter and broiled maryland style, served with two sides

    • Baltimore's Best $13.99+

      Two of chef jeff's house recipe crab cakes made the same since 1986, served with two sides

    • The Poppy $17.99

      Fresh line caught salmon, encrusted with poppy seeds, pan seared to medium temperature and smothered with fresh sliced tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, and asparagus tips in a chablis sauce and served over angel hair and choice of another side

    • Pink and Black $17.99

      Cajun crusted line caught salmon seared in butter and rested on a bed of black spinach and zested with a sriracha lime burre blanc and served with two sides

  • Celtic Fire
    • Chicken on Fire $13.99

      Our chicken breast is all natural steroid free boneless chicken breast.

    • The Powerhouse

      Topped with applewood smoked bacon and wisconsin cheddar

    • The Bruchetta

      Covered by our house made grape tomato, fresh herb, asiago mix

    • Chicken Baltimore $16.99

      Fire kist breast of chicken topped with chef jeff's baltimore crab cake and zested with a chesapeake bay remoulade

    • Bailey's Irish Chicken $14.99

      Fire grilled chicken breast topped with sauteed mushrooms, scallions and bailey's irish cream sauce

    • The Red Breast $14.99

      Grilled chicken breast topped with house marinara, four cheeses and served over chef's choice pasta with choice of one side.

  • Steaks and Chops
    • New York on Fire $21.99

      14-16 oz hand cut usda choice ny strip loin, rubbed with spices and cooked on open fire

    • Petite Fillet Medallions $15.99

      Hand cut usda choice fillet rubbed with spices cooked in butter to your specifications and served with choice of two sides

    • Green Apple Chop $15.95

      Two generous thick center cut boneless pork chop, cooked with flame and topped with green apple honey walnut compote

    • Fillet Tower $22.95

      Twin fillet medallions grilled to order then layered with homemade lump crab cakes placed on mashed potatoes and drizzled with chesapeake cream sauce and served with choice of side

  • Prime Rib
    • English Cut 8-10oz $12.99

    • King Cut 18-20oz $22.99

    • Queen Cut 14-16oz $19.99

    • King Cut 18-20oz $22.99

    • Coakley's Cut 28-30oz $29.99

Menu for Coakley's Irish Pub provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.