Allmenus.com
  • Pennsylvania
  • New Cumberland
  • Carnahans

Carnahans

(717) 774-4781

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 209 3rd St, New Cumberland, PA 17070
  • Restaurant website
  • No cuisines specified

  • $$$$$
  • Carnahans

  • (717) 774-4781
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Mozzarella Sticks $4.75

      Battered & fried. Served w/ our marinara sauce

    • Onion Rings $4.50

      Beer battered & deep fried.

    • Homemade Tortilla Chips & Salsa $3.95

    • Cowboy Mike's Hot Peppers $4.95

      Served in sauce w/ garlic bread

    • French Onion In A Crock $4.25

      Homemade, topped w/ three cheeses

  • More Stuff
    • Quesadillas $6.95

      Flour tortilla, meat, cheese, refried beans. Chicken or beef.

    • Wings $7.50

      12 Large wings. Choose from hot, medium, mild, BBQ, or garlic. Celery, blue cheese- $1.50

    • Boneless Wings $4.50

      6 Same choices as above.

    • Chicken Fingers & French Fries $7.95

      Tender chicken strips, battered & fried.

    • Loaded Brew Fries $4.95

      Brew city fries topped w/ cheese, bacon, & scallions. Served w/ ranch dressing.

    • Cheese O Fries $3.95

      Steak fries covered w/ two different cheeses. Served w/ secret recipe dipping sauce.

    • Brew City Fries $2.95

    • Fresh Cut French Fries $2.25

      Cajun, old bay seasoning -$0.25,

    • Blackened Chicken Fingers w/ French Fries $6.50

      Fresh chicken, seasoned & grilled. Served w/ ranch dressing.

  • Salads
    • House Salad $4.95+

      Romaine lettuce w/ toasted pine nuts, parmesan & special dressing. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Garden Salad $3.95+

      Fresh iceberg & romaine lettuce w/ mixed greens. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Harry's Greek $5.95+

      Lettuce, feta cheese, mixed greens & greek olives. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Chef's Salad $5.95+

      Mixed greens topped w/ eggs, cheese, ham, turkey, & roast beef. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Caesar Salad $4.25+

      The classic. Chicken $2.75 beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Pittsburgh Steak Salad $9.95

      Mixed greens topped w/ charbroiled tenderloin & french fries. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

    • Asian Sesame Chicken Salad $7.95

      All-natural chicken, romaine, almonds, sesame seeds, & crispy wonton stips tossed in & asian sesame vinaigrette. Chicken $2.75, beef tenderloin $5.00

  • Pasta
    Served w/ a garden salad & warm rolls
    • Spaghetti $9.95

      With marinara sauce

    • Spaghetti $10.95

      With meatballs

    • Linguini $11.95

      With clam sauce

    • Stuffed Shells $10.95

      Large shells topped w/ marinara sauce & provolone cheese

  • Sandwiches
    Served w/ chips & a pickle.
    • Pork Bar B Que $5.95

      Rubbed here, smoked here, cooked here. You eat it, you like it. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Elizabeth's Flatbread Sandwich $7.95

      Grilled chicken breast, bacon, provolone, parmesan, fresh spinach, & a pesto ranch sauce. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Bar B Que Shrimp Po Boy $8.95

      Medium shrimp stuffed in a sub roll w/ cajun seasoning. Served w/ rice. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Hamburger $5.95

      8 oz of Ground sirloin charbroiled to your liking. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Houston Po Boy $7.95

      Chicken smothered in bar b que sauce. Topped w/ fried onions, bacon, & provolone. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Tenderloin Steak Sandwich $8.95

      5 oz Tenderloin steak, grilled & topped w/ sauteed onions. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Harry's Sub $5.95

      Ham, cheese, cappicola, lettuce, tomato & onion. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Cheese Steak $6.95

      Steak, provolone, marinara sauce, mushroom, & onion. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Chicken Cheese Steak $6.95

      Chicken topped w/ mushrooms, onion, & provolone. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Fish Sandwich $6.95

      Batter dipped filet of fish. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Meatball Sub $6.95

      Homemade meatballs topped w/ sauce & provolone cheese. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

    • Pit Beef Sandwich $6.95

      Slow roasted & smoked beef piled high. Served w/ horseradish. Fries $1.00, coleslaw $1.00

  • Entrees
    Served w/ two sides & dinner rolls. Topping $0.75
    • Harry's Steak $21.95

      Tenderloin steak broiled in wine sauce.

    • Veal Parmesan $12.95

      Covered w/ house marinara sauce & three cheeses.

    • Chicken Parmesan $11.95

      Same as above made w/ yard bird.

    • Mom's Meatloaf $9.95

      The basic comfort food

    • Cowboy Mike's Hot Pepper Pizza $7.25

      Prepared on flatbread w/ athenian hot pepper sauce.

Menu for Carnahans provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.