• Pennsylvania
  • Middletown
  • Old Coaly Pub

Old Coaly Pub

(717) 388-1653
  • 101 East Main St, Middletown, PA 15057
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Snacks
    • Crispy Coconut Shrimp $8

      Lightly breaded shrimp, ginger cabbage slaw with sweet red chili sauce.

    • Hand-Breaded Calamari $10

      Lightly breaded calamari fried, herbs, lemon, marinara.

    • Old Coaly Wings $10

      Your choice of sauce.

    • Guacamole and Chips $8

      Rustic guacamole and corn tortillas.

    • Chicken Quesadilla $8

      Chicken breast - raised without antibiotics, smoked pepper-jack cheese, scallion, cilantro, cherry tomatoes, salsa.

    • Big Steamed Mussel Pot $8

      1 lb. organic P.E.L. mussels with crusty bread. Make it a double order 2 lb. for an additional charge. Your choice of - white wine garlic butter sauce or red plum tomatoes, garlic, and crushed red pepper.

    • Coaly Fries $8

      Fresh cut fries, jalapeno, scallions, bacon, smoked pepper-jack cheese.

    • Onion Rings $5

    • Fresh Cut Fries $4

  • Salads
    Protein options - chicken raised with antibiotics, salmon or shrimp for an additional charge.
    • Caesar Salad $10

      Romaine hearts, seasoned croutons, and classic Caesar dressing.

    • Straight A Salad $10

      Arugula, baby kale, toasted walnuts, goat cheese, dried cranberries, honey grains, organic balsamic dressing.

    • Greek Santorini Salad $9

      Romaine tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, Kalamata olives, scallions, feta cheese, and vinaigrette.

    • Thai Salad $9

      Mixed greens, edamame, cabbage, carrots, peanuts tossed in an Asian peanut sauce.

    • Beet and Avocado Salad $9

      Baby kale, beets, chickpeas, avocado, radish, quinoa, organic balsamic vinaigrette.

    • Arugula Side Salad $4

      Arugula, lemon vinaigrette, shared Parmesan.

  • Burgers
    Served with chips and spears pickle.
    • Coaly Burger $9

      Best seller. 1/2 lb. beef burger, NY sharp cheddar cheese, 1000 Island dressing, leaf lettuce, tomato, toasted brioche roll, mayo.

    • American Classic Burger $9

      1/2 lb. beef burger, ketchup, mustard, pickles, American cheese, toasted brioche roll.

    • Hickory Bacon Cheddar Burger $10

      1/2 lb. beef burger, thick-cut bacon, NY sharp cheddar cheese, mayonnaise, red onion, pickle, leaf lettuce, tomato.

    • Mediterranean Impossible Burger $14

      Impossible burger, tomatoes, goat cheese, arugula on a toasted multigrain roll.

    • Coaly Favorite Burger $8

      1/2 lb. beef burger, American cheese, ketchup, mustard, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, toasted brioche bun.

    • Santa Monica Turkey Burger $12

      Turkey burger, guacamole, arugula, tomato, toasted multigrain roll.

  • Coaly Handhelds
    Served with chips and spear pickle.
    • French Dip Coaly Handhelds $10

      Seasoned roast beef with Gruyere cheese, caramelized onion, and horseradish cream cheese. Served with house-made au jus for dipping.

    • Chicken Wrap Coaly Handhelds $8

      Spiced chicken raised without antibiotics, lettuce, tomato, red onion, garlic aioli in a naan wrap with pretty hot sauce on the side.

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich Coaly Handhelds $8

      Buttermilk fried chicken raised without antibiotics, spicy ranch dressing, tomato, lettuce, and pickles.

    • Fish Tacos Coaly Handhelds $9

      Grilled haddock, guacamole, pico de gallo, cilantro.

    • Classic Reuben Coaly Handhelds $12

      Raised corn beef with sauerkraut. 1000 Island dressing, Swiss cheese on toasted rye bread.

    • Crab Cake Sandwich Coaly Handhelds $14

      Lump crab cake, lettuce, tomato, remoulade on a toasted brioche roll.

  • Entrees
    • Fish and Chips $14

      Beer batter-dipped haddock with coleslaw, remoulade sauce, lemon, with fresh-cut fries.

    • Signature Crab Cakes $18.95

      2 super lump crab cakes, remoulade sauce with arugula salad.

    • Coaly Meatloaf $14

      Meatloaf served with whipped potatoes, crispy onion rings, and mushroom gravy.

    • Fried Chicken $14

      Boneless buttermilk fried chicken - raised without antibiotics, macaroni and cheese, coleslaw, served with cornbread and honey.

    • Crab Stuffed Salmon $18

      Atlantic salmon stuffed with jumbo lump crab, served with whipped potatoes.

  • Dessert Menu
    • Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee $6

      Rich vanilla custard topped with caramelized sugar.

    • Cheesecake $7

      Seasonal variety.

    • Warm Chocolate Chip Sundae $5

      Warmed chocolate chip cooked, topped with cream and triple chocolate sauce.

    • Cannoli Dip $7

      Sweetened cannoli filling, chocolate cuts, cannoli.

  • Kid's Menu Entrees
    Children's menu items include fresh fruit and a choice of beverage and dessert.
    • Kid's Chicken Breast $6

      Seasoned chicken breast raised without antibiotics.

    • Kid's Hamburger $6

      1/4 lb. irradiated beef.

    • Kid's Cheeseburger $6

      1/4 lb. irradiated beef.

    • Kid's Old Coaly Macaroni and Cheese $6

      Lightly pasta, creamy blended cheese sauce.

    • Kid's Chicken Fingers $6

      Lightly breaded - contains egg.

    • Kid's Pasta and Cheese $6

      Pasta, butter, Parmigiano-Reggiano.

    • KId's Haddock Dinner $6

      Crispy haddock, remoulade, lemon.

    • Kid's Grilled Cheese $6

      White bread, deluxe American cheese.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.