• Pennsylvania
  • Lititz
  • Tomato Pie Cafe

Tomato Pie Cafe

(717) 627-1762
  • 23 North Broad Street, Lititz, PA 17543
  • Website
  • Grubhub.com
  • Winter Features
    Served All Day
    • Nutella Chocolate Chip Muffin $3.25

    • Cranberry Pecan Scone $3.5

    • Banana Walnut Chocolate Chip Oatmeal $4.95

    • Peanut Butter Chia Pudding $6.15

      Topped with Granola

    • Chia Pudding $6.15

      Topped with Fresh Berries and Granola

    • Sausage Egg Wrap $6.25

      Eggs, Herb seasoned sausage, Monterey Jack and Chedder Cheese. Served with a side of pesto mayo

    • Spinach Artichoke Tomato Pie $8.1

      Served with herbed scone and greens. Add: Roasted butternut squash, Rosemary potatoes, Grit cake or Fruit, Carrot fries, or a cup of soup $2.85

    • Bleu & Pear Salad $8.45

      mixed greens, Fresh pear slices, Bleu cheese crumbles, craisins, and glazed walnuts. Served with side of Olio Star 25 Balsamic

    • Grilled Pear Sandwich $8.75

      Honey drizzled pears, Bleu cheese, Carmelized onions, Cheddar cheese, and Fresh Basil on grilled sourdough bread. Served with chips or greens

    • Peppermint Mocha $

      White or Dark chocolate

    • Snickerdoodle Latte $

    • Ginger Caramel Latte $

    • Winter Fog $

      Peppermint Tea, White Chocolate, and Steamed Milk

    • Peppermint Chai $

    • Frosted White Chocolate Peppermint Shake $5

  • Good Morning, Sunshine!
    • Baked Oatmeal $4.95

      Served with Milk, Featured, blueberry, Traditional Honey (Gluten Free)

    • Cali Bowl $7.15

      Nutty granola in steamed milk, topped with banana, and fresh berries

    • Avo Egg Toast** $6.65

      Multi-grain toast, avocado slices, sunny side up egg, arugula, and sweet sriracha

    • Breakfast Sausage Bowl** $10.15

      Quinoa, millet, amaranth, teff grains, roasted mushrooms, sausage, lemon kale, tomatoes, and Parmesan cheese. Topped with two eggs over easy

    • Buttermilk Pancakes $5.95

      Fluffy buttermilk pancakes, a timeless favorite

    • Maple & Spice French Toast $7.8

      brioche bread dipped in Maple spice batter, cinnamon honey butter and fresh berry garnish

  • Pies
    Our pies are served warm with greens and a savory herb scone. Add: carrot fries or small soup $2.85
    • Tomato Pie $

      Signature Tomato Pie

    • Quiche $8.15

      Baked in our own pie shell, three cheese, featured

    • Tomato Pie $

      Signature Tomato Pie

    • Quiche $8.15

      Baked in our own pie shell three cheese, featured

  • This And That
    • Seasonal Fruit $5.15

    • Rosemary Potatoes $2.75

    • Parmesan Grit Cake $3.15

    • Roasted Butternut Squash $3.25

    • Bacon $2.65

    • Chicken Feta Sausage $2.85

    • Pure Maple Syrup $1.1

    • Mini Chia Pudding $4.25

      vegan gluten-free

  • Muffins
    $3.25
    • Blueberry Lemon Curd

    • Nutella Chocolate Chip

    • Coffee Cake

  • Golden Egg
    Flippers Served with toast and choice of one: Rosemary Potatoes, Parmesan Grit Cake, Butternut Squash, Fresh Fruit or Mixed Greens. Toast choices: Sourdough, Multi-grain, Gluten-free bread $1.50. Egg whites $1.65
    • Tomato Pie Flipper $7.95

      Our signature tomato pie goodness inside flip style eggs

    • Triple Meat Flipper $9.15

      Ham, bacon, sausage, monterey jack, and cheddar cheese

    • Veggie Flipper $8.25

      Spinach, roasted cauliflower, red onion, tomatoes, roasted mushrooms, Monterey Jack and chedder cheese

    • Cali Keto Flipper $10.25

      Bacon, turkey, feta, spinach, avocado and cilantro lime sauce. Served with chia pudding topped with fresh berries (no toast)

    • Classic Egg Dish** $5.95

      Two eggs served with toast and one side

    • Sausage & Squash Hash** $9.25

      Seasoned sausage, roasted butternut squash, and rosemary potato hash topped with two eggs. Served with toast (no sides)

  • Breakfast Sandwiches
    Served with choice of one: Rosemary Potatoes, Parmesan Grit Cake, Butternut Squash, Fresh Fruit or Mixed Greens. Gluten-free bread $1.50
    • Veggie Egg Wrap $9.65

      Eggs, hummus, roasted cauliflower, spinach, red onions, tomatoes, roasted mushrooms, and feta tucked in a wrap

    • Egg & Ham Panini $9.5

      Eggs and ham layered with Vermont cheddar on ciabatta bread. Served with side of pesto mayo

    • Pretzel Breakfast Sandwich $9.65

      Grilled pretzel bun with two fried eggs, Vermont white cheddar, bacon, spinach, and raspberry honey mustard or sweet sriracha sauce

    • Fried Egg & Brie $9.85

      Two fried eggs, arugula, bacon, and raspberry brie on multi-grain toast

  • Lunch
    Served All Day
    • Tomato Bisque $4.95

    • Soup du Jour $4.95

    • Hummus Platter to Share $

      Housemade hummus served with naan bread, cauliflower, carrots, and artichoke Hearts

    • Carrot Fries $6.3

      Thick cut baked carrot fries sprinkled with sea salt and dill sauce for dipping

  • What Is Tomato Pie?
    • What is Tomato Pie? $5.25

      Fresh red tomatoes seasoned perfectly with herbs and baked in our own pie shell topped with a blend of cheeses. It's not Pizza!

  • Bowls
    Served with herb scone (scone is not gluten-free) add: TPC side salad $3.25
    • Spaghetti Squash & Meatballs $11.5

      Spaghetti squash topped with our housemade marinara sauce, spinach feta chicken meatballs, and parmesan cheese

    • Cilantro Lime Bowl $9.95

      Quinoa, millet, amaranth, and teff grains tossed with sautéed spinach, red onions roasted cauliflower, mushrooms, tomatoes, and avocado. Finished with cilantro lime dressing

    • Mac & Cheese Bowl $8.95

      Baked mac and cheese cups on mixed greens. Served with our signature tomato bisque

  • Take Two
    $9.85. Choose two items from the menu with*
    • 1/2 Flatbread

    • 1/2 Sandwich

    • 1/2 Salad

    • Soup

  • Sandwiches
    Sandwiches served with greens or gourmet chips. Sub for carrot fries or small soup $2.85
    • Meatball Parmesan Panini $9.95

      Chicken feta meatballs, red sauce, muenster, Parmesan and Mozzarella cheese on ciabatta bread

    • TPC Grilled Cheese* $8.1

      Muenster & Vermont cheddar cheese on grilled sour dough

    • Turkey Pesto Panini* $9.85

      Mesquite turkey, pesto, tomato, and muenster cheese on multi-grain bread

    • Ham & Brie Panini* $9.5

      Sliced ham, Brie cheese, fresh basil leaves, and raspberry honey mustard. Served on ciabatta bread

    • Pesto Chicken Panini* $9.65

      Chicken, caramelized onions, fresh mozzarella cheese, and pesto on ciabatta bread

    • Curry Chicken Wrap* $8.5

      Chicken, grapes, onion, almonds, and celery in a coconut curry mayo tucked in a wrap

    • Veggie Hummus Wrap* $8.3

      Hummus, spinach, roasted cauliflower, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, red onions all wrapped up

    • Cold Ham or Turkey* $8.25

      Smoked ham or turkey, muenster cheese, and greens on wheat sunflower bread. You choose the sauce: Sweet Sriracha, Pesto Mayo or Raspberry Mustard

  • Naan Flatbreads
    • Veggie Flatbread* $8.95

      Dill sauce, roasted cauliflower, spinach, mushrooms, artichoke hearts, onions, and mozzarella

    • Tomato Pie Flatbread* $8.25

      Our signature tomato pie goodness on warm naan

    • Chicken Butternut Squash Flatbread* $10.85

      Roasted butternut squash, chicken, caramelized onions, and goat cheese Drizzled with balsamic glaze

  • Salads
    Salads are served with our signature savory herb scones. Scones are not Gluten free. Dressing choices: Creamy Parmesan, Raspberry Honey Mustard, House Lemon Olio, Maple Dijon Vinaigrette. All Dressings are gluten-Free
    • Curry Chicken Salad* $8.95

      Chicken, grapes, onion, almonds, and celery in a coconut curry mayo topped with glazed walnuts and tomatoes on mixed greens

    • Kale Cobb Salad $9.85

      Lemon dressed kale, bacon, avocado, tomato, hard boiled egg, butternut squash, feta, and onion

    • TPC House Salad* $6.85

      Carrots, tomatoes, and cheddar Jack served on mixed greens or spinach

  • Salads - Add-Ons
    • Chicken $2.25

    • Bacon $2

    • Hard Boiled Egg $1

    • Avocado $2

  • Burgers
    Served with greens or gourmet chips. Sub for carrot fries or small soup $2.85
    • Rooster Street Beef Burger $11.25

      Local butcher, local farm, grass fed. Cooked medium with sweet sriracha aioli, red onions, tomatoes, and greens on pretzel bun

    • Farmhouse Turkey Burger** $10.5

      Turkey burger topped with muenster cheese, over easy egg, crisp bacon, tomato, and mixed greens on a grilled pretzel bun

    • Balsamic Turkey Burger $9.95

      A flavorful turkey burger on a grilled pretzel bun with balsamic caramelized onions, greens, tomato, and goat cheese

    • Smokey Veggie Burger $9.45

      Signature burger made with beets, cauliflower, garbanzo beans, onions and seasonings. On a vegan bun topped with vegan mayo, spinach, and avocado

  • Burger - Add-Ons
    • Vermont Cheddar $0.75

    • Muenster $0.75

    • Goat Cheese $0.75

    • Caramelized Onions $0.75

    • Roasted Mushrooms $0.75

    • Avocado $0.75

    • Arugula $0.75

    • Gluten Free Bread $1.5

  • Classic
    • House Coffee $2.3

    • Espresso $2.25

    • Americano $3.8

    • Cappuccino $3.05

    • Raw Cappuccino $3.3

    • French Press $

  • Latte
    • Vanilla $

    • Caramel $

    • Sugar & Spice $

    • Mocha $

      white or dark

    • White Lavender Mocha $

  • Tea
    Pot of Tea $3.05, Fogged Tea $3.55, $4.05, Honey Lavender Fog $3.55, $4.05. Loose Leaf Tea
    • Rooibos

    • Earl Grey

    • English Breakfast

    • Peppermint

    • Decaf English Breakfast

    • Green

    • Jasmine

    • Ginger Lemon

    • Herbal Chai

  • Steamer
    • Chai $

    • Golden Chai $

    • Hot Chocolate $

    • Peppermint Hot Chocolate $

    • Matcha $

    • Velvet Beet $

    • Golden Milk $

  • Cold
    • Cold Brew $3.5

    • Cold Brew Milk and Honey $4.5

    • Herb Lemonade $3.05

    • Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $3.05

    • Boylan Sodas $1.95

    • Coke $2.05

    • Diet Coke $2.05

    • Milk $2.05

    • Chocolate Milk $2.95

    • OJ $2.05

    • Apple Juice $2.05

  • Milkshake
    • Chocolate $5

    • Espresso $5

    • Chai $5

    • Frosted White Chocolate Peppermint $5

  • Smoothie
    • Mango $4.55

    • Pineapple $4.55

    • Strawberry $4.55

    • Green Machine $5.3

  • Featured Cakes
    • December: Chocolate Peppermint

      chocolate cake layered with peppermint mousse and covered in chocolate buttercream

    • January: Peanut Butter Tandy Cake

      White cake with peanut butter mousse, covered in chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache drizzle and mini peanut butter cups

    • February: Lets Fall in Love Cake

      Layers of red velvet and white cake, mascarpone mousse, and white chocolate

  • Main
    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Rawcake

      Almond Chocolate crust topped with a creamy peanut Butter cashew base "Cheesecake"

    • Flourless Chocolate Fudge Cake

      gluten-free

    • Cake in a Jar

      Perfect layers of assorted cake flavors, fillings, crumbles, icings and more. Plus you get to keep the glass jar

    • Jumbo Chocolate Salted Caramel Cupcake

      vegan

    • Salted Nutella Cookie Bar

      Brown sugar chewy cookie bar swirled with nutella and sea salt

  • Pies
    • Chocolate Cream

    • Peanut Butter Deluxe

  • Cookies
    • Snickerdoodle

    • Molasses

    • Chocolate Chunk

    • Oatmeal Sunshine

    • Iced Sugar

  • Whoopie Pies
    • Chocolate with Vanilla

    • Peanut Butter Filling

  • Gluten Free Cookies
    • Raspberry Thumbprint

      gluten-free

    • Pecan Shortbread

      vegan gluten-free

  • Sippers
    • Milk $1.75

    • Apple Juice $1.75

    • Orange Juice $1.75

    • Herb Lemonade $1.75

    • Kidccino $2

  • Breakfast
    served until 3pm
    • Kiddo Size Baked Oatmeal $3.4

    • Buttermilk Pancake $3.9

      gluten-free

    • Rainbow French Toast $3.15

    • 1 Egg, 2 Slices Bacon, Potatoes & Rainbow Toast $4.65

    • Chia Pudding $3.45

      dairy-free

    • Fresh Fruit Cup $2.5

  • Lunch & Dinner
    served all day
    • Kiddo Size Soup $2.65

    • PB & J with Chips $3.4

    • Rainbow Grilled Cheese with Chips $4.15

    • Ham or Turkey & Cheese with Chips $4.95

    • 3 Cheese Flatbread Pizza $3.85

    • Baked Mac & Cheese Cup w/ Carrot Fries & Applesauce $4.95

    • Spaghetti Squash w/ Marinara Sauce & Applesauce $4.5

      gluten-free

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.