• Ohio
  • Westerville
  • Barnum & Tibbetts

Barnum & Tibbetts

(614) 899-9720
  • 496 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American ,  Steak
(614) 899-9720
  • Menu
  • Starters
    • Artesian Cheese Selection $12

      dried fruit, assorted nuts

    • Soup Of The Day $5

      chef's selection

    • Tomato, Basil & Artichoke, Soup $5

      parmesan grana, cream

    • Marinated Olives $5

      cheese & crackers

    • Thai Stire Fried Calamari $6

      snow peas, cilantro, peanuts

    • Steamed Mussels $7

      jalapeno tomato butter, scallion lime aioli, crostinis

    • Tuna Sashimi Tacos $8

      mango, avocado, wasabi aioli, tamarind chili sauce

    • Pumpkin Ravioli $7

      brown butter-spiced rum sauce, grilled pears, parmesan grana

    • Beef & Shrimp Satay $8

      sesame cucumber noodles, red miso dip

    • Blackened Sea Scallops $9

      yuzu-mustard vinaigrette, maytag bleu cheese

    • Butternut Squash Gnocchi $7

      roasted chicken, cranberry-pecan chutney

    • Crostinis $12

  • Salads
    • House $5

      maple mustard vinaigrette, spiced walnuts, white cheddar, dried apricot

    • Bibb $7

      bibb lettuce, liquid roquefort, apple wood smoked bacon, tomatoes, scallions

    • Caesar $4

      romaine, radicchio, asiago, parmesan crouton

    • Chop Salad $5

      mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives, almonds, feta cheese, red wine herb vinaigrette

    • Caprese $0

  • Pasta
    • Beef Tenderloin Tips $14

      torchio pasta, green peppercorn sauce, asparagus, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese

    • Jumbo Shrimp & Angel Hair $17

      roasted peppers, pine nuts, baby spinach, lemon zest, virgin olive oil, shaved parmesan grana

    • Grilled Chicken Penne $13

      smoked tomato pesto, portobellos, artichoke hearts, scallions, asiago cheese

  • Seafood
    • Mahi-Mahi $17

      sweet potatoes fries, zucchini noodles, balsamic-maple butter sauce

    • Cracker Crusted Walleye $19

      toasted lemon crab sauce, parsnip scallop potatoes, broccoli

    • Seared Scallop Risotto $18

      sweet peas, yellow squash, radicchio, goat cheese, charred tomato coulis

    • Crispy Salmon $18

      sticky rice cakes, orange-fennel salad, wasabi-giner butter sauce, tamari soy syrup

  • Meats
    our beef is hand selected, dry aged and cut in house. Steaks may be prepared with cracked pepper & green peppercorn sauce for an additional $2 or blackened with lemon-crab sauce for $3
    • Filet Mignon $25

      red onion jam, garlic mashed yukon potatoes, demi sauce

    • New York Strip $28

      roast shiitakes, pearl onions, whipped zinfandel-roguefort, house fries

    • Braised Lamb Shank $21

      natural jus, brussel sprouts, capers, parmesan, mint pesto, mashed yukon gold potatoes

    • Pork Tenderloin $17

      apple braised cabbage, acorn squash, carmalized apple wood bacon, spiced walnut gremolata

    • Veal & Shiitake Mushrooms $19

      sauteed with lemon, capers, parsley, white wine sauce, garlic mashed yukon potatoes

    • Stuffed Chicken Breast $15

      roasted pepper pan sauce, goat cheese, pinenuts, broccoli, yukon gold potatoes

    • Short Ribs $17

      sage cranberry dressing, cider glazed carrots, zinfandel reduction

  • Wines By The Glass - White
    • Chard $7

      hidden mesa, monterey

    • Chard $7.5

      tortoise creek "unoaked", france

    • Chard $9.5

      chateau st. jean, sonoma

    • Chard $13

      joel gott, napa valley

    • Pinot Grigio $6

      biso, italy

    • Pinot Grigio $10

      bollino, italy

    • Sauvignon Blanc $7

      casa lapostolle, rapel valley, chile

    • Sauvignon Blanc $13

      groth, napa valley

    • Riesling $6

      schloss zell, germany

    • Riesling $8

      bonny doon, "paci? c rim" santa cruz, ca

    • Sparkling $8

      "so? a", by coppola, napa valley

    • Sparkling $22

      veuve clicquot, "yellow label" france

  • Wines By The Glass - Red
    • Sangiovese $7

      petraio, italy

    • Chianti $7

      tnuta farneta, italy

    • Pinot Noir $9

      castle rock, sonoma, ca

    • Pinot Noir $15

      au bon climat, snata maria valley, ca

    • Merlot $8

      greyson, paso robles, ca

    • Merlot $9

      st. francis, napa valley

    • Zinfandel $8

      monkey business, sonoma, ca

    • Zinfandel $11

      "zen of zin", sonoma

    • Cabernet $7

      cellar no. 8, ca

    • Cabernet $10

      bishop's peak, ?rock solid red", paso robles, ca

    • Cabernet $13

      sketchbook, mendicino

    • Meritage $10

      steltzner claret, napa valley

    • Cote Du Rhone $7

      gicon le ferme, rhone

    • Malbec $6

      falling star, argentina

    • Shiraz $9

      ferngrove, frankland river, australia

  • Wines By The Bottle - Champagne & Sparkling
    • Brut Dargent $25

      france

    • Roederer Estate $38

      anderson valley

    • Domaine Carneros $45

      by taittinger

    • Nicholas Feuillatte Brut Rose $73

      france

    • Taittinger $81

      “la francaise”, france

    • Veuve Cliquot $88

      “yellow label”, france

    • Dom Perignon $175

      france

  • Wines By The Bottle - Sauvignon Blanc
    • Allan Scott $26

      marlborough, new sealand

    • Mudhouse $27

      marlborough,new zealand

    • Mason $30

      napa valley

    • Pascal Jolivet $38

      sancerre, france

    • Duckhorn $46

      napa valley

    • Crocker & Starr $50

      napa valley

    • Rochioli $51

      russian river

  • Wines By The Bottle - Pinot Grigio, Pinot Gris, & Other Whites
    • Vinum $22

      “chard no way”, chenin blanc, napa valley

    • Esparto $25

      pinot grigio, italy

    • King Estate $27

      pinot gris, oregon

    • Ca'montini $27

      piot griio, italy

    • A To Z $27

      pinot gris, oregon

    • Luna $30

      pinot grigio napa valley

    • Gregory Graham $34

      viognier, napa valley

    • Robert Weil Estate $38

      qba riesling rheingau, germany

    • Gundlachbundschu $42

      gewurztraminer, sonoma, ca

    • Santa Margherita $43

      pinot grigio, italy

  • Wines By The Bottle - Chardonnay
    • Benziger $24

      sonoma

    • Evans & Tate $32

      margaret river, australia

    • Louis Latour $33

      pouilly fuisse, france

    • Napa Cellars $33

      napa valley

    • Domaine Chandon $34

      carneros

    • Clos La Chance $35

      santa cruz mountain

    • Scherrer $42

      aleexander valley

    • Pine Ridge $46

      "dijon clones", carneros

    • Talley $47

      "oliver's vineyard", edna valley, ca

    • Melville $50

      santa rita hills

    • Frank Family $50

      napa valley

    • Rombauer $50

      carnerso

    • Calk Hill $50

      sonoma

    • Ferrari-Carano $55

      carneros

    • Chateau Montelena $62

      napa valley

    • Ramey $65

      russioan river

    • Flowers $69

      sonoma coast

    • Patz & Hall $70

      hyde vineyards, sonoma

    • Far Niente $75

      napa valley

    • Louis Jadot $75

      puligny montrachet, france

    • Kistler $90

      sonoma coast

  • Wines By The Bottle - Half Bottles
    • Domaine Chandon $24

      champagne, napa valley

    • Dolce $123

      dessert, by far niente, napa valley

    • Honig $21

      sauvignon blanc, napa valley

    • Selene $27

      sauvignon blanc, hyde vineyards, napa valley

    • Landmark $26

      chard, "overlook", sonoma

    • Talley $29

      chard, arroyo grande, california

    • Benton Lane $22

      pnot noir, oregon

    • Etude $40

      pinot noir, carneros

    • Rutherfod Hill $27

      merlot, napa valley

    • Havens $27

      merlot, napa valley

    • Storybook $27

      sinfandel, napa valley

    • D Cubed $28

      zinfandel, napa valley

    • Justin $26

      cabernet, paso robles

    • Staglin $65

      cabernet, napa valley

  • Wines By The Bottle - Pinot Noir
    • Gino Da Pinot $24

      monterey

    • Joseph Voillot $123

      burgundy, france

    • Dan Jean-Barthaux $21

      givry, france

    • Acacia $27

      carneros

    • Cristom $26

      "mt. jefferson", oregon

    • Saintsbury $29

      carneros

    • David Bruce $22

      sonoma

    • Zd $40

      carneros

    • Four Graces $27

      willamette valley

    • Domaine Drouhin $27

      oregon

    • Etude $27

      carneros

    • Rochioli $28

      russian river

    • Patz & Hall $26

      alder springs

    • Domaine Serene $65

      willamette valley

  • Wines By The Bottle - Merlot
    • Sagelands $25

      washington

    • Franciscan $30

      napa valley

    • Whitehall Lane $46

      napa valley

    • Swanson $55

      napa valley

    • Frog’s leap $65

      napa valley

    • Paradigm $72

      napa valley

    • Selene $72

      napa valley

    • Duckhorn $82

      napa valley

    • Duckhorn $116

      3 palms, napa valley

  • Wines By The Bottle - Zinfandel
    • Graziano $27

      mendocino

    • St. Francis $32

      "old vines", sonoma

    • Rosenblum $33

      "appellation series" san francisco

    • Hendry $55

      "block 7", napa valley

    • Brown Estate $66

      napa valley

    • Biale $76

      "aldos vineyard,", napa valley

    • Nickel & Nickel $78

      "ponzo", russian river

  • Wines By The Bottle - Cabernet Sauvignon And Meritage
    • Los Vascos $30

      "reserve," chile

    • Montes $35

      "alpha," chile

    • Cinnabar $35

      "mercury rising", california

    • Bordeauz $40

      ch. siaurac, pomerol, france

    • White Oak $42

      napa valley

    • Simi $42

      sonoma

    • Paul Hobbs $43

      "cocodrillo", mendoza, argentina

    • Cain Cuvee $43

      napa valley

    • Bennett Lane $50

      "maximus", napa valley

    • Bonny Doon $50

      "cigar volant", santa cruz

    • Sequoia Grove $53

      napa valley

    • Cafaro $65

      napa valley

    • Silverado $67

      napa valley

    • Rocket Science $67

      "formula 103", napa valley

    • Mount Veeder $68

      napa valley

    • Turnbull $70

      napa valley

    • Crocker & Starr Cab Franc $70

      napa valley

    • Heitz $70

      napa valley

    • Joseph Phelps $75

      napa valley

    • Jordan $77

      alexander valley

    • Faust $78

      by quintessa, napa valley

    • Paradigm $82

      napa valley

    • Ristow $85

      napa valley

    • Shafer $90

      napa valley

    • Justin $90

      "isosceles", paso robles

    • Corison $93

      napa valley

    • Showkett $93

      napa valley

    • Selene $98

      napa valley

    • Silver Oak $105

      alexander valley

    • Nickel & Nickel $128

      "rock cairn", napa valley

    • Silver Oak $146

      napa valley

    • Far Niente $263

      "cave collection", napa valley 1996

    • Heitz $282

      "martha's vineyard", napa valley 1997

    • Far Niente $400

      "cave collection", napa valley 1997

  • Wines By The Bottle - Syrah And Shiraz
    • Wishing Tree $25

      australia

    • Havens $33

      napa valley

    • D'arenberg $33

      "the footbolt", australia

    • Cliff Edge $35

      "mount langi ghiran", australia

    • Elderton $49

      australia

    • August Briggs $58

      napa valley

    • Palmeri $75

      "stagecoach vineyard", napa valley

    • Neyers $82

      "hudson vineyard", napa valley

  • Wines By The Bottle - Wines Of The World
    • Dolcetto ?D' Alba $29

      mauro veglio, italy

    • Rioja $37

      palacious romondo, spain

    • Rioja $38

      muga, spain

    • Chianti $38

      le corti, italy

    • Chauteauneuf Du Pape $42

      lazaret, france

    • Montefalco Rosso $42

      caprai, umbria, italy

    • Barbaresco $50

      marchesi ?d' gresy, piedmont, italy 1996

    • Bandol $63

      domaine tempier rouge, france

    • Barolo $69

      chiarlo, italy

    • Amarone $81

      masi, italy

    • Gaja Sito Moresco $82

      italy

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.