Allmenus.com
  • Ohio
  • Tiffin
  • Carmella's

Carmella's

(419) 448-7699

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 2458 S State Route 231, Tiffin, OH 44883
  • Restaurant website
  • Italian
  • Carmella's

  • (419) 448-7699
  • Main
  • Dinner
  • Salads
    • Garden Salad $3.95+

      a blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce with onions, tomatoes and italian croutons

    • Pasta Salad $2.95+

      pasta tossed with italian tomatoes, peppers and onions in a garlic herb dressing with fresh basil.

    • Caesar Salad $5.95+

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Caesar Salad $7.95+

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Caesar Salad $8.95+

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Pomodoro E Cipolla $5.95+

      tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil with balsamic vinegar and olive oil, served over fresh mixed greens

    • Carmella's Salad $5.95+

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Carmella's Salad $7.95+

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Carmella's Salad $9.95+

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Chicken Tender Salad $8.95

      fried, breaded chicken tenders, green onions, bacon, tomato and cheddar cheese over crisp romaine lettuce with honey dijon dressing

    • Beefeater Salad $9.95

      grilled marinated steak with sauteed mushrooms and onions served over romaine lettuce

  • Sandwiches
    sandwiches may be plattered for an additional $1.95. sides include choice of one: french fries, onion rings, gardened or pasta salad.
    • Italian Sausage Wrap $5.95

      andouille sausage, capicolla ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and mozzarella cheese, rolled in a flour tortilla

    • Chicken Wrap $6.95

      flour tortilla filled with chicken, crisp bacon, tomato, lettuce, cheddar and aioli

    • Grilled Vegetable Wrap $5.95

      chargrilled mushrooms, red bell peppers, eggplant, tomato and zucchini, glazed with balsamic vinegar then rolled in a flour tortilla, finished with briw cheese

    • Turkey Reuben $7.95

      premium turkey breast, cole slaw, 1000 island dressing, and swiss cheese, served on swirled rye

    • Chargrilled Chopped Steak $3.95+

      served on a kaiser bun with a side of tomato, onion & lettuce.

    • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich $7.95

      chargrilled boneless breast of chicken, baked with marinara and mozzarella, served on toasted foccacia bread.

    • Meatball Sub $6.95

      carmella's homemade meatballs in our signature sauce, baked with mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted sub bun

    • Italian Sub $6.95

      capicolla ham, salami and pepperoni baked with mozzarella cheese and creamy italian dressing garnished with lettuce and roma tomatoes served on a toasted sub bun

    • Northern Italy Chicken & Basil Sandwich $6.95

      baked italian style diced chicken seasoned with basil, mozzarella cheese and onion, served on a toasted sub bun

  • Appetizers
    • Buffalo Bread $7.95

      toasted italian bread topped with pesto sauce, prosciutto ham, fresh melted mozzarella cheese and grilled tomatoes

    • Spinach And Asiago Dip $6.95

      a delightful blend of cream cheese, spinach and asiago cheese, heated and served in a bread bowl

    • Bruschetta $5.97

      toasted italian bread served with a mixture of onions, tomatoes and mushrooms, splashed with balsamic vinegar and olive oil

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.95

      breaded mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce

    • Carmella's Nachos $7.95

      corn tortillas topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, black olives, green onions, jalapenos, salsa, guacamole, and sour cream

    • Fried Calamari $6.97

      breaded calamari served with garlic aioli sauce

    • Combo Platter $9.95

      broccoli cheese balls, breaded chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, breaded calamari and ravioli served with marinara and garlic aioli sauce

    • Fried Olives $5.95

      parmesan stuffed kalamata olives, breaded and fried until golden

    • GArlic Bread $6.95

      garlic butter spread on italian bread, covered with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses and baked with roma tomatoes

    • Chicken Tenders $7.95

      breaded chicken tenders served with your choice of ranch, honey mustard, or hot sauce

    • Shrimp Cocktail $8.95

      classic chilled jumbo shrimp, served with zesty cocktail sauce

    • Cheezy Fries $6.95

      french fries topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, and scallions

  • Sides
    • French Fries $2.95

    • Onion ings $2.95

    • Vegetables $2.95

    • Redskins $2.95

    • Gnocchi $2.95

    • Cottage Cheese $2.95

    • Meatballs $2.95

    • Vegetable Of The Day $2.95

    • Cole Slaw $2.95

    • Pasta Salad $2.95

    • Baked Potato $2.95

    • Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions $2.95

    • Garden Salad $2.95

    • Fresh Fruit $3.95

  • Soups
    • Soup Of The Day $3.97

      tomato, red pepper tortellini

  • Drinks
    non-alchoholic
    • Orange Juice

    • Cranberry Juice

    • Pepsi

    • Diet Pepsi

    • 7-Up

    • Pink Lemonade

    • Mr. Dew

    • Ice Tea

    • Hot Tea

    • Hot Chocolate

    • Coffee

    • Special Coffee

      espresso, cappuccino, larre, mocha

    • Flavored Coffee

      caramel, vanilla, almond, hazelnut, raspberry

  • Pasta
    all entrees served with soup or salad
    • Create A Personalized Dish

      be the chef... create a personalized dish by choosing your own pasta, sauce and special ingredients. contact us for options.

    • Ravioli $7.97+

      filled ravioli in marinara sauce

    • Ravioli $8.97+

      filled ravioli in marinara sauce with meat sauce

    • Manicotti $6.97+

      filled pasta rolls baked in marinara sauce

    • Manicotti $7.97+

      filled pasta rolls baked in marinara sauce with meat sauce

    • Lasagna $7.97+

      sausage and beef layered between lasagna noodles with ricotta, mozzarella and red sauce

    • Vegetarian Lasagna $7.97+

      a medley of fresh vegetables baked with italian cheese in layers of lasagna

  • Steaks & Chops
    all entrees served with soup or salad. market price.
    • Strip Steak

      finest 12 oz. centercut new york strip steak, chargrilled to perfection, served with a baked potato

    • Sirloin Steak

      juicy 10 oz. chargrilled sirloin steak served with a baked potato

    • Ribeye Steak

      carmella's 12 oz. house ribeye steak chargrilled and served with a baked potato

    • Pizzalo Style Steak

      add $2.95 to market. smothered with grilled mushrooms shallots, tomatoes, zucchini and our signature sauce topped with mozzarella & baked to perfection

    • Hardwood Smoked Pork Chop

      bone in pork chop grilled to perfection served with your choice of a side.

  • Dinner
    all entrees served with soup or salad.
    • Parmesan Encrusted Orange Rouglry $14.95

      mild white fish topped with a blend of parmesan cheese, red bell peppers and mayonnaise then baked to a golden crust, served with wild rice

    • Carmella's Crab Cakes $15.95

      a blend of crabmeat, onions, red bell peppers and seasonings, baked and deep fried, served on angel hair pasta with lobster cream sauce

    • Chicken Parmesan $12.95

      boneless breast of chicken, sauteed then baked in a marinara with a blend of cheeses, served over a bed of pasta

    • Chicken Marsala $14.97

      boneless breast of chicken, sauteed in garlic with mushrooms, leeks and tomatoes in a marsala cream sauce, served over a bed of pasta

    • Frangelico Chicken $15.95

      boneless breast of chicken sauteed with toasted almonds and deglazed with frangelico, served with parmesan redskin potatoes

    • Hot & $15.95

    • Hot & Spicy Chicken Pasta $13.97

      sauteed boneless chicken breast, cajun sausage and penne pasta, tossed together in a spicy tomato sauce with chargrilled onions, peppers and tomatoes

    • Shrimp & Chicken Pasta $13.97

      grilled boneless chicken breast and shrimp with cheese tortellini and leeks, baked in an asiago cream sauce

    • Veal Marsala $16.97

      cutlets of veal, sauteed in garlic with mushrooms, leeks and tomatoes in marsala cream sauce, served over fettuccine pasta

    • Veal Parmesan $15.95

      breaded cutlets of veal, sauteed, then baked in marinara with a blend of cheeses, served over lettuccine pasta

    • Chicken Saltimbocca $13.97

      boneless breast of chicken, with prosciutto, sage, and gouda cheese, served over wild rice

    • Risotto

      an italian rice specialty, slowly cooked, resulting in rice that is delicately creamy yet firm. risotto may be flavored with a variety of ingredients such as seafood, vegetables, poultry of fresh herbs. please ask your server for our daily featured risotto.

  • Specialty Desserts
    • Specialty Desserts

      ask your server to see our full line of delicious desserts

Menu for Carmella's provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.