• Ohio
  • Tiffin
  • Carmella's

Carmella's

(419) 448-7699
  • 2458 S State Route 231, Tiffin, OH 44883
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Italian
(419) 448-7699
  • Main
  • Dinner
  • Salads
    • Garden Salad $3.95

      a blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce with onions, tomatoes and italian croutons

    • Pasta Salad $2.95

      pasta tossed with italian tomatoes, peppers and onions in a garlic herb dressing with fresh basil.

    • Caesar Salad $5.95

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Caesar Salad $7.95

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Caesar Salad $8.95

      romaine lettuce tossed with creamy anchovy pepper and parmesan dressing with italian croutons and tomatoes.

    • Pomodoro E Cipolla $5.95

      tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil with balsamic vinegar and olive oil, served over fresh mixed greens

    • Carmella's Salad $5.95

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Carmella's Salad $7.95

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Carmella's Salad $9.95

      fresh mixed greens tossed in wild berry vinaigrette with pancetta bacon, gorgonzola cheese, roma tomatoes and walnuts.

    • Chicken Tender Salad $8.95

      fried, breaded chicken tenders, green onions, bacon, tomato and cheddar cheese over crisp romaine lettuce with honey dijon dressing

    • Beefeater Salad $9.95

      grilled marinated steak with sauteed mushrooms and onions served over romaine lettuce

  • Sandwiches
    sandwiches may be plattered for an additional $1.95. sides include choice of one: french fries, onion rings, gardened or pasta salad.
    • Italian Sausage Wrap $5.95

      andouille sausage, capicolla ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and mozzarella cheese, rolled in a flour tortilla

    • Chicken Wrap $6.95

      flour tortilla filled with chicken, crisp bacon, tomato, lettuce, cheddar and aioli

    • Grilled Vegetable Wrap $5.95

      chargrilled mushrooms, red bell peppers, eggplant, tomato and zucchini, glazed with balsamic vinegar then rolled in a flour tortilla, finished with briw cheese

    • Turkey Reuben $7.95

      premium turkey breast, cole slaw, 1000 island dressing, and swiss cheese, served on swirled rye

    • Chargrilled Chopped Steak $3.95

      served on a kaiser bun with a side of tomato, onion & lettuce.

    • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich $7.95

      chargrilled boneless breast of chicken, baked with marinara and mozzarella, served on toasted foccacia bread.

    • Meatball Sub $6.95

      carmella's homemade meatballs in our signature sauce, baked with mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted sub bun

    • Italian Sub $6.95

      capicolla ham, salami and pepperoni baked with mozzarella cheese and creamy italian dressing garnished with lettuce and roma tomatoes served on a toasted sub bun

    • Northern Italy Chicken & Basil Sandwich $6.95

      baked italian style diced chicken seasoned with basil, mozzarella cheese and onion, served on a toasted sub bun

  • Appetizers
    • Buffalo Bread $7.95

      toasted italian bread topped with pesto sauce, prosciutto ham, fresh melted mozzarella cheese and grilled tomatoes

    • Spinach And Asiago Dip $6.95

      a delightful blend of cream cheese, spinach and asiago cheese, heated and served in a bread bowl

    • Bruschetta $5.97

      toasted italian bread served with a mixture of onions, tomatoes and mushrooms, splashed with balsamic vinegar and olive oil

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.95

      breaded mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce

    • Carmella's Nachos $7.95

      corn tortillas topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, black olives, green onions, jalapenos, salsa, guacamole, and sour cream

    • Fried Calamari $6.97

      breaded calamari served with garlic aioli sauce

    • Combo Platter $9.95

      broccoli cheese balls, breaded chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, breaded calamari and ravioli served with marinara and garlic aioli sauce

    • Fried Olives $5.95

      parmesan stuffed kalamata olives, breaded and fried until golden

    • GArlic Bread $6.95

      garlic butter spread on italian bread, covered with mozzarella and parmesan cheeses and baked with roma tomatoes

    • Chicken Tenders $7.95

      breaded chicken tenders served with your choice of ranch, honey mustard, or hot sauce

    • Shrimp Cocktail $8.95

      classic chilled jumbo shrimp, served with zesty cocktail sauce

    • Cheezy Fries $6.95

      french fries topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, and scallions

  • Sides
    • French Fries $2.95

    • Onion ings $2.95

    • Vegetables $2.95

    • Redskins $2.95

    • Gnocchi $2.95

    • Cottage Cheese $2.95

    • Meatballs $2.95

    • Vegetable Of The Day $2.95

    • Cole Slaw $2.95

    • Pasta Salad $2.95

    • Baked Potato $2.95

    • Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions $2.95

    • Garden Salad $2.95

    • Fresh Fruit $3.95

  • Soups
    • Soup Of The Day $3.97

      tomato, red pepper tortellini

  • Drinks
    non-alchoholic
    • Orange Juice $0

    • Cranberry Juice $0

    • Pepsi $0

    • Diet Pepsi $0

    • 7-Up $0

    • Pink Lemonade $0

    • Mr. Dew $0

    • Ice Tea $0

    • Hot Tea $0

    • Hot Chocolate $0

    • Coffee $0

    • Special Coffee $0

      espresso, cappuccino, larre, mocha

    • Flavored Coffee $0

      caramel, vanilla, almond, hazelnut, raspberry

  • Pasta
    all entrees served with soup or salad
    • Create A Personalized Dish $0

      be the chef... create a personalized dish by choosing your own pasta, sauce and special ingredients. contact us for options.

    • Ravioli $7.97

      filled ravioli in marinara sauce

    • Ravioli $8.97

      filled ravioli in marinara sauce with meat sauce

    • Manicotti $6.97

      filled pasta rolls baked in marinara sauce

    • Manicotti $7.97

      filled pasta rolls baked in marinara sauce with meat sauce

    • Lasagna $7.97

      sausage and beef layered between lasagna noodles with ricotta, mozzarella and red sauce

    • Vegetarian Lasagna $7.97

      a medley of fresh vegetables baked with italian cheese in layers of lasagna

  • Steaks & Chops
    all entrees served with soup or salad. market price.
    • Strip Steak

      finest 12 oz. centercut new york strip steak, chargrilled to perfection, served with a baked potato

    • Sirloin Steak

      juicy 10 oz. chargrilled sirloin steak served with a baked potato

    • Ribeye Steak

      carmella's 12 oz. house ribeye steak chargrilled and served with a baked potato

    • Pizzalo Style Steak

      add $2.95 to market. smothered with grilled mushrooms shallots, tomatoes, zucchini and our signature sauce topped with mozzarella & baked to perfection

    • Hardwood Smoked Pork Chop

      bone in pork chop grilled to perfection served with your choice of a side.

  • Dinner
    all entrees served with soup or salad.
    • Parmesan Encrusted Orange Rouglry $14.95

      mild white fish topped with a blend of parmesan cheese, red bell peppers and mayonnaise then baked to a golden crust, served with wild rice

    • Carmella's Crab Cakes $15.95

      a blend of crabmeat, onions, red bell peppers and seasonings, baked and deep fried, served on angel hair pasta with lobster cream sauce

    • Chicken Parmesan $12.95

      boneless breast of chicken, sauteed then baked in a marinara with a blend of cheeses, served over a bed of pasta

    • Chicken Marsala $14.97

      boneless breast of chicken, sauteed in garlic with mushrooms, leeks and tomatoes in a marsala cream sauce, served over a bed of pasta

    • Frangelico Chicken $15.95

      boneless breast of chicken sauteed with toasted almonds and deglazed with frangelico, served with parmesan redskin potatoes

    • Hot & $15.95

    • Hot & Spicy Chicken Pasta $13.97

      sauteed boneless chicken breast, cajun sausage and penne pasta, tossed together in a spicy tomato sauce with chargrilled onions, peppers and tomatoes

    • Shrimp & Chicken Pasta $13.97

      grilled boneless chicken breast and shrimp with cheese tortellini and leeks, baked in an asiago cream sauce

    • Veal Marsala $16.97

      cutlets of veal, sauteed in garlic with mushrooms, leeks and tomatoes in marsala cream sauce, served over fettuccine pasta

    • Veal Parmesan $15.95

      breaded cutlets of veal, sauteed, then baked in marinara with a blend of cheeses, served over lettuccine pasta

    • Chicken Saltimbocca $13.97

      boneless breast of chicken, with prosciutto, sage, and gouda cheese, served over wild rice

    • Risotto

      an italian rice specialty, slowly cooked, resulting in rice that is delicately creamy yet firm. risotto may be flavored with a variety of ingredients such as seafood, vegetables, poultry of fresh herbs. please ask your server for our daily featured risotto.

  • Specialty Desserts
    • Specialty Desserts $0

      ask your server to see our full line of delicious desserts

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.