Allmenus.com
  • Ohio
  • Sandusky
  • Thirsty Pony Restaurant

Thirsty Pony Restaurant

(419) 626-6761

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 1935 Cleveland Rd, Sandusky, OH 44870
  • Restaurant website
  • American ,  Burgers ,  Pizza ,  Sandwiches
  • $$$$$
  • Thirsty Pony Restaurant

  • (419) 626-6761
  • Menu
  • Super Starters
    • Lobster Bisque $10.95

      Served in a sourdough bread bowl

    • French Onion Soup $9.00

      Served in a crock and topped with cheese

    • Old Fashioned Chili $6.95

      Topped with mexican cheese & served with a trio of jalapenos, onions & sour cream on the side

    • Mozzaluna $8.00

      1/2 moons of deep fried mozzarella on a bed of red sauce

    • Onion Haystacks $7.00

      Battered sweet onions served with dippin sauce

    • Spinach Artichoke Dip $10.50

      Served in a bread with tri-colored nacho chips

    • Frickin' Chicken Dip $10.00

      Shredded frickin' chicken in a creamy wing sauce served with tri-colored nacho chips

    • Rice Fritters $10.00

      Six pack of rice balls in a trio of flavors: pesto, marinara & primavera

    • Tangy Red Pepper Poppers $8.00

      Breaded red jalapeno peppers stuffed with tangy chili cream cheese

    • Sauerkraut Balls $6.95

      Made from scratch, stuffed with sausage and kraut, and served with bistro sauce

    • Fried Pickles $6.95

      Dill pickle spears and spicy pickle chips, breaded and served with ranch dressing

    • Fried Green Beans $6.95

      Battered & fried & served with teriyaki dippin sauce

    • Fried Green Tomatoes $6.95

      Ripe green tomatoes breaded and deep fried, topped with pepper relish

    • Southwestern Egg Rolls $8.00

      A crispy flour tortilla filled with chicken, black beans, corn, jalapeno jack cheese, red peppers and spinach, served with ranch dressing

    • Jumbo Soft Pretzels $7.00

      Four jumbo soft pretzel sticks served with hot goopy cheese

    • Strip Tease Chicken $9.00

      Chicken strips & fries with BBQ, ranch or honey mustard sauce

    • Mini Cheeseburgers $9.00

      Three mini burgers served on a brioche bun topped with cheese & garnished with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle

  • Something Fishy Starters
    • Petite Perch $14.00

      Lake erie perch served with tartar sauce

    • Walleye Fingers $14.00

      Lake erie walleye served with tartar sauce

    • Coconut Shrimp $8.95

      Coconut shrimp served with a creamy coconut dipping sauce

    • Key West Shrimp Taco Trio $10.00

      Three soft shell tacos stuffed with coconut breaded shrimp, cilantro slaw, queso, tomatoes and topped with fresh avocado

  • Salads
    Salad dressings house italian, avocado ranch, cilantro lime, russian, creamy parmesan, bleu cheese, ranch, thousand island, creamy italian, light italian, sweet & sour, oil & vinegar.
    • House Salad $7.95

      A mix fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, marbled cheese, cucumbers, croutons and your choice of salad dressing. Add grilled chicken $4.00

    • Wedge Salad $9.95

      A wedge iceberg lettuce topped with crispy bacon, crumbled blue cheese, tomatoes and green goddess dressing

    • Taco Salad $10.95

      Romaine lettuce topped with taco beef, cheeses, black olives, tomatoes, green onions, salsa and sour cream served in a tortilla shell

    • Chef Salad $11.95

      A mix of fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, marbled cheese, cucumbers, ham, turkey, croutons and your choice of salad dressing

    • Frickin' Shrimp Salad By Fricker's $12.95

      A jumbo house salad topped with our crispy breaded shrimp served in your choice of wing sauce

    • Chicken Pepper Pasta Salad $12.95

      Grilled chicken, onions, red & green peppers over a bed of pasta and mixed greens

    • Grilled Black & Blue Steak House $12.95

      A mix of fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, croutons, crumbled bleu cheese, grilled and your choice of salad dressing

    • Chicken Caesar Salad $12.95

      Romaine lettuce, croutons and parmesan cheese topped with grilled chicken and our own creamy caesar dressing

    • Spinach Salad

      Baby spinach, applewood bacon, hard boiled eggs & red onions tossed in hot bacon dressing

    • Avocado & Chicken Spinach Salad $12.95

      Baby spinach, avocado, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, almonds and chopped grilled chicken with french celery seed better dressing

  • Flatbread Pizzatizers
    • Philly Cheese Steak Flatbread $10.00

      Philly cheese steak sauteed with peppers, mushrooms & onions & topped with mozzarella & provolone cheese on garlic buttered flatbread

    • Spinach Artichoke Flatbread $10.00

      Garlic buttered flatbread with creamy spinach & artichoke topped with tomatoes & parmesan cheese on garlic buttered flatbread

    • Cheesy Portobello Flatbread $10.00

      Marinated slices of portobello mushrooms topped with mozzarella, provolone & parmesan cheese on garlic buttered flatbread

    • Cheeseburger Flatbread $10.00

      Hamburger and melted cheddar cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, ketchup and mustard on a buttered flatbread

  • One Potato, Two Potato, Three Potato
    • Loaded Potato Skins $9.00

      Cheese, onions, black olives & bacon

    • Homemade Potato Chips $7.50

      Served with french onion chip dip

    • Italiano Style Potato Chips $8.50

      Drenched in a fresh buttery garlic sauce, topped with chives & parmesan cheese

    • Loaded Tater Pufffs $8.00

      Topped with cheese, bacon, sour cream and chives

    • Beer Battered French Fries $6.00

    • Tater Puffs $6.00

    • Goopy Cheesy Fries $7.00

    • Chili Cheese Fries $8.00

    • Potato Trio Sampler $8.00

      Sweet potato fries, beer battered french fries and tater puffs served with creamy brown sugar sauce, bourbon molasses and cheese sauce

    • Sweet Potato Waffle Fries $7.00

      Dusted in cinnamon sugar & served with a creamy brown sugar dippin sauce

  • Nacho Ordinary Part of the Menu
    • Super Nachos $15.00

      XXL nachos loaded with cheese, olives, taco meat or chicken, onions, tomatoes, jalapenos, refried beans, & anything else we can find-plenty to share. Served with salsa and sour cream. Guacamole upon request

    • Super Nachos 1/2 Order $10.00

      XXL nachos loaded with cheese, olives, taco meat or chicken, onions, tomatoes, jalapenos, refried beans, & anything else we can find-plenty to share. Served with salsa and sour cream. Guacamole upon request

    • Chicken Quesadillas $8.95

      Cheese, chicken, tomatoes & green onions grilled between tortillas served with sour cream and salsa. Guacamole upon request.

    • Steak Quesadillas $9.95

      Cheese, steak, tomatoes, black beans and green onions, grilled between tortillas served with sour cream and salsa. Guacamole upon request.

    • Carnitas Tostadas Stack $9.95

      Layers of seasoned pork, cheese, tomatoes, onions, cilantro slaw, avocados, queso, lettuce, rice, black beans and topped with jalapenos. Served with salsa & sour cream.

    • Queso $8.00

      Spicy south of the border cheese dip served with a warm tri-colored tortilla chips and salsa.

    • Guacamole, Chips & Salse $7.00

  • Frickin' Chicken Wings & Chunks
    Mix & match any 2 sauces together for your own flavor. Frickin' sauce: sweet teriyaki, bbq, candied chili pepper, cracked pepper parmesan, medium, garlic parmesan, hot, lonely pony honey garlic, hot honey mustard, spicy chipotle, little kicker, kicker, bbq killer, killer, frickin' x-scream. Frickin' sauces available by the bottle to go. Celery & carrots, bleu cheese, or ranch for $0.99 each
    • World Famous Frickin' Chicken Wings 10 Pieces $9.00

    • World Famous Frickin' Chicken Wings 20 Pieces $16.00

    • World Famous Frickin' Chicken Wings 50 Pieces $35.00

    • 30 Wing Sampler $23.00

      30 frickin' chicken wings in your choice of three frickin' sauces. Wings served naked upon request no breading. Drums only, add per 10 $1.00

    • Frickin' Chicken Chunks $8.95

      No bones about it. 10 ounces of tender chunks of chicken tossed in your favorite wing sauce

  • Gourmet Pizza
    A delicious thick crust-crispy on the outside, puffy on the inside, topped with mounds and mounds of cheese.
    • Create Your Own Pizza $13.95+

      Free unlimited toppings: pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, salami, mushrooms, black olives, onions, green olives, tomatoes, broccoli, green peppers, banana peppers, jalapenos, sauerkraut & pineapple

    • Pizza Margarita $13.95+

      Mozzarella & provolone cheese, garlic, basil, olive oil & slices of tomatoes

    • Frickin' Chicken Pizza $13.95+

      Mama frickin' mia-topped with fricker's chicken, your choice of wing sauce, with monterey and marble cheese. banana peppers upon request

    • Alfredo Chicken Pizza $13.95+

      Mozzarella, provolone, alfredo sauce and grilled chciken

    • Sweet Pig Pizza $13.95+

      Pizza sauce, pineapple, ham, bacon and red onions topped with mozzarella & provolone

    • The Bacon Ranch Chicken Pizza $13.95+

      Ranch dressing topped with fried chicken, bacon, cheddar, monterey jack, mozzarella and provolone cheese

    • Chicken & Broccoli Pizza $13.95+

      Rilled chicken, broccoli, diced tomatoes, cheddar, monterey jack, parmesan, mozzarella & provolone cheeses on a garlic butter crust

    • Pony Pizzalad $18.95

      Is it a pizza, is it a salad, it's both, a regular large pizza with a hole in it. Enjoy a double crust pizza with your choice of toppings with a centerpiece salad tossed in our homemade house sweet italian vinaigrette

  • Chicago Style Deep Dish Personal Pizza
    Standing three inches tall & six inches wide and hailing from chicago
    • Deep Dish Personal Pizza $10.00

      A deep dish thick crust with your choice of up to three toppings

    • Deep Dish Personal Pizza & Salad $14.00

      Your personal deep dish pizza with a side salad

    • Deep Dish Personal Pizza & Wings $15.00

      Your personal deep dish pizza with a side of five wings

  • Belly Buster Burger
    Belly buster burgers are 1/2 lb. Of fresh hand packed quality beef, cooked on the grill for maximum flavor & topped with lettuce, tomato & onion. All burgers are served on a kaiser bun with a bag of potato chips, coleslaw and a fried dill pickled. Substitute wedge, curly or sweet potato fries for just $2.00
    • Bald Burger $8.50

      Plain, no topping on a scored brioche bun

    • Goopy Cheese Burger $9.50

      A four-towel burger smothered in hot goopy cheese on a scored brioche bun

    • Bleu Streak Burger $9.50

      Topped with creamy & crumbled bleu cheese on a scored brioche bun

    • Whiskey Burger $9.50

      Topped with sauteed onions, our tangy jack daniel's BBQ sauce & american cheese on a scored brioche bun

    • Patty Melt $9.50

      Topped with american & swiss cheese and sauteed onions served on grilled marbled rye bread

    • The Thirsty Bam Burger $9.95

      Our signature burger ground with a touch of horseradish and fresh garlic, seasoned with salt, pepper & steak sauce, topped with swiss & mozzarella cheeses on ciabatta bread

    • Cluck Cluck Burger $9.50

      Not just for breakfast anymore, topped with a fried egg, bacon & american cheese on a pretzel bun

    • Chubby Hubby Burger $13.00

      A double decker topped with american & swiss cheeses & bacon on a scored brioche bun

    • Baby Chubby Burger $10.00

      A smaller version of the chubby hubby-1/2 lb. double decker topped with american & swiss cheese & bacon on a scored brioche bun

    • M & M Burger $9.50

      Topped with mozzarella & mushrooms on a scored brioche bun

    • Philly Burger $9.50

      Philly style with mozzarella cheese, sauteed green, red peppers & onions on a scored brioche bun

    • Bacon Burger $9.50

      Piled high with applewood bacon, lettuce & tomato on a pretzel bun

    • Bubba Burger $10.00

      Topped with grilled salami, mozzarella and creamy italian dressing served on ciabatta bread

    • Pepper Jack Cajun Burger $10.00

      Topped with pepper jack cheese, cajun seasoning and grilled peppers on a scored brioche bun

    • Guacamole Bacon Burger $10.50

      Topped with zesty guacamole, bacon pepper jack cheese on a pretzel bun

    • Mac & Cheese Burger $10.00

      Topped with mac & cheese and crumbled bacon on a brioche bun

  • Snooty Burgers
    For our guests with a more discerning palate. Our crew builds these burgers bigger, a minimum of 50% more beef. Snooties are kicked up a notch with gourmet toppings and are served on a brioche bun topped with spring mix artisan lettuce, tomato, onion, our signature fried dill pickle, and are served with a side of slaw and homemade potato chips.
    • Snooty M.O.B. Cheese Burger $14.00

      1 lb. burger topped with american & mozzarella cheese, bacon & our own bistro sauce. This is the mother of all burgers

    • Snooty Shroom Burger $14.00

      3/4 lb. burger ground with sausage & hamburger meat topped with swiss cheese, portobella mushrooms & a parmesan spread

    • Snooty S.O.B. Burger $14.00

      3/4 lb. burger stuffed with crumbled bacon, topped with sauteed onions, smoked gouda cheese, strips of applewood bacon & a horseradish steak house mayo

  • Pot Belly Sandwiches
    Sandwiches so big you might have to use a fork. Sandwiches served with a bag of potato chips, pasta salad and a fried dill pickle. Substitute wedge, curly or sweet potato fries for just $2.00
    • Pulled Pork BBQ Sandwich $9.00

      Traditional southern pulled pork smothered in fricker's BBQ sauce and served on ciabatta bread

    • Sloppy Pig $10.00

      Pulled pork with cheddar macaroni and cheese on a toasted hoagie bun

    • Toasted Philly Cheese Steak $10.00

      Sliced philly steak with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms and hot cheddar then topped with mozzarella cheese-all on a toasted hoagie bun

    • Reuben $9.50

      Kosher style corned beef, swiss cheese topped with sauerkraut and thousand island dressing served on grilled marbled rye bread

    • Reuben Gobbler $9.50

      Sliced turkey topped with swiss cheese, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing served on grilled marbled rye bread

    • New Yorker $9.50

      Kosher style corned beef topped with swiss cheese & homemade cole slaw on grilled marbled rye bread

    • Deli Stack Cuben $10.00

      Turkey, corned beef & ham topped with swiss & mozzarella, pickles & spicy mustard on ciabatta bread

    • Perch Sandwich $11.50

      Lake erie yellow perch with tartar sauce on a dusted kaiser bun

    • Walleye Sandwich $10.95

      Lake erie yellow served with tartar sauce on a dusted kaiser bun.

    • Toasted Italian Hoagie $10.00

      Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, & mozzarella with tomato, shredded lettuce, onion and creamy italian dressing on a toasted hoagie

    • Prime Rib French Dip $10.50

      Sliced prime rib, horseradish sauce, provolone cheese on a hoagie and french onion au jus for dunking

    • BL & Fried Green Tomato $9.50

      Applewood bacon, lettuce and fried green tomato with rosemary mayo on ciabatta bread

    • Frickin' Chicken Sandwich $9.50

      Breaded chicken breast sandwich topped with any frickers famous wing sauce on a dusted kaiser bun

    • The Naked Chicken Sandwich By Frickers $9.50

      Grilled chicken breast topped with any frickers famous wing sauce served on a dusted kaiser bun

    • Smothered Grilled Chicken Sandwich $10.00

      Topped with mozzarella cheese, sauteed onions & mushrooms on a kaiser bun

    • Cilantro Lime Chicken Sandwich $10.50

      Grilled chicken breast topped with tomato, mozzarella cheese & our homemade lime and cilantro sauce served on ciabatta bread

    • Chicken Guacamole Bacon Sandwich $10.50

      Grilled chicken breast topped with guacamole, bacon & pepper jack cheese

    • Chicken Philly $10.00

      Grilled chicken sliced philly style with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms & hot cheddar then topped with mozzarella cheese all on a toasted hoagie bun

    • Teriyaki Pineapple Chicken Sandwich $10.00

      Grilled chicken breast topped with a sweet teriyaki sauce & grilled pineapple on ciabatta bread

    • Turkey Bacon Wrap $9.95

      Thin sliced turkey topped with applewood bacon, avocado, american & swiss cheese wrapped in a spinach tortilla.

    • Chicken Caesar Wrap $9.95

      Grilled chicken breast, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing wrapped in a spinach tortilla

    • California Club Wrap $9.95

      Turkey, ham, applewood bacon, avocado, lettuce & tomato wrapped in a spinach tortilla

    • Fajita Chicken Wrap $9.95

      Grilled chicken breast with fajita seasoning then topped with grilled perppers and pepper jack cheese wrapped in a spinach tortilla

  • Steaks & Ribs
    All steak selections served with on salad selection & one side selection. Add sauteed mushrooms & onions to any steak for $2.00. Thirsty sides selections: choice of side salad, cole slaw or pasta salad thirsty sides selections: choice of curly or wedge fries, smashed potatoes mini bakers with sour cream & chives, sweet potato fries, mac & cheese, broccoli or fried green beans, add gravy for $0.79
    • T-bone Steak $18.50

      A 16 oz. t-bone charbroiled on an open flame

    • Bird & Beef Dinner $15.00

      A 6 oz. sirloin with five frickin' chicken wings in your choice of frickin' sauce

    • Beef & Shrimp Dinner $16.95

      A 6 oz. sirloin with five crispy cracklin' shrimp and cocktail sauce

    • 10 Oz. Bistro Steak $15.00

      10 oz. bistro sirloin steak charbroiled on an open flame

    • Parmesan Bistro Steak $16.00

      10 oz bistro sirloin steak charbroiled on an open flame and topped with a parmesan cream sauce

    • Portabella Garlic Bistro Steak $16.00

      10 oz bistro sirloin steak charbroiled on an open flame and topped with sauteed portabella mushrooms and garlic

    • Fiesta Bistro Steak $16.00

      8 oz. bistro sirloin steak charbroiled on an open flame and server over sauteed peppers & onions then topped with a crunchy queso cheese bite

    • Kentucky Bourbon Bistro Steak $16.00

      10 oz bistro sirloin steak charbroiled on an open flame smothered with kentucky molasses bourbon glaze and topped with a fried onion haystack.

    • Lake Erie Perch Dinner $19.00

      Lightly breaded deep fried lake erie yellow perch served with tartar sauce

    • Lake Erie Walleye $18.00

      A fillet of lake erie walleye lightly breaded and deep fried then served with tartar sauce

    • Coconut Shrimp Dinner $18.00

      Coconut shrimp served with a cream coconut dipping sauce

    • Thirsty Sides

      Salad selections: choice of side salad, cole slaw or pasta salad. Side selections: choice of beer battered fried, tater puffs, red skin mashed potatoes, pepper jack bacon mashed potatoes, mini bakers with sour cream and chives, sweet potato fries, mac & cheese, broccoli or fried green beans.

  • Little Pony
    Reserved for our little guest. includes smiley fries, applesauce a special treat & prize
    • Chicken Tenders $7.00

    • Cheese Quesadilla $7.00

    • 2 Mini Cheeseburgers $7.00

    • Ham & Cheese Sandwich $7.00

    • Mac & Cheese $7.00

    • Spaghettio's $7.00

  • Desserts
    • Funnel Cake Fries $5.00

      Served with chocolate dipping sauce

    • Dippin' Dots $4.00

      Banana split, cookies & cream w/ oreo's mint chocolate chip and cookie dough

    • Fat Matt's Fat Chocolate Cake $7.00

      Layers of chocolate cake and sweet cream filling topped with whipped cream, caramel and chocolate sauces-big enough to share

  • Beverages
    • Pepsi

    • Diet Pepsi

    • Cherry Pepsi

    • Mountain Dew

    • Diet Mountain Dew

    • Sierra Mist

    • Dr. Pepper

    • Orange Crush

    • Fruit Punch

    • Brisk Iced Tea

    • Raspberry Tea

    • Lemonade

    • Ginger Ale

    • Bottled Root Beer

    • Cream Soda

    • Smoothies & Milkshakes

      Ask your server for today's flavor

    • Phony Pony Brew

      Only for the 21 and under crowd-a yummy drink of caramel and vanilla soda with a creamy whip cream top, served in a mason jar mug. Just like harry potter butter beer

Menu for Thirsty Pony Restaurant provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.