Mary Coyle Ice Cream
(330) 253-1511

Appetizers

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Applesauce $2.25
- Stuffed Mushrooms $7.25
  
  Stuffed with our homemade sausage and walnuts, topped with provolone cheese.
- Chili $4.25
  
  A hearty blend of pinto and kidney beans, with lean beef and tomatoes.
- Garlic Bread $2.95
  
  Available until 10 pm. Baked with our homemade butter and garlic.
- Garlic Bread with Melted Provolone $4.95
  
  Baked with our homemade butter and garlic.
- Fresh Tomato Bread $5.95
  
  Fresh tomatoes baked with garlic and melted provolone cheese.
- Meatballs in Tomato Sauce $2.75
  
  Two fresh homemade meatballs served with our "award winning" sauce.
- Bread & Butter $1.50

Salads

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Garden Salad $3.25
  
  With "old world" Italian dressing.
- Jumbo Salad $8.25
  
  A meal in itself.
- Antipasto $11.25
  
  A hearty salad with mixed greens, Genoa salami, aged provolone, pepperoncini, fresh tomatoes, cabbage and carrots.

Sandwiches

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Hot Dog $4.50
  
  Pure beef served on a fresh poppy seed bun.
- Chicago Style Hot Dog $5.50
  
  Just say "give me a Chicago".
- Tuna Salad with Melted Provolone $6.95
  
  Made fresh daily. Dolphin safe tuna, fresh eggs with a touch of mayo.
- Meatball $6.95
  
  Fresh made meatballs topped with provolone.
- Tuna Salad $5.95
  
  Made fresh daily. Dolphin safe tuna, fresh eggs with a touch of mayo.
- Sausage Parm $5.95
  
  "a 3-napkin sandwich" - homemade, mildly spiced - fresh tomato sauce topped with melted provolone.
- Salami Sub $6.95
  
  Genoa salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato and topped with our homemade Italian dressing. Served hot or cold.
- Chili Dog $5.50
  
  Topped with our homemade chili sauce.
- Chicken Parm $6.95
  
  Fresh tomato sauce topped with melted provolone. Baked and served on a toasted bun.
- Fish $5.95
  
  Baked white fish. Served on a toasted bun.

Pizza

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Pepperoni Pizza $8.25
- Italian Sausage (Homemade) Pizza $8.25
- 2 Items Pizza $9.50
- Anchovies Pizza $8.25
- Plain (Tomato & Cheese) Pizza $7.00
  
  Available until 10:00 pm.
- Black Olives Pizza $8.25
- 3 Items Pizza $10.75
- Fresh Tomatoes Pizza $8.25
- Fresh Mushrooms Pizza $8.25
- 4 Items Pizza $12.00
- Fresh Cut Green Peppers Pizza $8.25
- Hot Banana Peppers Pizza $8.25
- Tuna Fish Pizza $8.25
- Fresh Diced Onions Pizza $8.25
- Garlic Pizza (No Tomato Sauce) $8.25

Pasta Dinners

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Spaghettism $7.50
  
  Imported noodles made to order. Served with our "award winning" sauce.
- Manicotti $9.25
  
  Crepes stuffed with ricotta cheese topped with provolone.
- Italian Sausage Parmigiano $11.25
  
  Our own homemade sausage topped with provolone. Served on a bed of spaghetti.
- Ravioli $9.25
  
  Stuffed with ricotta cheese.
- Tortellini $9.25
  
  Spinach egg noodle stuffed with ricotta cheese.
- Lasagna $9.25
  
  Fresh ricotta, imported romano topped with provolone.
- Mostaccioli (Rigatoni) $7.50
  
  Imported noodles made to order (like sewer pipes).
- Shrimp Ravioli $10.25
  
  Stuffed with shrimp and ricotta cheese.
- Stuffed Eggplant $9.25
  
  Topped with provolone, baked and served in a sizzling casserole.
- Spaghetti with Anchovies $10.25
  
  Anchovy fillets sauteed in extra virgin olive oil.
- Spaghetti with Clam Sauce $10.25
  
  Clams and garlic sauteed in butter and olive oil. With our "award winning" red or white sauce.
- Veal Cannelloni $10.25
  
  Crepes stuffed with a blend of veal and fresh ricotta.
- Baked Fish $11.25
  
  White fish, baked and served with our famous spaghetti.
- Fettuccine Alfredo $9.25
  
  Egg noodles covered in our famous rich cheese sauce.
- Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Parm $14.00
  
  Egg noodles covered in our famous rich cheese sauce.
- Spaghetti with Calamari Sauce $10.25
  
  Homemade sauce with sauteed squid.
- Chicken Parmigiano $12.25
  
  Baked breast of chicken topped with provolone. Served on a bed of spaghetti.
- Spaghetti ad Aglio e Olio $9.25
  
  Garlic and olive oil.
- Gnocchi $10.75
  
  Potato pasta (like dumplings).

Banana Bowls

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- The Original $8.25
  
  Vanilla, strawberry and chocolate, marshmallow and cherry-pineapple toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The U.S. Mint $8.75
  
  3 large scoops of mint chocolate chip, hot fudge topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Strawberry $8.50
  
  3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow topping, gobs of strawberries, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Butterscotch $8.25
  
  3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and butterscotch toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Peanut Butter $8.50
  
  3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and peanut butter toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Chocolate $8.25
  
  3 large scoops of chocolate, marshmallow and chocolate toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Hot Fudge $8.50
  
  3 large scoops of vanilla, hot fudge topping, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.
- The Blueberry $9.00
  
  3 large scoops of vanilla, marshmallow and blueberry toppings, crushed nuts and fresh bananas.

Milk Shakes

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Milk Shakes $5.25
  
  Your choice of flavors - chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, cherry, lime, lemon, raspberry, mint, butterscotch, root beer, peanut butter, burgundy cherry, pineapple, coffee, blueberry, black raspberry, apple cinnamon, fresh peach, fresh banana or marshmallow.
- Specialty Shakes $6.95

Old Fashion Sodas

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Chocolate Coffee Soda $5.45
  
  A giant glass with 2 large scoops of vanilla ice cream.
- Chocolate Cherry Soda $5.45
  
  A giant glass with 2 large scoops of vanilla ice cream.
- Lemon Lime Soda $5.45
  
  A giant glass with 2 large scoops of vanilla ice cream.
- Sodas $4.75
  
  Your choice of flavors - chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, cherry, lime, lemon, raspberry, mint, butterscotch, root beer, burgundy cherry, pineapple, coffee or black raspberry.
- Hoboken Soda $5.00
  
  A giant pineapple soda with 2 large scoops of chocolate ice cream.
- Chocolate Mint Soda $5.45
  
  A giant glass with 2 large scoops of vanilla ice cream.

Showboats

Available from Monday to Saturday.
- Hot Tin Roof $6.25
  
  Vanilla - hot fudge topping - Spanish peanuts.
- Copper Roof $6.00
  
  Vanilla - butterscotch topping - Spanish peanuts.
- Almond Toffee Treat $6.25
  
  Butter toffee almond - marshmallow and butterscotch toppings.
- Mocha Magic $6.50
  
  Old colonial coffee - marshmallow and maple walnut toppings.
- Merry Mint $6.00
  
  Peppermint chip - hot fudge topping.
- Perfect Peach $6.75
  
  Vanilla - fresh peach and marshmallow toppings - crushed nuts.
- Apple Crunch $6.75
  
  Vanilla - apple cinnamon and marshmallow toppings - crushed nuts.
- Cherry Cordial $6.75
  
  Chocolate chip - chocolate and burgundy cherry toppings.
- Strawberry Supreme $6.25
  
  Strawberry - marshmallow topping - fresh bananas.
- English Nut $6.00
  
  Vanilla - maple walnut topping.
- Banana Fudge $6.00
  
  Banana - hot fudge topping.
- Buckeye $6.50
  
  Peanut butter fudge - hot fudge topping - crushed nuts.
- Chocolate Dream $6.75
  
  Chocolate butter fudge - marshmallow topping - crushed nuts - fresh bananas.
- Chocolate Mellow $6.25
  
  Vanilla and chocolate - marshmallow and chocolate toppings.
- Banana Royal $6.75
  
  Banana - marshmallow topping - crushed nuts - fresh bananas.
- Razz-Ma-Tazz $7.00
  
  Vanilla - red raspberry and marshmallow toppings - crushed nuts.
- Cocoanut Fudge $6.50
  
  Vanilla - hot fudge topping - cocoanut - fresh bananas.
- Mint Fudge $6.50
  
  Green mint - hot fudge topping - crushed nuts.
- Peanut Butter & Jelly $6.75
  
  Vanilla - peanut butter and black raspberry toppings.
- Pina Colada $5.75
  
  Cocoanut - pineapple topping.
- Blueberry Hill $6.50
  
  Vanilla - marshmallow and blueberry toppings.
- Banana Butterscotch $6.75
  
  Vanilla - marshmallow and butterscotch toppings - crushed nuts - fresh bananas.
- Burgundy Snow $6.75
  
  Burgundy cherry - marshmallow and burgundy cherry toppings - cocoanut.
- Tin Roof $6.00
  
  Vanilla - chocolate topping - Spanish peanuts.
- Jack's Maple Marvel $6.75
  
  Maple walnut - hot fudge topping - Spanish peanuts - fresh bananas.

Sundaes

Served with two large scoops of vanilla.
- Marshmallow $5.00
- Cherry $5.00
- Hot Fudge $6.75
- Black Raspberry $5.25
- Chocolate Marshmallow $5.50
- Butterscotch $5.00
- Peach $5.00
- Chocolate $5.00
- Butterscotch Marshmallow $5.50
- Burgundy Cherry $5.25
- Peanut Butter $5.25
- Strawberry $5.25
- Apple Cinnamon $5.25
- Blueberry $5.25
- Red Raspberry $5.25
- Cherry Pineapple $5.25
- Hot Fudge Cocoanut Delight $5.75

Beverages Ice Cream
- Phosphates $2.08
  
  Soda water mixed with flavor syrup (cherry soda, etc.) your choice of flavors: cherry, lime, strawberry, lemon, vanilla, raspberry or chocolate.
- Sherbet Freeze $3.85
  
  Sherbet and soda water. A refreshing mix! Your choice of flavors: orange, lime, raspberry, pineapple or lemon.
- Floats $3.85
  
  Soda pop with vanilla ice cream your choice of flavors: root beer, cherry, lime, strawberry, lemon, vanilla, raspberry, chocolate or Pepsi.

Menu for Mary Coyle Ice Cream provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.