• New York
  • Williamsville
  • Muscarella's

Muscarella's

(716) 204-9020
  • 5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221
  • American ,  Pizza ,  Sandwiches ,  Wings ,  Wraps
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Daily Specials
    • Colossal Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 30 Wings $71.29

    • Small Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 10 Wings $33.34

    • Large Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 10 Chicken Fingers $49.44

    • Large Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 20 Wings $57.49

    • Sheet Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 50 Wings $98.89

  • Boneless Wings Specials
    • Small Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 10 Boneless Wings $29.89

    • Large Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 20 Boneless Wings $48.29

    • Colossal Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 30 Boneless Wings $63.24

    • Sheet Pizza (C+1 Topping) & 50 Boneless Wings $79.34

  • Pizza & Calzones
    • Colossal Pizza $27.29

      Includes cheese

    • Large Pizza $22.99

      Includes cheese add toppings for an additional charge.

    • Personal Pizza $8.04

    • Sheet Pizza $41.39

    • Small Pizza $14.94

    • Calzone: Chicken Finger $17.2

    • Calzone: Steak $17.2

    • Calzone: The Works $17.2

    • Calzone: Broccoli & Cheddar $17.2

    • Calzone: Sicilian $17.2

    • Calzone: The "Hog" $17.2

    • Calzone: The Romano $17.2

    • Calzone: Cheese & Pepperoni $14.9

    • Calzone: Build Your Own $11.44

  • Specialty Pie: Lg & Sht. & Col.
    • Chicken Finger Pizza: Lg $31.04

      Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).

    • Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Lg $25.29

      Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.

    • Steak Pizza: Lg $32.19

      Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.

    • Sicilian Pizza: Lg $25.29

      Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.

    • The Works Pizza: Lg $32.19

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    • The "Hog" Pizza: Lg $36.79

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.

    • The Romano Pizza: Lg $27.59

      Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

    • Colossal Chicken Finger Pizza $41.39

      Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).

    • Colossal Broccoli & Chedder Pizza $32.19

      Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.

    • Colossal Steak Pizza $41.39

      Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.

    • Colossal Sicilian Pizza $32.19

      Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.

    • Colossal Works Pizza $41.39

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    • Colossal Hog Pizza $45.99

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.

    • Colossal Romano Pizza $36.79

      Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

    • Chicken Finger Pizza: Sheet $56.34

      Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).

    • Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sheet $50.59

      Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.

    • Steak Pizza: Sheet $56.34

      Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.

    • Sicilian Pizza: Sheet $50.59

      Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.

    • The Works Pizza: Sheet $56.34

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    • The "Hog" Pizza: Sheet $67.84

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.

    • The Romano Pizza: Sheet $50.59

      Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

  • Specialty Pie: Per. & Sm
    • Chicken Finger Pizza: Per. $13.79

      Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).

    • Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Per. $11.49

      Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.

    • Steak Pizza: Per. $13.79

      Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.

    • Sicilian Pizza: Per. $11.49

      Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.

    • The Works Pizza: Per. $13.79

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    • The "Hog" Pizza: Per. $13.79

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.

    • The Romano Pizza: Per. $12.64

      Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

    • Chicken Finger Pizza: Sm $21.84

      Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).

    • Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sm $18.39

      Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.

    • Steak Pizza: Sm $21.84

      Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.

    • Sicilian Pizza: Sm $18.39

      Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.

    • The Works Pizza: Sm $21.84

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    • The "Hog" Pizza: Sm $21.84

      Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.

    • The Romano Pizza: Sm $20.69

      Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

  • Wings & Fingers
    • Wings: 10pcs $19.54

    • Wings: 20pcs $34.49

    • Wings: 30pcs $45.99

    • Wings: 50pcs $80.49

    • Boneless Wings: 10pcs $16.09

    • Boneless Wings: 20pcs $26.44

      Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.

    • Boneless Wings: 30pcs $35.64

      Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.

    • Boneless Wings: 50pcs $51.74

      Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.

    • Fingers Sm: 5pcs $16.68

    • Fingers Lg: 10pcs $28.74

    • Fingers XL: 15pcs $42.54

  • Whole submarine: includes lettuce, tomato & cheese. Onions on request
    • Sub: Assorted $16.09

    • Sub: B.L.T $14.94

    • Sub: Bacon Cheeseburger $17.24

      Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.

    • Sub: Cheese Baked $8.04

    • Sub: Cheeseburger $16.09

    • Sub: Chicken Cordon Blue $18.39

      Sahlen's ham, chicken fingers and Swiss cheese.

    • Sub: Chicken Finger $17.24

    • Sub: Grilled Chicken $12.64

    • Sub: Grilled CK Supreme $13.79

    • Sub: Ham Sahlens $14.94

    • Sub: Hamburger $14.94

    • Sub: Italian Sausage Patty $16.09

    • Sub: Musc Melt $18.39

      Melted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes.

    • Sub: Pizza $9.19

    • Sub: Salami $14.94

    • Sub: Steak Supreme $17.24

    • Sub: Steak & Sausage $19.54

    • Sub: Stinger $20.69

      Includes chicken fingers, steak & bacon. Lettuce and tomato on request

    • Sub: Tuna $11.49

    • Sub: Turkey $14.94

    • Sub: Turkey Bacon Club $17.24

    • Sub: Vegetarian $8.04

    • Sub: Vincenzo Special $17.24

    • Sub: Sicilian Pizza Sub $8.04

      Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.

    • Sub: Steak $17.24

  • Half submarine: includes lettuce, tomato & cheese. Onions on request
    • Sub Half: B.L.T $9.19

    • Sub Half: Bacon Cheeseburger $10.34

    • Sub Half: Cheese Baked $4.59

    • Sub Half: Cheeseburger $9.19

    • Sub Half: Chicken Cordon Blue $11.49

    • Sub Half: Chicken Finger $10.34

    • Sub Half: Grilled Chicken $8.04

    • Sub Half: Grilled CK Supreme $9.19

    • Sub Half: Ham Sahlens $8.04

    • Sub Half: Hamburger $8.04

    • Sub Half: Italian Sausage Patty $9.19

    • Sub Half: Musc Melt $11.49

      Melted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes.

    • Sub Half: Assorted $9.19

    • Sub Half: Pizza $5.74

    • Sub Half: Salami $8.04

    • Sub Half: Steak Supreme $10.34

    • Sub Half: Steak & Sausage $11.49

    • Sub Half: Stinger $12.64

      Includes chicken fingers, steak & bacon. Lettuce and tomato on request

    • Sub Half: Tuna $6.89

    • Sub Half: Turkey $8.04

    • Sub Half: Turkey Bacon Club $9.19

      Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.

    • Sub Half: Vegetarian $4.59

    • Sub Half: Vincenzo Special $10.34

    • Sub Half: Sicilian Pizza Sub $4.59

    • Sub Half: Steak $10.34

  • Parm Subs
    • Parm Half: Steak $9.19

    • Parm Half: Eggplant $8.04

    • Parm Half: Meatball $8.04

    • Parm Half: Italian Sausage $9.19

    • Parm Half: Chicken Finger $10.34

    • Parm: Steak $16.09

    • Parm: Eggplant $12.64

    • Parm: Meatball $13.79

    • Parm: Italian Sausage $16.09

    • Parm: Chicken Finger $17.24

  • Wraps
    • Wrap: Grlld Steak Caesar $8.61

    • Wrap: Grlld Chicken $8.04

    • Wrap: Grlld Chicken Caesar $8.61

    • Wrap: Grlld Steak Supreme $8.61

    • Wrap: Grlld CK Supreme $8.61

    • Wrap: Chicken Finger $8.04

    • Wrap: Turkey $6.89

    • Wrap: Assorted $7.46

    • Wrap: Tuna $6.89

    • Wrap: Vegetarian $5.74

    • Wrap: Grlld Steak $8.04

    • Wrap: Ham $6.89

    • Wrap: Antipasto $6.99

  • Salads
    • Salad Sm: Antipasto $12.65

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions,ham, cappicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives,green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.

    • Salad Sm: Julienne $10.34

    • Salad Sm: Tuna $10.34

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    • Salad Sm: Grilled Chicken $13.79

    • Salad Sm: Caesar $8.04

    • Salad Sm: Gr. Chicken Caesar $13.79

    • Salad Sm: Chefs $8.04

    • Salad Sm: Chicken Finger $13.79

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar.

    • Salad Lg: Antipasto $18.39

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, cappicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives,green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.

    • Salad Lg: Julienne $14.94

    • Salad Lg: Tuna $14.94

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    • Salad Lg: Grilled Chicken $19.54

      Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    • Salad Lg: Caesar $11.49

    • Salad Lg: Gr. Chicken Caesar $19.54

    • Salad Lg: Chicken Finger $19.54

    • Salad Lg: Chefs $11.49

  • Sides
    • Frankie Fries $9.19

      Bbq dip included. grilled steak (chopped sirloin) cheddar and french fries.

    • French Fries $5.74

      Includes bleu cheese.

    • BBQ French Fries $6.89

      Includes bleu cheese. bbq sauced then blackened in oven

    • Loaded Fries $8.04

      Includes bacon and cheddar.

    • Sweet Potato Fries w/Honey $6.89

    • Waffle Fries $6.89

    • Onion Rings $6.89

    • Fried Cauliflower: 15pcs $7.48

    • Fried Mushrooms: 15pcs $7.48

    • Fried Zucchini: 15pcs $7.48

    • Jalapeno Poppers: 5pcs $6.89

    • Fried Dough Balls $7.48

    • Loaded Garlic Bread $5.74

      Includes spinach onions tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.

    • Mozzarella Sticks: 5pcs $8.04

      Five pieces.

    • Pizza Logs: 5pcs $12.64

      Five pieces.

    • Cajun Onion Rings $8.04

      Bbq sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven

    • Cajun French Fries $7.48

      Bbq sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven

    • Garlic Bread w/Cheese $4.59

    • Garlic Bread w/Cheese & Tomato $5.16

    • Bread Sticks $5.16

    • Bread Sticks w/Cheese $7.46

    • Tator Tots $6.89

    • Loaded Tator Tots $9.19

    • Garlic Bread No Cheese $2.35

    • Loaded Waffle FF $8.04

  • Beverages
    • Water $2.88

    • Coke: 20oz $2.88

    • Sprite: 20oz $2.88

    • Diet Coke: 20oz $2.88

    • Cherry Coke: 20oz $2.88

    • Root Beer: 20oz $2.88

    • Orange Soda:20oz $2.88

    • Diet Coke: 2 Liter $3.74

    • Sprite: 2 Liter $3.74

    • Coke: 2 Liter $3.74

    • Loganberry: 20oz $2.88

    • Dasani: 20oz $2.88

    • Lemonade: 20oz $2.88

    • Cherry Coke: 2 Liter $3.74

    • Loganberry: 2 Liter $3.74

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.