• New York
  • Water Mill
  • Silver Lining Diner

Silver Lining Diner

(631) 901-1800
  • 32 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, NY 11976
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Breakfast Classics
    Served with crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast. Egg whites for an additional charge.
    • Eggs Your Way $10.5

      2 eggs

    • Avocado Toast $12.5

      Honey grain bread, satur farms field greens.

  • Salads
    Add organic chicken, salmon, grilled steak or chilled shrimp for an additional charge.
  • Bowls
  • Eggies
    Serving the best breakfast sandwiches in America, on a roll or soft tortilla. Egg whites for an additional charge.
    • Classic Scrambled $10

      With American cheese.

    • Egg Melt $11

      Grafton cheddar, caramelized onions,and roasted tomato.

  • Benedicts
    2 poached eggs, tarragon hollandaise over toasted English muffin, and crisp golden home fries.
    • Smoked Country Ham $15

    • Spinach and Kale $14

    • Catsmo Smoked Salmon $16

    • Spanish Scramble Platter $16

      3 eggs, chorizo, onions, peppers, jack cheese & jalapeño.

  • All Day Breakfast
    • Buttermilk Hot Cakes $14

    • Brioche French Toast $14

    • Buttermilk Belgian Waffles $14

    • Fried Chicken & Waffles $17

      All buttermilk with salted butter and maple syrup.

    • Eggs Any Style $13

      With home fries and toast.

    • Omelet Your Way $17

      3 eggs, crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast

  • Farm Fresh Organic Omelets
    • Omelet Your Way $12

      3 eggs, crisp golden home fries, your choice of toast.

  • From the Griddle
    Served with sweet butter and Vermont maple syrup.
    • Buttermilk Hot Cakes $11.5

    • Brioche French Toast $11.5

    • Buttermilk Belgian Waffles $11.5

    • Fried Chicken & Waffles $15

      All buttermilk with salted butter and maple syrup.

    • Catsmo Smoked Salmon Platter $16

  • Small Plates
  • Sandwiches
    Make it deluxe with hand-cut fries and Alabama slaw for an additional charge.
  • Eric's Incredible Burgers
    Comes with lettuce, tomato, and pickle. Make it deluxe with hand-cut fries and Alabama slaw for an additional charge
    • Pick Your Snake River Farm beef Burger $16

    • Pick Your Turkey Burger $14

    • Pick Your Superior Veggie Burger $14

  • From the Fryer
    Perfectly anson mills corn flour-fried. Served with cider vegetable slaw and tartar sauce.
    • Montauk Fish N' Chips $18

    • Deluxe Mixed Fry Seafood Combo $21

      With crispy potato fries

    • Jumbo Atlantic Shrimp $21

      With crispy potato fries.

    • Montauk Sea Scallops $22

      With crispy potato fries.

  • Entrees
  • Breakfast Sides
    • Applewood Smoked Bacon $5

    • Maple Cured Country Ham $5

    • Pork Sausage Links $5

    • Chicken Sausage Links $5

    • Crisp Golden Home Fries $3

    • Bagel $4

  • Sides
    • Mesclun Greens $7

    • Mashed Potatoes with Parmesan and Cream $7

    • Crisp Potato Fries $7

    • Farm Stand Vegetables $7

    • BBQ Rubbed Sweet Potato Fries $7

  • Desserts
    • Key Lime Pie $12

      Graham cracker crust, French meringue.

    • Key Lime Pie a la Mode $16

      Graham cracker crust, French meringue.

    • Chocolate Marquis $12

      Vanilla soft serve ice cream.

    • Chocolate Marquis a la Mode $12

      Vanilla soft serve ice cream.

    • Fresh Berry Cheesecake $12

      Blueberry and raspberry sauce.

    • Fresh Berry Cheesecake a la Mode $16

      Blueberry and raspberry sauce.

    • House Made Carrot Cake $12

    • House Made Carrot Cake a la Mode $16

    • Banana Cake Sundae $12

    • Banana Cake Sundae a la Mode $16

  • Soft Serve, Hand Spun Daily
    • Soft Serve $5

  • Milkshakes
    • Tahitian Vanilla $10

    • Black N White Swirl $10

    • Fresh Local Berry $10

    • Coffee Milkshake $10

    • Chocolate Milkshake $10

    • Vanilla Milkshake $10

    • Vanilla Milkshake $10

    • Strawberry Milkshake $10

  • Joe and Liza's Ice Cream
    • Kids Scoop Ice Cream $4

    • 2 Scoops Ice Cream $6

    • 3 Scoops Ice Cream $8

  • Signature Smoothies
  • Floats & Sodas
    • Classic Egg Cream $7

    • Kombucha Float $11

    • Mexican Coca Cola $5

    • Fanta Orange Pure Cane Sugar $5

    • Root Beer Float $9

  • Coffee
    • House Blend Drip $3.5

    • Double Espresso $4.5

    • Cappuccino $5

    • Latte $5

    • Americano $5

    • Macchiato $5

    • Cortado $5

    • Flat White $5.5

    • Cold Brew Coffee $4.5

    • Iced Double Espresso $6

    • Iced Latte $6.5

    • Iced Americano $6.5

    • Iced Unsweetened Black Tea $4

  • Tea
    • Chamomile $3

    • Chai Latte $6

    • Chai Tea $4.5

    • Earl Grey $3

    • English Breakfast Assam $3

    • Matcha $6

    • Mint $3

    • Yorkshire Gold $3.5

    • Jasmine Pearl Green $3

  • Non-Alcoholic
    • Iced Unsweetened Black Tea $4

    • Lemonade $5

    • Mexican Coca Cola $5

    • Fanta Orange Pure Cane Sugar $5

    • Fanta Pineapple Pure Cane Sugar $5

    • Fanta Grape Pure Cane Sugar $5

    • Abita Root Beer $5

    • Ting, Grapefruit Soda $5

    • Apple Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5

    • Pomegranate Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5

    • Tomato Juice, R.W. Knudsen $5

    • Still Water, Acqua Panna $7

    • Sparkling Water, San Pellegrino $7

    • Hot Chocolate $4

  • Juices
    • Just Squeezed 8oz Florida Orange $7

    • Just Squeezed 8oz Ruby Red Grapefruit $7

    • Fresh Pressed Pure Green Juice $9

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.