• New York
  • Staten Island
  • Bagels by the Bay

Bagels by the Bay

(718) 815-4447
  • 1235 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305
  • $$$$$
  • Seamless.com
  • Menu
  • Beverages
    • Coffee

    • Tea

    • Flavored Herbal Tea

    • Hot Chocolate

    • French Vanilla Cappuccino

    • 24 oz. Cup Iced Coffee $4.25

    • 20 oz. Soda $3

    • Bottled Water

    • Snapple $3

    • Small Tropicana Juice $2

    • Large Tropicana Juice $3.25

    • Quart Tropicana Juice $4.75

    • Half Gallon Tropicana Orange Juice $6.75

    • Espresso

    • Pure Leaf Iced Tea $3

      Assorted flavors

    • Nesquick or Yoohoo Chocolate Milk $3.25

      Assorted flavors

    • Monster Energy Drink $3.5

    • Red Bull Energy Drink $3.5

      Regular or Sugar Free 8 oz.

  • Cream Cheese Sandwiches
    • Bagel and Plain Cream Cheese $3.25

    • Bagel and Butter $2.25

    • Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Jelly $3.75

    • Bagel with Butter and Jelly $2.75

    • Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese Spread $4.5

    • Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Fresh Lox $10.5

      Salmon.

    • Bagel with Butter and Fresh Lox $11.5

      Salmon.

    • Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Bacon Sandwich $5.5

    • Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Ham Sandwich $5.5

    • Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese and Turkey Sandwich $5

    • Bagel with Butter and Bacon Sandwich $5.5

    • Bagel with Butter and Ham Sandwich $5.5

    • Bagel with Butter and Turkey Sandwich $5.5

    • BLT $6.5

    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich $4.5

      American cheese.

    • 1 lb. of Flavored Cream Cheese Spread $15

    • Single Bagel $1.25

      With no toppings.

  • Egg Sandwiches
    • Egg Sandwich (two extra large eggs) $4.75

    • Egg(Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $5.25

    • Egg (Two extra large eggs), Ham with Cheese Sandwich $7.25

    • Egg (Two extra large eggs), Bacon with Cheese Sandwich $7.25

    • Sausage, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $7.75

    • Salami, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $7.25

    • Bologna, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $7.25

    • Steak, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $8.75

    • Pastrami, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich $8.75

    • Potato and Egg (Two extra large eggs) Sandwich

    • Egg (Two extra large eggs), Turkey with Cheese Sandwich $7.25

    • Potato, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese Sandwich

    • Turkey Bacon, Egg (Two extra large eggs) and Cheese

  • Hero Egg Sandwiches
    • Hero Egg Sandwich $7.75

    • Hero Egg and Cheese Sandwich $8.75

    • Hero Egg, Bacon and Cheese Sandwich $10.75

    • Hero Egg, Ham and Cheese Sandwich $10.75

    • Hero Egg, Turkey and Cheese Sandwich $10.75

    • Hero Sausage, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $11.25

    • Hero Salami, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $10.75

    • Hero Bologna, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $10.75

    • Hero Steak, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $11.75

    • Hero Pastrami, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $11.75

    • Hero Potato, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $11.25

    • Hero Turkey Bacon, Egg and Cheese Sandwich $11.25

  • Breakfast Platters
    • 3 Eggs, choice of Bacon, Ham or turkey, Cheese, and Home Fries Platter $11.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Sausage, 3 Eggs, Cheese and Home Fries Platter $12.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Turley Bacon, 3 Eggs, Cheese and Home Fries Platter $12.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • 5 Pancakes Platter (No toast) $8

      Served with syrup on the side.

    • Pancakes and Bacon Platter $9.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Pancakes and Ham Platter $9.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Pancakes and Turkey Platter $9.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Egg Omelet with Cheese and Toast $6.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Western Omelet Platter $13

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread and home fries.

    • Vegetable Omelet Platter $11

      Green pepper, tomatoes and onions home fries. Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • 3 Eggs, Turkey, Cheese and Home Fries Platter $11.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • 3 Eggs, Bacon, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter $11.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • 3 Eggs, Ham, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter $11.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • 3 Eggs, Turkey, Cheese and Hashbrowns Platter $11.5

      Served with buttered white, whole wheat or rye bread.

    • Home Fries

    • French Fries

  • Bagels
    • Bagel $1.25

    • Half Dozen Bagels $7.5

      Does not include rainbow, cheddar & jalapeno or french toast bagels. Additional charges may apply. Please indicate bagel flavor quantities in the special instructions. With 1 free bagel.

    • Dozen Bagels $15

    • Rainbow Bagel (Plain, nothing on it) $2.25

    • French Toast Bagel (Plain, nothing on it) $2.25

    • Cheddar Cheese & Jalapeno Bagel (Plain, nothing on it) $2.25

  • Muffins
    • Yogurt Muffin $3

      Nothing on it

    • Toasted Muffin with Butter $3.75

    • Toasted Muffin with Butter and Jelly (Grape) $4.5

  • Salads
    • Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad

      Crisp romaine lettuce topped with our marinated grilled chicken breast, baked seasoned croutons, sliced onions, grated Parmesan cheese and a classic Caesar dressing.

    • Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Salad

      Fresh water mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, red roasted peppers, black olives on a bed of crisp lettuce and choice of dressing.

    • Garden of Eden Salad

      A bed of mixed lettuce, sliced tomatoes, cucumber slices, onions, sweet, hot and roasted peppers, green and black olives, fresh backed seasoned croutons and choice of dressing.

    • Antipasto Salad

      Red roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, thinly sliced prosciutto, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, green and black olives on bed of crisp lettuce, choice of dressing.

    • Tossed Salad

      A bed of mixed lettuce, fresh sliced tomatoes, cucumber slices, fresh baked seasoned croutons and choice of dressing.

    • Mediterranean Salad

      On a crisp bed of lettuce sliced tomatoes, firm cucumber slices, Bermuda onions, sliced hard-boiled egg, crunchy walnuts, sweet raisins and choice of dressing.

  • Panini
    • Vegeterian Delight Panini $14

      Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, lettuce, tomato, onion, olive oil, vinegar and oregano.

    • Roast Beef Panini $15

      Roasted beef with Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, tomatoes and Russian dressing.

    • Tiny Bikini Panini $15

      Oven roasted turkey mozzarella cheese,roasted pepper and sun-dried tomato, pesto.

    • The Italiano Panini $15

      Grilled chicken, roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, pesto.

    • The Godfather Part II Panini $16

      Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes, lettuce, pesto dressing.

    • Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini $15

      Choice of baked or fried chicken cutlet topped with Virginia ham slices, melted mozzarella cheese and your choice of dressing.

    • Pastrami Supreme Panini $15

      Hot pastrami, crisp bacon and melted Swiss cheese with spicy Board's Head mustard.

    • Create Your Own Panini $16

      Choice of any one meat and any one cheese with any topping.

  • Signature Wraps
    • Turkey and Cheddar Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Italiano with Sweet Pepper Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Italiano with Hot Peppers Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Italiano with Roasted Peppers Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Chicken Wrap $9.99

      With your choice of chicken and lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Virginia Ham and Swiss Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Roast Beef, Bacon and Cheese Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Salsalito Turkey and Pepper Turkey Wrap $9.99

      Pepper jack cheese with lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Cajun Roast Beaf and American Cheese Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Black Forest Ham and Cheddar Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • The Chuck Chillout Wrap $9.99

      Caesar chicken and fresh mozzarella. With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Chicken Salad Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Tuna Salad Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

    • Egg Salad Wrap $9.99

      With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

  • Lunch Appetizer
    • Lunch Chicken Fingers $12

      With french fries.

    • Lunch Onion Ring

    • Lunch French Fries

    • Lunch Large French Fries with Cheese and Gravy $9.25

      With melted fresh mozzarella cheese and gravy on side.

  • Lunch Home Made Salad
    • Lunch Chicken Salad $7.5

      Comes on either a roll, bagel or bread.

    • Lunch Tuna Salad $7

    • Lunch Egg Salad $6.5

    • Homemade chicken salad by the pound $13.99

      Homemade chicken salad

    • Homemade tuna salad by the pound $12.99

      homemade tuna salad

    • Homemade Egg salad $11.99

      homemade egg salad

  • Lunch Menu
    • The Turkey Melt Lunch

      Hot oven roasted turkey, crisp bacon, melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato and choice of dressing.

    • Lunch Chicken Fantastic

      Breast of chicken cutlet, crisp bacon, melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and choice of dressing.

    • Lunch Philly Cheese Steak

      Hot roast beef, brown gravy and melted American cheese with peppers and onions on toasted garlic bread.

    • Lunch Pastrami Supreme

      Hot pastrami, crisp bacon and melted Swiss cheese with spicy Boars Head mustard.

    • Lunch Classic Reuben

      Hot corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, boars head spicy mustard on rye bread.

    • Lunch Texas Melt

      Hot BBQ chicken breast, melted American cheese, smothered in hickory smoked BBQ sauce on toasted garlic bread.

    • Lunch Buffalo Stampede

      Hot chicken cutlet topped with melted mozzarella cheese, blue cheese dressing, and a dash of Tabasco sauce.

    • The Terminator Lunch

      Oven roasted turkey breast, hot roast beef, melted mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, choice of dressing.

    • The Italiano Lunch

      Sweet cappy ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese topped with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, hot and or sweet peppers, oil, vinegar and oregano.

    • The Godfather Part I Lunch

      Hot capicola, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers topped with onions, lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper and oregano.

    • The Robert Deniro Lunch

      Marinated chicken cutlet in sun dried tomatoes and balsamic vinegar, topped with fresh mozzarella, red onions and Romaine lettuce.

    • The Al Pacino Lunch

      Marinated lemon chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers topped with onions, lettuce, tomato, and Caesar dressing.

    • Lunch Meatball Explosion

      German style meatballs, with brown gravy, melted American yellow cheese, topped with fried onions on toasted garlic bread.

    • Lunch Vegetarian Delight

      Fried eggplant slices, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar and oregano.

    • The Kim Basinger Lunch

      Our homemade tuna salad topped with sliced red onions and hot cherry pepper slices.

    • The Frank Sinatra Lunch

      Boar's Head peppered turkey piled high on toasted garlic bread topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles and Your Way sauce.

    • Lunch Chicken Cordon Bleu

      Choice of baked or fried chicken cutlet topped with Virginia ham slices, melted mozzarella cheese and your choice of dressing.

    • The Rosebank Special Lunch

      Oven roasted turkey breast, crispy bacon, sliced Swiss cheese, crumbled hard-boiled egg, lettuce, tomato, sliced onion, and Thousand Island dressing.

    • The Twin Towers Lunch

      Thinly sliced Boar's Head lean corned beef and pastrami, Swiss cheese, sliced pickle topped with spicy mustard.

    • Lunch the Stinger

      Hormel DiLusso salami, slicing pepperoni, Boar's Head boiled ham, sliced provolone topped with hot cherry peppers, onions and balsamic vinegar.

    • Lunch Monte Cristo

      Boar's Head brand #1 boiled ham, Oven Gold roasted turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.

    • Lunch Chicken Cutlet Special

      Baked or fried chicken cutlets, fried eggplant slices, red roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic vinegar.

    • Lunch Lamb Gyro $8

      Served on Greek bread, with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and tzatziki sauce.

    • Lunch Cheeseburger Deluxe

      Served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion, pickles, and french fries.

    • Lunch French Fries

    • Lunch Large French Fries with Cheese and Gravy $10

      With melted fresh, mozzarella cheese and gravy on the side.

  • Lunch Specials
    • Chicken Salad Sandwich Lunch Special $8

      On Mondays only

    • Roast Beef Sandwich Lunch Special $9

      On Wednesdays Only.

    • Pastrami Sandwich Lunch Special $9

      On Thursdays Only.

    • Corned Beef Sandwich Lunch Special $9

      On Thursdays Only.

    • Tuna Sandwich Lunch Special $7.5

      On Fridays Only.

    • Egg salad Sandwich Lunch Special $7.5

      On Tuesday only.

  • Cold Cuts
    • choice of Boars Head Peppermill Turkey Or Ham,Salami,Balogna,Pepperoni,Overngold turkey Per Lb

    • Choice of Boars Head

      Choice of Boars head Roast Beef Or Pastrami Or Prosciutto Or Hot Capocollo Or Sopressata Or Corned Beef Or Honey Turkey

    • Choice of Boars Head Yellow American. White American Cheese

    • Cheese

      Choice Of Boars head Mozzerella, Cheddar,Swiss,Pepperjack,Meunster,Provolone,Fresh Mozerella Cheese

  • Lunch Sandwhiches
    • Bagels By The Bay Special

      Choice of Turkey,Ham,Salami,Balogna,Peppermill Turkey, and your choice of one type of cheese. Includes Mayo,Chesse,Lettuce,Tomato.Onions,

    • Bagels By The Bay Special

      Choice of Boars Head Honey turkey,Pastrami,Roast Beef, Corned Beef, Prosciutto,Sopresetta, Hot Capocollo With your choice of 1 Cheese, Includes Mayo,Lettuce,Tomato,Onions

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.