• New York
  • Smithtown
  • Old Street Restaurant & Bar

Old Street Restaurant & Bar

(631) 979-9073
  • 92 E Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American
(631) 979-9073
  • Main
  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Cocktail Party
    open bar for 2 hours with name brand liquor, domestic bottled and draft beers (excludes sam adams & bluepoint) 1 hour of butler style hors d'oeuvres tossed salad select 2 from the following cloro coordinated linens included pp tax & gratuity
    • Pepper Steak $26.95

    • Sausage, Pepper And Potato $26.95

    • Honey Dipped Fried Chicken $26.95

    • Chicken Francaise $26.95

    • Chicken Marsala $26.95

    • Chicken Piccata $26.95

    • Rigatoni A La Vodka $26.95

    • Pasta Carbonara $26.95

    • Penne Sapparito $26.95

  • Burger Platters
    half pound of freshly ground beef charbroiled to perfection. served with steak house fries, beer battered onion rings, coleslaw, garlic dill pickles, tomato and lettuce on a specially baked roll.
    • Sauteed Mixed Vegetables $0.5

    • Sweet Potato Fries $1.95

    • Beer Battered Onion Rings $1.95

    • Veggie Burger $8.95

    • Turkey Burger $8.95

  • Specialty Burger Platters
    • Texas Burger $11.95

      served open and smothered with chili, cheddar, monterey jack cheeses, sauteed onions

    • Danish Burger $9.95

      bacon and danish bleu cheese

    • Rueben Burger $9.95

      sauerkraut and melted swiss cheese with russian dressing

    • El Paso Burger $9.95

      sour cream & jalapeno peppers

    • Moonlight Burger $9.95

      sour cream & sauteed mushrooms

    • Hickory Burger $10.45

      based with barbecue sauce and topped with sauteed onions, bacon and swiss cheese

    • Verde Burger $9.95

      sauteed onions and green peppers

    • Pizza Burger $9.95

      marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese

    • Portobello Mushroom Burger $10.95

      grilled portabello mushroom cap, and roasted red peppers

    • Hero Burger $13.95

      a full pound of charbroiled ground beef served on a hero with mushroom gravy

    • Black Forest Burger $11.95

      hot pastrami and muenster cheese, with russian dressing

    • Tuscan Burger $11.95

      grilled proscuitto, melted mozzarella and roasted red peppers

    • Canadian Burger $10.45

      grilled canadian bacon, bbq sauce and osp soft cheddar cheese

    • Black Jack Burger $11.95

      melted jack cheese, cajun spices and sauteed onions with a side of mayo

    • Diet Burger $8.95

      grilled burger with mixed vegetables, lettuce and tomato no bun, no fries, no onion rings

    • Montreal Burger $10.95

      montreal spices, horseradish sauce, and melted cheddar cheese

    • Cowboy Burger $10.95

      sauteed mushrooms & onions, bacon and monterey jack cheese

    • Hot Burger $10.95

      jalapeno peppers, zinger sauce and melted monterey jack cheese

    • Blue Moon Burger $10.95

      sauteed mushrooms, topped with danish bleu cheese

    • Teriyaki Mushrooms Burger $10.95

      basted with teriyaki and topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions

    • Cordon Bleu Burger $10.95

      grilled ham, melted swiss cheese and dijon mustard

    • Bistro Burger $10.95

      brie cheese and sauteed onions topped with bacon

    • Hawaiian Burger $10.95

      grilled ham topped with a grilled pineapple slice

  • Soups
    • Crock Of French Onion Soup Au Gratin $4.5

    • Soup Of The Day $2.95

    • Onion Soup $2.95

    • Chowder Of The Day $2.95

  • Starters
    • Seafood Sampler $12.95

      baked clams, coconut shrimp & maryland crab cake

    • Tasty Treats $9.95

      mozzarella sticks, stuffed skins, onion rings, chicken tenders

    • Coconut Shrimp $7.95

      with pina colada dipping sauce

    • Shrimp Cocktail $7.95

      chilled gulf shrimp with tangy cocktail sauce

    • Blooming Onion $5.95

      with spicy bistro dipping sauce

    • Baked Clams $5.95

      lightly seasoned and chopped

    • Pierogies $5.95

      with sauteed onions and sour cream

    • Wing Zingers $5.95

      breaded buffalo style wings with hot sauce

    • Stuffed Mushroom Caps $6.95

      seafood stuffing, sherry wine, and melted muenster cheese

    • Potato Skins $6.45

      crisp fried skins loaded with old street cheddar, bacon and sour cream

    • Old Street's Homemade Chill $4.95

      with cheddar cheese

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.45

      fried to a golden brown and served with marinara sauce for dipping

    • Osp's Cheese & Crackers $4.95

      our popular deep fried rye served with beer & cheddar spread

    • Fried Calamari $6.95

      crispy fried calamari rings with spicy marinara sauce

    • Chicken Tenders $6.25

      lightly fried and served with honey mustard sauce

    • Steamed Mussels (Pei) $7.95

      garlic, white wine & butter sauce with fresh herbs

    • Maryland Crab Cakes $7.45

      with homemade dipping sauce

    • Lobster Ravioli $6.95

      in a pink marinara sauce

    • Half Rack Of Baby Back Ribs $8.95

      hickory smoked and basted in bbq sauce

  • The Sandwich Shoppe
    served w/steak house fries, cole slaw & pickles substitute baked potato $1.25, mixed vegetables $0.50, sweet potato fries $1.95, onion rings $1.95, add melted mozzarella cheese or sauteed onions to any sandwich $1.25
    • Sirloin Steak Sandwich $9.95

      center cut 8 oz choice ny shell

    • Garlic Steak Tidbits $10.95

      grilled & sliced ny strip steak over toast with garlic butter

    • Fleet Street $8.95

      thinly sliced hot roast beef hero w/sauteed onions & aujus gravy

    • Beachcomber $8.95

      filet of sole oven baked with olive oil & bread crumbs served on a roll w/ tartar sauce

    • Garlic Chicken Tidbits $9.95

      sliced grilled chicken cutlet over toast with garlic butter

    • Turkey Club Sandwich $8.95

      triple decker with turkey breast, lettuce, tomato & bacon on white toast

    • Grilled Or Blackened Chicken Sandwich $8.25

      on a soft bun with lettuce & tomato

    • Monte Cristo $8.95

      filled with ham, mozzarella, swiss cheese and turkey and sauteed in our special batter

    • Corned Beef Or Pastrami Rueben $9.95

      open faced w/sauerkraut, & topped with melted swiss

    • Open Hot Turkey $9.95

      over stuffing, topped with homemade gravy and mashed potatoes

    • Open Hot Roast Beef $9.95

      thinly sliced & topped with homemade gravy and mashed potatoes

    • Chicken Supreme Hero $9.95

      twin grilled chicken breasts with lettuce, tomato, red onion & bacon

  • Salads
    add grilled or blackened. chicken $3, tuna steak $5, shrimp $5
    • Black & Blue Sliced Steak Salad $14.95

      skillet seared cajun spiced shell steak, sliced & served over mixed greens, red onion, crumbled bleu cheese, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette.

    • Crispy Chicken Salad $10.95

      bite sized morsels of crispy chicken tenders with tomato, red onion, crispy bacon, hard cooked egg, shredded cheddar, over mixed greens honey mustard dressing

    • Blackened Shrimp Salad $12.95

      shrimp, field greens, crumbled goat cheese with remoulade dressing

    • Caesar Salad $7.95

      crisp romaine with creamy caesar dressing

    • Greek Salad $9.95

      mixed greens, feta cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumbers, pepperoncini & olives

    • Chicken Salad Or Tuna Salad Platter $8.95

      with fresh garden greens, potato salad & coleslaw

    • Chef Salad $9.95

      julienne deli meats over mixed greens

    • House Salad $3.95

      mixed greens, tomato and cucumber with choice of dressing

    • Spinach Salad $8.95

      chilled spinach leaves w/ red onion, egg & bacon-choice of dressing

    • Old Street Salad $10.95

      mesculin greens, diced peas, toasted walnuts, sun-dried cranberries, crumbled goat cheese, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette

  • Chicken
    • Chicken Saltimbocca $17.95

      sherry brown sauce w/ mushrooms, proscuitto & mozzarella over spinach

    • Chicken Scampi Or Francaise $16.95

      your choice - served over pasta

    • Chicken Cardinal $16.95

      sauteed with roasted red peppers, melted mozzarella in a white wine butter sauce

    • Chicken And Shrimp Scampi $17.95

      in a garlic and lemon butter sauce, over pasta

    • Grilled Or Blackened Chicken Platter $15.95

      simply delicious chicken breasts-straight up

    • Chicken Old Street $17.95

      sauteed with ham & swiss cheese in a mushroom wine gravy

  • The Butcher Block
    substitute- french onion soup $1.25, caesar salad $1.95, sweet potato fries $1.95, add - sauteed mushrooms & onions $2.95, garlic butter $1.50, creamed spinach $2.95
    • Beef & Reef $26.95

      grilled ny shell steak & stuffed shrimp

    • Land & Sea $28.95

      grilled ny shell steak & danish lobster tails

    • Ny Shell Steak $18.95

      choice center cut boneless shell

    • Chopped Sirloin Steak $14.95

      with mushrooms and brown gravy

    • Prime Minister Trio $18.95

      1/2 rack of baby back ribs, fried shrimp & chicken breast

    • Baby Back Ribs $17.95

      hickory smoked and served with bbq sauce

    • Grilled Porterhouse Steak $26.95

      the steak house favorite

  • Wraps
    hand rolled in a flour tortilla. served with red skin potato salad
    • Blackened Shrimp $10.95

      goat cheese, sun dried tomato mayo, roasted red peppers, mesculin greens

    • Turkey $8.95

      sliced breast of turkey, muenster cheese, roasted red peppers & honey mustard dressing

    • Greek Chicken $8.95

      grilled chicken breast, feta, tomato, onion, mixed greens, greek salad dressing

    • Grilled Chicken $8.95

      caesar grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, plum tomato, caesar salad dressing

    • Mediterranean $8.95

      goat cheese, tomatoes, sliced portabello and mixed greens.

    • Olde English $8.95

      shaved roast beef, romaine lettuce, sliced tomatoes, mild cheddar & horseradish sauce

  • Pasta
    served with choice of soup or salad add grilled or blackened chicken $3, shrimp $5
    • Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe Over Rigatoni $16.95

      tossed in garlic & olive oil

    • Fettuccine Alfredo $13.95

      creamy sauce of butter, parmigiana cheese

    • Rigatoni Alla Vodka $14.95

      made with marinara, proscuitto, vodka, and cream

    • Lobster Ravioli $16.95

      in a pink marinara sauce

  • Dock Side
    • Neptune Platter $25.95

      baked clams, danish lobster tails, filet of sole & shrimp-butter, white wine sauce

    • Stuffed Shrimp $18.95

      butterfied and piled high with seafood stuffing. white wine butter sauce

    • Shrimp Scampi $17.95

      in a garlic and lemon butter sauce, over pasta

    • Tuna Steak $16.95

      grilled or blackened

    • Fried Shrimp Platter $16.95

      large gulf shrimp fried to a golden brown

    • Beer Battered Fish And Chips $14.95

      with malt vinegar & tartar sauce

    • Shrimp Stewart $16.95

      shrimp with seafood stuffing, garlic butter, mozzarella cheese & fresh copped bacon

    • Broiled Filet Of Sole $16.95

    • Stuffed Filet Of Sole $17.95

      with seafood stuffing

  • Sides
    • French Fries $2.95

    • Potato Salad $2.5

    • Steamed Broccoll $2.95

    • Cole Slaw $1.95

    • Beer Battered Onion $4.25

    • Mixed Vegetables $2.95

    • Sweet Potato Fries $4.25

    • Garlic Dill Pickles $1.95

    • Baked Potato W/ Sour $2.5

    • Creamed Spinach $2.95

    • Sauteed Broccoll Rabe $3.45

    • Garlic Mashed Potatoes $1.95

  • The NY Deli Counter
    served with coleslaw and garlic dill pickles. substitute a cup of soup & 1/2 sandwich - no extra charge
    • Pastrami $8.95

      ny style pastrami on rye

    • Chicken Salad $7.95

      all white meat chicken blended with celery, roasted red peppers, mayo

    • Tuna Salad $7.95

      tuna mixed with celery, onion, and hellmann's mayo

    • Grilled Cheese, Bacon & Tomato $7.95

      served open faced

    • Corned Beef $8.95

      ny corned beef on rye

    • Turkey $7.95

      oven roasted turkey breast. choice of bread

    • Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato $7.25

      the classic sandwich

    • Roast Beef $7.95

      thinly sliced roasted beef. choice of bread

  • Omelets
    three freshly beaten eggs served with steak house fries
    • Plain Omelet $7.95

    • Cheese $8.45

    • Bacon & Cheese $8.95

    • Western $8.95

    • Quiche Omelet $9.45

    • Green Pepper & Sauteed Onions $8.95

    • Spinach & Bacon $8.95

    • Broccoli & Cheddar $8.95

    • Jalapeno Peppers & Sour Cream $8.95

  • Luncheon Packages - Package ( A )
    weekdays only - 2 hours unlimited soda coffee & tea pp tax & gratuity
    • Burger Platter $12.95

      served with steak house fries, lettuce & tomato, cole slaw, & pickles. (turkey or veggie burger available)

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.95

      grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, plum tomato and caesar salad dressing.

    • Crispy Chicken Salad $12.95

      bite sized morsels of crispy chicken tenders with tomato, red onion, crispy bacon, hard cooked egg & shredded cheddar over mixed greens honey mustard dressing

    • Beachcomber $12.95

      filet of sole over baked with olive oil & bread crumbs served on a roll w/ tartar sauce

    • Large Greek Salad $12.95

      mixed greens with feta cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumbers, pepperoncini & olives

  • 2:54:41 AM Luncheon Packages - Package ( B )
    garden salad with house dressing unlimited soda coffee & tea pp tax & gratuity
    • Garlic Steak Tidbits $15.95

      grilled & sliced ny strip steak served on toast with garlic butter, rice & vegetable.

    • Chicken "Old Steet" $15.95

      sauteed with ham & swiss in a mushroom wine sauce

    • Rigatoni Ala Vodka $15.95

      marinara sauce with proscuitto, vodka & cream

    • Sole Bearnaise $15.95

      broiled filet of sole topped with beamaise sauce & scallions, served with rice & vegetable.

  • Afternoon Party Packages - Package ( C )
    old street "cheese & crackers" garden salad with house dressing unlimited soda occasion cake included coffee & tea color coordinated linens pp tax & gratuity
    • Chicken Entree $19.95

      choice of chicken old street, francaise, marsala, cardinale or scampi.

    • Garlic Steak Tidbits $19.95

      grilled & sliced ny sirloin steak served on toast with garlic butter, rice & vegetable.

    • Seafood Entree $19.95

      choice of sole bearnaise or sole almondine served with rice & vegetable.

    • Pasta Entree $19.95

      choice of rigatoni ala vodka, penne carbonara, or penne sapparito

  • Afternoon Party Packages - Package ( D )
    old street "cheese & crackers" garden salad with house dressing unlimited soda occasion cake included coffee & tea color coordinated linens pp tax & gratuity
    • Choice Of 5 Chafing Dishes $22.95

      a wide variety of selections in each category chicken beef seafood pasta vegetable

  • Dinner Packages - Package ( E )
    old street "cheese & crackers" garden salad with house dressing unlimited soda coffee / tea & ny cheesecake
    • Choice Of Three Entrees $21.95

      a wide variety of selections in each category chicken seafood pasta pp + tax & gratuity

  • Dinner Packages - Package ( F )
    old street "cheese & crackers" soup garden salad with house dressing unlimited coffee & tea & ny cheesecake pp tax & gratuity
    • Choice Of Four Entrees $25.95

      a wide variety of selections in each category chicken seafood pasta boneless sirloin steak

  • Salads
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Tossed Garden Salad $20

    • Greek Salad $25

    • Caesar Salad $20

    • Old Street Spinach Salad $20

    • Grilled Or Blackened Chicken Caesar Salad $40

    • Gorgonzola Salad $22

    • Crispy Chicken Salad $40

    • Old Street Salad Pears, Walnuts, Goat Cheese, Mesculin Greens $40

  • Wraps
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Assorted Wraps $45

  • Pastas
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Rigatoni Ala Vodka $35

    • Tortellini Alfredo $35

    • Farfella Primavera $35

      (marinara or alfredo)

    • Penne Sapparito $45

      sun dried tomatoes, proscuitto, mushrooms

    • Baked Ziti $35

    • Penne W/ Garlic Shrimp & Roasted Red Peppers $55

    • Fettuccine & Shrimp Florentine $45

    • Linguine With Clam Sauce $35

    • Stuffed Shells $35

  • Chicken Entrees
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Chicken Francaise $45

      lemon, butter, white wine

    • Chicken Marsala $45

      mushrooms, marsala wine sauce

    • Chicken Mancini $50

      artichoke, red pepper, lemon, butter, white wine

    • Chicken Scampi $45

      lemon butter, garlic, white wine

    • Chicken San Marco $50

      sherry brown sauce, sun dried tomatoes

    • Honey Dipped Fried Chicken $35

    • Chicken Piccata $45

      lemon, butter, white wine, artichokes, capers

    • Wing Dings $35

    • Chicken Gismonde $50

      sherry sauce, peas, potatoes

    • Chicken Marie $45

      artichokes, mushrooms, lemon sauce

    • Chicken Fingers $40

  • Beef Entrees
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Beef & Broccoli $45

    • Sausage, Pepper, & Potato $45

    • Pepper Steak $45

    • Beef Tips In Mushroom Burgundy Brown Sauce $45

    • Swedish Meatballs $30

  • Seafood Entrees
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Stuffed Flounder Athenian $45

    • Stuffed Flounder $45

    • Seafood Newburgh $45

    • Seafood Fra Diavolo $50

    • Stuffed Clams $35

    • Mussels Marinara Or Fra Diavolo $40

    • Mussels $40

      with garlic & oil

    • Shrimp Creole $50

    • Fried Calamari $45

  • Sides
    1/2 tray serves 8-10, full tray serves 15-20
    • Rice Pilaf $25

    • New Potatoes $25

      w/ butter & parsley

    • Steamed $25

      garden vegetables

    • Broccoli Bartel $35

      w/ cheese & cracker crumb topping

    • String Beans Almondine $25

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.