• New York
  • Sag Harbor
  • Bagel Buoy

Bagel Buoy

(631) 725-7690
  • 3 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
  • Website
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Breakfast All Day
    • Big "2" $5.59

      2 eggs, 2 meats and 2 cheeses.

    • Little "2" $4.59

      2 eggs, meat and cheese.

    • The Croissant $5.59

      2 eggs, meat and cheese.

  • Omelettes
    All served with homefries & buttered bagel.
    • Avocado $8.95

      Tomato, onions and jack and cheddar.

    • Western $8.95

      Ham, peppersand onion.

    • Popeye $8.95

      Spinach, mushrooms and mozzarella.

    • Italian $8.95

      Salami, sausage, tomato and provolone.

    • Mushroom & Cheese $8.95

    • Vegetable $8.95

      Mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomato and cheese.

    • Fajita $8.95

      Chicken breast, salsa and cheese.

    • Lox & Onions $13.95

    • Plain $6.95

    • Diet Specials $8.95

      Egg whites, turkey bacon and alpine swiss.

    • Cheese $6.95

  • Lunch & Dinner
    • Turkey Club $9.95

      Lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo and French fries.

    • Rancho Hero $9.95

      Chicken cutlets, bacon, swiss, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.

    • Philly Cheese Steak $9.95

      Grilled onions, peppers and cheese served on a grilled hero.

    • 2 Hot Dogs & French Fries $6.95

      Boars head hot dogs.

    • New York Combo $9.95

      Grilled pastrami and corned beef, swiss, lettuce, tomato and deli mustard on a grilled hero.

    • Chicken Cutlet Special $9.95

      Bacon, cheddar and French fries.

    • Italian Sub $9.95

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions and Italian dressing.

    • Fish & Chips $9.95

      Cole slaw, tartar sauce and French fries.

    • Chicken Quesadilla $8.95

      Cheddar jack cheese, guacamole and sour cream.

  • Spreads & Salads
    • Lo-Fat Cream Cheese $1.5

    • Peanut Butter $2.5

    • Vegetable or Scallion $1.5

    • Butter or Jelly $2

    • Shrimp Cocktail(Per Lb) $21.99

    • Egg Salad $8.95

    • Tuna Lite Salad $8.95

    • Sundried Tomato $1.5

    • Cream Cheese & Bacon $4.59

    • Honey Walnut Chicken $8.95

    • Lobster Salad (Per Lb) $49.99

    • Chicken Salad $8.95

    • Tofu or Vegetable Tofu $1.5

    • Cinnamon Raisin Walnut $1.5

    • Solid White Tuna Salad $8.95

    • Egg White Salad $8.95

    • Chicken Cutlets $8.95

    • Lox Spread or Walnut $1.5

    • BBQ Chicken Salad $8.95

    • Cream Cheese $1.5

    • Whitefish Salad $8.95

  • Chicken Sandwiches
    All served with lettuce, tomato & French fries.
    • Classic $9.95

    • Cajun $9.95

      Blackened, cole slaw and mayo.

    • Wrangler $9.95

      Bacon, cheddar and bulls eye Barbeque sauce.

    • Fajita $9.95

      Onions, peppers, jack and cheddar cheese, chipotle mayo.

    • Californian $9.95

      Fresh avocado, jack and cheddar cheese and mayo.

    • Honey Mustard $9.95

      Bacon and mayo.

  • Buoy Burgers
    Home of the 1/2 lb burger. All served with lettuce, tomato, & French fries.
    • Bacon Bleu $9.95

      Crumbled bleu cheese and bacon.

    • Wrangler $9.95

      Bacon, cheddar and bulls eye Barbeque sauce.

    • Black Jack $9.95

      Blackened and pepper jack.

    • Classic $9.95

    • Guacamole $9.95

      Bacon, Swiss and guacamole.

    • 5 Alarm $9.95

      Blackened, pepper jack, jalapeno, salsaand chipotle mayo.

  • Wrap Specials
    Overstuffed and made to order.
    • Souvlaki $9.95

      Grilled chicken, garden salad and tzatziki sauce.

    • Cajun Wrap $9.95

      Blackened chicken, swiss, garden salad, spicy mustard and mayo.

    • Portobello $9.95

      Grilled portobello and carrots, goat cheese, romaine and balsamic vinegar.

    • Cobb $9.95

      Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, garden salad, bleu cheese and balsamic vinegar.

    • Tom & Moe $9.95

      Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, romaine, red peppers and balsamic vinegar.

    • Caesar $9.95

      Grilled chicken and caesar salad.

    • Turkey $9.95

      Sliced turkey, fresh avocado, swiss, garden salad and mayo.

    • BBQ $9.95

      Sliced Barbeque chicken, cheddar, bacon, garden salad, mayo and bulls eye Barbeque.

    • Montauk $9.95

      Solid white tuna salad and garden salad.

    • Spicy Beef $9.95

      Roast beef, American cheese, garden salad and horseradish sauce.

  • Bagel
    • Lo-Carb Bagel $1.5

    • Everything Bagel $1.5

    • Bakers Dozen $13.8

    • Plain Bagel $1.5

    • Single $1.15

  • Famous For Our Sliced Nova Scotia
    • New Yorker $12.95

      Cream cheese, nova, red onion and tomato.

    • Lox & Cream Cheese or Butter $10.95

  • Breakfast Staples
    • Extra Egg $0.5

    • Egg & Cheese $4.59

    • Potato & Egg $4.99

    • French Toast $5.95

    • Extra Meat $1

    • Side Of Meat $3.99

    • Egg & Meat $4.59

    • Meat & Cheese $4.59

    • Home Fries $3.99

    • Egg, Meat & Cheese $5.09

    • Egg $3.59

    • B.l.t $5.99

    • Pancakes $5.95

  • Bakery
    • German Butter Cake $2.25

    • Crumb Cake $2.25

    • Cinnamon Bun $2.5

    • Croissants $2.25

    • Dreesen Donuts $0.85

    • Muffins $2.5

      Blueberry, chocolate chip, carrot cake, bran, berry blast, double chocolate, etc.

    • Apple Turnover $2.25

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.