• New York
  • Sag Harbor
  • The Cuddy

The Cuddy

(631) 725-0101
  • 29 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Pub Food
  • $$$$$
(631) 725-0101
  • Menu
  • Starters & Sides
    • Season's Soup $7

    • Romaine Caesar Salad $11

      Olive oil croutons, shaved parmesan

    • Tuscan Kale Salad $14

      Pickled shallot, toasted walnuts, radish, balsamic vinaigrette, gluten free

    • Roasted Beet Salad $14

      Seasonal greens, frisee, bacon, aged cheddar. Add grilled chicken or salmon to any salad $8.00, gluten free

    • Braised Pork Belly $14

      Chickpea salad, dates, spicy bajan sauce. Add egg $2.00

    • Steamed PEI Mussels $12

      Grilled bread, choice of white wine fennel broth or tomato & red wine chili sauce

    • Greek Yogurt & Granola $6

      Fresh fruit

    • Deviled Eggs $5

      Truffle oil, chives

    • Sweet Potato Chips & Dip $5

      Jalapeno hummus or tzatziki, gluten free

    • Carrot & Cucumber Pickles $4

      House made, gluten free, vegan

    • Hand Cut French Fries $6

      Truffle salt, gluten free, vegan

    • Side Salad $6

      Seasonal greens, red wine vinaigrette, gluten free, vegan

    • Bacon $7

      Gluten free

    • English Muffin or Toast $2

    • Grits Tomato Jam $5

    • Broccoli Rabe $6

      Gluten free, vegan

  • Entrees
    • Fish of the Day

    • Fried Chicken & Waffles $22

      Confit, scallion waffles, plum jam, honey butter

    • Grilled Salmon $29

      Cauliflower puree, sauteed brussel sprouts, gluten free

    • The Cuddy Burger $20

      Aged cheddar, bibb lettuce, tomato jam, pickle, caramelized onion, brioche bun, hand cut truffle fries. Add house cured bacon or sunny side up egg $2.00

    • Roasted Chicken $24

      Rice pilaf, grilled leeks, garlic lemon sauce, gluten free

    • Short Ribs $27

      Polenta cake, sauteed spinach, rosemary red wine jus, gluten free

    • Scallops & Grits $29

      Grits, frisee, tomato jam, house cured bacon, panang curry

    • Grilled Pork Loin $27

      Pickled cabbage, seared cauliflower, juniper reduction, gluten free

  • Small Plates
    • Season's Soup $7

    • Romaine Caesar Salad $11

      Olive oil croutons, shaved parmesan

    • Sweet Potato Chips & Dip $5

      Jalapeno hummus or tzatziki, gluten free

    • Tuscan Kale Salad $14

      Pickled shallot, toasted walnuts, radish, balsamic vinaigrette, gluten free, vegan

    • Carrot & Cucumber Pickles $4

      House made, gluten free, vegan

    • Roasted Beet Salad $14

      Seasonal greens, frisee, bacon, aged cheddar. Add grilled chicken or salmon to any salad $8.00, gluten free

    • Grits Tomato Jam $5

    • Steamed PEI Mussels $12

      Grilled bread. Choice of tomato & red wine chili sauce or white wine & fennel broth

    • Grilled Leeks $8

      Gluten free, vegan

    • Braised Pork Belly $14

      Chickpea salad, dates, spicy bajan sauce

    • Deviled Eggs $5

      Truffle oil, chives, gluten free

    • Roasted Sunchokes $7

      Gluten free, vegan

    • Hand Cut French Fries $6

      Truffle salt, gluten free vegan

    • Broccoli Rabe $6

      Garlic oil saute, gluten free, vegan

    • Sauteed Brussels Sprouts $7

      Gluten free, vegan

  • Large Plates
    • Grilled Cheese $14

      Aged cheddar, goat cheese, tomato jam, frisee, sourdough bread with truffle fries or side salad

    • House Cured Bacon, Egg & Cheddar Cheese $11

      Brioche bun, with a side salad

    • Eggs Benedict $12

      Smoked salmon, two poached eggs, hollandaise sauce, english muffin, with a side salad

    • Two Eggs, any Style $8

      Side salad and toast. Substitute egg whites $1.00

    • Omelete $12

      Spinach, goat cheese, with a side salad. Substitute egg whites $1.00

    • Salmon Sandwich $16

      Bibb lettuce, tomato, tzatziki sauce, brioche bun with truffle fries or side salad

    • Challah French Toast $11

      Whipped cream, pure maple syrup

    • Classic Waffles $9

      Whipped cream, pure maple syrup

    • Steamed PEI Mussels $12

      Grilled bread and a choice of tomato & red wine chili sauce or white wine fennel broth

    • The Cuddy Burger $20

      Bibb lettuce, aged cheddar, tomato jam, pickles, caramelized onion, brioche bun, with truffle fries or side salad. Add house cured bacon or sunny side up egg $2.00

    • Fried Chicken & Waffles $22

      Confit, scallion waffles, plum jam, honey butter

    • Scallops & Grits $29

      Grits, panang curry, frisee, tomato jam, house cured bacon

    • Roasted Chicken $24

      Rice pilaf, grilled leeks, garlic lemon sauce, gluten free

    • Short Ribs $27

      Polenta cake, sauteed spinach, rosemary red wine jus, gluten free

  • Brunch Plates
    • Grilled Cheese $14

      Aged cheddar, goat cheese, tomato jam, frisee on sourdough bread with truffle fries or side salad

    • Salmon Sandwich $16

      Bibb lettuce, tomato, tzatziki sauce, brioche bun with truffle fries or side salad

    • The Cuddy Burger $20

      Bibb lettuce, aged cheddar, tomato jam, pickle, caramelized onion, brioche bun, with truffle fries or side salad. Add house cured bacon or sunny side up egg $2.00

    • House Cured Bacon, Egg and Cheddar Cheese $11

      On an brioche bun, side salad

    • Eggs Benedict $12

      Smoked salmon, poached eggs, hollandaise sauce, english muffin, side salad

    • Two Eggs, any Style $8

      Side salad and toast. Substitute egg whites $1.00

    • Omelet $13

      Spinach, goat cheese, side salad. Substitute egg whites $1.00

    • Challah French Toast $11

      Whipped cream, pure maple syrup

    • Classic Waffles $9

      Whipped cream, pure maple syrup

  • Homemade Refreshers
    Spike with prairie vodka, add $5.00
    • Homemade Lemonade $5

      Fresh lemon juice & agave syrup

    • Arnold Palmer $5

      Fresh lemon juice & black tea syrup

    • Lime Ricky $5

      Fresh lime juice, simple syrup & club soda

    • Unsweetened Iced Tea $4

      Tea steeped with fresh lemon, orange & mint

    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $4

      Orange, lime & lemon juices are always fresh squeezed

    • Hot Mulled Cider $5

      Cinnamon & honey

  • Coffee
    • Java Nation Coffee, Decaf $3

    • Nespresso Espresso $3

    • Nespresso Americano $3

    • Nespresso Cappuccino $4

    • Nespresso Cafe Latte $4

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.