- New York
- Sag Harbor
- Madison and Main
Madison and Main
Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.
- 126 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
-
No cuisines specified
- $$$$$
-
Madison and Main
-
-
Super - Starters
-
Bouchot Mussels 1 lb $12.00
Herbs, garlic, shallots, white wine, garlic toast
-
Braised Angus Short Ribs of Beef & Barley Risotto $14.00
Crispy red onions
-
Charleston Wild Giant Shrimp $15.00
Creamy grits, crispy shallots
-
Fresh Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes $16.00
Roasted corn, avocado, tomato, salad
-
Whole Belly Ipswich Clams $16.00
Crispy, chipotle tartare sauce
-
Fritto Misto $16.00
Calamari, scallops, shrimp, zucchini, shiitake, herbs, lemon aioli
-
Eastern Shore Steamer Clams 1 lb $18.00
Savory old bay herb broth
-
-
Super - Soups & Salads
-
Roasted Corn, Carrot, Fresh Pea Chowder $10.00
Brushetta of summer mushrooms
-
North Fork Baby Lettuce Salad $12.00
Champagne vinegar, heirloom tomatoes, vermont goat cheese
-
Romaine Hearts & Treviso Caesar Salad $12.00
Parmesan, garlic toast, anchovy dressing
-
Peconic Fisherman's Soup $14.00
Shrimp, scallop, fish, garlic toast, saffron, aioli, fennel
-
Iceberg Wedge Salad $14.00
Crisp bacon lardons, heirloom tomato, maytag blue cheese dressing
-
-
Super - Mains, Fish & Pasta
-
Petite Ravioli of Fresh Peas $22.00
Braised summer vegetable broth
-
Pan Seared Local Fillet of Sole $28.00
Brown butter, capers, lemon, parsley, red potatoes
-
Roasted Black Sea Bass $28.00
Summer vegetable cous-cous, heirloom tomatoes, baby clams
-
Montauk Tuna $29.00
Roasted, sicilian style, eggplant, garlic, pine nuts, balsamic glaze
-
Eastern Sea Scallops $29.00
Seared, white beans, corn & summer vegetable succotash
-
-
Supper - Raw BarFreshly grated horseradish cocktail sauce & summer pepper salsa
-
Eastern Shore Clams $9.00
Little necks (6)
-
Eastern Shore Oysters $16.00
Montauk, blue point, blue island (6)
-
Wild Giant Shrimp Cocktail $18.00
Chilled & iced (6)
-
Hard Shell Maine Lobster $19.00
Chilled & iced half 2 lb lobster
-
Raw Bar Platters $49.00
Iced half 2 lb chilled lobster 6 little neck clams 6 local oysters 6 giant shrimp cocktail
-
-
Super - For the Table
-
Crispy Stuffed Meatballs $10.00
Sheep milk cheese, herbs & lemon
-
Crab Stuffed Top Neck Clam $13.00
Seafood stuffed cherry stone clams
-
Wild Mushroom Flat Bread $14.00
Spinach, parmesan & goat cheese
-
Charred Octopus, Hot Chili Peppers, Olives & Tomato $16.00
Garlic
-
Local Tuna Citrus Ceviche $16.00
Roasted pineapple salsa & tobiko
-
Lobster Slider $18.00
Fresh shucked lobster, lemon, potato roll
-
-
Super - Mains, Meat & PoultryAngus burger cooked to order
-
Nicolas Prime Angus Burger $18.00
Smoked bacon, caramel onions, wisconsin cheddar, fried potatoes
-
Charcoal Grilled Organic Chicken Paillard $22.00
Chopped mediterranean salad, feta cheese
-
Organic Chicken $25.00
Herb crusted, cast iron pressed, parmesan mashed potatoes
-
Roasted Crisp Crescent LI Duck $29.00
North fork root vegetables, orange & cherry jus
-
-
Fried Herb Potatoes
-
Fried Idaho Potatoes $8.00
-
Parmesan Mashed Potatoes $8.00
-
-
Market Vegetables
-
Steamed Mixed Vegetables $10.00
-
Creamed Parmesan Spinach $10.00
-
-
Madison & Main's SpecialtiesServed with fried potato, vegetable
-
Bone-in NY Strip Steak $39.00
-
Bone-in Double Rib Eye Steak $49.00
-
Double Barrel Cut Filet Mignon $39.00
-
2 lb Hard Shell Eastern Shore Lobster $45.00
Steamed lemon & butter
-
-
Kid's Menu - Main CourseIncludes drink, side & dessert
-
Chicken Tenders $10.00
French fries
-
All Natural Hamburger on Potato Bun $10.00
French fries
-
All Natural Cheddar Cheese Burger on Potato Bun $10.00
French fries
-
Rigatoni with Fresh Tomato Sauce & Parmesan $10.00
-
-
Desserts
-
Brioche Molten Chocolate Bread Pudding
Fresh cherries jubilee
-
Caramelized Apple & Almond Tart
Tahitian vanilla gelato
-
Double Chocolate Gooey Cake
Pistachio gelato
-
Aunt Carol's Graham Cracker Key Lime Pie
French meringue
-
Greek Yogurt Pannacotta
Honey tahitian vanilla & fresh blue berries
-
Seasonal Melon & Fresh Berries
Drizzled with local honey & lemon
-
Michael's Cookie Monster Sundae
Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie, vanilla gelato & homemade chocolate syrup
-
-
Kids Menu - Desserts
-
Michael's Cookie Monster Sundae $10.00
-
-
Kids Menu - Drinks
-
Milk $10.00
-
Juice $10.00
-
Shirley Temple $10.00
-
Any Fountain Soda $10.00
-
-
Starters
-
Bouchot Mussels 1 lb $12.00
Herbs, garlic, shallots, white wine, garlic toast
-
Wild Giant Shrimp $14.00
Creamy grits, crispy shallots
-
Fresh Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes $16.00
Roasted corn, avocado, tomato, salad
-
Local Tuna Citrus Ceviche $16.00
Roasted pineapple salsa and tobiko
-
Whole Belly Ipswich Clams $16.00
Crispy, chipotle tartare sauce
-
Charred Octopus, Hot Chili Peppers, Olives & Tomato $16.00
Garlic
-
Fritto Misto $17.00
Calamari, scallops, shrimp, zucchini, shiitake, herbs, lemon aioli
-
Eastern Shore Steamer Clams 1 lb $18.00
Savory old bay, herb broth
-
-
Big Luncheon SaladsAll salads available as vegetarian
-
North Fork Baby Lettuce Salad $14.00
Champagne vinegar, heirloom tomatoes, vermont goat cheese
-
Organic Roast Chicken, Romaine & Treviso Caesar Salad $16.00
Parmesan, garlic toast
-
Charcoal Grilled Organic Chicken Paillard $16.00
Chopped mediterranean salad, feta cheeset
-
Aged Black Angus NY Sirloin Chopped Wedge Salad $20.00
Lardon, heirloom tomatoes, maytag blue cheese
-
Grilled Shrimp, Asparagus & Arugula Salad $21.00
Crisp potato, egg, dijon mustard dressing
-
-
Soups & Pastas
-
Peconic Fisherman's Soup $14.00
Shrimp, scallop, fish, garlic toast, saffron, aioli, fennel
-
Fresh English Peas Petite Ravioli $22.00
Braised summer vegetable broth
-
-
Raw BarFreshly grated horseradish cocktail sauce & summer pepper salsa.
-
Eastern Shore Clams $9.00
Little necks (6)
-
Eastern Shore Oysters $16.00
Montauk, blue point, blue island (6)
-
Wild Giant Shrimp Cocktail $18.00
Chilled & iced (6)
-
Hard Shell Maine Lobster $19.00
Chilled & iced half 2 lb lobster
-
Raw Bar Platter $49.00
Iced half 2 lb chilled lobster 6 little neck clams 6 local oysters 6 giant shrimp cocktail
-
-
Hamburgers & SandwichesAll served with fried idaho potatoes, cabbage & celery root slaw
-
Prime Angus Burger (Cooked to Order) $16.00
Smoked bacon, caramel onions, wisconsin cheddar
-
Vegetable Sandwich $14.00
Zucchini, eggplant, caramel onions, avocado, tomato, sprouts, lemon aioli
-
Crisp Local Fluke Sandwich $15.00
Chipotle tartare sauce, melted cheddar
-
Organic Grilled Chicken Sandwich $15.00
Vermont goat cheese, avocado, heirloom tomato
-
Jumbo Shrimp BLT $16.00
Smoked bacon, heirloom tomatoes, north fork arugula, chipotle may
-
Crisp Whole Belly Clam Roll $16.00
Chipolte tartare sauce, lemon
-
Pan Roasted Sweet & Spicy Fresh Ahi Tuna Taco $16.00
Summer vegetable slaw
-
Fresh Shucked Lobster Roll $20.00
Toasted potato roll, lemon, parsley celery.
-
-
Big Luncheon SaladsAll salads available as vegetarian
-
North Fork Baby Lettuce Salad $14.00
Champagne vinegar, heirloom tomatoes, vermont goat cheese
-
Charcoal Grilled Organic Chicken Paillard $16.00
Chopped mediterranean salad, feta cheese
-
Organic Roast Chicken, Romaine & Treviso Caesar Salad $18.00
Parmesan, garlic toast
-
Aged Black Angus NY Sirloin Chopped Wedge Salad $20.00
Lardon, heirloom tomatoes, maytag blue cheese
-
Grilled Shrimp, Asparagus & Arugula Salad $21.00
Crisp potato, egg, dijon mustard dressing
-
-
Raw BarFreshly grated horseradish cocktail sauce & summer pepper salsa.
-
Eastern Shore Clams $9.00
Little necks (6)
-
Eastern Shore Oysters $16.00
Montauk, blue point, blue island (6)
-
Local Tuna Citrus Ceviche $16.00
Roasted pineapple salsa and tobiko
-
Wild Giant Shrimp Cocktail $18.00
Chilled & iced (6)
-
Hard Shell Maine Lobster $19.00
Chilled & iced half 2 lb lobster
-
Raw Bar Platter $49.00
Iced half 2 lb chilled lobster 6 little neck clams 6 local oysters 6 giant shrimp cocktail
-
-
Eggs & GriddleAll served with vegetable hash brown potatoes, country bread toast
-
2 Organic Eggs (Any Style) $12.00
Smoked bacon or virginia ham.
-
Cast Iron Challah French Toast $12.00
Bananas foster, ny maple syrup
-
Stack of Dutch Country Buttermilk Pancakes $13.00
Fresh berries
-
Poached Eggs on Toasted Country Bread $14.00
Virginia ham, hollandaise sauce
-
Organic Omelette $15.00
Wisconsin white cheddar, vegetables, caramel onions
-
Charleston Wild Giant Shrimp, Creamy Grits & Poached Eggs $16.00
Country ham
-
Chicken Fried Black Angus Steak & 2 Fried Eggs $18.00
Toast, gravy
-
-
Hamburgers, SandwichesAll served with fried idaho potatoes, cabbage & celery root slaw
-
Vegetable Sandwich $14.00
Zucchini, eggplant, caramel onions, avacado, tomato, sprouts, lemon aiolo
-
Organic Grilled Chicken Sandwich $15.00
Goat cheese, avocado, heirloom tomato, lettuce
-
Crisp Local Fluke Sandwich $15.00
Chipotle tartare sauce, melted cheddar, avocado, tomato
-
Pan Roasted Sweet & Spicy Fresh Ahi Tuna Taco $16.00
Summer vegetableslaw
-
Prime Angus Burger. $16.00
Smoked bacon, caramel onions, wisconsin cheddar
-
Jumbo Shrimp BLT $16.00
Smoked bacon, heirloom tomatoes, north fork arugula, chipotle mayo
-
Fresh Shucked Lobster Roll $20.00
Toasted potato roll, lemon, parsley celery, lemon
-
Menu for Madison and Main provided by Allmenus.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.