Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • Five Mile Stone

Five Mile Stone

(212) 933-0913

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 1640 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
  • American ,  Bar Food
  • $$$$$
  • Five Mile Stone

  • (212) 933-0913
  • Menu
  • Chilled Oysters
    • East Coast And West Coast

    • Shrimp Cocktail $10.00

      house cocktail sauce

    • Platter $15.00+

      oysters, shrimp, mussels

  • Bar Snacks
    • Smoked-Spiced Peanuts $3.00

    • House Pork Rinds $4.00

      chili salt

    • Jalapeño Peanut Brittle $3.00

    • Jerky Jar $5.00

    • Pickle Plate Chef $7.00

      selected seasonal vegetables

    • House Chips $4.00

  • Small Plates - Sliders
    • Short Rib $14.00

      stout braised short rib, gruyère, creamy horseradish, potato bun

    • Turkey $13.00

      herb smoked turkey, cranberry compote, cornbread stuffing, red-eye gravy, potato bun

    • Crab $14.00

      lump crab, celery, tarragon, scallion aioli, romaine hearts, potato bun

  • Small Plates - Wings $13
    • Nashville Hot

    • Miso Molè

    • Maple & Orange

  • Small Plates - Soup Du Jour
    • Crab Cakes $15.00

      house remoulade, blacked tomato salad

    • Mac 'n Quack $15.00

      duck confit, creamed kale, house-smoked cheddar, parmesan, crisp duck skin

    • Fried Green Tomatoes $9.00

      house-made ranch dressing

    • Beer Battered Feta $10.00

      honey, pine nuts, herbs

    • Mussels $12.00

      house chorizo, ipa, cilantro

    • Mussels $4.00

      add fries

  • Small Plates - Soup Du Jour
    • Soup, Salad & Sandwich

      chef's selection

  • Salads
    • Shaved Brussel Sprouts $14.00

      apple, toasted hazelnuts, shaved pecorino, apple cider vinaigrette

    • Fall Salad $15.00

      candied beets, fennel, pine nuts, pomegranate, carrots, arugula, sherry vinaigrette

    • Warm Goat Cheese $15.00

      bacon lardons, potatoes, radishes, frisèe, sauce gribichè

    • Quinoa $15.00

      frisèe, fuji apples, bleu cheese, red onions, yellow raisins, apple cider vinaigrette

    • Grilled Caesar $14.00

      romaine head, polenta croutons, parmesan, caper dust, red onion marmalade

  • Sandwiches
    • Po' Boy $15.00

      oyster

    • Po' Boy $15.00

      shrimp

    • Po' Boy $15.00

      catfish

    • Beer Can Chicken Club $14.00

      avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion, bacon, scallion aioli

    • Grilled Vegetable Club $14.00

      squash, zucchini, red bell peppers, scallions, lettuce, tomato, onion, peanut butter hummus

    • Philly Cheese Steak $14.00

      house-smoked cheddar sauce, peppers, onions, french bread

    • Country Ham & Cheese $14.00

      gruyère, caramelized onions, fresh basil

  • Burgers
    • House $14.00

      lettuce, tomato, onion, house pickles, scallion aioli, sesame seed bun

    • House $1.00

      add cheddar or aged bleu

    • House $2.00

      add bacon

    • PBJ & B $15.00

      peanut butter, candied bacon, red onion jam

    • Barley $15.00

      house-made veggie burger, roasted garlic aioli, avocado, red onions

    • Breakfast $15.00

      house bacon, cheddar, sunny side up egg, lettuce, tomato, onion, scallion aioli

    • Lamb $16.00

      feta, mint chimichurri sauce, red pepper jam

  • Entrees
    • Crab Stuffed Shrimp $22.00

      jalapeño-cheddar grits, bacon, kale, hot sauce beurre blanc

    • Pumpkin Risotto $18.00

      fall succotash, pumpkin seeds, crispy sage, parmesan

    • Seared Duck Breast $26.00

      sweet potato purèe, roasted brussel sprouts, sour demi-glace

    • Butcher Steak $27.00

      fall succotash-sweet potatoes, squash, zucchini, corn, red wine demi-glace

  • Sides
    • House Fries $6.00

    • Cauliflower Au Gratin $8.00

    • Mixed Green Salad $6.00

    • Roasted Brussel Spouts & Squash $8.00

  • Kick Starters
    • Bacon Sampler $9.00

      smokey, sweet, spicy

    • Pickle Plate $7.00

    • Duck Pancakes $14.00

      corncakes, stone fruit

    • Crab Cakes $15.00

      blacked tomato salad

    • Beer Batter Feta $10.00

      honey, herbs, pine nuts

  • Eye Openers
    • Oyster Shooters $8.00

      bloody or garden

    • Bloody Mary $9.00

      with house pickle juice

    • Garden Mary $9.00

      tomattillos, cucumber, peppers

    • Pimm & Proper $11.00

      pimm's #1, basil-infused vodka, cucumber-mint syrup, lemon juice

    • French 75 $19.00

      city of london gin, lemon juice, simple syrup, champagne

  • Eggs
    Served With Hashbrowns. No Substitutions.
    • Chicken Fried Steak $15.00

      cowboy biscuit, redeye gravy, fried egg

    • Cowboy Breakfast $15.00

      spiced short rib ragu, over easy egg, scallion-cheddar fondue, cowboy biscuit

    • The Sandwich $13.00

      bacon, eggs, cheese, chili, hero

    • Breakfast Burger $17.00

      house bacon, cheddar, sunny side up egg, lettuce, tomato, onion, scallion aoili

    • Green Eggs & Ham $14.00

      country ham, fried green tomatoes, sunny side up eggs, scallion-cheddar fondue, cowboy biscuit

    • Smoked Salmon Benedict $14.00

      poached eggs, english muffin, sautéed greens, cherry tomatoes, onions, capers, hollandaise

    • Eggs Florentine Creamed Kale $13.00

      friend green tomatoes, poached eggs, hollandaise

    • Eggs Cochon $14.00

      poached eggs, pork debris, cowboy biscuit, hollandaise

    • Eggs Benedict $14.00

      country ham, cowboy biscuit, poached eggs, hollandaise

  • Mains
    • Shrimp & Grits $19.00

      crab stuffed shrimp, jalapeño-cheddar grits, bacon, kale, hot sauce beurre blanc

    • French Toast $13.00

      challah bread, fresh fruit, whipped cream

    • Pumpkin Pancakes $14.00

      caramel apples, candied pecans

    • House Burger $14.00

      lettuce, tomato, onion, house pickles, scallion aioli, sesame seed bun, fries or salad

    • House Burger $1.00

      add cheddar or aged bleu

    • House Burger $2.00

      add bacon

    • Barley Burger $15.00

      house-made veggie burger, roasted garlic aioli, avocado, red onions, fries or salad

    • Warm Goat Cheese Salad $15.00

      bacon loardons, potatoes, radishes, frisée, sauce gribiché

    • Fall Salad $15.00

      candied beets, fennel, pine nuts, pomegranate, carrots, arugula, sherry vinaigrette

  • Bar Snacks
    • Smoke-Spiced Peanuts $3.00

    • House Pork Rinds $4.00

      chili salt

    • Jalapeño Peanut Brittle $3.00

    • Jerky Jar $5.00

    • Pickle Plate $7.00

      chef selected seasonal vegetables

    • House Chips $4.00

  • Plates
    • House Fries $6.00

    • Crispy Wings $13.00

      nashville hot, miso molè or maple & orange

    • Crab Slider $14.00

      celery, tarragon, scallion aioli, romaine, potato bun

    • Fried Green Tomatoes $9.00

      house-made ranch dressing

    • Cauliflower Au Gratin $8.00

      smoked cheddar, gruyère cheese sauce

    • Shaved Brussel Sprout Salad $14.00

      apples, toasted hazelnuts, pecorino, apple cider vinaigrette

    • House Burger $14.00

      lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, scallion aioli, sesame seed bun

    • Barley Burger $15.00

      house-made veggie burger, garlic aioli, avocado, red onions

  • Kid's
    • House Made Mac & Cheese

    • Chicken Tenders

      with hand-cut fries

    • Sliders

      two beef sliders served with hand-cut fries

  • Dessert
    • Sweet Potato Cheesecake

    • Churros

      with side dolce de leche

    • Mexican Chocolate Brownie

      caramel sauce & cream

    • Mini Date Cupcakes

      maple cream icing topped with pistachios and crumbled bacon

  • Cocktails
    • Garden District

      basil infused wodka, yellow chartreuse, cucumber-mint syrup fresh lemon juice

    • Privateer

      diplomatico añejo rum, cointreau, pineapple syrup, ithaca ginger beer, scrappy's lime bitters

    • Extra Vert

      serrano-cilantro infused tequila blanco, fresh grapefruit juice, cucumber-mint syrup, regan's bitters

    • Manhattan

      rittenhouse rye, carpano anitica sweet vermouth, angostura bitters

    • Last Word

      green chartreuse, beefeater gin, maraschino liqueur, lime juice

    • Corpse Reviver #2

      plymouth gin, lillet, cointreau, fresh lemon juice, vieux pontarlier absinthe rinse

    • Five Miles To Tijuana

      cazadores reposado tequila, campari, noilly prat dry vermouth, rosemary agave syrup, grapefruit juice, regan's bitters & vida mezcal rinse

    • Fitzgerald

      city of london gin, lemon juice, simple syrup, angostura bitters

  • Draft Beer On Tap
    • Abita Wrought Iron IPA $8.00

    • Ace Pineapple Cider $7.00

    • Allagash White $8.00

    • Anchor Steam $7.00

    • Anderson Valley The Kimmie $6.00

      the yink and the holy gose

    • Bear Republic Peter Brown Tribute Brown Ale $7.00

    • Bronx Pale Ale $7.00

    • Brooklyn Lager $7.00

    • Coney Island Mermaid Pilsner $7.00

    • Downeast Cider Cranberry Blend $7.00

    • Downeast Cider Original Blend $7.00

    • Firestone Walker Velvet Merlin $7.00

    • Founders Breakfast Stout $8.00

    • Founders Centennial IPA $8.00

    • Guinness Stout $7.00

    • Gun Hill Void Of Light $7.00

    • Innis & Gunn Toasted Oak IPA $8.00

    • Lagunitas Lil Sumpin Sumpin Ale $7.00

    • Ommegang Rare Vos $8.00

    • Rodenbach Classic Flemish Red $8.00

    • Rogue Shakespeare Stout Nitro $8.00

    • Speakeasy Suspect $7.00

    • Two Roads No Limits Hefeweizen $7.00

    • Veltins Pilsner $7.00

  • Bottles
    • Amstel Light $7.00

    • Bud Light $6.00

    • Budweiser $6.00

    • Clausthaler Amber Non-Alcoholic $7.00

    • Coors Light $6.00

    • Corona $7.00

    • Dixie Jazz Amber Light $7.00

    • Estrella Damm Daura $7.00

    • Heineken $7.00

    • Heineken Light $7.00

    • Magners Irish Cider $7.00

    • Miller Lite $6.00

  • Draft Beer On Deck
    • Harviestoun Old Engine Oil $9.00

    • Port City Maniacal DIPA $8.00

  • Red
    • Pinot Noir

      gravelly ford

    • Carmenere

      root:1

    • Malbec

      high note

    • Cabernet Sauvignon

      14 hands

    • Côtes Du Rhône

      notre dame

  • White
    • Chardonnay

      cousino-macul

    • Riesling

      bex

    • Torrontès

      tilla

    • Pinot Grigio

      zenato

    • Sauvignon Blanc

      sileni

    • Chenin Blanc & Viognier

      pine ridge

  • Rosé
    • Pas Du Cerf

      cotes de provence rose.

  • Sparkling
    • Spumante

      j. roget

    • Amond Champagne

      wilson creek

    • Brut Rose

      juvé y camps

    • Prosecco

      stellina di notte

Menu for Five Mile Stone provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.