• New York
  • New York
  • Hill and Bay

Hill and Bay

(212) 245-5554
  • 581 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10016
  • American
  • $$$$$
  • Seamless.com
  • Menu
  • Brunch
  • Burgers
  • Sandwiches
  • Salads
  • Share Plates
    • Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken $14.95

      Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

    • Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos $16.95

      Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

    • Avocado Toast $14.95

      Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes.

    • Wings $0

      Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

    • Marvelous Mac and Cheese $13.95

      Jack, cheddar, asiago.

    • Nonni's Meatballs $13.95

      Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

    • Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips $15.95

      avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

    • Quesadilla $14.95

      Tortilla, mixed cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream, choice of chicken, steak, shrimp or veggie.

  • Sides
    • Shoestring Fries $4.5

    • Sweet Potato Fries $4.5

    • Tater Tots $4.5

    • Bagel $4

    • Fresh Fruit $7.25

    • Half Avocado $4.5

    • Smoked Salmon $10.5

    • Bacon $6.5

    • Sausage $6.5

    • 5-Grain Toast $2

    • Biscuits & Gravy $5

    • French Onion Soup $8.5

      Served with gruyere cheese.

    • Tomato Soup $7.25

  • Pastries
    • Carrot Walnut Muffin $3

    • Blueberry Muffin $3

    • Chocolate Banana Muffin $3

    • Brownie $3

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie $3

    • Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie $3

    • Chocolate Zucchini Muffin $3

  • Coffees, Teas, Etc.
    • Coffee $2.25

    • Decaf $2.25

    • Cold Brew $3.5

    • Iced Tea $3.5

    • Espresso $2.5

    • Double Espresso $3

    • Cappuccino $3.75

    • Iced Cappuccino $4.5

    • Latte $3.75

    • Iced Latte $4.5

    • Mocha $4.5

    • Iced Mocha $5

    • Chai Latte $4

    • Iced Chai Latte $4.5

    • Americano $3

    • Cortado $3.5

    • Flat White $3.5

    • Macchiato $3

    • Hot Cocoa $3.5

    • Hot Tea $0

    • Dr Feel Good $6

    • Vanilla Nice $5

  • Smoothies
    • There's Something About Berry $7.5

      Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

    • The Green Mile $7.5

      Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

    • The Hulk $7.5

      Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

    • Last Mango in Paris $7.5

      Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

    • The Nutty Professor $7.5

      Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

    • Dude, Where's My Orange? $7.5

      Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

    • 50 Shades of Strawberry $7.5

      Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

    • Pineapple Express $7.5

      Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

  • Cocktails
  • Beer
    • Dogfish Head $5

      Liquid Truth Serum - Draft 16 oz

    • Montauk $4

      Driftwood Ale - Draft 16 oz

    • Sloop Brewing $5

      Juice Bomb IPA - Draft 16 oz

    • Narragansett $4

      Lager - Draft 16 oz

    • Victory $4

      Prima Pils - Draft 16 oz

    • Allagash White $5

      Belgian Ale - Draft 16 oz

    • Corona $4

      Mexican Lager - Bottle

    • Miller Lite $3

      Light Lager - Bottle

    • Brooklyn $4

      Lager - Draft 16 oz

    • Ithica Flower Power $5

      American IPA - Bottle

    • Flying Dog Gonzo $6

      Imperial Porter - Bottle

    • Ommegang Hennepin $7

      Belgian Saison - Bottle

    • Troegs Hopback $4

      Amber Ale - Bottle

    • Mckenzie's $4

      Hard Apple Cider - Bottle

    • Coney Island $4

      Merman NY IPA - Can

    • Tecate $3

      Mexican Lager - Can

    • Montauk. $3

      Pumpkin Ale - Can

    • Dogfish Head. $5

      Seaquench Sour Ale - Can

    • Wolffer Estate $8

      Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

  • Wine by the Bottle
    • Cabernet Sauvignon $16

      Citra - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Pinot Noir $18

      Cycles Gladiator - California - 750 ml Bottle

    • Malbec $20

      High Note - Argentina - 750 ml Bottle

    • Rioja $20

      Viña Bujanda - Spain - 750 ml Bottle

    • Pinot Grigio $16

      Stella - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Sauvignon Blanc $20

      Kato - New Zealand - 750 ml Bottle

    • Chardonnay $20

      Tilia - Argentina - 750 ml Bottle

    • Sparkling Rosé $20

      Valdo - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Prosecco $18

      Zardetto - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Rosé $16

      Laurent Miquel - France - 750 ml Bottle

  • Soft Drinks
    • Coke $3

    • Diet Coke $3

    • Sprite $3

    • Ginger Ale $3

    • Club Soda $3

    • Lemonade $3

    • Iced Tea. $3

    • Iced Tea & Lemonade $3

    • Cranberry Juice $3

    • Grapefruit Juice $3

    • Orange Juice $3

    • Pineapple Juice $3

    • Poland Spring $3

  • Desserts
    • Butterscotch Bread Pudding $11

      Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

    • Warm Apple Cobbler $11

      Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

    • Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae $11

      Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

    • Key Lime Pie $10

      Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie $10

      Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

    • Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae $11

      Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

  • Entrees
    • Ribeye Steak $28.95

      Truffle mashed potatoes, H&B butter.

    • Argentinian Steak Frites $26.95

      NY strip steak, fries, chimichurri sauce.

    • Pan Seared Mahi Mahi $20.99

      Roasted asparagus, mango-pineapple salsa.

    • Salmon Caponata $20.99

      Roasted asparagus, mango-pineapple salsa.

    • Thai Chili Glazed Salmon $20.99

      Sweet chili sauce, sautéed spinach.

    • Chicken Mash Kale $23.95

      Grilled boneless half chicken, mashed potatoes, sautéed kale, mushroom-red wine sauce.

    • Pasta Bolognese $17.95

      Penne, beef, sausage, marinara, cream.

    • Chicken Piccata $16.95

      Spaghetti, lemon butter wine sauce, caper, shallot.

    • Spinach Ravioli $14.95

      Truffle-parmesan cheese sauce, tomato, shallot.

    • Chicken Parmesan $20.95

      Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

    • Eggplant Parmesan $17.95

      Spaghetti, marinara, parmesan, mozzarella.

  • Burgers
  • Salads
  • Share Plates
    • Wings. $0

      Choice of buffalo or Asian glazed.

    • Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos. $16.95

      Corn tortillas, tri-colored slaw, chipotle mayo, tomatillo salsa.

    • Buttermilk Fried Boneless Chicken. $14.95

      Comes with buffalo blue cheese and honey dijon dipping sauce.

    • Nacho Libre $15.95

      Corn tortillas, black beans, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream.

    • Marvelous Mac and Cheese. $13.95

      Jack, cheddar, asiago.

    • Nonni's Meatballs. $13.95

      Ground beef, sweet fennel sausage, parmesan.

    • Mozzarella Sticks $9.95

      Marinara sauce.

    • Avocado Toast. $14.95

      Olive oil, lemon juice, pepper flakes.

    • Guacamole w/ Tortilla Chips. $15.95

      avocado, jalapeño, onion, cilantro, lime juice, tomato

  • Sides
    • Shoestring Fries. $4.5

    • Sweet Potato Fries. $4.5

    • Tater Tots. $4.5

    • Crispy Brussels Sprouts $9.5

      Pancetta, cider agrodolce.

    • Roasted Asparagus $9.5

    • Roasted Cauliflower $7.95

    • Sauteed Kale $7.5

    • Mashed Potatoes $6.75

    • Half Avocado. $4.5

    • French Onion Soup. $8.5

      Served with gruyere cheese.

    • Tomato Soup. $7.25

  • Beer
    • Dogfish Head.. $5

      Liquid Truth Serum - Draft 16 oz

    • Montauk.. $4

      Driftwood Ale - Draft 16 oz

    • Sloop Brewing. $5

      Juice Bomb IPA - Draft 16 oz

    • Narragansett. $4

      Lager - Draft 16 oz

    • Victory. $4

      Prima Pils - Draft 16 oz

    • Allagash White. $5

      Belgian Ale - Draft 16 oz

    • Corona. $4

      Mexican Lager - Bottle

    • Miller Lite. $3

      Light Lager - Bottle

    • Brooklyn. $4

      Lager - Draft 16 oz

    • Ithica Flower Power. $5

      American IPA - Bottle

    • Flying Dog Gonzo. $6

      Imperial Porter - Bottle

    • Ommegang Hennepin. $7

      Belgian Saison - Bottle

    • Troegs Hopback. $4

      Amber Ale - Bottle

    • Mckenzie's. $4

      Hard Apple Cider - Bottle

    • Wolffer Estate. $8

      Dry Rosé Cider - Bottle

    • Coney Island. $4

      Merman NY IPA - Can

    • Tecate. $3

      Mexican Lager - Can

    • Montauk... $3

      Pumpkin Ale - Can

    • Dogfish Head... $5

      Seaquench Sour Ale - Can

  • Cocktails
  • Wine by the Bottle
    • Cabernet Sauvignon. $16

      Citra - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Pinot Noir. $18

      Cycles Gladiator - California - 750 ml Bottle

    • Malbec. $20

      High Note - Argentina - 750 ml Bottle

    • Rioja. $20

      Viña Bujanda - Spain - 750 ml Bottle

    • Pinot Grigio. $16

      Stella - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Sauvignon Blanc. $20

      Kato - New Zealand - 750 ml Bottle

    • Chardonnay. $20

      Tilia - Argentina - 750 ml Bottle

    • Sparkling Rosé. $20

      Valdo - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Prosecco. $18

      Zardetto - Italy - 750 ml Bottle

    • Rosé. $16

      Laurent Miquel - France - 750 ml Bottle

  • Soft Drinks
    • Coke. $3

    • Diet Coke. $3

    • Sprite. $3

    • Ginger Ale. $3

    • Club Soda. $3

    • Lemonade. $3

    • Iced Tea.. $3

    • Iced Tea & Lemonade. $3

    • Cranberry Juice. $3

    • Grapefruit Juice. $3

    • Orange Juice. $3

    • Pineapple Juice. $3

    • Poland Spring. $3

  • Smoothies
    • There's Something About Berry. $7.5

      Blueberry, beet, spinach, oj, banana.

    • The Green Mile. $7.5

      Spinach, pineapple, peach nectar, banana.

    • The Hulk. $7.5

      Kale, spinach, pineapple, ginger, lemon.

    • Last Mango in Paris. $7.5

      Mango, banana, almond milk, honey, greek yogurt.

    • The Nutty Professor. $7.5

      Almond milk, cocoa, peanut butter, honey, banana.

    • Dude, Where's My Orange?. $7.5

      Oj, mango, sweet potato, ginger, banana.

    • 50 Shades of Strawberry. $7.5

      Strawberry, mango, oj, banana.

    • Pineapple Express. $7.5

      Pineapple, mango, banana, greek yogurt.

  • Coffees, Teas, Etc.
    • Coffee. $2.25

    • Decaf. $2.25

    • Cold Brew. $3.5

    • Iced Tea... $3.5

    • Espresso. $2.5

    • Double Espresso. $3

    • Cappuccino. $3.75

    • Iced Cappuccino. $4.5

    • Latte. $3.75

    • Iced Latte. $4.5

    • Mocha. $4.5

    • Iced Mocha. $5

    • Chai Latte. $4

    • Iced Chai Latte. $4.5

    • Americano. $3

    • Cortado. $3.5

    • Flat White. $3.5

    • Macchiato. $3

    • Hot Cocoa. $3.5

    • Hot Tea. $0

    • Dr Feel Good. $6

    • Vanilla Nice. $5

  • Desserts
    • Butterscotch Bread Pudding. $11

      Brioche, butterscotch custard, ice cream.

    • Warm Apple Cobbler. $11

      Buttermilk biscuit top, ice cream.

    • Hot Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae. $11

      Chocolate ganache, ice cream, whipped cream.

    • Key Lime Pie. $10

      Graham cracker crust, whipped cream.

    • Chocolate Peanut Butter Silk Pie. $10

      Graham cracker crust, ganache, candied peanuts, whipped cream.

    • Dulce De Leche Brownie Sundae. $11

      Ice cream, butterscotch chips, whipped cream.

  • Pastries
    • Carrot Walnut Muffin. $3

    • Blueberry Muffin. $3

    • Chocolate Banana Muffin. $3

    • Brownie. $3

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie. $3

    • Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie. $3

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.