Two Little Red Hens menu - New York NY 10028 -

Main Menu

Classic Cakes

3-day advance notice required. Available for pick up Tuesday - Sunday. We recommend placing your order early, as our baking schedule may fill up prior to weekends & holidays. Includes optional inscription & decorative sprinkles
- Brooklyn Blackout $38
  
  Four layers of chocolate cake, three layers of chocolate pudding filling & fudge frosting
- Red Velvet $38
  
  A light red butter cake with a hint of cocoa & homestyle cream cheese frosting
- Yellow Cake / Chocolate Cake $38
  
  Two layers of classic yellow cake or chocolate cake with your choice of Swiss vanilla buttercream with spiral frosting & decorative sprinkles, or homestyle Chocolate fudge frosting & decorative sprinkles
- Carrot $38
  
  A carrot spice cake with walnuts & cream cheese frosting, decorated with classic buttercream carrots
- Banana $38
  
  Available in winter, spring & summer. A moist banana cake made with fresh bananas & homestyle cream cheese frosting
- Pumpkin Harvest $48
  
  Available in the fall. A super-moist pumpkin spice cake with apricot pumpkin cream cheese frosting & buttercream fall leaf decoration
- Lemon Gingerbread $38
  
  Available in December. A classic gingerbread cake with homestyle lemon cream cheese frosting

Cheesecake

3-day advance notice required. Available for pick up Tuesday - Sunday. We recommend placing your order early, as our baking schedule may fill up prior to weekends & holidays
- New York Cheesecake* $29
  
  Our classic New York cheesecake with a toasted graham cracker crust
- Cherry Cheesecake $36
  
  Our classic New York Cheesecake with a Michigan sour cherry topping
- Pumpkin Cheesecake $36
  
  Available fall. A smooth & rich spiced pumpkin cheesecake with a molasses graham cracker crust confection

Cupcakes

By the half dozen. 2-day advance notice required for cupcake orders - cakes & pies require 3 days notice. Cupcake orders for Monday pickup available after 4pm. We bake all of our cupcakes fresh daily. Beginning with the Brooklyn Blackout by 10am, each flavor becomes available on a "rolling basis" as soon as it is baked & decorated. The widest selection of flavors, including "Chilled' n' Filled, " is typically available by late afternoon

Classics
- Yellow or Chocolate $2.15
  
  with your choice of: Swiss vanilla buttercream (less sweet & silky smooth) Chocolate fudge frosting
- Red Velvet $2.15
  
  with cream cheese frosting
- Carrot* $2.15
  
  with cream cheese frosting (& walnuts)
- Marble $3.75
  
  ("black & white") with a swirl of chocolate fudge & Swiss vanilla buttercream

Seasonal

Mini $2.15 / Large $3.75
- Banana
  
  with cream cheese frosting (winter, spring, summer)
- Pumpkin
  
  pumpkin harvest cake with pumpkin apricot cream cheese frosting (autumn)
- Lemon Gingerbread
  
  gingerbread cake with lemon cream cheese frosting (December)

Filled

Mini $2.15 / Large $4.25
- Brooklyn Blackout
  
  chocolate cake, chocolate pudding, fudge frosting
- Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl*
  
  chocolate cake, PB buttercream filling, PB chocolate fudge swirl frosting

Chilled 'N' Filled™

Mini $2.15 / Large $4.25
- Boston Cream
  
  chiffon cake, vanilla pastry cream filling, fudge &chocolate glaze with chocolate shavings (in-store only)
- Key Lime
  
  chiffon cake, key lime cream filling, key lime-infused whipped cream with fresh lime zest (in-store only)
- Coconut Cream
  
  chiffon cake, coconut cream filling, coconut whipped cream with toasted coconut shavings (in-store only)
- Eggnog Bavarian^
  
  Chiffon cake, eggnog Bavarian cream, whipped cream & fresh nutmeg (December). Seasonal
- Irish Cream^
  
  Chocolate chiffon cake, Irish cream filling (made with Bailey's™), chocolate fudge & glaze (March). Seasonal

Winter Pies

10-inch serves 8 / $36. 3-day advance notice required. Available for pick up Tuesday - Sunday. We recommend placing your order early, as our baking schedule may fill up prior to weekends & holidays
- Apple
  
  A classic "double crust" apple pie made with a seasonal blend of apples & a dash of spice
- Apple Crumb
  
  Our classic apple pie with a cinnamon oatmeal & brown sugar crumb topping
- Cherry
  
  Two varieties of Michigan sour cherries with a classic lattice crust & checkered with crumble topping
- Lemon Chess
  
  A sweet southern custard pie
- Pecan / Chocolate Pecan
  
  A Southern tradition with toasted pecans & a sweet buttery filling with (or without) rich chunks of Callebaut 60/40 chocolate

Weekend Pies

Available Friday & Saturday. 10-inch serves 8 / $36. 3-day advance notice required. Available for pick up Friday & Saturday. We recommend placing your order early, as our baking schedule may fill up prior to weekends & holidays
- Key Lime
  
  A classic Key Lime pie with fresh-squeezed lime juice, decorated with whipped cream, thinly sliced limes & lime zest with a toasted graham cracker crust
- Chocolate Mousse
  
  Rich Chocolate mousse made with Callebaut semi-sweet chocolate, fresh whipped cream & chocolate shavings
- Coconut Cream
  
  Coconut pastry cream with whipped cream, & coconut shavings with a toasted coconut graham cracker crust