Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

(646) 588-4179

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 521 West Street, New York, NY 10014
  • Barbecue
  • $$$$$
  • Brother Jimmy's BBQ

  • (646) 588-4179
  • Main
  • Lunch
  • Salad & Stews
    • House Salad $6.95

      Add chicken any style $3.00, add pulled pork $4.00

    • Chopped Cobb Salad $12.25

      Lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled fried or buffalo chicken

    • Jimmy's Wedge $9.50

      Iceberg lettuce, bacon bits, diced tomato, smothered in blue cheese dressing & covered w/onion straws

    • The Wright Salad $10.95

      Romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette add grilled chicken $3.00

    • Brunswick Stew $5.75

      A tomato based southern stew w/corn, smoked chicken & pork

    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Chili $6.25

      Topped w/melted cheddar, served w/sour cream & onion

  • Sandwiches n Burger
    With one side and pickles
    • Po' Boys $10.75

      Blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread with lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo

    • BBQ Grilled Chicken $9.95

      Basted with BBQ sauce on a roll w/lettuce, tomato & onion

    • Press'd Bourbon BBQ Brisket $10.75

      With bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast

    • Fried Chicken $10.25

      Buffalo style or original on a roll

    • Burgers $9.75

      Add chili, applewood bacon or cheese 1.00

    • Bj's BBQ Burger $10.75

      Grilled w/chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped w/onion straws

  • Sandwiches
    With one side and pickles slaw $0.50 extra
    • Carolina Pulled Pork $10.50

    • Pulled Chicken $10.50

    • Sliced Brisket $10.75

      Lean or most

    • BBQ Meatloaf $10.25

      On grilled texas toast with tomato

  • BBQ
    All of our bbq is smoked over hickory wood for 5-12 hours served w/ two sides cornbread and pickles. A half rack of St. Louis style ribs
    • Northern Style Ribs $20.75

      Smoked & then grilled with brothers jimmy original BBQ sauce

    • Southern Style Ribs $20.75

      Smoked with brother jimmy's memphis style rub

    • Brothers Jimmy Dry Rub Ribs $20.75

      Smoked with brothers jimmy signature rub tastes like a country sausage

    • Combo Rib Platter $21.75

      Choose from our 3 style of ribs lil more than a half rack

    • Carolina Pulled Pork $16.95

      Pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's carolina BBQ

    • Pulled Chicken $15.95

      Smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce

    • Sliced Brisket $17.95

      Smoked for up to 12 hours lean or moist

    • 1/2 BBQ Chicken $16.50

      Smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce

    • BBQ Chicken & Ribs $19.50

    • BBQ Meatloaf $15.95

      Beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked

  • Jimmy Pig Pick
    Choose any 4 items from the following selections northern, southern or dry rub ribs, pulled pork , brisket BBQ chicken or pulled chicken served with hush puppies and coleslaw
    • Jimmy Pig Pick $23.95

  • Beginnings
    • Hush Puppies W/ Maple Butter $7.25

    • Fried Green Tomatoes with Spicy Aioli $8.25

    • Frickles w/ Horseradish Sauce $7.95

    • Peel & Eat Shrimp $12.50

      With lemon & old bay

    • Popcorn Shrimp W/ Cajun Mayo $9.75

    • Onion Straws $7.50

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $10.25

    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Nachos $12.50

      Chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole

    • Fried Buffalo Chicken ?Minis $10.50

      Topped w/blue cheese & lettuce on a slider roll

    • Rib Tips Northern Style $9.50

    • Bucket O' Tips $17.50

    • Hot Wings $9.95

      Buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked

    • Bucket O' Hot Wings $17.50

    • Bbq Wings $9.95

      Cut wings dusted w/our southern rub & basted w/our special wing sauce

    • Chicken Fingers $9.25

      Original, buffalo or chipotle

    • Jalapeno Poppers $9.25

      Homemade & stuffed w/a mixture of cream cheese & spices served w/ranch dressing

    • Quesadilla w/Salsa & Sour Cream $9.50

      Pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken or smoked brisket

  • Southern Specialties
    With two sides and pickle
    • Country Fried Steak w/Gravy $17.25

      Top round steak, tenderized & dredged in our seasoned flour, fried ?til crisp & tender and topped w/gravy

    • Fried Chicken Dinner $16.50

      Tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off w/ toasted garlic

    • Choose any Four Sides $14.50

    • Blackened Chicken $15.50

      Dipped in our special blackening spice_nice & spicy

    • Blackened Catfish $12.95

      A southern seafood staple with a kick to it

    • Nag's Head Veggie $12.95

      Beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad

  • Sides
    • Potato Salad $4.00

    • Cole Slaw $4.00

    • French Fries $4.00

    • Fried Okra $4.00

    • Sweet Potato Fries $4.50

    • Spiced String Beans $4.50

    • Black Eyed Peas with Bacon $4.50

    • Mashed Potatoes with Garvy $4.50

    • Collard Greens $4.50

    • Corn on the Cob $4.50

    • Macaroni & Cheese $5.25

    • BBQ Baked Beans with Pulled Pork $5.25

    • Canadied Yams with Walnuts $5.25

    • Fried Brussel Sprouts $5.25

    • Wild Rice Salad $5.25

  • Salads & Stews
    • House Salad $6.95

      Add chicken any style $3.00 add pulled pork $4.00

    • Chopped Cobb Salad $12.25

      Lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken

    • The Wright Salad $10.95

      Romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette add grilled chicken $3.00

    • Brunswick Stew $5.75

      A tomato based southern stew w/ corn, smoked chicken & pork

  • Sandwiches & Burgers
    With one said and pickles
    • Pulled Pork Wrap $9.25

      Pulled pork, pickles & slaw

    • Pulled Chicken Wrap $8.75

      Pulled chicken, applewood bacon & cheddar

    • BLT $8.75

      Applewood bacon, lettuce tomato on country white bread

    • Burger $9.75

      Add chili, applewood bacon or cheese $1.00

    • BJ's BBQ Burger $10.75

      grilled with bourbon BBQ sauce cheddar & topped with onion strews

    • BBQ Grilled Chicken $9.95

      Basted with BBQSsauce on a roll with lettuce, tomato & onion

    • Po' Boys $10.75

      Blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on French bread with lettuce, tomato and cajun mayo.

    • Fried Chicken $10.25

      Buffalo style or original on a roll.

    • Press'd Bourbon BBQ Brisket $10.75

      With bourbon BBQ sauce, Gouda cheese and onion straws pressed on Texas toast.

    • Brother Jimmy's Cuban $9.25

      Sliced smoked port, buckboard bacon, Gruyere cheese and frickles.

    • Grilled Cheese $8.95

      Smoked cheddar cheese and applewood bacon served with French fries.

  • Sandwiches
    With one side and pickles slaw $0.50 extra
    • Carolina Pulled Pork $10.50

    • Pulled Chicken $10.50

    • Sliced Brisket Lean or Marbled $10.75

    • BBQMeatloaf on Grilled Texas Toast with Tomato $10.25

  • BBQ
    • BBQ Lunch Special $14.95

      Choice of brunswick stew or house salad & choose from any style ribs pulled pork, brisket 1/4 BBQchicken or pulled chicken served with choice of one side

  • Platters
    Served with two sides, cornbread & pickles
    • Northern Style Ribs $20.75

      Smoked & then grilled with brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce

    • Southern Style Ribs $20.75

      Smoked with brother jimmy's memphis style rub

    • Brother Jimmy dry Rub Ribs $20.75

      Smoked with brother jimmy signature ture rub tastes like a country sausage

    • Carolina Pulled Pork $16.95

      Pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/brother jimmy's carolina BBQ

    • Pulled Chicken $15.95

      Smoked & pulled w/brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce

    • Sliced Brisket $17.95

      Smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled

    • 1/2 BBQ Chicken $16.50

      Smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce

    • BBQ Meatloaf $15.95

      Beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked

  • Beginnings
    • Hush Puppies with Maple Butter $7.25

    • Frickles with Horseradish Sauce $7.95

    • Peel & Eat Shrimp $12.50

      With lemon & old bay

    • Popcoen Shrimp with cajun Mayo $9.75

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $10.25

    • Quesadilla with Salsa Sour Cream $9.50

      Pulled pork or BBQ grilled chicken

    • Brother Jimmy BBQ Nachos $12.50

      Chips BBQ beans chili cheese sour cream, salsa & guacamole

    • Rib Tips Northern Style $9.50

    • Bucket O Tips $17.50

    • Hot Wings $9.95

      Buffalo chipotle or crispy naked

    • Bucket O Hot Wings $17.50

    • BBQ Wings $9.95

      Two Part wing smoked & grilled in brother jimmy original BBQ sauce

    • Jalapenos Poppers $9.25

      Homemade & stuffed with a mixture of cream cheese & spices served with ranch dressings

  • Southern Specialties
    • Nag's Head Veggie $12.95

      Fresh grilledvegetables& baked sweet potatoes

    • Fried Chicken Dinner $16.50

      Mashed potatoes & corn on the cob

    • Blackened Chicken $15.50

      With smoky corn & black bean chow chow

    • Steak n Fries $20.50

      grilled skirt steak with homemade steak sauce & handcut fries

  • Sides
    • Potato Salad $4.00

    • Cole Slaw $4.00

    • French Fries $4.00

    • Smokey Corn & Black Bean Chow Chow $4.00

    • Sweet Potato Fries $4.50

    • Spiced String Beans $4.50

    • Black Eyed Peas with Bacon $4.50

    • Mashed Potatoes $4.50

    • Collard Greens $4.50

    • Corn on the Cob $4.50

    • Macaroni & Cheese $5.25

    • BBQ Baked beans with Pulled Pork $5.25

    • Candied Yams with Walnuts $5.25

    • Fried Brussel Sprouts $5.25

Menu for Brother Jimmy's BBQ provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.