• New York
  • New York
  • Brother Jimmy's Union Square

Brother Jimmy's Union Square

(212) 673-6465
  • 116 E 16th St, New York, NY 10003
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Barbecue ,  Soul Food
  • $$$$$
(212) 673-6465
  • Menu
  • Drinks
    • Soda $3.25

    • Boylan Soda $3.5

    • Cheerwine Cherry Soda $3.25

    • Fiji Bottled Water $3

    • Quart of Lemonade $5.25

    • Quart of Homemade Iced Tea $5.25

    • Quart of Raspberry Lemonade $5.25

    • Ginger Beer $3.5

    • Homemade Iced Tea $2.5

    • Homemade Lemonade $2.5

    • Monster $4

    • Southern Sweet Tea $2.5

  • To Share
    • Hush Puppies $8.75

      Served with maple butter.

    • Frickles $10

      Served with horseradish sauce.

    • Popcorn Shrimp $12.25

      Served with Cajun mayo or buffalo style with bleu cheese dressing.

    • BBQ Wings $12

      Cut wings dusted with our southern rub, smoked and basted with our special wing sauce.

    • Rib Tips (Northern Style) $13.25

      Smoked and grilled with our original BBQ sauce.

    • Quesadilla $12.5

      Served with salsa and sour cream.

    • Loaded Fries $12.5

      Your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken topped with cheese, diced tomatoes, original BBQ sauce and ranch.

    • Humongous Nachos $19

      Chips, BBQ beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa and gaucamole served with your choice of pulled pork, pulled chicken or veggies.

    • Brunswick Stew $6.5

      A tomato based southern stew with corn, smoked chicken and pork.

    • Catfish Bites $12.25

      Cornmeal crusted and served with homemade roasted tomato tartar sauce.

    • Fried Green Tomatoes $10.5

      Served with homemade ranch dressing.

  • Greens
    • Caesar Salad $11

      Romaine with cornbread croutons and homemade Caesar dressing.

    • Chopped Cobb Salad $15.75

      Salad mix, onion, tomato, bacon bits, crumbled bleu cheese, avocado and choice of grilled, fried or Buffalo chicken.

    • House Salad $7.5

    • Jimmy's Wedge Salad $11.75

      Iceburg lettuce, bacon bits, diced tomato, smothered in homemade blue cheese dressing and topped with onion rings.

  • Dips
    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $10.5

      Served with homemade tortilla chips.

    • Buffalo Chicken Dip $12.25

      Served with homemade tortilla chips.

  • Grilled Flatbreads
    • Spinach & Artichoke Flatbread $12.75

    • BLT Flatbread $12.75

    • Loaded Baked Potato Flatbread $12.75

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Flatbread $12.75

  • Tacos
    • Grilled Shrimp Tacos $13

      With roasted corn salsa.

    • Fried Shrimp Tacos $13

      With roasted corn salsa.

    • Grilled Catfish Tacos $13

      With roasted corn salsa.

    • Fried Catfish Tacos $13

      With roasted corn salsa.

    • Pulled Chicken Tacos $13

      With pineapple slaw.

    • Pulled Pork Tacos $13

      With pineapple slaw.

  • Sliders
    • Buffalo Chicken Sliders $14.25

      Three per order. Served with homemade blue cheese dressing and lettuce.

    • Nashville Hot Chicken Sliders $14.25

      Three per order. With pickle aioli.

    • BBQ Minis Sliders $14.25

      Three per order.

    • Cheeseburger Sliders $14.25

      Three per order. With pickles and ketchup.

  • Chicken Fingers & Wings
    • Chicken Fingers $12.75

    • Chicken Wings $13.25

  • Sandwiches and Burgers
    • Fried Chicken Sandwich $13.5

      Original with lettuce, tomato and onion or buffalo with blue cheese and shredded lettuce. Served with one side and pickles.

    • BBQ Grilled Chicken Sandwich $13.5

      Basted with BBQ sauce. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, one side and pickles.

    • Grilled Mac & Cheese Sandwich $12.25

      Mac and cheese and sliced cheddar, pressed and melted on Texas toast. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Country Catfish Sandwich $13.5

      Griddled or fried with roasted tomato tartar sauce, avocado and tomato. Served on Texas toast with 1 side and pickles.

    • Press'd Bourbon BBQ Brisket Sandwich $15.5

      Sliced brisket with cheddar, onion rings, & our homemade bourbon BBQ sauce on Texas toast. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Portobello Mushroom Sandwich $14.75

      Grilled portobellos with Swiss cheese topped with onion rings and chiptole BBQ mayo on a butter toasted roll. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Sloppy Jimmy Sandwich $12.25

      Our version of a Sloppy Joe, with pork & beef, tomato base & a hint of heat. Sweet, smoky, tangy & messy on a butter-toasted roll. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Jimmy's Burger $14.75

      8 oz. of ground beef grilled to perfection, on a butter-toasted roll. Served with one side and pickles.

    • BBQ Burger $15.75

      8 ounces of ground beef, basted with chipotle BBQ sauce & topped with cheddar & onion rings, on a butter-toasted roll. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Turkey Burger $14.75

      Well-seasoned, ground turkey on a buttered toasted roll with BBQ chipotle mayo and grilled onions. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Toasted Shrimp Sandwich $13.5

      Fried shrimp topped with slaw and roasted tomato tartar sauced and served on Texas Toast. Served with one side and pickles.

  • Southern Fried
    • Nashville Hot Chicken $16

      Extra spicy, served on Texas toast with extra pickles.

    • Southern Fried Catfish $19

      Cornmeal crusted & fried with roasted tomato tartar sauce. A choice of one side & cornbread.

    • Southern Fried Chicken $19

      Tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off with our Southern spice. A choice of one side & cornbread.

    • Dixie Hoe Cake $12.5

      Choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken on top of a corn cake with coleslaw and chipotle BBQ sauce.

  • BBQ Platters
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Platter $18.5

      Pork shoulder slow smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • Pulled Chicken Platter $18.5

      Smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • Sliced Brisket Platter $21.5

      Certified black Angus brisket smoked four up to 14 hours, lean or marbled. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • Northern Style Ribs Platter $23.75

      Hickey smoked then grilled with original BBQ sauce. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • Baby Back Ribs Platter $23.75

      Dry rubbed and hickey smoked then dipped in our "special" sauce. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • 1/2 BBQ Chicken Platter $18.25

      Smoked, grilled, and basted in Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

    • BBQ Chicken $11

      Smoked, grilled, and based in our original BBQ sauce.

    • Half Pound of BBQ $10

    • Ribs $9

    • Make It A Platter $12

      Served with two sides, cornbread and pickles.

  • BBQ Sandwiches
    • Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich $14

      Pork shoulder slow smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Pulled Chicken Sandwich $14

      Smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with one side and pickles.

    • Sliced Brisket Sandwich $15.5

      Certified black Angus brisket smoked four up to 14 hours, lean or marbled. Served with one side and pickles.

  • Sides
    • Mashed Potato with White Gravy $6

    • Hand Cut French Fries $6

    • Tater Tots $6

    • Coleslaw $6

    • Green Salad $6

    • Basket of Cornbread $6

    • Collard Greens $6

    • Fried Brussels Sprouts $6

    • Macaroni and Cheese $6

    • BBQ Baked Beans with Pulled Pork $6

    • Spiced String Beans $6

    • Potato Salad $6

    • Fried Okra $5

    • Corn on the Cob $6

  • Homemade Desserts
    • Fried Oreos $6

    • Ol' Fashioned Banana Pudding $6

    • Homemade Brownie $6

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.