Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • Amsterdam Tavern

Amsterdam Tavern

(212) 280-8070

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 938 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025
  • American ,  Bar Food
  • Amsterdam Tavern

  • (212) 280-8070
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • New York's Best Nachos $11.95

      housemade tortilla chips smothered with a blend of 3 cheeses, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream, and jalapenos

    • New York's Best Nachos $4.00

      add chili or pulled pork

    • Oversized Wings $7.95+

      buffalo, chipotle bbq or thai chili

    • Pan Seared Crab Cakes $12.95

      fresh lump crabmeat with dijon aioli

    • Spinach Artichoke Cheese Dip $10.95

      with housemade pita chips

    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.95

      with house marinara sauce

    • Hummus $8.95

      traditional or chiptole

    • Taverns Famous Chili $9.95

      our 5 chili blend, with cheese if you want

    • Steamed Mussels $10.95

      in white wine with garlic sauce

    • Carly's Buffalo Nachos $12.95

      monterey jack and cheddar melted over carly's famous buffalo chicken dip

    • Sesame Crusted Tuna $12.95

      sushi grade ahi with seaweed salad & soy ginger dressing

    • Fried Calamari $11.95

      house marinara, buffalo or sweet thai chili

    • Truffled Grilled Cheese $10.95

      gruyeye, cheddar, truffled butter with a little tomato sauce

    • House Made Chicken Fingers $9.95

      fresh cut chicken breast coated with panko and served with honey-porter mustard & tavern bbq sauce

    • Edamame $7.95

      lightly sprinkled with sea salt

    • House Made Pork Taquitos $8.95

      our bbq pulled pork rolled in a crisp taco shell with salsa verde and queso blanco

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese

      artisanal trumpet pasta with our 3 cheese blend

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2.00

      add bacon

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $5.00

      add lobster

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2.00

      add truffle butter

  • Crispy Flatbreads
    • Margherita $9.95

      mozzarella & basil

    • Tavern Pulled Pork $12.95

      black pepper slaw

    • Goat Cheese & Veggie $12.95

      balsamic glaze

  • Sliders & Tacos
    • Tavern Burger Sliders $10.95

      our pat lafrieda burger blend

    • BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders $10.95

      creamy black pepper slaw

    • Crispy Fish Tacos $12.95

      pico di gallo, baja sauce, & avocado

    • Crispy Buffalo Chicken $10.95

      bleu cheese sauce

    • Lobster Salad Sliders $14.95

      housemade with lemon tarragon aioli

    • Crab Cake Sliders $12.95

      chipotle aioli

    • Seared Tuna Tacos $12.95

      avocado salsa, sesame greens, sriracha rach on crispy wonton chips

  • The Burger
    • The Burger $11.95

    • The Burger $1.00

      additions: american cheese, cheddar, mozzarella, pepperjack, swiss, sauteed onions, sriracha aioli, avocado ranch, chipotle ketchup, tavern secret sauce

    • The Burger $1.50

      additions: applewood smoked bacon, avocado, portobello mushrooms, guacamole, mesa chili, truffled butter, beer batter jalapeños, manchego, gruyere

    • The Double Bypass $17.95

      two of our custom blend burgers, 2 layers of bacon, 2 layers of manchego, beer battered jalapenos & onions and sriracha ranch sauce

  • Sandwiches
    • House Roasted Turkey $12.95

      on multi-grain with avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato & cilantro mayo

    • Grilled Salmon Wrap $13.95

      sweet thai chili aioli & julienne vegetables

    • The Tavern Steak Sandwich $16.95

      sliced new york strip with onion straws gruyere and garlic-herb butter on a roll

    • Southwest Chicken Wrap $12.95

      monterey jack & smoked cheddar, guac, black bean-corn salsa, and chipotle mayo

    • Roasted Pork Tenderloin Sandwich $12.95

      bacon wrapped roast pork on a portuguese roll with creamy horseradish sauce with fries

    • Grilled Chicken $12.95

      with fresh mozzarella roasted red peppers & home made pesto on a baguette

  • Big Salads
    • The Tavern Health Bowl $12.95

      stir fried green beans, asparagus, red peppers, mushrooms and tomatos on a bed of toasted red quinoa in a light lemon garlic sauce

    • Carly's Winter Salad $12.95

      baked goat cheese, roasted beets, walnuts, red onion over mixed greens with citrus honey mustard

    • Cobb Salad $12.95

      the classic, sliced chicken breast, avocado, crispy smoked bacon, boiled egg, tomato and lettuce with house made chunky bleu cheese dressing

    • Grilled Shrimp Salad $14.95

      mixed greens, avocado,tomato, sliced almonds, toasted pita points in a roasted tomato-caper vinaigrette

    • Classic Caesar Salad $9.95

      romaine lettuce tossed with classic caesar dressing, shaved parmesan & toasted croutons

    • Classic Caesar Salad $4.00

      add chicken

    • Classic Caesar Salad $5.00

      add shrimp

    • Classic Caesar Salad $6.00

      add steak

  • More Entrees
    • Beer Batter Fish & Chips $15.95

      fresh tilapia in beer batter made from one of our craft beers served with home made tartar sauce

    • Chipotle Honey Glazed Baby Back Ribs $14.95

      mac n' cheese croquette and garlicky green beans

    • Tavern Steak Frites $18.95

      grilled 8oz aged new york strip with truffled fries & tavern steak sauce

  • Sides
    • Fresh Cut French Fries $6.95

    • Sweet Potato Fries $6.95

    • Beer Battered Green Beans $7.95

    • Chipotle Aioli

    • Million Dollar Fries $9.95

      with truffle oil & shaved parmesan

    • Fresh Cut Beer Battered Onion Rings $6.95

    • Small Salad $6.95

  • Brunch
    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.95

      with marinara sauce

    • Tavern Omelet $12.95

      different every week - ask your server!

    • Steak And Eggs $17.95

      8oz new york strip steak with 2 eggs cooked your way

    • Fish And Chips $12.95

      beer battered tilapia & homemade tarter sauce

    • The Benny Burger $12.95

      our custom pat lafrieda blend topped with canadian bacon & chipotle hollandaise on an english muffin

    • Eggs Benedict $12.95

      2 poached eggs, canadian bacon and hollandaise sauce on an english muffin

    • Crabcake Benedict $4.59

      2 poached eggs, lump crabcakes, asparagus & chipotle hollandaise sauce on an english muffin

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $12.95

      with fresh mozzarella, red peppers & pesto

    • Tavern Health Bowl $12.95

      stir-fried green beans, asparagus, red peppers, mushrooms & tomato on a bed of toasted red quinoa topped in a lemon garlic dressing

    • Cobb Salad $14.95

      sliced chicken breast, avocado, crispy smoked bacon, boiled egg, tomato & crumbled bleu cheese on a bed of mixed greens

  • Tavern Specialties
    • French Toast B.L.T. $12.95

      brioche french toast topped with double cut bacon, gruyere, roasted tomatoes and mixed greens with garlic bacon aioli

    • Lobster Salad Sliders $16.95

      fresh lobster with lemon-tarragon aioli on brioche sliders

    • Ultimate Hangover Cure

      a split croissant filled with our bbq pulled pork topped with a poached egg and smokey salsa

  • Snacks
    • Jumbo Wings $7.95+

      buffalo, thai chili, or chipotle bbq

    • Tavern Famous Nachos $11.95

    • Tavern Famous Nachos $4.00

      add chili or pulled pork

    • Chicken Fingers $9.95

      homemade, panko-coated with honey porter mustard & bbq sauce

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $9.95

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2.00

      add bacon

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $5.00

      add lobster

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2.00

      add truffle butter

    • Beer Batter Green Beans $7.95

  • Daily Specials
    • Grilled Chorizo Sandwich $12.00

      on a portuguese roll with fresh mozzarella, tomato, lettuce and red pepper aioli with fries

    • Pumpkin Mac N' Cheese $10.00

    • Crab Butternut Bisque $8.00

      with crispy squash chips & popcorn

    • Buffalo Shrimp Quesadilla $12.00

      monterey/cheddar on multigrain wrap with a side of pico & guac

    • Tavern Grilled Cheese Of The Day

      ($10 to $12)

  • Beers
    • Cisco Brewers "Pumple Drumkin" $7.00+

      style: pale ale. subtle hints of pumpkin pie and a malty finish make this one of our favorite pumpkins, nice dry finish that leaves a pie crust flavor in your mouth

    • Dogfish Head Punkin Ale $7.00

      style: pumpkin ale. a full bodied brown ale brewed with organic pumpkin and brown sugar, the perfect beer to warm up as the season cools

    • Smutty Nose Pumpkin $7.00

      style: pumpkin ale. this highly rated ale has a rich pumpkin pie flavor thanks to the addition of fresh pumpkin and spices to the mash, easily one of our favorite fall beers

    • Elysian "The Great Pumpkin" Ale $7.00

      style: pumpkin ale. more pumpkin and more alcohol than their night owl ale, this big ale is bursting with different flavors, pours a lovely hazy orange with notes of cherry cola as well as the typical pumpkin pie spices you would expect

    • Founders Breakfast Stout $7.00

      style: coffee stout. perhaps the most loved american stout, brewed with imported bitter chocolate, kona and sumatra coffe with a lovely cinnamon head, this is the taverns idea of breakfast, get it while it lasts

    • Abita Pecan Harvest $7.00+

      style: seasonal ale. the addition of roasted louisiana pecans give this seasonal a slightly nutty flavor that is complemented by caramel malt and willamette hops to create a lovely fall ale

    • Nectar "Humboldt Brown" Ale $7.00+

      style: brown ale. formerly called hemp ale, this one of a kind brew with an incredibly rich flavor profile which is attributed to the addition of herbs and hem seed during the brewing process

    • Great Divide "Hoss" $7.00+

      style: marzen lager. based on the traditional marzen style lagers of germany, multilayerd notes of malt, cherries and dark fruits with the addition of rye give it a complex character with a crisp, dry finish

    • Firestone Walker Union Jack IPA $7.00+

      style: american ipa. this well balanced, west coast ipa is dry hopped 3 separate times, each lot giving it more and more of the grapefruit citrus hop aroma and flavor it is known for. overall it utilizes over 4 pounds of pacific northwest hops per barrel.

    • Stone Levitation $7.00+

      style: amber ale. this deep amber ale has rich malt flavors, a big hoppy character, and citrus overtones.

    • Goose Island 312 $7.00+

      style: urban wheat. 312's spicy aroma of cascade hops is followed by a crispy, fruity ale flavor delivered in a smooth, creamy body.

    • Stella Artois $7.00+

      style: euro pale lager. a creamy lager with a yeasty quality, sweet fruity undertones, and a dry finish.

    • Harpoon Ufo Pumpkin $7.00

      style: american unfiltered pumpkin beer. the malt combination provides a smooth body and slightly sweet flavor, which balances perfectly with the earthy notes derived from the pure pumpkin.

    • Shipyard Pumpkinhead Ale $7.00

      style: pumpkin ale. hints of pumpkin cinnamon and nutmeg combined with a smooth refreshing finish make this a great fall beer, one of our favorite pumpkins

    • Shocktop Pumpkin Wheat $6.00

      style: pumpkin. notes of ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg complement this crisp easy drinking wheat beer

    • Saranac Ubu Pumpkin $7.00

      style: pumpkin ale. a fall variation of saranacs flagship ale, organic mashed pumpkin is added during fermentation, the addition of cinnamon, cloves and nutmeg gives it slightly spicy finish

    • Ommegang Rare Vos $7.00+

      style: belgian style ale. an exceptional belgian style ale from one of the best craft breweries in america, a great balance of flavors and a hint of citrusy hops.

    • Captain Lawrence Freschester Pale Ale $7.00+

      style: ipa. an aromatic beer with notes of citrus, pine, noticeable bitterness, and a touch of malty backbone to balance it out.

    • Tröegs "Dream Weaver" $7.00+

      style: wheat beer. a combination of four wheat types with munich and pils malts, noble saaz hops, and a yeast strain that imparts a spicy, peppery, clove taste with a slight hint of bananas.

    • Goose Island Harvest Ale $7.00+

      style: seasonal ale. this copper colored esb is made with cascade hops and the richest midwestern malts and finishes with fruity american hop aroma and toasty malt character.

    • Captain Lawrence Liquid Gold $7.00+

      finish style: belgian ale. aromas of orange, spice and green grass combine with a clean malt dominated flavor, and a subdued hop

    • Guinness $7.00+

      style: irish dry stout. a smooth and sweet malt upfront that moves into dark fruits, and a burnt, hoppy, bitter aftertaste.

    • Magners Original Irish Cider $7.00+

      style: cider. made with authenticity and the time honored tradition of cider making in ireland, this cider is a delicious alternative to beer.

    • Blue Point Blueberry Ale $7.00+

      style: fruit beer. a wonderful blend of 132 lbs of fresh blueberries and all american ingredients matched with a distinctive, thirst quenching ale.

  • Cocktails $10
    • Blood Orange Margarita

      riazul silver tequila, patron citronge, fresh blood orange puree & fresh lime juice

    • Berry Battered Boyfriend

      stoli blueberry, stoli vanilla, fresh blackberry puree & fresh lime juice

    • Mango Mojito

      bacardi silver, fresh mango puree, crushed mint leaves & fresh lime juice

    • Tavern Dark & Stormy

      meyer's rum, belvoir ginger cordial & coca cola

    • Pumpkin Martini

      crop pumpkin voda, stoli vanilla, pineapple juice with a cinnamon rim

    • The White Pumpkin

      ketel one vodka, frangelico, baileys, pumpkin syrup, with a cinnamon rim

  • Red
    • Cabernet Sauvignon "Avalon" California $8.00

    • Merlot "Cycles Gladiator" California $7.00

    • Pinot Noir "Angeline" California $8.00

    • Malbec "Santa Alicia Reserva" Chile $8.00

    • Shiraz "Altoona Hills" Australia $8.00

  • White
    • Chardonnay "Mark West" California $8.00

    • Sauvignon Blanc "Mt Fishtail" New Zealand $8.00

    • Pinot Grigio "Due Torri" Italy $7.00

    • Riesling "2 Princes" Germany $7.00

  • Sparkling
    • Pommery "Pop" France $16.00

    • Freixinet Brut Spain $8.00

Menu for Amsterdam Tavern provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.