• New York
  • New York
  • Amsterdam Tavern

Amsterdam Tavern

(212) 280-8070
  • 938 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American ,  Bar Food
(212) 280-8070
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • New York's Best Nachos $11.95

      housemade tortilla chips smothered with a blend of 3 cheeses, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream, and jalapenos

    • New York's Best Nachos $4

      add chili or pulled pork

    • Oversized Wings $7.95

      buffalo, chipotle bbq or thai chili

    • Pan Seared Crab Cakes $12.95

      fresh lump crabmeat with dijon aioli

    • Spinach Artichoke Cheese Dip $10.95

      with housemade pita chips

    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.95

      with house marinara sauce

    • Hummus $8.95

      traditional or chiptole

    • Taverns Famous Chili $9.95

      our 5 chili blend, with cheese if you want

    • Steamed Mussels $10.95

      in white wine with garlic sauce

    • Carly's Buffalo Nachos $12.95

      monterey jack and cheddar melted over carly's famous buffalo chicken dip

    • Sesame Crusted Tuna $12.95

      sushi grade ahi with seaweed salad & soy ginger dressing

    • Fried Calamari $11.95

      house marinara, buffalo or sweet thai chili

    • Truffled Grilled Cheese $10.95

      gruyeye, cheddar, truffled butter with a little tomato sauce

    • House Made Chicken Fingers $9.95

      fresh cut chicken breast coated with panko and served with honey-porter mustard & tavern bbq sauce

    • Edamame $7.95

      lightly sprinkled with sea salt

    • House Made Pork Taquitos $8.95

      our bbq pulled pork rolled in a crisp taco shell with salsa verde and queso blanco

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese

      artisanal trumpet pasta with our 3 cheese blend

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2

      add bacon

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $5

      add lobster

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2

      add truffle butter

  • Crispy Flatbreads
    • Margherita $9.95

      mozzarella & basil

    • Tavern Pulled Pork $12.95

      black pepper slaw

    • Goat Cheese & Veggie $12.95

      balsamic glaze

  • Sliders & Tacos
    • Tavern Burger Sliders $10.95

      our pat lafrieda burger blend

    • BBQ Pulled Pork Sliders $10.95

      creamy black pepper slaw

    • Crispy Fish Tacos $12.95

      pico di gallo, baja sauce, & avocado

    • Crispy Buffalo Chicken $10.95

      bleu cheese sauce

    • Lobster Salad Sliders $14.95

      housemade with lemon tarragon aioli

    • Crab Cake Sliders $12.95

      chipotle aioli

    • Seared Tuna Tacos $12.95

      avocado salsa, sesame greens, sriracha rach on crispy wonton chips

  • The Burger
    • The Burger $11.95

    • The Burger $1

      additions: american cheese, cheddar, mozzarella, pepperjack, swiss, sauteed onions, sriracha aioli, avocado ranch, chipotle ketchup, tavern secret sauce

    • The Burger $1.5

      additions: applewood smoked bacon, avocado, portobello mushrooms, guacamole, mesa chili, truffled butter, beer batter jalapeños, manchego, gruyere

    • The Double Bypass $17.95

      two of our custom blend burgers, 2 layers of bacon, 2 layers of manchego, beer battered jalapenos & onions and sriracha ranch sauce

  • Sandwiches
    • House Roasted Turkey $12.95

      on multi-grain with avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato & cilantro mayo

    • Grilled Salmon Wrap $13.95

      sweet thai chili aioli & julienne vegetables

    • The Tavern Steak Sandwich $16.95

      sliced new york strip with onion straws gruyere and garlic-herb butter on a roll

    • Southwest Chicken Wrap $12.95

      monterey jack & smoked cheddar, guac, black bean-corn salsa, and chipotle mayo

    • Roasted Pork Tenderloin Sandwich $12.95

      bacon wrapped roast pork on a portuguese roll with creamy horseradish sauce with fries

    • Grilled Chicken $12.95

      with fresh mozzarella roasted red peppers & home made pesto on a baguette

  • Big Salads
    • The Tavern Health Bowl $12.95

      stir fried green beans, asparagus, red peppers, mushrooms and tomatos on a bed of toasted red quinoa in a light lemon garlic sauce

    • Carly's Winter Salad $12.95

      baked goat cheese, roasted beets, walnuts, red onion over mixed greens with citrus honey mustard

    • Cobb Salad $12.95

      the classic, sliced chicken breast, avocado, crispy smoked bacon, boiled egg, tomato and lettuce with house made chunky bleu cheese dressing

    • Grilled Shrimp Salad $14.95

      mixed greens, avocado,tomato, sliced almonds, toasted pita points in a roasted tomato-caper vinaigrette

    • Classic Caesar Salad $9.95

      romaine lettuce tossed with classic caesar dressing, shaved parmesan & toasted croutons

    • Classic Caesar Salad $4

      add chicken

    • Classic Caesar Salad $5

      add shrimp

    • Classic Caesar Salad $6

      add steak

  • More Entrees
    • Beer Batter Fish & Chips $15.95

      fresh tilapia in beer batter made from one of our craft beers served with home made tartar sauce

    • Chipotle Honey Glazed Baby Back Ribs $14.95

      mac n' cheese croquette and garlicky green beans

    • Tavern Steak Frites $18.95

      grilled 8oz aged new york strip with truffled fries & tavern steak sauce

  • Sides
    • Fresh Cut French Fries $6.95

    • Sweet Potato Fries $6.95

    • Beer Battered Green Beans $7.95

    • Chipotle Aioli

    • Million Dollar Fries $9.95

      with truffle oil & shaved parmesan

    • Fresh Cut Beer Battered Onion Rings $6.95

    • Small Salad $6.95

  • Brunch
    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.95

      with marinara sauce

    • Tavern Omelet $12.95

      different every week - ask your server!

    • Steak And Eggs $17.95

      8oz new york strip steak with 2 eggs cooked your way

    • Fish And Chips $12.95

      beer battered tilapia & homemade tarter sauce

    • The Benny Burger $12.95

      our custom pat lafrieda blend topped with canadian bacon & chipotle hollandaise on an english muffin

    • Eggs Benedict $12.95

      2 poached eggs, canadian bacon and hollandaise sauce on an english muffin

    • Crabcake Benedict $4.59

      2 poached eggs, lump crabcakes, asparagus & chipotle hollandaise sauce on an english muffin

    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $12.95

      with fresh mozzarella, red peppers & pesto

    • Tavern Health Bowl $12.95

      stir-fried green beans, asparagus, red peppers, mushrooms & tomato on a bed of toasted red quinoa topped in a lemon garlic dressing

    • Cobb Salad $14.95

      sliced chicken breast, avocado, crispy smoked bacon, boiled egg, tomato & crumbled bleu cheese on a bed of mixed greens

  • Tavern Specialties
    • French Toast B.L.T. $12.95

      brioche french toast topped with double cut bacon, gruyere, roasted tomatoes and mixed greens with garlic bacon aioli

    • Lobster Salad Sliders $16.95

      fresh lobster with lemon-tarragon aioli on brioche sliders

    • Ultimate Hangover Cure

      a split croissant filled with our bbq pulled pork topped with a poached egg and smokey salsa

  • Snacks
    • Jumbo Wings $15.95

      buffalo, thai chili, or chipotle bbq

    • Tavern Famous Nachos $11.95

    • Tavern Famous Nachos $4

      add chili or pulled pork

    • Chicken Fingers $9.95

      homemade, panko-coated with honey porter mustard & bbq sauce

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $9.95

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2

      add bacon

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $5

      add lobster

    • Tavern Mac N' Cheese $2

      add truffle butter

    • Beer Batter Green Beans $7.95

  • Daily Specials
    • Grilled Chorizo Sandwich $12

      on a portuguese roll with fresh mozzarella, tomato, lettuce and red pepper aioli with fries

    • Pumpkin Mac N' Cheese $10

    • Crab Butternut Bisque $8

      with crispy squash chips & popcorn

    • Buffalo Shrimp Quesadilla $12

      monterey/cheddar on multigrain wrap with a side of pico & guac

    • Tavern Grilled Cheese Of The Day

      ($10 to $12)

  • Beers
    • Cisco Brewers "Pumple Drumkin" $21

      style: pale ale. subtle hints of pumpkin pie and a malty finish make this one of our favorite pumpkins, nice dry finish that leaves a pie crust flavor in your mouth

    • Dogfish Head Punkin Ale $7

      style: pumpkin ale. a full bodied brown ale brewed with organic pumpkin and brown sugar, the perfect beer to warm up as the season cools

    • Smutty Nose Pumpkin $7

      style: pumpkin ale. this highly rated ale has a rich pumpkin pie flavor thanks to the addition of fresh pumpkin and spices to the mash, easily one of our favorite fall beers

    • Elysian "The Great Pumpkin" Ale $7

      style: pumpkin ale. more pumpkin and more alcohol than their night owl ale, this big ale is bursting with different flavors, pours a lovely hazy orange with notes of cherry cola as well as the typical pumpkin pie spices you would expect

    • Founders Breakfast Stout $7

      style: coffee stout. perhaps the most loved american stout, brewed with imported bitter chocolate, kona and sumatra coffe with a lovely cinnamon head, this is the taverns idea of breakfast, get it while it lasts

    • Abita Pecan Harvest $21

      style: seasonal ale. the addition of roasted louisiana pecans give this seasonal a slightly nutty flavor that is complemented by caramel malt and willamette hops to create a lovely fall ale

    • Nectar "Humboldt Brown" Ale $21

      style: brown ale. formerly called hemp ale, this one of a kind brew with an incredibly rich flavor profile which is attributed to the addition of herbs and hem seed during the brewing process

    • Great Divide "Hoss" $21

      style: marzen lager. based on the traditional marzen style lagers of germany, multilayerd notes of malt, cherries and dark fruits with the addition of rye give it a complex character with a crisp, dry finish

    • Firestone Walker Union Jack IPA $25

      style: american ipa. this well balanced, west coast ipa is dry hopped 3 separate times, each lot giving it more and more of the grapefruit citrus hop aroma and flavor it is known for. overall it utilizes over 4 pounds of pacific northwest hops per barrel.

    • Stone Levitation $7

      style: amber ale. this deep amber ale has rich malt flavors, a big hoppy character, and citrus overtones.

    • Goose Island 312 $21

      style: urban wheat. 312's spicy aroma of cascade hops is followed by a crispy, fruity ale flavor delivered in a smooth, creamy body.

    • Stella Artois $19

      style: euro pale lager. a creamy lager with a yeasty quality, sweet fruity undertones, and a dry finish.

    • Harpoon Ufo Pumpkin $7

      style: american unfiltered pumpkin beer. the malt combination provides a smooth body and slightly sweet flavor, which balances perfectly with the earthy notes derived from the pure pumpkin.

    • Shipyard Pumpkinhead Ale $7

      style: pumpkin ale. hints of pumpkin cinnamon and nutmeg combined with a smooth refreshing finish make this a great fall beer, one of our favorite pumpkins

    • Shocktop Pumpkin Wheat $6

      style: pumpkin. notes of ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg complement this crisp easy drinking wheat beer

    • Saranac Ubu Pumpkin $7

      style: pumpkin ale. a fall variation of saranacs flagship ale, organic mashed pumpkin is added during fermentation, the addition of cinnamon, cloves and nutmeg gives it slightly spicy finish

    • Ommegang Rare Vos $21

      style: belgian style ale. an exceptional belgian style ale from one of the best craft breweries in america, a great balance of flavors and a hint of citrusy hops.

    • Captain Lawrence Freschester Pale Ale $18

      style: ipa. an aromatic beer with notes of citrus, pine, noticeable bitterness, and a touch of malty backbone to balance it out.

    • Tröegs "Dream Weaver" $21

      style: wheat beer. a combination of four wheat types with munich and pils malts, noble saaz hops, and a yeast strain that imparts a spicy, peppery, clove taste with a slight hint of bananas.

    • Goose Island Harvest Ale $21

      style: seasonal ale. this copper colored esb is made with cascade hops and the richest midwestern malts and finishes with fruity american hop aroma and toasty malt character.

    • Captain Lawrence Liquid Gold $21

      finish style: belgian ale. aromas of orange, spice and green grass combine with a clean malt dominated flavor, and a subdued hop

    • Guinness $19

      style: irish dry stout. a smooth and sweet malt upfront that moves into dark fruits, and a burnt, hoppy, bitter aftertaste.

    • Magners Original Irish Cider $19

      style: cider. made with authenticity and the time honored tradition of cider making in ireland, this cider is a delicious alternative to beer.

    • Blue Point Blueberry Ale $21

      style: fruit beer. a wonderful blend of 132 lbs of fresh blueberries and all american ingredients matched with a distinctive, thirst quenching ale.

  • Cocktails $10
    • Blood Orange Margarita

      riazul silver tequila, patron citronge, fresh blood orange puree & fresh lime juice

    • Berry Battered Boyfriend

      stoli blueberry, stoli vanilla, fresh blackberry puree & fresh lime juice

    • Mango Mojito

      bacardi silver, fresh mango puree, crushed mint leaves & fresh lime juice

    • Tavern Dark & Stormy

      meyer's rum, belvoir ginger cordial & coca cola

    • Pumpkin Martini

      crop pumpkin voda, stoli vanilla, pineapple juice with a cinnamon rim

    • The White Pumpkin

      ketel one vodka, frangelico, baileys, pumpkin syrup, with a cinnamon rim

  • Red
    • Cabernet Sauvignon "Avalon" California $8

    • Merlot "Cycles Gladiator" California $7

    • Pinot Noir "Angeline" California $8

    • Malbec "Santa Alicia Reserva" Chile $8

    • Shiraz "Altoona Hills" Australia $8

  • White
    • Chardonnay "Mark West" California $8

    • Sauvignon Blanc "Mt Fishtail" New Zealand $8

    • Pinot Grigio "Due Torri" Italy $7

    • Riesling "2 Princes" Germany $7

  • Sparkling
    • Pommery "Pop" France $16

    • Freixinet Brut Spain $8

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.