Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner
(212) 679-0442

We make ordering easy.

Classic Sarge's Sandwiches
- Hot Pastrami Sandwich $31.53
  
  We cure our pastrami in-house with our special blend of spices. It is then slow cooked to perfection.
- Hot Corned Beef Sandwich $30.36
  
  Our homemade corned beef is cured, then boiled to perfection.
- Tongue Sandwich $32.70
- Fresh Roast Turkey Sandwich $25.68
- Hot Brisket of Beef Sandwich $30.36
- Roast Beef Sandwich $29.19
  
  Home cooked to perfection (served rare to medium rare).
- Turkey Pastrami Sandwich $26.85
- Rolled Beef Sandwich $31.53
- Salami Sandwich $25.68
- Hard Salami Sandwich $25.68
- Boiled Ham Sandwich $23.34
- Chopped Liver Sandwich $24.51
- Chicken Salad Sandwich $22.17
- Egg Salad Sandwich $19.83
- Tuna Salad Sandwich $21.00
- Whitefish Salad Sandwich $23.34
- Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich $23.34
- Sandwich Meat Combo $36.21
  
  Choice of any two or three items.
- Corned Beef Reuben $36.21
  
  Coleslaw and Russian Dressing
- Pastrami Reuben $36.21
  
  Pastrami, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, grilled.
- Turkey Reuben $36.21
  
  Turkey, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut, grilled.
- The Hudson “Born December 12th 2018” $38.55
  
  Open faced Pastrami & Corned Beef stacked on Rye, Swiss cheese and Sauerkraut grilled.
- Sweet Baby Dave's Smokehouse Pastrami $32.70
  
  Sarge's homemade pastrami topped with coleslaw and chipotle honey mustard on a toasted hero.
- Half Sandwich and Soup $28.02
- Shrimp Salad $24.51

Sarge's Hot Sandwiches
- The Third Avenue $40.89
  
  Hot Corned Beef & Hot Pastrami, Open on Rye Bread with French Fries & Stuffed Derma
- Hot Open Brisket $35.04
  
  with French Fries and Gravy
- French Dip Sandwich $37.38
  
  Shaved Prime Roast Beef Dipped in Au Jus on a Club Roll with Horseradish Sauce and Au Juson the side with fries
- Cheese Steak $37.38
  
  Shaved slow roasted prime Roast Beef, smothered with sautéed Onions & Peppers, topped with melted American cheese on a toasted Garlic Club Roll with Fries
- Chicken Parm Sandwich $32.70
  
  Fried Chicken cutlet, topped with melted Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato Sauce on a toasted Garlic Club Roll with fries
- Chicken Loco $35.04
  
  Chicken Cutlet, Pastrami, Melted Swiss, Cole Slaw, & Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll with fries
- The #3 $36.21
  
  CORNED BEEF & PASTRAMI Cole Slaw & Russian Dressing.
- Sarges Favorite $35.04
  
  Hot slow-cooked brisket of beef on potato pancake with homemade gravy and applesauce.
- The Suzy Greenberg $29.19
  
  Fried Chicken Cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, Bacon & Russian Dressing on a Toasted Club Roll
- Boneless Chicken Sandwich $26.85
  
  On a Kaiser Roll (Grilled or Fried) with Lettuce & Tomato served with French Fries

Craving Something Different?
- Chicken Pot Pie $23.34
  
  Blend of chicken, peas, carrots, onions, potatoes and fresh cream in a pie shell pastry.
- Bacon Egg and Cheese $12.81
  
  on rye
- Grilled Cheese $12.81
- BLT $18.66
  
  Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on white toast
- Tuna Melt $30.36
  
  with Tomato and American Cheese on Grilled Rye
- Turkey Club $32.70
  
  Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on white toast with Mayo
- Chicken Salad Club ( Junior ) $31.53
  
  Chicken Salad, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on white toast with Mayo
- Sarge's Favorite $35.04
  
  Hot Brisket on Potato Pancake with Gravy & Applesauce
- Mulberry Street $26.85
  
  Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted red peppers, oil & vinegar on a hero.

Unreal Deli
- Unreal Corned Beef or Turkey Sandwich $22.17
  
  Your choice of Mrs. Goldfarb's 100% plant-based corned beef or turkey 100% vegetarian.
- Unreal Corned Beef or Turkey Reuben $26.85
  
  Your choice of Mrs. Goldfarb's 100% plant based Corned Beef or Turkey served with Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut grilled to perfection.

Sarge's Noshes Franks and Appetizers
- Frank on a Bun $9.30
  
  Served on a Bun with Sauerkraut or Red Onions
- Knish $9.30
- Grilled Knockwurst $11.64
  
  on a bun
- Stuffed Knish
  
  Square potato knish stuffed with a hot dog, corned beef or pastrami topped with mustard or Russian, grilled add melted cheese and sauerkraut.
- Gefilte Fish $12.81
- Chopped Liver $17.49
- Stuffed Derma $19.83
  
  Our kishka is famous (watch the 3rd episode of season one of "The Deuce" on HBO. A scene in this episode was filmed at Sarge's.
- Stuffed Cabbage $19.83
- Fried Kreplach $17.49
  
  with fried onions
- Potato Pancake (1) $8.13
- Chicken Fingers $19.83

Jewish Dairy Specials
- Cheese Blintzes $28.02
  
  Three blintzes served with complimentary Sour Cream
- Noodle Kugel $16.32
  
  Serves 2
- Matzo Brei $22.17
  
  with Apple Sauce
- Potato Pancakes (3) $22.17
  
  Three pancakes served with sour cream or applesauce.
- Potato Pirogen (4) $26.85
  
  With fried onions and 8 oz sour cream.

Sides
- French Fries $11.64
- Sweet Potato Fries $12.81
- Old Fashioned Onion Rings $15.15
- Coleslaw $8.13
- Potato Salad $8.13
- Macoroni Salad $8.13
- Corned Beef Hash $21.00
- Bacon $10.47
- Breakfast Sausage $10.47
- Fried Mushrooms and Onions $10.47
- Egg Barley and Mushrooms $13.98
- Kasha Varnishkas $13.98
- Baked Beans $11.64
- Pickled Tomatoes $9.30
- Tossed Green Salad $11.64
- Stuffing $10.47
- Fruit Salad $9.30
- side Sauerkraut $6.96
- Sweet Peppers $9.30
- Hot Peppers $9.30
- Side Tomato $3.45
- Side Avocado $5.79
- Side Egg $3.51

Sarge's Famous Burgers
- Beef Burger $23.34
- Cheeseburger $25.68
- Central Park $30.36
  
  Corned beef and melted American cheese
- Skyscraper $31.53
  
  Pastrami and melted American cheese
- Patty Melt $23.34
  
  On Grilled Rye, With Sauteéd Onions & Melted American Cheese
- Sliders $23.34
  
  4 Mini Burgers with Grilled Onions & Melted American Cheese
- Cookout Burger $29.19
  
  Smokey BBQ Sauce, Melted Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Sauteéd Mushrooms, and Onions
- Veggie Burger $19.83

Salads
- Caesar Salad $22.17
  
  with Romain, Croutons, Grated Parmesan and Creamy Caesar
- Chopped Salad $24.51
  
  with Iceberg, Romaine, Radicchio, Cucumber, Tomato, Green Onions, Chick Peas and Roasted Corn
- Cobb Salad $29.19
  
  Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Sliced Egg & Tomatoes on Mixed Greens
- Chef Salad $29.19
  
  Fresh Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Swiss, and Tomatoes on Mixed Greens

Eggs
- Three Eggs Served Any Style $18.66
  
  Three eggs any style with toast and fries or homefries
- Garden Omelette $25.68
  
  Tomato, Onions, Mushrooms, Broccoli
- Western Omelette $23.34
  
  Ham, Peppers, Onion
- Cheese Omelette $23.34
  
  Choice of American, Swiss or Cheddar
- Delicatessen $35.04
  
  Corned Beef, Pastrami, Tonuge, Salami
- Make Your Own Omelette $18.66
- Challah French Toast $19.83
  
  dipped in Egg Batter and grilled to a golden brown
- Pancake $19.83
  
  Chocolate Chip or Blueberry
- Bagel, Roll, or English Muffin $4.62
- Toast $3.45

Smoked Fish
- Nova Special $42.06
  
  Two bagels, extra Nova Scotia cured salmon, cream cheese, onion, tomato
- Pick Two Combo $49.08
  
  Choice of Two Smoked Fish Selections, accompanied by Two Bagels, Cream Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Bermuda Onion
- Supreme $59.61
  
  Two bagels, extra Nova Scotia cured salmon, cream cheese, onion, tomato
- Our Classic Smoked Fish
  
  Served with bagel, choice of cream cheese, onion, tomato
- Herrings $15.15
- Herring Sampler $33.87
  
  Combination of all 4 herrings served with bagel and cream cheese

Deli Meat
- Beef Bologna (1lb) $24.57
- Beef Franks (1lb) $25.74
- Beef Knockwurst (1lb) $25.74
- Beef Salami (1lb) $24.57
- Boiled Ham (1lb) $17.55
- Brisket (1lb) $42.12
- Corned Beef (1lb) $44.46
- Fresh Roasted Turkey (1lb) $35.10
- Hard Salami (1lb) $32.76
- Liverwurst (1lb) $16.38
- Pastrami (1lb) $49.14
- Roast Beef (1lb) $39.78
- Rolled Beef (1lb) $49.14
- Tongue (1lb) $51.48
- Turkey Pastrami (1lb) $37.44
- Unreal Corned Beef (1lb) $24.57
- Unreal Turkey (1lb) $24.57
- Whole Roast Chicken $21.00
- Half Roast Chicken $11.64
- Grilled Chicken Breast $8.13
- Fried Chicken Breast $9.30

Deli Items
- Mustard (1/2) $4.07
- MUSTARD
- Russian (1/2lb) $5.24
- RUSSIAN
- MAYO
- Single Bagel $1.76
- Challah Bread (Loaf) $10.47
- Challah Bread (Slice) $0.47
- Rye Bread (Slice) $0.47
- Rye Bread (1/2 Loaf) $6.96
- Rye Bread (Loaf) $13.92
- Plain Cream Cheese (1lb) $11.70
- Scallion Cream Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Vegetable Cream Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Baked Kippered Salmon (1lb) $59.67
- Baked Salmon Salad (1lb) $33.93
- Belly Lox (1lb) $59.67
- Chicken Salad (1lb) $22.23
- Chopped Chicken Liver (1lb) $21.06
- Chopped Herring (1lb) $16.38
- Cole Slaw (1lb) $11.70
- Cottage Cheese $8.13
- Cranberry Sauce $6.96
- Cucumber Salad (1lb) $11.70
- Egg Barley with Mushrooms (1lb) $11.70
- Egg Salad (1lb) $17.55
- Gravy $6.96
- Gravy ON SIDE
- Herring Filet (EA) $4.68
- Herring in Cream Sauce (1lb) $18.72
- Kasha Varnishkas (1lb) $11.70
- Macaroni Salad (1lb) $11.70
- Nova Salmon (1lb) $59.67
- Potato Salad (1lb) $11.70
- Smoked Sable (1lb) $76.05
- Smoked Whitefish (1lb) $32.76
- Sturgeon (1lb) $76.05
- Tuna Salad (1lb) $22.23
- Whitefish Salad (1lb) $33.93
- Olives $8.13
- SM Pickle (EA) $1.46
- LG Pickle (EA) $4.10
- Quart of Pickles (EA) $9.30
- sm SOUR pickle only with sandwich
- sm HALF SOUR pickle only with sandwich
- Mixed Pickles only with sandwich
- Chocolate Babka $18.66
- Ruggelach (1lb) $20.97

Deli Cheese
- Cheddar Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- American Cheese (1lb) $12.87
- Mozzarella Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Muenster Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Plain Cream Cheese (1lb) $11.70
- Scallion Cream Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Vegetable Cream Cheese (1lb) $15.21
- Swiss Cheese (1lb) $17.55
- Provolone Cheese (1lb) $17.55

Deli Soups
- Old Fashioned Chicken Consommé $9.30
- Matzo Ball Soup $9.95
  
  Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more of our soup extras.
- Kreplach Soup $9.95
- Matzo Noodle Soup $9.95
  
  Chicken consomme with 1 matzo ball and noodles. Freshly made every day, enjoy it plain or add in one or more of our soup extras.
- Noodle Soup $9.95
- Rice Soup $9.95
- Souper Soup $14.95
  
  Matzo Ball, Kreplach, & Noodles
- Mushroom Barley Soup $9.95
- Vegetable Soup $9.95
  
  Homemade vegetable soup with seasonal vegetables.
- Split Pea Soup $9.95
  
  Served with homemade croutons on the side.
- Borscht $9.95
  
  with sour cream
- French Onion $11.95
- Dry Matzo Ball $4.62
- Dry Kreplach $4.62
- Dry Noodles $4.62
- Matzo Ball soup for 2 $28.95
- Kreplach Soup for 2 $28.95

Deli Drinks
- Dr Browns $4.62
- Fountain Soda $3.80
- Can Soda $3.80
- Legendary Egg Cream $6.96
- Milkshake (Extra Thick) $10.47
- Columbian Coffee $4.10
- Hot Tea $4.10
- Juice $5.79
- Orange Juice $6.96
- Iced Tea $4.68
- Andy's 18th Hole $6.96
  
  80% Iced Tea, 20% Lemonade, 100% refreshing
- Bottle of Water $2.93
- Iced Coffee $4.68

Salad Platter

All platters served with Potato Salad, Cole Slaw, Tomato, Cucumbers, and Sliced Egg on a Bed of Lettuce
- Salad Platter $25.68
- Smoked Fish Sld Platter $31.53

Cold Cuts Platters
- Assorted Cold Cuts Ala Sarge $46.74
  
  Choice of any 4 Meats or Cheese, with Cole Slaw & Potato Salad (Enough for 2)
- Cold Roast Beef Platter $36.21
- Hot Corned Beef Platter $37.38
  
  Thinly Sliced & Delicious, Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
- Hot Pastrami Platter $39.72
  
  Served With Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
- Combination Hot Corned Beef & Hot Pastrami Platter $39.72
- Tongue Platter $42.06
  
  Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw
- Cold Sliced Turkey Platter $35.04
  
  Center Cut Slices & Lots of Them, Served with Potato Salad & Cole Slaw

Entrees (Copy)
- Chkn in the pot $38.55
  
  in the Pot with Matzo Ball, Noodles, Peas, & Carrots
- Pot Roast $38.55
- Half Roast Chicken $38.55
  
  with Stuffing
- Roast Turkey $37.38
  
  All White or Mixed Meat with Stuffing, & Gravy
- Hungarian Beef Goulash $37.38
  
  with Broad Noodles, Casserole, Peas and Carrots
- Corned Beef and Cabbage $38.55
  
  with Boiled Potatoes
- "Specials" $32.70
  
  Choice of grilled or boiled knockwurst, served with sauerkraut, baked beans, and french fries
- Broiled Salmon $38.55

Potatoes & Vegetables (Copy)
- French Fries $9.95
- Baked Yam $10.47
- Baked Potato $9.30
- Mashed Potato $9.30
- Boiled Potato $9.30
- Home Fries $10.47
- Sweet Potato Fries $10.95
- Candied Sweets $10.47
- Corn on the Cob $9.30
- Fresh Broccoli $9.30
- Sliced Carrots $9.30
- String Beans $9.30
- Sweet Peas $9.30
- Creamed Spinach $11.64

Beverages
- Dr Browns $4.62
- Fountain Soda $4.68
- Can Soda $4.10
- Legendary Egg Cream $6.96
- Milkshake (Extra Thick) $10.47
- Juice $5.79
- Orange Juice $6.96
- Iced Tea $5.79
- Andy's 18th Hole $6.96
  
  80% Iced Tea, 20% Lemonade, 100% refreshing
- Bottle of Water $2.93
- Iced Coffee $5.79
- Milk $4.62
- Chocolate Milk $5.79

Beer
- Guinness $10.53
- Brooklyn IPA $10.53
- Bud Light $10.53
- Budweiser $10.53
- Corona $10.53
- Heineken $10.53
- Samuel Adams $10.53
- Stella Artois $10.53
- Michelob Ultra $10.53
- Kona $10.53

Wine
- Cabernet Sauvignon $11.64
- Merlot $11.64
- Chardonnay $11.64
- Pinot Grigio $11.64
- White Zinfandel $11.64
- Champagne $15.15

Cakes
- Apple Strudel $11.64
- Carrot Cake $12.81
- Chocolate Fudge Cake $12.81
- Chocolate Mousse Cake $12.81
- German Chocolate Cake $12.81
- Red Velvet Cake $12.81
- Seven Layer Cake $12.81

Sarge's Homemade Cheesecakes
- Original New York $12.81
- Strawberry Cheesecake $15.15
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip $15.15
- Oreo Cheesecake $15.15

Pies
- Apple Crumb Pie $11.64
- A La Mode $3.51
- Banana Cream Pie $11.64
- Pecan Pie $11.64
- Chocolate Cream Pie $11.64
- Key Lime Pie $9.30
- Lemon Meringue $9.30

Cookies & Ice Cream
- Large Black & White Cookie $5.79
- Large Chocolate Chip Cookie $5.79
- Linzer Tart $5.79
- French Ice Cream $9.30
- Chocolate Eclair $10.47
- Ruggelach (6) $10.47
- Marble Nut Halvah ( Seasonal ) $11.64

Menu for Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

What is Seamless

Why use Seamless

Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner