• New York
  • New York
  • Croton Reservoir Tavern

Croton Reservoir Tavern

(212) 997-6835
  • 108 West 40th St, New York, NY 10018
  • Website
  • American ,  Bar Food
  • $$$$$
  • Seamless.com
  • Menu
  • Lunch Starters and Bites
    • Bavarian Pretzel Lunch $11

      Bavarian soft pretzel sticks, beer cheese sauce.

    • Spinach Artichoke and Corn Dip Lunch $14

      Roasted artichoke hearts, creamed spinach, corn, cheddar, pepper jack cheese, tortilla chips.

    • Burrata Lunch $14

      Bulgur wheat, celery, pears, parsley, lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil and grilled crostini.

    • Roasted Brussels Sprouts Lunch $14

      Apple cider reduction, sage and pomegranate seeds.

    • Grandma's Meatballs Lunch $16

      Herb polenta cake, fresh herbs, ricotta and tomato sauce.

    • Hummus Lunch $13

      Roasted garlic, roasted vegetables, harissa and warm pita.

  • Lunch Burgers and Sandwiches
    Served with small portion of mixed greens, add shoestring or sweet potato fries for an additional charge.
    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Burger Lunch $17

      Beef patty, yellow cheddar, shredded lettuce and brioche sesame bun. Add bacon, avocado for an additional charge.

    • Tuna Burger Lunch $19

      Spicy slaw, tomato, miso aioli and brioche sesame bun.

    • Steak Sandwich Lunch $20

      Marinated Angus skirt steak, baby arugula, garlic aioli and rustic ciabatta.

    • Veggie Burger Lunch $17

      House made three bean veggie burger, lettuce, tomato, sprouts, avocado cream, multigrain bun.

    • BLATT Sandwich Lunch $16

      Bacon, butter lettuce, avocado, beefsteak tomato, turkey and grilled country loaf.

    • Frangelico Lobster Roll Lunch $24

      Celery, aioli, old bay, chives and brioche bun.

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich Lunch $17

      Buttermilk fried chicken, pimento cheese, lettuce, pickles and brioche sesame bun.

    • Short Rib Cheesesteak Sandwich Lunch $19

      Braised short rib, red wine caramelized onion and mushrooms, arugula, pepper jack cheese, horseradish aioli and French baguette.

  • Lunch Entrees
    • Grilled Salmon Lunch $27

      Seared salmon, couscous, parsnip, butternut squash, zucchini and romesco sauce.

    • Handcraft Mac and Cheese Lunch $17

      Shells, Gruyere, Asiago, slab bacon, kale, bread crumbs and scallions. Add pulled pork, chicken or steak for an additional charge.

    • Short Rib Gnocchi Lunch $26

      Braised short rib, mushrooms, leeks, fresh herbs and grana padana.

    • Grilled Mahi Mahi Lunch $27

      Butternut squash puree, black lentils, fennel and cured lemon.

    • Chicken Paillard Lunch $20

      Mixed greens, arugula, cherry tomato, mandarin oranges, radish and mint vinaigrette.

  • Lunch Soups
    • Lobster Bisque Lunch $12

      Classic lobster bisque, puff pastry and chives.

  • Lunch Salads
    Add grilled chicken, grilled salmon, steak, seared tuna, 3 bean veggie patty or grilled shrimp for an additional charge.
    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Salad Lunch $16

      Haricots vert, fennel, tri-colored carrots, cherry tomato, mix greens, ricotta salata, dill and yogurt vinaigrette.

    • Classic Caesar Salad Lunch $13

      Romaine lettuce, kale, garlic-herb croutons, Parmesan and house made Caesar dressing.

    • Kale Salad Lunch $15

      Kale, Parmesan, golden raisin, raw almonds and red wine vinaigrette.

    • Cobb Salad Lunch $18

      Mixed greens, tomato, avocado, bacon, egg, bleu cheese crumbles, herb-roasted chicken and green goddess dressing.

    • Arugula Salad Lunch $15

      Buttenut squash, candied pecans, apples, blue cheese crumbles and citrus vinaigrette.

  • Lunch Sides
    • Basket of Sweet Potato Fries Lunch $8

    • Basket of Shoestring Fries Lunch $8

    • Truffle Parmesan Fries Lunch $12

    • Roasted Carrots Lunch $8

    • Chips and Guacamole Lunch $10

  • Dinner Starters and Bites
    • Bavarian Pretzel $11

      Bavarian soft pretzel sticks, beer cheese sauce.

    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Nachos $14

      Vegetarian three bean chili, pepper jack, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream and cilantro. Add pulled pork, chicken or ribeye for an additional charge.

    • Spinach Artichoke and Corn Dip $14

      Roasted artichoke hearts, creamed spinach, corn, cheddar, pepper jack cheese and tortilla chips.

    • Margherita Pizza $14

      Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil olive oil.

    • Sliders $12

      Beef, cheddar, tomato, pickle or pulled pork slider with spicy slaw.

    • Burrata $14

      Bulgur wheat, celery, pears, parsley, lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil and grilled crostini.

    • Chicken Wings $12

      Caribbean spiced, spicy chipotle BBQ or buffalo sauce with blue cheese dressing.

    • Hummus $13

      Roasted garlic, roasted vegetables, harissa and warm pita.

    • Roasted Brussels Sprouts $14

      Apple cider reduction, sage and pomegranate seeds.

    • Grandma's Meatballs $16

      Herb polenta cake, fresh herbs, ricotta and tomato sauce.

  • Dinner Burgers and Sandwiches
    Served with small portion of mixed greens, add shoestring or sweet potato fries for an additional charge.
    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Burger $17

      Beef patty, yellow cheddar, shredded lettuce and brioche sesame bun.

    • Tuna Burger $19

      Spicy slaw, tomato, miso aioli and brioche sesame bun.

    • Bison Burger $26

      Bison patty, applewood smoked bacon, manchego, avocado, chipotle aioli, beefsteak tomato, red onion and brioche sesame bun.

    • Veggie Burger $17

      House made three bean veggie burger, lettuce, tomato, sprouts, avocado cream and multigrain bun.

  • Dinner Entrees
    • Fish and Chips $19

      Beer battered haddock, fries, spicy slaw and tartar sauce.

    • Grilled Salmon $27

      Seared salmon, couscous, parsnip, butternut squash, zucchini and romesco sauce.

    • Short Rib Gnocchi $26

      Braised short rib, mushrooms, leeks, fresh herbs and grana padana.

    • Handcraft Mac and Cheese $16

      Shells, Gruyere, Asiago, slab bacon, kale, bread crumbs and scallions. Add pulled pork, chicken or ribeye for an additional charge.

    • Grilled Mahi Mahi $27

      Butternut squash puree, black lentils, fennel and cured lemon.

    • Chicken Paillard $20

      Mixed greens, arugula, cherry tomato, mandarin oranges, radish and mint vinaigrette.

    • Steak Frittes $27

      Grilled skirt steak, fries, avocado butter and arugula salad.

    • 20 oz. Bone in Ribeye $32

  • Dinner Soups
    • Lobster Bisque $12

      Classic lobster bisque, puff pastry and chives.

  • Dinner Salads
    Add grilled chicken, grilled salmon, steak, seared tuna, 3 bean veggie patty or grilled shrimp for an additional charge.
    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Salad $16

      haricot vert, asparagus, summer corn, tomato, mixed greens, ricotta salata and citrus vinaigrette.

    • Kale Salad $15

      Parmesan, golden raisins, raw almonds and red wine.

    • Arugula Salad $15

      Buttenut squash, candied pecans, apples, blue cheese crumbles and citrus vinaigrette.

    • Classic Caesar Salad $13

      Romaine lettuce, kale, garlic-herb croutons, Parmesan and house made Caesar dressing.

    • Side Salad $8

      Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, onions, radish and balsamic vinaigrette.

  • Dinner Sides
    • Roasted Carrots $8

    • Basket of Sweet Potato Fries $8

    • Basket of Shoestring Fries $8

    • Truffle Parmesan Fries $12

    • Chips and Guacamole $10

  • Late Night - Bar Bites
    • Bavarian Pretzel $10

      Bavarian soft pretzel sticks and beer cheese sauce.

    • Spinach Artichoke and Corn Dip $14

      Roasted artichoke hearts, creamed spinach, corn, cheddar, pepper jack cheese and tortilla chips.

    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Nachos $14

      Vegetarian 3 bean chili, pepper jack, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream and cilantro.

    • Margherita Pizza $12

      Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil olive oil.

    • Chicken Wings $12

      Spicy chipotle BBQ or buffalo sauce with blue cheese dressing.

    • Hummus $13

      Roasted garlic, roasted vegetables, harissa and warm pita.

    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Burger $17

      Beef patty, white cheddar, shredded lettuce and brioche sesame bun. Add fries, bacon or avocado for an additional charge.

    • Handcraft Mac and Cheese $16

      Shells, Gruyere, Asiago, slab bacon, kale, bread crumbs and scallions. Add chicken for an additional charge.

    • Croton Reservoir Tavern Salad $16

      Haricot vert, asparagus, summer corn, tomato, mixed greens, ricotta salata and citrus vinaigrette.

    • Chips and Guacamole $10

  • Late Night - Sliders
    • Lobster Sliders $19

      3 sliders of lobster salad and frangelico liquor.

    • Cheeseburger Sliders $12

      3 sliders, cheddar, tomato and pickle.

  • Late Night - Sides
    • Basket of Fries $8

    • Sweet Potato Fries $8

  • Starters
    • Grandma's Meatballs $13

      creamy polenta, marinara, grana padana, toasted country bread

    • Croton Chicken Wings $13

      choice of buffalo or whiskey bbq

    • Couscous & Vegetable Salad $14

      mixed greens, couscous, roasted corn, tri-color carrots, radish, butternut squash, lemon vinaigrette

    • Handcraft Mac n Cheese $17

      shells, kale, bacon, gruyere, asiago, garlic bread crumbs

    • Kale and Artichoke Dip $16

    • Croton Nachos $15

      corn and bean chili, pico de gallo, guacamole, cheese sauce, sour cream

    • Truffle Fried Burrata $13

      mushroom duxelle, arugula, fresh herbs

    • Buttermilk Fried Chicken Caesar Salad $15

  • Handhelds
    served with side salad
    • CRT Burger $16

      cheddar, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun

    • Three Bean Veggie Burger $16

      house made three bean patty, pickled onion, roasted tomatoes, lettuce, brioche bun

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich $18

      beer cheese, lettuce, pickles, brioche bun

    • Chicken Finger Platter $15

      4 fingers, served with fries, and choice of buffalo or whiskey bbq

  • Everyday Brunch
    add a mimosa kit for $10 (1btl champagne and 16oz oj)
    • Breakfast Burrito $16

      Scrambled eggs, black beans, cheddar, guacamole, pico de gallo

    • Breakfast Sandwich $16

      2 eggs, bacon, cheddar, pico de gallo, on English muffin

    • Brunch Burger $16

      Cheddar, lettuce, tomato, fried egg, on English muffin

  • Sides
    • French Fries $7

    • Sweet Fries $7

    • Crispy Brussels Sprouts $11

    • Side Bacon $5

    • Side Mac n Cheese $12

      no bacon or breadcrumbs

    • Bavarian Pretzel $11

      beer cheese, mustard

  • Family Meals
    • Chicken Finger and Burgers $45

      8 fingers, 2 burgers, basket of fries

    • Burger Meal $45

      4 burgers, basket of fries

    • Burger and Chicken Sandwich Meal $45

      2 burgers, 2 chicken sandwiches, basket of fries

    • Mac N Cheese Tray $45

      family style, shells, kale, bacon, gruyere, asiago, garlic bread crumbs

    • Burrito Pack $40

      chicken, black beans, rice, queso, guacamole, pico de gallo, crema

  • Beverages
    • Coke $3

    • Diet Coke $3

    • Sprite $3

    • Ginger Ale $3

    • Red Bull $3

  • Bottle Wine (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    • Cabernet $10

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Cotes du Rhone $10

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Sauvignon Blanc $10

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Rose $10

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Malbec $15

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • Bottle Beer (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    • Allagash White $7

      16 oz. can. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Corona $3

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Chimay White $5

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • PorkSlap Pale Ale $3

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Narragansett $3

      12oz can. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Sloop Juice Bomb IPA $5

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Abita Purple Haze $5

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Abita Amber $3

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Abita Big Easy IPA $3

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • Bottle Liquor (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    • Titos $35

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Ketel One $40

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • House Vodka $15

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Jameson $45

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Jack Daniels $40

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Altos Tequila $35

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • 16 oz. Craft Beer Cans (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    • Barrier Money IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • LIC Coded Tiles APA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • LIC Party Crasher IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • KCBC Superhero Sidekicks IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • KCBC Janiac Maniac Pilsner $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • KBCB Robot Fish Simcoe Smash IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • KCBC Pleasure Craft IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • KCBC Extremely Dangerous Precedent Double IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Finback IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Finback Rolling in the Clouds IPA $8

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Finback Fields of Tall Grass Double IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Finback Whale Watching DDH IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Other Half Forever Ever Session IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Other Half DDH Double Mosaic Dream Imperial IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Other Half DDH Mylar Bags Imperial IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Other Half Green City DDH IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Other Half All Citra Everything DDH IPA $9

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • Craft Cocktails (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    12 oz. bottle, serves 2.5 drinks.
    • Negroni $20

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Old Fashioned $20

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Bourbon Sweet Tea $15

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Vodka Sweet Tea $15

      Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Margarita $15

      Must be 21 to purchase.

  • Today's Specials (Must be 21 to Purchase)
    • 8oz. Marinated Skirt Steak Bourbon or Wine Deal $45

      8oz skirt steak, garlic mashed potatoes, brussels sprouts, chimichurri, choice of 375ml bottle Bulleit Bourbon or bottle of wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Cheeseburger Wine Deal $29

      CRT Burger, Fries, and Select Bottle of Wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Filet Mignon Cheesesteak Wine Deal $35

      caramelized onions, beer cheese, toasted baguette, served with onion rings and bottle select wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Open Faced Bison Meatloaf Sandwich w/ choice of beverage $30

      lettuce, tomato, red onion, pepper jack cheese, toasted ciabatta bread, served with fries and choice of bottle Bourbon Tea or Bottle Wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • St. louis Style Half rack Ribs with a bottle of wine $35

      Half Rack of Ribs, severed with garlic mashed potatoes, and baked beans served with a bottle of wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Chicken Tacos $30

      Marinated chicken, Shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, guacamole with Chips 12oz of Margarita or Blood Orange Margarita. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Grilled Skirt Steak Sandwich Wine Deal $35

      grilled steak, white cheddar cheese, caramelized red onions, pickled jalapeno, on a toasted hero bun, served with fries and choice of select wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Blackened Shrimp Tacos Margarita Fiesta $29

      4 blackened shrimp tacos, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, guacamole, tortilla chips, 12oz of House Made bottled margarita. Must be 21 to purchase.

    • Short Rib Gnocchi Wine Dinner $34

      Braised short ribs, asparagus, mushrooms, parmesan cheese, bottle of select wine. Must be 21 to purchase.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.