Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • The Mermaid Inn

The Mermaid Inn

(212) 799-7400

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 568 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
  • Restaurant website
  • Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • The Mermaid Inn

  • (212) 799-7400
  • Menu
  • Raw Bar
    • Oysters

      selection of east & west coast

    • Chilled 1/2 Lobster $16.00

    • Littleneck Clams $10.00

    • Classic Shrimp Cocktail $14.00

    • Yellow Fin Tuna Crudo $12.00

      jalapeno, avocado, lime & sea salt

    • Baby Grand Platter $32.00

      6 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo

    • Grand Platter $72.00

      12 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo, shrimp cocktail, 1/2 chilled lobster

  • Appetizers
    • Tomato Bread Soup $10.00

      parmesan, extra virgin olive oil

    • Sweet & Spicy Charred Octopus $14.00

      scallion, chinese sausage & fingerling potatoe salad

    • Jonah Crab Cake $16.00

      savory horseradish slaw, creole mustard

    • Potato Ravioli $14.00

      shallots, brussels & sage

    • Potato Ravioli $19.00

      with lobster

    • Mermaid Wedge Salad $11.00

      cherry tomatoes, red onion, maytag blue cheese, apple-smoked bacon & buttermilk dressing

    • Seared Calamari $13.00

      cremini, shiitake, frisee & feta

    • Chopped Romaine Salad $12.00

      gold beets, garlic chips, lentils & parmesan

    • Chopped Romaine Salad $19.00

      with lobster

    • Steamed Littleneck Clams $13.00

      white beans, piquillos, sweet sausage, garlic bread

  • Entrees
    • Sauteed Local Skate $22.00

      butternut squash, fennel, piqiullos & lemon butter

    • Pappardelle Pasta $18.00

      sweet peas, wild mushrooms, radishes, lemon creme fraiche

    • Pappardelle Pasta $26.00

      with shrimp

    • Blackened Southern Style Catfish $23.00

      hush puppies, collard greens & crayfish butter

    • Pan Roasted Chicken Breast $24.00

      smashed potato salad, pickled onion, dried tart cherry jus

    • Grilled Brook Trout $26.00

      roast cauliflower, tomatoes, capers, ricotta salatta & lemon oil

    • Mermaid Fish Tacos $22.00

      beer batter, red cabbage, pickled jalapeños & pico de gallo

    • Lobster Sandwich $28.00

      grilled brioche bun & old bay fries

    • Grilled Atlantic Salmon $26.00

      shiitake, baby bok choy, ponzu vinaigrette

  • Sides
    • Sautéed Kale $7.00

      garlic, olive oil & sea salt

    • Old Bay Fries $6.00

    • Hush Puppies $7.00

      gouda & chile remoulade

    • Grain Salad $8.00

      pumpkin seeds, butternut squash, pecorino & kale

    • Seared Asparagus $8.00

      parmesan & olive oil

    • Smoked Gouda Mac & Cheese $8.00

    • House Salad $8.00

      parmesan, red onion, lemon citronette

  • Sides
    • Lobsterpalooza - Every Sunday $26.00

      a pound and 1/4 lobster, grilled corn on the cob, red bliss potatoes

    • Old Fashioned Crab Boil - Every Tuesday In Summer $26.00

      bucket of steamed blue crabs, red bliss potatoes, grilled corn on the cob & jalapeño cornbread

  • Kids $6
    • Spaghetti

      with butter or tomato sauce

    • Chicken Fingers

      crispy chicken breast, fries or green salad

    • Mac & Cheese

      mozzarella and parmesean

    • Fish Fingers

      crispy tilapia, fries or green salad

    • Quesadilla

      flour tortillas, melted mozzarella

    • Grilled Chicken Breast

      with fries or green salad

  • Brunch
    • Tres Leche Challah French Toast $12.00

      strawberries & powdered sugar

    • Buttermilk Pancakes $12.00

      bananas, strawberries & vermont maple syrup

    • Cast Iron Fritatta $13.00

      broccoli, white cheddar & bacon

    • Uws Steak & Organic Eggs $15.00

      grilled hanger steak, eggs any style, herb oil, onion rings

    • Eggs Any Style $12.00

      chicken & apple sausage, lyonnaise potatoes & toast

    • Huevos Rancheros $14.00

      eggs sunny, cheddar cheese, black beans

    • Smoked Salmon Benedict $15.00

      lyonnaise potatoes, english muffin & old bay hollandaise

  • Salads & Sandwiches
    • Grilled Summer Squash Salad $12.00

      pine nuts, confetti tomatoes, basil, cucumber greek yogurt

    • Mermaid Black Angus Burger $15.00

      sunny side egg, sautéed vidalia onions, old bay fries

    • Mermaid Egg Sandwich $12.00

      sausage patty, 2 eggs over easy, white cheddar & old bay fries

    • Seared Tuna Nicoise Salad $15.00

      haricot vert, hard cooked egg & tapenade vinagrette

    • Ragin' Cajun Po' Boy $16.00

      shrimp, oysters, griddled broiche, tartar, pico de gallo, cole slaw & fries

    • Mermaid Fish Tacos $7.00

      tilapia, marinated red cabbage, pickled jalapeños

    • Lobster Sandwich $28.00

      griddled brioche, old bay fries

  • Sides
    • Apple Smoked Bacon $6.00

    • Chicken & Apple Sausage $6.00

    • Toast $3.00

    • Old Bay Fries $4.00

    • Onion Rings $5.00

    • Seasonal Fruit $6.00

    • Lyonnaise Potatoes $5.00

  • Cocktails $7
    • The Fresca

      hangar one mandarin, st. germain, lemon, soda

    • Chilly Margaret

      silver tequila, lime, jalapeno sugar

    • Mimosa

      cava, fresh squeezed orange juice

    • Bellini

      prosecco, white peach puree

  • Raw Bar $1
    • Littleneck Clams

    • Oysters

      east coast

  • Snack Bar
    • Mini Tomato Bread Soup $3.00

      parmesan, extra virgin olive oil

    • Fried Oysters $3.00

    • Fried Calamari $7.00

    • Mini Mermaid Fish Taco $3.00

      blackened tilapia, avocado, smoked jalapeno

    • Grilled Shrimp & Avocado Slider $7.00

    • Fried Clam Slider $6.00

  • Cocktails $7
    • Campari Spritz

      cava & campari

    • Mermaid Mary

      old bay spice, bloody mary mix

    • Dark & Stormier

      dark rum, ginger beer, lime

    • Gone With The Gin

      gin, pamplemousse, thyme, lemon

    • Hot & Dirty

      vodka, olive juice, tabasco

  • Beer $5
    • Mermaid Pilsner

      rich & dark with bready malt

    • Sixpoint Sweet Action Cream Ale

      barley, hops, balance of sweet and bitter

  • Wine By The Glass $6
    • White

    • Red

    • Rosé

    • Sparkling

  • Cocktails
    • Dark & Stormier $12.00

      gosling's rum, domaine de canton. ginger beer

    • The Kiss Of Mother Carey $12.00

      ketel one, blackberry jam, lime

    • Campari Spritz $11.00

      cava, campari

    • Mermaid Mary $12.00

      hangar one, old bay spiced mary mix, skewered shrimp

    • Hot & Dirty $11.00

      tito's vodka, tobasco, olive, peppadew pepper

  • Beer $7
    • Red Wagon I.P.A.

      crisp with floral, fruity hops (ocean beach, ny)

    • Southampton Double White Ale

      full body with lively citrus (long island,ny)

    • Left Hand Milk Stout

      sweet dark stout, chocolate & caramel (longmont, co)

    • Blue Point Toasted Lager

      crisp and clean with a balanced bitterness (patchogue, ny)

    • Lagunitas Pilsner

      czech style lager with refreshing spicy hops (petaluma, ca)

  • Tap Beer $7
    • Mermaid Pilsner

      rich & dark with bready malt

    • Sixpoint Sweet Action Cream Ale

      barley, hops, balance of sweet and bitter

  • Sparkling
    • Prosecco Extra Dry NV $11.00

      ca furlan (veneto)

    • Prosecco Rose 2012 $11.00

      sorelle casa (veneto)

    • Brut Cava NV $10.00

      casas del mar (penedes)

  • Whites
    • Ugni Blanc 2012 $10.00

      domaine de pouy (cotes de gascogne)

    • Gruner Veltliner 2012 $10.00

      forstreiter (austria)

    • Chardonnay 2012 $11.00

      petit chapeau (burgundy)

    • Sancerre 2012 $12.00

      la foret (loire)

    • Chenin Blanc 2011 $12.00

      domaine de la perruche (loire)

  • Rosé
    • Ebling 2012 $10.00

      "rosay" dostert (mosel)

  • Reds
    • Barbera 2011 $10.00

      cascina (piedmont)

    • Pinot Noir 2012 $11.00

      boutinot (languedoc)

    • Grenache 2010 $10.00

      paul jaboulet (rhone)

Menu for The Mermaid Inn provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.