Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • The Comfort Diner

The Comfort Diner

(212) 471-1010

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 25 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10010
  • American ,  Diner
  • The Comfort Diner

  • (212) 471-1010
  • Brunch
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Brunch
    • The All American $4.95

      2 farm fresh eggs cooked any style with hash browns and your choice of loast add bacon ham or sausage for two bucks

    • Country Breakfast $6.95

      2 eggs cooked any style, 2fluffy buttermilk biscuits with white sausage gravy and grits

    • Breakfast Burrito $6.95

      scrambled eggs, triple bean chili, avocado, shredded cheddar, fresh salsa, sour cream all rolled inside peasant bread-burrito style add bacon ham or sausage for two bucks

    • The BBC $7.95

      no, it's not an English television station, it's our most popular omelet, made with bacon, broccoli and cheddar cheese with hash brown and toast

    • Comfort's Healthy Omelet $8.95

      egg whites and grilled vegetable omelet served with sliced tomato and whole grain toast

    • Huevos Rancheros $8.95

      crisp tortilla chips topped with fried eggs, fresh salsa, black beans, jack cheese and sour cream served with grits or hash browns

    • Imagination Omelet $8.95

      let your imagination run wild! add up to 3 of the following to fill your omelet: ham, bacon, mushrooms, triple bean chili, spinach, onions, peppers or any of our great cheeses

    • Red Flannel Hash $8.95

      homemade corned beef hash made with sweet potato and roasted beets with poached eggs and toast

    • Eggs Benedict Sandy's Way $8.95

      poached eggs on toasted English muffin halves with American bacon and hollandaise sauce

    • Smoked salmon Benedict $10.95

    • The Leo (Lox, Eggs and Onions) $9.95

      3 scrambled eggs with smoked salmon and caramelized onions with hash browns and toast

    • Steak and Eggs $13.95

      grilled black angus steak, 2 eggs any style, hash browns and toast

  • Sides
    • Half a Grapefruit $1.95

    • Hash Browns or Grits $1.95

    • Half a Melon or Fresh Fruit Cup $2.95

    • Bacon, Ham or Sausage $2.95

    • Red Flannel Hash $4.95

  • Pancakes, Waffles French Toast and More
    we serve 100% maple syrup-grade A amber
    • Belgian Waffle $6.50

    • Big Buttermilk Pancakes $6.95

      made from scratch of course! for a buck fifty add toasted pecans, bananas, strawberries or blueberries

    • Big Bread Challah French Toast $7.50

    • Blueberry Lemon Ricotta Pancakes $7.95

    • Berry Stuffed French Toast $8.95

      we cut a pocked in our thick challah bread and overstuff it with juicy berries for good measure we pile more on top

    • Banana Hazelnut French Toast $8.95

      with this version of our stuffed French toast we load it up with sliced bananas and toasted hazelnuts and of course we add more on top!

    • Red, White and Blue Waffle $8.95

      we just love piling fruit on top of things this time it's one of our big Belgian waffles that gets the treatment and it's strawberries, bananas and blueberries that provide the treat!

    • The Lumberjack $10.95

      2 buttermilk pancakes, 2 eggs any style and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage

    • The New Yorker $11.95

      a toasted bagel with smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, capers and red onion

  • Coffee and Other Good Things to Drink
    • Coffee or Tea $2.25

    • Hot Chocolate $2.75

    • Espresso $2.95

    • Cappuccino or Latte $3.95

    • Freshly Squeezed Orange or Grapefruit Juice $2.95+

    • Cranberry, Pineapple or Tomato Juice $2.50+

    • A Tall Glass of Lemonade $3.00

    • Strawberry Lemonade $3.50

    • Sandy's Fruit and Yogurt or Susie's Fruit and Sorbet Smoothie $4.50

  • Sandwiches
    all of our sandwiches are served with homemade coleslaw and a great pickle for $1.95 more, order a deluxe and we'll add hand cut Idaho or sweet potato to your plate
    • Grilled Cheese $6.50

      no designer cheeses here-just good old-fashioned grilled American cheese with tomato on us with bacon add a buck

    • BLT $7.50

      Thick cut bacon, ripe tomato, red leaf lettuce and mayo on toasted whole grain bread

    • Mediterranean Melt $8.50

      goat cheese, oven-roasted tomatoes and pesto-grilled on rosemary bread

    • Retro Turkey Sandwich $8.95

      remember this one from the 80's? roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, avocado, sprouts, tomato and honey mustard on whole grain

    • Grilled Chicken Club $8.95

      a triple-decker with grilled chicken, bacon, red leaf lettuce, ripe tomato and mayo

    • Classic Tuna Melt $8.95

      solid white tuna salad, tomato and melted cheese served on a toasted English muffin

    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $8.95

      crispy chicken breast toasted with spicy buffalo wing sauce served with lettuce, tomato, shredded carrot and bleu cheese dressing on a hero roll

    • Pulled BBQ Pork $8.95

      slow cooked bbq pork on a soft bun with cheddar and caramelized onions melt in your mouth delicious

    • Southwestern Chicken Wrap $8.95

      Grilled Chicken, avocado, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and chipotle Mayo in a black bean wrap

    • Philly Cheese Steak $9.95

      thinly sliced top round, loads of sauteed mushrooms, onions and cheese whiz, provolone or American Cheese on a hero roll

    • Maine Crab Burger $12.95

      a great crab cake served on a big bun with sweet potato French fries, zippy homemade tartar sauce and creamy coleslaw

    • Comfort Burger (Beef, Buffalo, Turkey or Veggie) $7.95

      a delicious half-pound broiled to perfection and placed on a comfortable bun make it cheeseburger add one dollar

    • Imagination Burger $9.95

      let your imagination run wild choose and or all of these to top your burger: bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions, avocado, cheddar, provolone, Swiss, mozzarella, blue cheese or vegetarian chili

  • Large Plates
    • A Large Caesar Salad $7.95

      hearts of Romaine, shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious Caesar dressing add grilled chicken or portobello mushroom for 3 bucks grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Pear and Gorgonzola Salad $9.95

      mixed greens, pears, gorgonzola, pistachios, grapes and dried cranberries tossed with raspberry vinaigrette; add grilled chicken for 3 bucks grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Warm Taco Salad $10.95

      seasoned ground beef, cheddar, fresh salsa, sour cream and tortilla chips atop shredded lettuce; new available with seasoned shredded chicken breast!

    • Pistachio Chicken Salad (Low Carb) $11.95

      pistachio crusted seared chicken breast, grilled asparagus and cherry tomatoes tossed with Romaine lettuce and avocado lime dressing

    • Comfort Diner Chicken Salad $11.95

      grilled chicken breast with oven roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, chickpeas and warm goat cheese atop balsamic vinaigrette tossed greens

    • Macaroni and cheese $8.95

      macaroni and a yummy blend of cheese baked with a crunchy golden top

    • A Bowl of Vegetarian Chili $8.95

      a hearty helping of our chili topped with cheddar, sour cream, fresh salsa and crisp corn tortilla chips

    • Chili Mac $8.95

      we top half an order of our mac and cheese with half an order of our vegetarian chili-it's a great combo!; make it chili mac con came-we add seasoned ground beef-for two bucks more

    • Soft Shell Chicken Tacos $11.95

      two soft tortillas filled with chicken, shredded lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded pepper jack cheese served with black beans, Spanish rice and guacamole

    • Thanksgiving Every Day $11.95

      talk about comfort food1 roasted turkey breast stuffing, mashed potatoes with gravy, homemade cranberry sauce and fresh veggies you will thank us!

    • Chicken Fried Chicken $11.95

      chicken breast dusted in seasoned flour and pan fried until nice 'n' crispy with roast garlic mashed potatoes, lumpy cream gravy and collard greens

    • Brinley's Lemon Chicken $11.95

      seared chicken breast served with sauteed mushrooms, a lusciously light lemon pansauce, jasmine rice and the vegetable of the day

    • Oven Crisped Fish and Chips $12.95

      we top a fillet of fish with seasoned bread crumbs and cut Idaho potatoes into nice thick wedges then we bake both until they get nice and crispy and serve it to you with homemade tartar sauce coleslaw and malt vinegar

    • Mom's Meatloaf (on Her Best Day) $11.95

      with caramelized onion and mushroom gravy, roast garlic mashed potatoes and today's vegetable

  • Small Plates
    • A Nice Bowl of soup $4.95

    • Grandma's Chicken Soup $4.95

      loaded with chicken, carrots, celery and noodles yum!

    • A Nice Green Salad $4.95

      with tomato, cucumber and red onion our dressing choices: house vinaigrette, bleu cheese, thousand Island, ranch, avocado lime or citrus vinaigrette

    • Caesar Salad $4.95

      hearts of Romaine, shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious Caesar dressing

    • Maple Fries $4.95

      our delicious sweet potato fries served with on equally delicious maple dipping sauce

    • A Cup of Vegetarian Chili $4.95

      with shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream, house made salsa and crisp tortilla chips

    • Wild Mushroom Potato Pancakes $5.95

      with our homemade chunky applesauce and sour cream

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.95

      made here mozzarella wedges, battered, fried and served with marinara sauce

    • Potato Skins $5.95

      baked and stuffed with bacon and cheddar then topped with a dollop of sour cream; add our vegetarian chili for $2.00

    • Buffalo Chicken Wings $6.95

      spicy wings with bleu cheese dressing, carrot and celery sticks

    • Grilled Chicken Skewers $6.95

      marinated chicken breast grilled and served with honey mustard or barbecue dipping sauce and mixed greens

    • Comfort Quesadilla $6.95

      loaded with pepper jack cheese and black beans topped with fresh salsa and sour cream add avocado for a buck, chicken for three or grilled shrimp for four

    • Sliders- (Mini Burgers) $12.95

      six delicious 2 ounce burgers with lettuce and tomato on brioche rolls; make it a dozen for $19.95

  • Sandwiches
    all of our sandwiches are served with homemade coleslaw and a great pickle for $1.95 more, order a deluxe and we'll add hand cut Idaho or sweet potato French fries, roast garlic or mashed potatoes, rice or steamed broccoli to your plate
    • Grilled Cheese $6.50

      no designer cheeses here-just good old-fashioned grilled American cheese; with tomato on us with bacon add one dollar

    • BLT $7.50

      thick bacon, ripe tomato, lettuce and mayo on toasted whole grain bread

    • Mediterranean Melt $8.50

      goat cheese, oven- roasted tomatoes and pesto- grilled on rosemary bread

    • Retro Turkey Sandwich $8.95

      remember this one from the 80's? roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, avocado, sprouts, tomato and honey mustard on whole grain

    • Grilled Chicken Club $8.95

      a triple-decker with grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, ripe tomato and mayo

    • Classic Tuna Melt $8.95

      solid white tuna salad, tomato and melted cheese served on a toasted English muffin

    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $8.95

      crispy chicken breast tossed with spicy buffalo wing sauce served with lettuce, tomato, shredded carrot and bleu cheese dressing on a hero roll

    • Pulled BBQ Pork $8.95

      slow cooked bbq pork on a soft bun with cheddar and caramelized onions melt in your mouth delicious

    • Southwestern Chicken Wrap $8.95

      grilled chicken, avocado, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo in black bean wrap

    • Philly Cheese Steak $9.95

      thinly sliced top round, loads of sauteed mushrooms, onions and cheese whiz, provolone or American cheese on a hero roll

    • Comfort Burger (Beef, Buffalo, Turkey or Veggie) $7.95

      a delicious half- Pound broiled to perfection and placed on a comfortable bun make it a cheeseburger add one dollar

    • Imagination Burger $9.95

      let your imagination run wild choose any or all of these to top your burger bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions, avocado, cheddar, provolone, Swiss, mozzarella, bleu cheese or vegetarian chili

  • Large Plates
    • A Large Caesar Salad $7.95

      Romaine, shredded Parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious Caesar dressing; add grilled chicken or portobello mushroom for 3 bucks grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Pear and Gorgonzola Salad $9.95

      mixed greens, pears, gorgonzola, pistachios, grapes and dried cranberries tossed with raspberry vinaigrette; add grilled chicken for 3 bucks grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Warm Taco Salad $10.95

      ground beef, shredded cheddar, salsa, sour cream and tortilla chips atop shredded lettuce; new now available with seasoned shredded chicken breast!

    • Pistachio Chicken Salad (Low Carb) $11.95

      pistachio crusted chicken breast, asparagus and cherry tomatoes tossed with Romaine and avocado lime dressing

    • Comfort Diner Grilled Chicken Salad $11.95

      grilled chicken breast with oven roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, chickpeas and warm goat cheese atop balsamic vinaigrette tossed greens

    • Macaroni and Cheese $8.95

      macaroni and a yummy blend of cheese baked with a crunchy golden top

    • A Big Bowl of Vegetarian Chili $8.95

      a hearty, healthy helping of our chili topped with cheddar, sour cream, fresh salsa and crisp corn tortilla chips

    • Chili Mac $8.95

      we top half an order of our mac and cheese with half and order of our vegetarian chili- it's o great combo!; make it chili mac con carne-we add seasoned ground beef- for two bucks more

    • Spinach and Ricotta Ravioli $10.95

      served with homemade marinara sauce and shaved parmesan

    • Grilled Soft Shell Chicken Tacos $11.95

      two soft tortillas filled with chicken, chopped lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded pepper jack cheese, served with black beans, Spanish rice and guacamole

    • Thanksgiving Every Day $11.95

      talk about comfort food roasted turkey breast, stuffing, mashed potatoes with gravy, homemade cranberry sauce and fresh veggies, you will thanks us!

    • Mom's Meatloaf (On Her Best Day) $11.95

      with caramelized onion and mushrooms gravy, roast garlic mashed potatoes and today's vegetable.

    • Chicken Fried Chicken $11.95

      chicken breast dusted in seasoned flour and pan fried until nice 'n' crispy, with a heap of roast garlic mashed potatoes, lumpy cream gravy and collard greens

    • Brinley's Lemon Chicken $11.95

      seared chicken breast served with sauteed mushrooms, a lovely light lemon pan sauce, jasmine rice and the vegetable of the day

    • Pecan Crusted Catfish $12.95

      drizzled with garlic lime butter and served with mashed sweet potatoes and collard greens

    • Honey Dipt Southern Fried Chicken $12.95

      with mac and cheese and collard greens

    • Gulf Coast Jambalaya $13.95

      chicken, shrimp and choriza sausage cooked in a spicy combo of rice, tomatoes, peppers, celery and onions

    • Oven Crisped Fish and Chips $13.95

      if you love fish and chips but are afraid of the fryer, this version if for you, we top scrod fillet with seasoned bread crumbs and cut Idaho potatoes into nice thick wedges, then we bake both until they get nice and crispy and served if to you with home made tartar sauce, coleslaw and malt vinegar

    • Herb Crusted Salmon (Low Carb) $14.95

      pan seared and served with steamed broccoli and 'mock' mashed potatoes

  • Small Plates
    • A Nice Bowl of Soup $4.95

    • Grandma's Chicken Soup $4.95

      loaded with chicken, carrots, celery and noodles, yum!

    • A Nice Green Salad $4.95

      with tomato, cucumber and red onion, our dressing choices; house vinaigrette, bleu cheese, Thousand Island, Ranch, avocado lime or citrus vinaigrette

    • Caesar Salad $4.95

      hearts of romaine, shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing

    • Maple Fries $4.95

      our delicious sweet potato fries served with an equally delicious maple dipping sauce

    • A Cup of Vegetarian Chiu $4.95

      with shredded cheddar cheese, sour cream, house made salsa and crisp tortilla chips

    • Wild Mushroom Potato Pancakes $5.95

      with our homemade chunky applesauce and sour cream

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.95

      made here mozzarella wedges, battered, fried and served with marinara sauce

    • Potato Skins $5.95

      baked and stuffed with bacon and cheddar then topped with a dollop of sour cream add our vegetarian chili for $2.00

    • Buffalo Chicken Wings $6.95

      spicy wings with bleu cheese dressing, carrot and celery sticks

    • Grilled Chicken Skewers $6.95

      marinated chicken breast grilled and served with honey mustard or barbecue dipping sauce and mixed greens

    • Comfort Quesadilla $6.95

      loaded with pepper jack cheese and black beans, topped with fresh salsa and sour cream add avocado for a buck, chicken for two or grilled shrimp for three

    • Suders (Mini Burgers) $12.95+

      six delicious 2 ounce burgers with lettuce and tomato on brioche rolls

  • Sandwiches
    all of our sandwiches are served with homemade coleslaw, a great pickle and your choice of hand cut Idaho or sweet potato fries, baked potato, roasted garlic or mock mashed potatoes or steamed broccoli
    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $10.95

      crispy chicken breast tossed with spicy buffalo wing sauce served with lettuce, tomato, shredded carrot and bleu cheese dressing on a hero roll

    • Pulled BBQ Pork $10.95

      slow cooked bbq pork on a soft bun with cheddar and caramelized onions melt in your mouth delicious

    • Philly Cheese Steak $11.95

      thinly sliced top round, loads of sauteed mushrooms, onions and cheese whiz, provolone or American cheese on a hero roll

    • Comfort Burger (Beef, Buffalo, Turkey or Veggie) $9.95

      a delicious half-pound broiled to perfection and placed on a comfortable bun, make it a cheeseburger add one dollar

    • Imagination Burger $11.95

      let your imagination run wild, choose any or all of these to top your burger, bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions, avocado, cheddar, provolone, Swiss, mozzarella, bleu cheese or vegetarian chili

  • Salads
    • A Large Caesar Salad $8.95

      hearts of Romaine, shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing add grilled chicken or portobello mushroom for 3 bucks, grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Pear and Gorgonzola Salad $10.95

      mixed greens, pears, Gorgonzola, pistachios, grapes and dried cranberries tossed with raspberry vinaigrette add grilled chicken or for 3 bucks grilled shrimp for 4 bucks

    • Warm Taco Salad $12.95

      seasoned ground beef, shredded cheddar, fresh salsa, sour cream and tortilla chips all atop shredded lettuce new now available with seasoned shredded chicken

    • Pistachio Chicken Salad (Low Carb) $13.95

      pistachio crusted seared chicken breast, grilled asparagus and cherry tomatoes tossed with Romaine lettuce and avocado lime dressing

    • Comfort Diner Grilled Chicken Salad $13.95

      grilled chicken breast with oven roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, chickpeas and warm goat cheese atop balsamic vinaigrette tossed greens

  • Large Plates
    • Macaroni and Cheese $10.95

      macaroni and a yummy blend of cheese baked with a crunchy golden top

    • A Big of Vegetarian Chili $10.95

      a hearty, healthy helping of our chili topped with aged cheddar, sour cream, fresh salsa and crisp corn tortilla chips

    • Chili Mac $10.95

      we top half an order of our mac and cheese with half an order of our vegetarian chili it s a great combo make it chili maccon came we add seasoned ground beef for two bucks more

    • Grilled Soft Shell Chicken Tacos $12.95

      two soft tortillas filled with chicken, chopped lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded pepper jack cheese served with black beans, Spanish rice and guacamole

    • Spinach and Ricotta Ravioli $12.95

      served with homemade marinara sauce and shaved parmesan

    • Comforting Chicken Pot Pie $12.95

      savory chunks of chicken, carrots, celery, potatoes and peas in a velvety cream sauce baked with a flaky crust, it doesn't get better than this

    • Chicken Fried Chicken $13.95

      chicken breast dusted in seasoned flour and pan fried until nice 'n' crispy with a heap of roast garlic mashed potatoes, lumpy cream gravy and collard greens

    • Thanksgiving Every Day $13.95

      talk about comfort food roasted turkey breast, stuffing, mashed potatoes with gravy, homemade cranberry sauce and fresh veggies, you will thank us

    • Brinley's Lemon Chicken $13.95

      seared chicken breast served with sauteed mushrooms, a lovely light lemon pan sauce, jasmine rice and the vegetable of the day

    • Honey Dipt Southern Fried Chicken $13.95

      with mac and cheese and collard greens

    • Mom's Meatloaf (On Her Beset Day) $13.95

      with caramelized onion and mushroom gravy, roast garlic mashed potatoes and today's vegetable,

    • Pecan Crusted Catfish $14.95

      drizzled with garlic lime butter and served with mashed sweet potatoes and collard greens

    • Oven Crisped Fish and Chips $14.95

      if you love fish and chips but are afraid of the fryer, this version if for you, we top scrod fillet with seasoned bread crumbs and cut Idaho potatoes into nice thick wedges, then we bake both until they get nice and crispy and serve it to you with home made tartar sauce, coleslaw and malt vinegar

    • Gulf Coast Jambalaya $15.95

      chicken, shrimp and chorizo sausage cooked in a spicy combo of rice, tomatoes, peppers, celery and onions

    • Herb Crusted Salmon (Low Carb) $15.95

      pan seared and served with steamed broccoli and 'mock' mashed potatoes

    • Crab Cakes $16.95

      two crab cakes, pan seared and served with angel hair pasta and home made marinara sauce

    • Black Angus Stead and Potatoes $18.95

      certified angus steak served with oven roasted potatoes and today's vegetable

Menu for The Comfort Diner provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.