Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • Shaffer City

Shaffer City

(212) 255-9827

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 5 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010
  • Restaurant website
  • American
  • Shaffer City

  • (212) 255-9827
  • Menu
  • On a Bed of Ice
    • Selected Atlantic $2.00

    • Atlantic $2.50

    • Pacific $2.50

    • Long Island Little Neck Clams $2.00

    • Cherrystone Clams $2.00

    • Fruit De Mer Platter $55.00+

  • Smaller Dishes
    • Crabcakes $16.00

      pan roasted over black bean and corn salsa

    • Steamed Mussels $16.00

      PEI mussels in white wine, garlic and black pepper broth

    • Chilled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $15.00

    • Shrimp Dumplings $12.00

      with coconut curry thai sauce

    • Fried Oyster $18.00

      with creamed spinach and chipotle sauce

    • Twin Tartares $14.00

      salmon and tuna with pita chips

    • Fried Calamari $10.00

    • Chilled Shrimp Cocktail $15.00

    • Twin Tartares Salmon and Tuna $14.00

      pita chips

    • Shrimp Dumplings $12.00

      with a curried thai sauce

    • Fried Calamari $10.00

      with calabresse and remoulate sauces

    • Fried Oysters $18.00

      with creamed spinach and chipotle aioli

    • Pan Seared Crabcakes $16.00

      with roasted corn salsa and a tomatillo sauce

  • Soups And Salads
    • Oyster Po Boy $21.00

      with coleslaw and chipotle sauce

    • Fried Shrimp Roll $18.00

    • Soup du Jour $6.00+

    • New England Clam Chowder $4.00+

    • House Mixed Baby Green Salad $7.00

      roasted shallot and herb vinaigrette

    • Baby Romaine Caesar Salad $8.00

      with 7 grain croutons and anchovy filet

    • Pan Seared Salmon Burger $16.00

      with sauce remoulade

    • Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich $15.00

    • Shaffer City Steak Burger $14.00

    • Soup du Jour

    • New England Clam Chowder $6.50

    • PEI Mussels $12.00

      with black pepper herb garlic white wine broth

    • Mixed Organic Baby Greens $7.00

      roasted shallot and herb vinaigrette

    • Caesar Salad $8.00

      7 grain croutons and anchovy filet

  • Big Dishes
    • Salmon $24.00

      blackened salmon chickpeas olives tomatoes tzatziki

    • Skate En Papillote $22.00

      steamed in paper with lemon rice summer squash and asian chili sauce

    • Asian Glazed Shrimp $21.00

      vegetable soba noodle lo mein

    • Seasonal Fish Du Jour $22.00

    • Pasta du Jour $19.00

    • Tuna Nicoise $26.00

      mustard vinaigrette, haricots verts, nicoise olives and romaine lettuce

    • Steak Frites $28.00

    • Pan Roasted Diver Scallops $28.00

      summer squash ragout with truffle cream and bacon

    • Salmon $27.00

      grilled salmon chickpeas tomatoes olives and tzatziki sauce

    • Pan Seared Yellow Fin Tuna $30.00

      wasabi mashed potatoes French beans and orange coriander

    • Steak au Poivre $34.00

      grilled herb potatoes grilled asparagus and steak sauce

    • Pan Roasted Day Boat Monkfish $28.00

      red lentils sauteed leeks and carrots in caper butter sauce

    • Red Snapper $32.00

      white beans and bacon asparagus tomato confit and sauce choron

    • Wild Stripped Bass $29.00

      crispy polenta cake roasted peppers and fennel

    • Skate En Papillote $26.00

      steamed in paper sriracha asian chili rubbed pineapple lemon rice and summer squash

    • Garlic and Lemon Shrimp Over Hand Cut Fettucine $27.00

  • Atlantic Oyster Selections
    • Belons - Maine $2.00

      large round shell houses east coast answer to a west coast oyster

    • Blue Point - Connecticut Side of Long Island Sound $2.00

      produces a fairly briny firm fleshed oyster with a sweet and clean finish

    • Blue Islands - Atlantic Side of Long Island $2.00

      similar in taste, texture and size to teh blue points, only slightly more salty

    • Buzzards Bay - Cape Cod, Massachusetts $2.00

      this sweet, crisp and clean oyster should be on every east oyster lover's wish list

    • Canadian Cove, PEI $2.00

      this medium clean, crisp and slightly briny oyster is perfect for your first timers

    • Cape Ann - Nova Scotia, Canada $2.00

      classically salty medium oyster with sweet crisp finish

    • Falmouth - Rhode Island $2.00

      from teh waters off of providence comes these slightly sweet and briny treasures

    • French Hooter - PEI Canada $2.00

      clean and salty medium oyster a favorite for any east coast oyster fan (gotta luv the name)

    • Malpeque - PEI, Canada $2.00

      easiest oysters to eat, light in flavor and texture with a sweet mild finish

    • Martha Vineyard - Cape Cod, Massachusetts $2.00

      medium sized sweet, mild and slightly briny with a slightly coppery finish

    • Narragansettes - Connecticut $2.00

      medium oyster with classic east coast salty finish

    • Pemaquid - Pemaquid Bay, Maine $2.00

      firm, sweet and a hint of cucumber at the end

    • Pickle Point - PEI, Canada $2.00

      sweet, salty and crisp another PEI winner

    • Peconic Bay, Long Island $2.00

      small long Island Oyster, sweet, mild and a bit briny

    • Shaffer Cove, Long Island $2.00

      created by us for you and it's our very own and it's sweet, crisp and salty

    • Tatamagouche, Nova Scotia, Canada $2.00

      this Medium sized clean and crisp oyster ends with a lettuce like finish

    • Wellfleet, Massachusetts $2.00

      one of America's favorite oysters, sweet, crisp and salty

  • Pacific Oyster Selections
    • Cortez Island - British Columbia $2.50

      medium to large pacific cold water oyster with creamy metallic finish

    • Denman Island - British Columbia $2.50

      medium sized, slighty musky and creamy with big pacific briny finish

    • Elkhorn - British Columbia $2.50

      medium to large oyster with creamy briny and slightly exotic finish

    • Fanny Bay - Baynes Sound, B.C. $2.50

      imported from japan these medium sized oysters have a slightly creamy exotic taste

    • Hama Hama - Hama Hama River, Washington State $2.50

      large creamy crisp texture with a touch of brine 'a favorite at shaffer city'

    • Hood Canal - Hood Canal, Washington State $2.50

      large deep cupped oyster with classic west creamy texture and musky finish

    • Kumomoto - Puget Sound Washington $2.50

      originally found in Japan these deep cupped small oysters are intensely flavored

    • Malaspina - Oregon $2.50

      medium sized creamy and succulent, nice change from the strong tastes of Washington

    • Nootka - Oregon $2.50

      deep cupped oyster with sweet liquor, creamy and musky, hama hama's watchout

    • Quilcene - Washington State $2.50

      medium sized musky and classically creamy, hama hama fans will love these babies

    • Pearl Points - Washington State $2.50

      medium sized slightly metallic oyster with classic creamy texture and slight muskiness

    • Royal Miyagi - Washington State $2.50

      medium sized oyster with a plump creamy richy briny little fella inside

    • Sinku - British Columbia $2.50

      this west coast oyster is slightly metallic and musky in flavor with briny finish

    • Skookums - Washington State $2.50

      west coast winner, creamy metallic finish with smaller oyster inside

    • Snowy Creeek - Oregon $2.50

      similar to elkhorn with characteristic washington state creamy flavor

    • Stranger Bay - California $2.50

      west coast medium sized oyster, slightly briny and musky

    • Whale Points - British Columbia $2.50

      strong musky oyster flavor with briny finish. 'a true west coast oyster lover's delicacy.

Menu for Shaffer City provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.