Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • New York
  • Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

(212) 501-7515

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 428 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
  • Restaurant website
  • American ,  Barbecue
  • Brother Jimmy's BBQ

  • (212) 501-7515
  • Menu
  • Salads
    Dressings: vinaigrette, buttermilk ranch, blue cheese.
    • House Salad $4.95

      Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumber.

    • Charred Chicken Salad $9.25

      Mixed greens w. grilled cihcken.

    • Southern Salad $10.75

      Mixed greens w. cheese, shrimp, sausage & blackened chicken.

    • Chopped Cobb Salad $9.75

      Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled chicken.

  • Stews
    Served w. cornbread.
    • Brunswick Stew $4.75

    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Chili $4.75

    • Red Beans & Rice $4.75

      Add andouille sausage for $1.50.

  • Sandwiches N' Burgers
    W. 1 trimming & pickles, bacon or cheese $1 extra.
    • Blackened Chicken Po'Boy $8.95

      On french bread w. lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo.

    • Shrimp Po'Boy $9.25

      On french bread w. lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo.

    • Grilled Chicken $8.95

    • Fried Chicken $8.95

      Buffalo style or original.

    • Catfish $8.95

      Fried, grilled or blackened.

    • Hamburger $7.95

    • Chili Burger $8.95

    • BBQ Burger $8.95

      W. fried onions.

  • Ribs
    St. Louis style ribs. W. 2 trimmings, cornbread & pickles.
    • Northern Style $17.95

      Sweet & tender, falls off bone.

    • Southern Style $17.95

      Smoked 5 hours, spicy & tart, firmer than northern.

    • Brother Jimmy's Dry Rub Ribs $17.95

      Made w. 21 spices, tastes like a great piece of country sausage, spicy!

    • Combo Rib Platters $17.95

      Your choice of 2 different styles or a "lil' of each."

    • BBQ Sampler Platter $21.95

      Choose any 4 bbq items & 1 trimming.

  • BBQ Dinners
    W. 2 trimmings, cornbread & pickles.
    • 1/2 BBQ Chicken $12.95

    • BBQ Chicken & Ribs $16.95

      1/4 BBQ chicken & 3 ribs either northern, southern or dry rub.

    • Pulled Pork $13.95

      North or south carolina style.

    • Sliced Brisket $13.95

    • Chopped Brisket $13.95

      Burnt ends.

  • BBQ Sandwiches
    W. 1 trimming & pickles. coleslaw $.50 extra.
    • Pulled P

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $8.25

      North or south carolina style.

    • Pulled Chicken $7.75

      Original BBQ sauce.

    • Sliced Brisket $8.75

      Original BBQ sauce.

    • Chopped Brisket $8.75

      Burnt ends, original BBQ sauce.

  • Standards
    W. 2 trimmings, cornbread & pickles.
    • Catfish $12.95

      Fried, grilled or blackened.

    • Chicken Fried Steak $13.95

      W. gravy.

    • Cider Glazed Pork Chop $14.95

    • Fried Chicken Dinner $12.95

    • The Nag's Head Veggie $10.95

      Fresh seasoned & grilled veg.

  • Trimmings
    4 for $10.50.
    • BBQ Baked Beans $3.50

    • Black Eyed Peas $3.50

    • Candied Yams w. Walnuts $3.50

    • Collard Greens $3.50

    • Corn on the Cob $3.50

    • French Fries $3.50

    • Fire Fries $3.50

    • Macaroni & Cheese $3.50

    • Mashed Potatoes w. Gravy $3.50

    • Potato Salad $3.50

    • String Beans $3.50

    • Cole Slaw $3.50

    • Biscuits & Gravy $3.50

  • Desserts
    • Pecan Pie $5.00

    • Mississippi Mud Cake $5.00

    • Key Lime Pie $5.00

    • Banana Cream Pie $5.00

    • Apple Crumb Pie $5.00

  • Beginnings
    • Hush Puppies $5.25

      W. maple butter.

    • Fried Green Tomatoes $6.75

    • Fried Okra $6.95

      W. spicy dipping sauce.

    • Onion Straws $6.25

    • Spinach & Artichoke Dip $7.95

      Served hot w. chips.

    • Corn Fritters $5.75

    • Frickles $5.95

      Fried pickles w. horseradish sauce.

    • Rib Tips $7.50

      Northern style.

    • Bucket O' Tips $12.95

    • Hot Wings $8.25

      Buffalo style, chipotle bbq or mustard. W. blue cheese & celery, additional blue cheese $.50 extra.

    • Bucket O' Hot Wings $14.95

    • BBQ Wings $8.95

    • Quesadilla $8.50

      W. salsa & sour cream, pulled pork or grilled chicken.

    • Stuffed Jalapenos $7.25

      W. shrimp & cheese.

    • Peel & Eat Shrimp $10.95

      W. lemon & old bay.

    • Popcorn Shrimp $8.50

      W. cajun mayo.

    • Brother Jimmy's BBQ Nachos $9.50

      Chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole.

    • Chicken Fingers $7.95

      Original or buffalo style.

    • Flaming Pig Pick $15.95

      Rib tips, bbq wings, pulled pork, hush puppies, onion straws.

  • Beverages
    • Coke, Diet Coke, Ginger Ale & Sprite $2.50

    • Bottled Water $2.25

    • Boylan's Soda $2.50

      Root beer, diet root beer, cream, black cherry, orange, grape.

    • Homemade Iced Tea, Lemonade, Raspberry Lemonade $2.50

    • Southern Sweet Tea $2.50

      A southern standard made in-house.

Menu for Brother Jimmy's BBQ provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.