• New York
  • New York City
  • 72nd Eatery

72nd Eatery

(212) 721-7800
  • 261 Columbus Ave, New York City, NY 10023
  • Deli Food ,  Pizza ,  Sandwiches
  • $$$$$
  • Seamless.com
  • Menu
  • Personal Pie (10")
    • Cheese $11.95

    • Margherita $11.95

    • Pepperoni $12.95

    • Buffalo Chicken $12.95

    • BBQ Chicken $12.95

    • Chicken, Bacon & Ranch $12.95

    • Sausage, Peppers & Onions $12.95

    • White Broccoli $12.95

    • Meatlovers $12.95

    • Veggie Lovers $11.95

    • Jalapeno sausage $12.95

  • Whole Pie(18")
    • Cheese $21

    • Margherita $27

    • Pepperoni $27

    • Buffalo Chicken $30

    • BBQ Chicken $30

    • Chicken, Bacon & Ranch $35

    • Sausage, Peppers & Onions $35

    • White Broccoli $35

    • Meatlovers $39

    • Veggie Lovers $30

    • Jalapeno Sausage $35

  • Hearty Breakfast
    Start the day right
    • Egg Sandwich $5.95

      2 Eggs (any style) Add cheese or meat

    • 2 Eggs on a Roll Sandwich $5.5

    • 2 Eggs with Meat on a Roll Sandwich $7.5

      Choose bacon, ham or sausage.

    • 2 Eggs with Meat on a Roll Sandwich $7.5

      Choose bacon, ham or sausage.

    • 2 Eggs with Cheese on a Roll Sandwich $5.5

    • 2 Eggs with Cheese on a Roll Sandwich $6.5

    • Egg Platter $8.95

      2 Eggs served with Potatoes and Toast Add Bacon, Ham or Sausage

    • 2 Eggs Platter $6.25

      Served any style. Includes potatoes and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Meat Platter $7.95

      Served any style. Includes potatoes and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Meat Platter $8.95

      Served any style. Includes potatoes and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Meat Platter $6.95

      Eggs served any style with bacon, ham or sausage. Includes potatoes and toast.

    • 2 Eggs with Meat Platter $7.95

      Eggs served any style with bacon, ham or sausage. Includes potatoes and toast.

    • Egg White Wraps $10.95

      On Whole Wheat, Spinach, Sun Dried Tomato, or White Flour Wrap

    • Omelette Platter (3 Eggs) $11.95

      Cheese, Western, Meat Lovers, Greek, California, Garden, Florentine, or Lox

    • Create Your Own Omelette Platter (3 Eggs) $11.95

      Choose Any Three Toppings

    • Cinnamon Challah French Toast $8.95

    • Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes $8.95

    • Hot Oatmeal $5.5

      Includes 3 toppings. Add extra toppings for an additional charge.

    • Fresh Fruit Salad $6.95

      Seasonal fruits and melon with mixed berries.

    • Grilled cheese with French fries $10.95

  • Egg White Wraps
    Choice of wrap: whole wheal, spinach, sun-dried tomato, plain white flour.
    • Western Wrap $9.95

      Onions, peppers and ham.

    • Meat Lovers Wrap $9.95

      Bacon, ham or sausage.

    • Greek Wrap $9.95

      Feta cheese and tomatoes.

    • California Wrap $9.95

      Mushrooms, tomatoes, low-fat cheese.

    • Garden Wrap $9.95

      Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms.

    • Florentine Wrap $9.95

      Fresh spinach, tomatoes and feta cheese.

  • Omelettes
    All omelettes are made with 2 eggs. Add extras and side of home fries for an additional charge.
    • Cheese Omelette $9.95

      American or Swiss.

    • Western Omelette $11.95

      Onions, peppers and ham.

    • Meat Lovers Omelette $11.95

      Bacon, ham, sausage.

    • Greek Omelette $11.95

      Feta cheese and tomatoes.

    • California Omelette $11.95

      Mushrooms, tomatoes and low-fat cheese.

    • Garden Omelette $11.95

      Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms.

    • Florentine Omelette $11.95

      Spinach, tomatoes and feta cheese.

    • Lox Omelette $11.95

      Onion and scallion.

  • Freshly Baked Bagels
    Plain, onion, everything, poppy, cinnamon raisin, sesame, pumpernickel, whole wheat, multi-grain.
    • Plain Bagel $1.75

    • Butter Bagel $1.95

    • Jelly Bagel $1.95

    • Peanut Butter Bagel $3.95

    • Cream Cheese $3.25

    • Lox Spread $4.95

    • Vegetable Cream Cheese Bagel $3.25

    • Scallion Cream Cheese Bagel $3.25

    • Smoked Norwegian Salmon with Cream Cheese Bagel $16.95

  • Organic Rotisserie Chicken
    • Organic Rotisserie Chicken with sides

      Comes with 2 Sides

  • Your Favorite Sandwiches
    • Our New York Signature Sandwich $14.95

      Lean steamed corned beef or pastrami sliced to order and piled high on Jewish rye bread. Served with Gulden's deli mustard, coleslaw and kosher pickles.

    • Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich $12.95

      Muenster cheese, arugula, tomatoes, sliced apples and Dijonnaise dressing on ciabatta.

    • Applewood Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich $12.95

      Brie cheese, honey mustard, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a crispy Parisian baguette.

    • Pico de Gallo Chicken Sandwich $12.95

      Grilled chicken, cheddar, avocado, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo on sourdough.

    • Turkey Avocado Sandwich $12.95

      Turkey breast, avocado, lettuce, tomato, herb mayo on sourdough.

    • Traditional Tuna Salad Sandwich $12.95

      White albacore tuna tossed with mayonnaise and celery, topped with oven roasted red peppers, plum tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a whole grain baguette.

    • California Turkey Pita Sandwich $12.95

      Smoked turkey with avocado, tomato, sprouts, cucumber and lemon herb dressing on a low-fat and low-cal whole wheat pita bread.

    • All Natural Turkey Pita Sandwich $12.95

      Smoked turkey, tomatoes, organic mesclun and low-fat mayo on a whole wheat pita. Low-cal.

    • Tuna Pita Sandwich $12.95

      White albacore tuna salad, sliced tomatoes and mixed greens on a whole wheat pita. Low-cal.

    • Hickory Smoked Turkey Pita Sandwich $12.95

      Smoked turkey, green leaf lettuce and plum tomato with honey mustard in a pita. Low-cal.

    • Our Gourmet Suggestion Sandwich $14.95

      smoked salmon , cream cheese and black bread

    • Tuna Salad Club Sandwich $12.95

      Albacore tuna salad, sliced hard boiled egg, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast.

    • Chicken Salad Club Sandwich $12.95

      Crispy bacon, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast.

    • Avocado BLT Club Sandwich $12.95

      Fresh ripe avocado, crispy bacon, plum tomato and green leaf lettuce on white toast with mayonnaise.

  • Panini
    • Smoked Turkey Melt Panini $12.95

      Grilled vegetable ratatouille and pesto mayo with melted Swiss cheese on focaccia.

    • Sierra Turkey Panini $12.95

      Fresh roasted turkey with pepper jack cheese and South Western chipotle sauce on 5-grain bread.

    • Italian Club Panini $12.95

      Turkey, ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, red onions and garlic aioli on Napolitano Italian bread.

    • Chicken Milano Panini $12.95

      Charbroiled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella and pesto mayo on Romano focaccia.

    • Cubano Panini $12.95

      Oven roasted ham, fresh turkey, Swiss cheese, dill pickle chips and Russian dressing on Crespino flatbread.

    • Tuscan Melt Panini $12.95

      Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto mayo on Napoli flatbread.

    • Tuna Melt Panini $12.95

      Our albacore tuna salad with roasted red peppers and American cheese on 5-grain whole wheat flatbread.

    • Grilled Chicken Tijuana Panini $12.95

      Mexican grilled chicken breast, chipotle BBQ sauce, grilled pepperd and onions with Monterey Jack cheese on rustic focaccia.

    • Baked Chicken Parmigiana Panini $12.95

      Tender chicken cutlet, breaded and oven-baked with our fresh homemade marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese and 7 fresh basil in an Italian hero.

    • Turkey Bacon Guacamole Panini $12.95

      Real turkey breast, crispy smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, guacamole and ranch dressing in a sourdough panini.

    • Chicken Italiano Panini $12.95

      Grilled chicken breast, fresh mozzarella cheese, lemon roasted garlic spread, caramelized onions and sweet peppers.

    • Chicken Panini with can soda free and combo $13.95

  • Burgers
    Add cheese, mushroom, caramelized onion, bacon and avocado for an additional charge.
    • Burger Deluxe $15.95

      Served with our steak fries, lettuce, tomato, sliced red onion and kosher dill pickle.

    • Hickory BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger $17.95

      Unforgettable! Our great burger grilled with our special hickory BBQ sauce smothered with caramelized onions and topped with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese. Served with steak fries.

    • Santa Fe Burger $17.95

      Think tex-mex our burger with chipotle sauce, crispy bacon, pepper jack cheese and salsa. Served with spicy steak fries.

    • Turkey Burger $17.95

      Our turkey burger seasoned and drilled perfectly. Served topped with avocado, pico de gallo, provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun. Served with steak fries.

    • Veggie Burger $15.95

      Our chef's homemade vegetarian delight. Served on toasted multi-grain baguette with pesto sauce, lettuce and tomato. Served with your choice of steak fries or grilled vegetable.

    • Mexican Burger $16.95

      Our chef's homemade Mexican style beef burger, served with pico de gallo, guacamole, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickle. Served with spicy steak fries.

    • Beef, Turkey, or Veggie Burger $10.95

      Severed with lettuce & tomato

    • Cheese burger Deluxe $16.95

  • From Our Grill
    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.95

    • Grilled Cheese with Bacon Sandwich $6.95

    • Grilled Cheese with Ham Sandwich $6.95

    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Steak Fries $10.95

    • Reuben Sandwich $14.95

      Corned beef or fresh turkey, served open face with sauerkraut and melted Swiss on Jewish rye bread.

    • Tuna Melt Sandwich $12.95

      Our albacore tuna salad served open face with melted American or Swiss on white bread.

    • Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich $12.95

      Prime roast beef, grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions and melted cheese on a semolina hero.

    • Grilled Chicken Deluxe Sandwich $15.95

      Served on a toasted seeded bun with lettuce, tomatoes and crispy stick fries.

    • Fish Fillet on Sole Deluxe Sandwich $16.95

      Served on a toasted seeded bun, with lettuce, tomatoes and tartar sauce and crispy fries.

    • Crispy Chicken Fingers $16.95

      Served with sweet potato fries, BBQ sauce and our homemade honey mustard sauce.

    • Louisiana Hot Chicken Wings $16.95

      Served with steak fries and Maytag blue cheese dressing.

    • Kebab $16.95

      Charcoal broiled chunks of chicken kebab over rice with BBQ sauce or lemon juice.

  • Pastry, Cookies and Bars
    Available in whole wheat.
    • Muffin $3.25

      Honey raisin bran, orange cranberry, old fashioned blueberry, banana walnut, chocolate chip, corn.

    • Fat-Free Muffin $3.25

      High fiber bran, blueberry, triple berry, corn.

    • Croissant $3.25

      Plain, filled with chocolate, apple, almonds.

    • Danishes $4.25

      Cinnamon, raisins, cheese, apple turnover.

    • Cinnamon Bun $4.25

    • Yogurt Loaf $4.25

      Banana walnut, lemon king, double chocolate , marble.

    • Scones $4.25

      Blueberry, chocolate chip, cranberry, raisin.

    • Bars $4.25

    • Cookies $4.25

    • Cheese Cake $7.95

    • Chocolate moose cake $7.95

    • Strawberry cheese Cake $7.95

    • Cup cake $4.95

    • Cannoli $6.95

    • Eclair $6.95

  • Potato Chips
    • Cape Cod Chips $1.95

      Original, 40% reduced fat, BBQ, sea salt and vinegar.

    • Baked Lays Chips $1.95

      Original, sour cream and onion.

    • Doritos Chips $1.95

      Nacho cheese and cool ranch.

    • Veggie Chips $1.95

      Garden veggie straws, rosemary, olive oil.

  • Hot Beverages
    Piping hot.
    • Colombian House Blend

    • Decaf House Blend

    • Flavored Gourmet Coffees

    • Tea

    • Herbal Tea

    • Hot Chocolate

    • Mochaccino

    • Cappuccino

    • Cafe Latte

    • Cafe Au Lait

    • Espresso

  • Cold Beverages
    Ice cold.
    • Freshly Squeezed Juice $4.95

    • Freshly Squeezed Lemonade $2.95

    • Tropicana Orange Juice $2.95

    • Vitamin Water $2.95

      Choose your flavor.

    • Honest Tea $2.95

    • Bottled Water $1.95

    • Snapple $2.95

    • 20 oz. Soda $2.95

    • Gatorade $3.5

    • Vitamin water $3.5

    • Iced coffee

  • Entree Salads
    • Gotham Chopped Salad $13.95

      Chicken breast, country ham, hard-cooked eggs, tomatoes, bacon, cheddar cheese and Swiss cheese over iceberg lettuce.

    • Grilled Chicken over Caesar Salad $13.95

      Grilled breast of chicken over our crisp, refreshing Caesar salad.

    • Southwestern Chicken Salad $13.95

      Slow-roasted Cajun chicken, Santa Fe corn salad and garni over baby organic greens.

    • Oriental Chicken Salad $13.95

      Tender chicken in light ginger sesame dressing with Chinese noodles, oriental vegetables and water chestnuts over house salad. Low fat.

    • Greek Salad $12.95

  • Simply Delicious Wraps
  • Side Salad
    • Tuna Salad $7.95

    • Chicken Salad $7.95

    • Brazilian Chicken $7.95

    • Sun-dried Tomato Pasta Salad $6.95

    • Pesto Pasta Salad $6.95

    • 3 Bean Mango Salad $6.95

    • Lentil Salad $6.95

    • Coleslaw $6.95

    • Potato Salad $6.95

  • Soup
    • Chicken Noodle Soup $8.5

    • Lent Soup $8.5

    • Split Pea Soup $8.5

  • Meat loaf
    • Meat loaf $16.95

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.