Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Montauk
  • John Papas Cafe

John Papas Cafe

(631) 668-1511

Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

Google map
  • 126 S Emerson Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
  • American
  • John Papas Cafe

  • (631) 668-1511
  • Main
  • Breakfast
  • Dinner
  • Starters
    • Soup Of The Day $4.00+

    • Fried Calamari $8.00

    • Dolmades $6.00

      (stuffed grape leaves).

    • Mozzarella Sticks $6.00

      with tomato sauce.

    • Shrimp Cocktail $10.00

    • Feta Saganaki $7.00

    • Chicken Wings $7.00

    • Chicken Fingers $6.50

    • Shrimp Saganaki $12.00

      (dinner)

    • Tzatziki Sauce $4.00

      with toasted pita.

    • Onion Rings $5.00

    • French Fries $3.00+

  • Salads
    • Tossed $6.00

    • Greek $10.00

    • Baby Greek $7.50

    • Country Greek $11.00

      (season)

    • Caesar $8.00

    • Chef $14.00

    • Spinach $9.00

    • Tomato, Cucumber & red onion $9.00

      (season)

    • Grilled chicken over tossed salad $11.00

      with greek dressing.

    • Grilled chicken over greek salad $13.00

    • Baked Potato & Broccoli $10.00

      with tomato & red onion with greek dressing.

    • Scoop Of Chicken Or Tuna Salad $8.00

      on bed of lettuce & tomato.

    • Spinach $9.00

      with mixed nuts, raisins and balsamic-mustard vinaigrette.

    • Tomato & Trimmings $12.00

    • Add Grilled Chicken To Any Salad $5.00

      (excluding greek salad).

    • Add Grilled Shrimp To Any Salad $1.75

      per shrimp (4 minimum).

  • Sandwiches
    Served on pita or hand roll add $1.00. Tomato extra $1.00.
    • Grilled Cheese $5.00

    • Grilled Chicken On A Bun $7.50

    • Chicken Cutlet On A Bun $7.50

    • Fried Fish On A Bun $7.50

    • Bacon, Lettuce & tomato $6.50

    • Ham & Cheese $7.50

    • Egg Salad $6.50

    • Tuna Salad $7.50

    • Melt $8.50

    • Chicken Salad $7.50

    • Turkey $8.50

      (white meat)

    • Roasted Beef $8.50

    • Hot Pastrami $8.50

    • Reuben $10.50

    • Frankfurter $4.00

  • Club Sandwiches
    Served on your choice of white, whole wheat or rye with mayonnaise, cole slaw, potato chips & pickle. You may also have club sandwich on pita or hard roll.
    • Sliced Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce & tomato $12.00

    • Chicken Salad, Bacon, Lettuce & tomato $12.00

    • Roast Beef, Cheese, Lettuce & tomato $12.00

    • Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce & tomato $12.00

    • Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Lettuce & tomato $12.00

    • Ham, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato $12.00

  • Burgers
    Handmade & char - grilled, served with lettuce, tomato & pickle.
    • Hamburger $7.00+

    • Turkey Burger $7.00

      deluxe: french fries & cole slaw add $3.00. with feta melt add $3.00 with swiss cheese & avocado add 3.00.

    • Garden burger $7.00

      with cheese add $3.00.

    • Papas Burger $13.00

      burger on top of a pita bread covered with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, onions, tzatziki sauce and greek dressing.

  • Melts
    Served on garlic bread with fresh fries and cole slaw.
    • Turkey With Mozzarella $12.00

    • Roast Beef With Mozzarella $12.00

    • Tuna Salad Greek Style $13.00

      (tomato & feta)

    • Tuna Salad $12.00

      with american or swiss cheese.

  • Platters & Baskets
    • Fried Chicken $16.00

      1/2 chicken with french fries, salad & garlic bread.

    • Fried Shrimp Platter $16.00

      with french fries, salad, garlic bread & tartar sauce.

    • Fried Clam Platter $13.00

      with french fries, salad, garlic bread and tartar sauce.

    • Fish & Chips $13.00

      with tartar sauce & cole salw.

    • Shrimp In A Basket $12.00

      with french fries, cole slaw & tartar sauce.

    • Chicken Wings Platter $14.50

      with french fries, cole slaw & blue cheese dressing, hot sauce, or bbq.

    • Norwegian Smoked Salmon Platter $14.50

      bagel & cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, capers.

  • Greek Specialties
    Tossed salad nstead of fries $2.00 extra or greek salad $3.00 extra.
    • Moussaka $18.00

      potato, eggplant, meat sauce & bechamel sauce. served with small greek salad & garlic bread.

    • Pastichio $17.00

      baked macaroni with meat sauce & bechamel sauce. served with small greek salad & garlic bread.

    • Spinach Pie $15.00

      spinach, feta & cottage cheese in filo pastry. served with small greek salad & garlic bread.

    • Chicken Souvlaki $12.00

      with lettuce, tomato & onion wrapped in pita bread. served with french fries & "our own" tzatziki sauce.

    • Pork Souvlaki $12.00

      with lettuce, tomato & onion wrapped in pita bread served with french fries & "our own" tzatziki sauce.

    • Beef Gyro $12.00

      with lettuce, tomato, onion wrapped in pita bread. served with french fries & "our own" tzatziki sauce.

    • Shrimp Souvlaki $14.00

      with lettuce, tomato & onion wrapped in pita bread. served with french fries & "our own" tzatziki sauce.

  • Cereals
    • Assorted Cold Cereal With Milk $4.00

    • Hot Instant Oatmeal $4.50

    • Hearty Granola With Milk $5.00

    • Granola With Yogurt $6.50

  • Fresh Fruit
    • Half Grapefruit $3.50

    • Half Melon $5.50

    • Half Melon $7.00

      with cottage cheese.

    • Fruits And Cream $4.50+

    • Juices $2.50+

      orange, apple, tomato, cranberry, grapefruit.

  • Eggs & Omelettes
    Served with home fries (until they're gone-french fries after that) & toast.
    • Eggs $5.50+

      any style, with bacon, suasage, ham or canadian style bacon add $3.50.

    • Eggs Benedict $13.00

      (english muffin, canadian bacon, poached eggs with hollandaise sauce).

    • Omelette $6.50+

    • Pastrami, Ham, Bacon Or Sausage Omelette $10.00

    • Feta Cheese Omelette $10.00

    • Western Omelette $10.00

      (ham, peppers, onion)

    • Spinach, Bacon, Swiss Cheese Omelette $11.00

    • Spinach Omelette $10.00

      (peppers, onion, tomato) with side of salsa

    • California $11.00

      (sliced avocado and swiss cheese).

    • Parthenon $13.00

      (sauteed onions, mushrooms, feta, tomato, calamata olives).

    • Scallion & Swiss Omelette $9.00

    • Farmer's Omelette $13.00

      (ham, bacon, sausage, red & green peppers)

    • Vegetables For Omelette $1.00

      tomato, mushrooms, onions, fresh spinach, bell pepper, broccoli, scallions, asparagus. add cheese to any omelette $2.00 additional.

    • Egg White Omelette $2.00

      additional. substitute for toast: any muffin, hard roll, bagel or pita add $1.50.

  • Pancakes
    • Pancakes $7.00

      with butter & syrup. with ice cream and syrup add $4.00.

    • Blueberry Pancakes $9.00

    • Mixed Fruit Pancakes $11.00

      (blueberries, strawberries, banana).

  • French Toast
    • French Toast $7.00

      with butter & syrup

    • Italian Bread French Toast $8.00

  • Authentic Belgain Waffles
    • Authentic Belgain Waffles $11.00

      with syrup and powdered sugar $8.00. with fresh and cream.

    • Smoked Salmon & Scrambled Eggs $14.00

      served with avocado.

    • Pastrami Eggs $12.00

    • 8 Oz. Black Angus Shell Steak & Eggs $16.00

    • Norwegian Smoked Salmon Platter $14.50

      with bagel, cream cheese, red onions, tomato, lettuce and capers.

  • Breakfast Menu
    Complementary guest breakfast menu of 2008.
    • Assorted Double Pack Cold Cereal

    • Hot Instant Regular Oatmeal

    • Bagel With Cream Cheese

    • Gronola With Milk Or Plain Yogurt

    • Half Of Cantaloupe With Cottage Cheese

    • Fresh Fruit Of The Day With Cream

    • Fresh Fruit Of The Day

      with home fries and toast.

    • Two Eggs, Any Style

      with bacon or sausage, home fries and toast.

    • Plain Omelette

      with home fries and toast.

    • Cheese Omelette

      with home fries and toast.

    • Pancakes

      with butter and syrup.

    • French toast

      with butter and syrup.

    • Authentic Belgian Waffle

      with syrup and powdered sugar.

    • Two Eggs With Cheese

      bacon or sausage on a roll.

  • Breakfast Menu - Extras
    Complementary guest breakfast menu of 2008.
    • Add Cheese To Any Omelette $2.00

    • Add Feta Cheese To Any Omelette $3.00

    • Extra Egg $2.00

    • Egg Whites - Only, Add $2.00

    • Bagel, Pita Bread $2.00

      english muffin or hard roll add.

    • Any One Vegetable Add $2.00

    • Bacon, Ham, Sausage $3.00

      or canadian-style bacon

    • Pastrami, Ham Steak $5.00

    • 8 Oz Breakfast Steak $9.00

    • Fruit Added To Pancakes $4.00

    • Ice Cream Atop Pancakes $4.00

      or french toast.

    • Home Fries $3.00

    • Sliced Tomatoes $2.00

  • Kids Menu
    Under 10 only.
    • Peanut Butter & jelly $7.00

      with french fries, juice or soda.

    • Grilled Cheese $8.50

      with french fries & Juice or Soda.

    • Hot Dog $8.00

      with french fries & juice or soda.

    • Hamburger $9.00

      with french fries & juice or soda.

    • Ham & Cheese $8.50

      with french fries & juice or soda.

    • Mozzarella Sticks $8.50

      with french fries & juice or soda.

    • Chicken Fingers $9.00

      with french fries & juice or soda.

    • Pasta Marinara $8.00

      with juice or soda (dinner only)

    • Pasta $9.50

      with meat sauce with juice or soda (dinner only).

    • Pizza On Pita $9.00

      with french fries, juice or soda.

  • Desserts
    • Assorted Cakes $6.00

    • Dish Of Ice Cream $6.00

    • Banana Split $9.00

    • Assorted Pies $5.00

    • Jello-O With Whipped Cream. $4.00

    • Pie A La Mode Or Cake A La Mode $3.00

      add.

    • Homemade Rice Pudding $5.00

    • French Silk Pie $6.00

  • Beverages
    Ask for bottled waters and sparkling mineral waters.
    • All Sodas $2.25

    • Iced Teas $2.50

    • Tea $1.75

    • Herbal Tea $2.00

    • Milk $3.00+

      with chocolate syrup add $0.50.

    • Fresh Lemonade $3.50

    • Country Lemonade $2.50

    • Hot Cocoa $2.50+

      with whipped cream.

    • Egg Cream $3.25

    • Milk Shakes $6.00

    • Ice Cream Sodas $5.00

    • Juices $2.50+

      orenge, tomato, grapefruit, apple cranberry.

  • Coffees
    • Brewed Coffee And Decaf $1.75+

    • Ice Coffee $2.50

    • Espresso, Decaf Espresso $3.00

    • Double Espresso $3.75

    • Cappuccino $4.50

    • Iced Cappuccino $5.00

    • Cafe Latte $4.00

    • Cafe Mocha $5.00

  • Entrees - Poultry
    Served with soup or salad, vegetabl & either pasta, rice or potato (mashed, baked or fries).
    • Chicken Piccata $17.00+

      chicken breast sauteed in lemon, butter & white wine.

    • Chicken Francaise $17.00+

      chicken breast dipped in flour & egg, and sauteed in lemon, butter and white wine.

    • Chicken Scampi $17.00+

      chicken breast sauteed in butter, garlic, white wine & lemon sauce.

    • Chicken Parmesan $17.00+

      breaded chicken cutlet topped with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

    • Chicken Marsala $17.00+

      sauteed chicken breast with mushrooms, shallots, butter & marsala wine.

    • Marinated Grilled Chicken $15.00+

    • 1/2 Roasted Chicken $17.00

      (plain & bbq style)

    • 1/2 Roasted Duck $22.00

      (very lean) with orange cranberry sauce.

  • Entrees - Meat
    Served with soup or salad, vegetable & choice of pasta, rice or potato (mashed, baked or fries).
    • New York Shell Steak (Black Angus) $23.00+

      charbroiled to your specs. and topped with onion rings.

    • Rib- Eye Steak Pizzaiolla $26.00

      sliced rib-eye steak served with sauteed peppers, mushrooms, onions, white wine, and a touch of marinara.

    • Prime Rib Au Jus $26.00

    • Boneless Pork Chops $20.00

      charbroiled, served with apple sauce.

    • Rack Of Lamb $17.00

      served with mint sauce.

    • Chopped Steak $18.00

      with sauteed mushrooms & onions in brown sauce & a touch of red wine.

    • Char-Grilled London Broil $19.00

      with sauteed mushrooms & onions in brown sauce & a touch of red wine.

  • Entrees - Fish
    Served with soup or salad, vegetable & either pasta, rice or potato (mashed, baked or fries)
    • Flounder Francaise $22.00

      fillet dipped in four & egg sauteed in lemon, butter & white wine.

    • Flounder Scampi Style $22.00

      in lemon, butter, garlic & white wine.

    • Broiled Codfish, Greek Style $21.00

      feta, tomato & onion

    • Shrimp Scampi $22.00

      sauteed in lemon, butter, garlic & white wine.

    • Shrimp Saganaki $23.00

      sauteed shrimp in light tomato sauce with feta saganaki.

    • Broiled Twin Lobster Tails $27.00

      with drawn butter.

  • Entrees - Pasta
    Served with soup or salad, vegetable & garlic bread.
    • Pasta Marinara $14.00

    • Pasta With Meat Sauce $16.00

    • Pasta Primavera $18.00

      (marinara or olives & garlic).

    • Pasta With Broccoli $16.00

      (olive oil & garlic or marinara).

Menu for John Papas Cafe provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.