• New York
  • Middletown
  • Coney Island Cafe

Coney Island Cafe

(845) 343-3714
  • 10 Railroad Ave, Middletown, NY 10940
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Breakfast Specials
    Served all day, served with choice of coffee, tea or hot chocolate till 11am
    • English Breakfast $6.1

      Scrambled egg whites, ham, and American cheese on a toasted English muffin.

    • Pancakes $7.99

    • French Toast $8.15

    • Oatmeal $3.99

    • 2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast $6.1

    • 2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Ham $8.49

    • 2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Bacon $8.49

    • 2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Sausage $8.49

    • 2 Eggs with Toast $4.99

      No potatoes.

    • 2 Eggs with Toast and Ham $7.82

    • 2 Eggs with Toast and Bacon $7.82

    • 2 Eggs with Toast and Sausage $7.82

    • Ham and Cheese Omelette $10.12

    • Western Omellete $10.5

      Made with ham, peppers and onions.

    • Huevos Rancheros $10.15

      Two 6" tortillas grilled with refried beans, cheddar cheese, and over-easy eggs topped with salsa & guacamole

    • Egg Quesadillas Special $10.99

      Wheat tortilla stuffed with scrambled eggs with tomatoes, peppers, onions, and choice of bacon or sausage with melted jack cheese served with salsa and guacamole.

  • Breakfast Breads and Desserts
    • Buttered Toast $1.99

    • Assorted Muffins $2.49

    • Croissant with Cream Cheese $3.49

    • Toasted Bagel $2.08

    • Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese $2.99

    • Buttered Roll $1.59

    • English Muffin $2.06

    • Crossaint $2.18

    • Banana Bread $2.49

      Slice of banana bread

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.99

    • Tapioca Pudding $2.99

    • Rice Pudding $2.99

  • Breakfast Sandwiches
    Comes with coffee before 11 am.
    • Fried Egg and Cheese $3.25

    • Croissant Sausage Egg and Cheese Sandwich $6.25

    • Western Egg and Cheese Sandwich $6.49

    • Ultimate Egg Sandwich $7.49

      Fried egg, bacon, American cheese, home fries, and jalapenos on a brioche roll

    • Bacon, Tomato, Avocado Crossaint $7.62

      Scrambled eggs, bacon, tomato, and avocado on a crossaint

  • Breakfast Wraps and Sandwiches
    • Ultimate Wrap $7.62

      2 scrambled eggs, home fries, sausage, jalapenos and pepper jack cheese in a wheat wrap. Spicy.

    • Mediterranean Wrap $7.49

      3 egg whites, fresh mozzarella and tomato in a wheat wrap

    • Meat Lover's Egg Wrap $7.62

      Bacon, sausage, onions, peppers, 2 scrambled eggs and Swiss cheese, in a wheat wrap.

  • He-Man Breakfast
    • 3 Meat Spicy Skillet $10.87

      Ham, bacon, and sausage topped with 2 scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese over home fries and green peppers. Served with toast.

    • French Delight $10.64

      2 slices of french toast and 2 eggs served with bacon.

    • Mediterranean Skillet $10.42

      3 scrambled eggs over homefries, roasted red peppers, diced tomatoes, and spinach topped with feta cheese and served toast.

    • Grand Slam Breakfast $11.1

      2 eggs with ham, bacon, and sausage served with home fries and choice of pancakes or french toast.

    • Steak & Eggs Breakfast $11.62

      5 oz. sirloin steak served with 2 eggs, home fries and toast.

  • Signature Omelettes
    Served with home fries and toast, unless otherwise stated.
    • Coney Island Omelette $10.54

      2 franks, cheese, onions and chili sauce.

    • Farmers Omelette $10.54

      Ham, onions, peppers, bacon, sausage and cheese.

    • Caprese Signature Omelette $10.06

      Sliced tomato, melted mozzarella, chopped basil and toast.

    • Gracian Omelette $9.49

      Spinach, feta cheese and tomatoes.

    • Western Omelette $10.06

      Made with ham, pepper and onions.

    • Chicken Fajita Signature Omelette $10.86

      Chicken, American and Monterey Jack cheese, onion and peppers served with salsa and guacamole.

    • Spicy Avocado Omelette $10.54

      Grilled onions, peppers, avocado and pepper jack cheese drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.

    • Tex Mex Signature Omelette $10.54

      Diced red and green peppers, sauteed onions and pepper jack cheese.

  • Egg and Omelettes
    Comes with home fries and toast.
    • 1 Egg $3.58

    • 2 Egg $4.08

    • 1 Egg with Meat $4.12

    • 2 Eggs with Meat $4.56

    • Mushroom Omelette $8.57

    • Mushroom Omelette with Cheese $8.99

    • Cheese Omelette $8.12

      Choice of American, Swiss or cheddar.

    • Ham Omelette $8.9

    • Ham Omelette with Cheese $9.3

    • Bacon Omelette $8.9

    • Bacon Omelette with Cheese $9.3

    • Sausage Omelette $8.9

    • Sausage Omelette with Cheese $9.3

    • Broccoli Omelette $8.55

    • Broccoli Omelette with Cheese $8.99

  • Say Hello to the Benedicts
    All benedicts include a side of home fries.
    • Classic Benedict $9.92

      2 poached eggs on a grilled Canadian bacon on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce.

    • Irish Benedict $9.92

      2 poached eggs, served over housemade corned beef hash and a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce.

    • Mexi Benedict $9.92

      2 poached eggs served with refried beans on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce then drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.

    • California Benedict $9.92

      2 poached eggs, over grilled tomato, fresh avocado on a toasted English muffin and finished with hollandaise.

    • Chipotle Bacon Benedict $10.26

      2 poached eggs. Served with crisp bacon and guacamole on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce, drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.

  • Pancakes and French Toast
    • Pancakes $7.98

    • French Toast $7.42

    • Blueberry Cakes $8.37

      Filled with blueberries.

    • Short Stack Pancakes $5.25

    • Short Stack French Toast $5.42

    • Chocolate Chips Pancakes $7.42

    • Cinnastack Pancakes $8.29

      Pancakes layered with cinnamon spread and topped with cream cheese icing.

    • Strawberry Fields $8.38

      3 thick slices french toast topped with strawberry compote and whipped cream.

    • Banana Bread French Toast $8.48

      Our delicious homemade banana bread topped with bananas, cinnamon and powdered sugar.

  • Appetizers and Soups
    • OverLoaded Potato Skins $7.98

      Topped with cheddar jack cheese, bacon, diced onions, tomato, jalapeños, and black olives, served with sour cream on the side.

    • Sweet Potato Fries $5.92

      Sweet potato sliced and fried to perfection

    • Homemade Fried Green Beans $7.98

      Fresh green beans lightly battered & fried to perfection, served with ranch

    • French Fries $6.49

      With mozzarella cheese and gravy.

    • Bacon Cheese Fries $7.57

      French fries with melted cheese and crisp bacon with a side of ranch.

    • Chili Con Carne $5.57

    • Chili Cheese Fries $7.42

      French fries topped with our signature chili sauce and shredded cheese.

    • Large Chicken Noodle Soup $4.45

      Chicken,Carrots, celery ,Onions and egg noodles in seasoned broth

  • Glorious Salads
    • California Supreme Salad $10.96

      Breast of chicken, grilled and sliced over fresh green salad with tomato, cucumbers, onions, shredded cheese, and choice of dressing.

    • Caesar Salad $8.93

      Crisp hearts of romaine lettuce tossed with our creamy caesar dressing with freshly grated Parmesan cheese and fresh croutons. Add grilled chicken for an additional charge.

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad $11.25

      Grilled chicken over romaine, shredded cheddar jack, diced tomatoes, chopped bacon, and ranch.

    • Greacian Chicken Salad $10.98

      Grilled chicken, shredded romaine lettuce, peppers, onions, and diced tomatoes served with tzatziki sauce.

    • Pepper Jack Chicken Romaine Salad $10.62

      Crispy romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, pepper jack cheese, and chipotle ranch dressing.

    • Fajita Chicken Salad $10.96

      Cajun chicken, romaine, corn, black beans, tomato, and tortilla chips with chipotle ranch dressing. Spicy.

    • Chef's Salad $11.25

      A bed of fresh lettuce topped with turkey, roast beef, ham, Swiss cheese, tomato, and cucumbers, and garnished with a hard boiled egg.

  • Coney Island Combos
    • 1. Coney Dog Combo $8.12

    • Coney Island Chili Dog $3.49

      Coney island chili sauce, mustard and onions.

    • Plain Dog $2.64

    • Plain Dog Combo $6.99

    • Chicago Coney Dog $3.49

      Mustard, onions, relish, pickle, tomato, and jalapenos.

    • Manhattan Coney Dog $3.49

      Red onion sauce, mustard, and sauerkraut.

    • Philly Coney Dog $3.49

      Grilled onions and cheddar cheese.

    • Red Onion Sauce Coney Dog $3.49

    • Southwestern Coney Dog $3.49

      Ketchup, cheese, jalapenos, and coney island chili sauce.

    • New Yorker Coney Dog $3.49

      Spicy mustard, grilled onions, and kraut.

    • Cheeseburger Sandwich $5.49

    • Cheeseburger Sandwich Combo $9.96

    • Double Cheeseburger Sandwich $6.49

    • Double Cheeseburger Sandwich Combo $10.27

    • Greek Gyro Sandwich $8.49

    • Greek Gyro Sandwich Combo $12.85

    • Coney Cheesesteak Sandwich $8.49

    • Coney Cheesesteak Sandwich Combo $12.87

    • Chicken Wings $5.49

    • Chicken Tenders $7.49

    • Chicken Tenders Combo $11.75

    • Coney Island Combo $7.12

      Chips not included in combos.

  • Hard Pressed Burgers
    Served with french fries, cole slaw, and pickle. Substitute sweet potatoes or onion rings for an additional charge.
    • Chipotle Bacon Burger $8.45

      With pepper jack cheese, bacon, red onions, and chipotle sauce wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla. Spicy.

    • Spicy Philly Burger $8.45

      Our hand-pressed burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, sautéed onions, jalapeños, and chipotle sauce on a hamburger bun. Spicy.

    • Swiss Melt Burger $8.45

      With fried onions, mushrooms, and melted Swiss on rye.

    • Cajun Bacon Jack Burger $8.45

      Our hand pressed burger Cajun-seasoned, topped with melted pepper jack cheese and bacon on a hamburger bun.

  • Paninis, Wraps and Melts
    Served with potato chips, pickle, and cole slaw. Substitute fries, sub sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional charge.
    • Turkey Melt $8.95

      Grilled American cheese with turkey, tomato, and Russian dressing on rye bread.

    • Philly Roast Beef Melt $9.99

      Homemade roast beef, thinly sliced and grilled topped with cheddar cheese, grilled onions and served with sourdough bread.

    • Tuscan Roast Beef Panini $9.99

      Roast beef sliced thin, grilled, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, sauteed spinach, and tomatoes on grilled rye.

    • Hickory Chicken Melt $8.99

      Grilled chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, and BBQ sauce on grilled rye bread.

    • Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap $9.99

      Grilled chicken breast topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar and filled with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla. Spicy.

    • Pepperjack Pastrami Wrap $9.99

      Thinly sliced and grilled pastrami topped with pepperjack cheese, roasted red peppers, and mayo in a whole wheat tortilla.

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $8.49

      Crispy buffalo chicken, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing. Spicy.

    • Crispy Chicken Wrap $10.35

      Crispy fried chicken, bacon, shredded cheese, avocado, cucumber, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.

    • Chipotle Chicken Wrap $9.99

      Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon, shredded cheddar jack cheese, tomato, and chipotle sauce in a wheat tortilla. Spicy.

  • Signature Sandwiches
    All served with french fries, pickle, and cole slaw. Substitute sweet potato fries or onions rings for an additional charge.
    • French Dip Signature Sandwich $11.15

      Thin sliced roast beef and melted Swiss cheese on a baguette brushed with garlic butter with au jus on the side. Add onions and mushrooms for an additional charge.

    • Chicken Avocado Signature Sandwich $9.99

      Grilled chicken topped with Swiss cheese and avocado. Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo on a bun.

    • Grilled Reuben Signature Sandwich $10.95

      Lean corned beef and sauerkraut topped with melted Swiss cheese on rye bread with Russian dressing on the side.

    • Corned Beef Pastrami Combo Signature Sandwich $9.99

      Grilled corned beef and pastrami on rye.

  • Tasty Sandwiches
    Served with chips, cole slaw and pickle.
    • Roast Beef Sandwich $8.35

      Served with lettuce.

    • Roast Turkey Sandwich $8.35

      Served with lettuce.

    • Virginia Ham Sandwich $8.35

      Served with lettuce.

    • Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich $6.45

    • Chicken Salad Sandwich $7.99

      Served with lettuce.

    • Egg Salad Sandwich $6.87

      Served with lettuce.

    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich $5.48

  • Triple Decker's
    Served with potato chips, pickle and cole slaw.
    • Sliced Turkey Triple Decker $10.32

      Served with turkey, lettuce, tomato and bacon.

    • Sliced Roast Beef Triple Decker $10.32

      Served with roast beef, lettuce, tomato, bacon and American cheese.

    • Sliced Ham Triple Decker $10.32

      Served with ham, lettuce, tomato and Swiss cheese.

  • Mexican Fiesta
    • Chicken and Black Bean Quesadilla $10.3

      Wheat tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, shredded cheese, corn salsa and black beans. Served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.

    • Burrito $9.5

      Wheat tortilla filled with seasoned beef, refried beans and shredded cheese. Topped with lettuce, tomato, salsa and sour cream.

    • Fajita Quesadillas $9.5

      Wheat tortilla filled with grilled chicken and shredded cheese. Topped with lettuce and tomato. Served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.

  • Cincinatti Style Chili
    • 3 Way Cincinatti Style Chili $6.8

      Spaghetti with chili sauce and shredded cheese.

    • 4 Way Cincinatti Style Chili $7.12

      Spaghetti chili sauce, shredded cheese and onions.

    • 5 Way Cincinatti Style Chili $7.75

      Spaghetti chili sauce, shredded cheese, onions and kidney beans.

  • Hot Entrees
    Served with vegetables and mashed potatoes.
    • Hot Open Turkey $10.99

    • Hot Open Virginia Style Ham $10.99

    • Hot Open Sirloin of Beef $10.99

  • Side Orders
    • Side of Bacon $3.49

    • Side of Sausage $3.49

    • Side of Ham $3.49

    • Corned Beef Hash $5.49

      House made corned beef

    • Sirloin Steak $5.99

    • Turkey Sausage $3.99

    • Home Fries $3.99

    • French Fries $4.99

    • Onion Rings $5.99

    • Sweet Potato Fries $5.99

    • Fries with Mozzarella and Gravy $6.49

    • Cole Slaw $3.49

    • Mac and Cheese $3.99

  • Shakes and Smoothies
    • Chocolate Milkshake $4.5

    • Strawberry Milkshake $4.5

    • Vanilla Milkshake $4.5

    • Banana Smoothie $4.99

    • Blueberry Smoothie $4.99

    • Mango Smoothie $4.99

    • Strawberry Smoothie $4.99

    • Mixed Fruit Smoothie $4.99

  • Beverages
    • Apple Juice 16oz $2.99

    • Cranberry Juice 16oz $2.99

    • Orange Juice 16oz $2.99

    • Large Ice Coffee24 oz $2.99

    • Small Ice Coffee16oz $2.49

    • Sweet Ice Tea24 oz $2.49

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.