• New York
  • Island Park
  • Pancho's Cantina

Pancho's Cantina

(516) 897-8300
  • 4245 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • Mexican
  • $$$$$
(516) 897-8300
  • Menu
  • With Your Chips
    • Guacamole Appetizer $9.99

    • Spicy Southwest Guacamole $9.99

      Served with corn, black beans, and a touch of jalapeno.

    • Tropical Guacamole $10.99

      Blended with mango salsa.

    • Mild Queso Dip $4.99

    • Spicy Queso Dip $4.99

      Melted cheese blended with roasted peppers.

  • Starters
    • Spicy Queso Dip $4.99

      Melted cheese blended with roasted peppers.

    • Chicken Wings $12.99

    • Chorizo Empanadas $10.99

      Chorizo and seasoned beef with sauteed onions, peppers, and potatoes inside a classic pastry.

    • Grilled Mini Burritos $7.99

      BBQ beef and mozzarella, spicy chicken and roasted corn, or grilled portobello and poblano pepper. 2 per order.

    • Crispy Calamari $13.99

    • Wing Ding Sampler $17.99

      All four styles of wings, spicy Buffalo, crispy Jorge, mild grilled BBQ, and honey BBQ. 3 different dipping sauces.

    • Buffalo Sampler $18.99

      Chicken quesadillas, wings, calamari, and fingers. All Buffalo style.

    • Tidbit Sampler $18.99

      Grilled BBQ wings, BBQ ribbits, pork carnitas quesadilla, and BBQ beef mini burrito.

    • Guacamole Appetizer $9.99

    • BBQ Baby Back Rib Bits $13.99

    • Chicken Fingers $10.99

    • Cornbreaded Popcorn Shrimp $13.99

      Served with creamy garlic dipping sauce.

    • Jalapeno Poppers $9.99

      Crispy chile peppers stuffed with cheddar cheese.

    • Traditional Tacos $4.99

      Panchos classic tacos with lettuce, tomato, cheese, and salsa.

    • Buffalo Chicken Mini Wrap $9.99

      Breaded Buffalo chicken rolled with blue cheese, celery, carrots, and romaine lettuce in flour tortillas.

    • Dinner Avocado Toast $9.99

      Avocado, tomatoes, pumpkin seeds, black bean, corn relish, cilantro, and avocado oil.

  • Entree Salad
    • Tortilla Basket Salad $16.99

      Lettuce, tomato, onions, carrots, cheese, and bean salad in a crisp pesto tortilla basket. Served with our Mexican vinaigrette.

    • Pancho's Mesclun Salad $16.99

      Baby salad greens, diced tomatoes, corn, black bean relish, and spiced croutons. Served with low fat chipotle ranch dressing.

    • Seasonal Salad $16.99

      Romaine hearts, baby greens, mango salsa, diced avocado, chopped grilled veggies, and craisins tossed with our thyme lime vinaigrette. Topped with blue corn chips.

    • Salad Supreme $24.99

      Panchos mesclun salad with chicken, steak, and shrimp.

    • Rice Bowl Salad $16.99

      Western rice, black beans, sauteed bell peppers, onions, tomato salsa, romaine lettuce, and avocado topped with sour cream. Served in a crispy tortilla basket.

  • Chili and Soup
    • Chihuahua Chicken Soup $5.99

      Served with avocado, tomato, onions, and cilantro.

    • Colorado Chili $8.99

      Cheese and sour cream.

    • Veggie Chili $8.99

      Served with cheese.

    • Black Bean Soup $5.99

      Onions and sour cream.

    • Tortilla Soup $5.99

      Our version of the Mexican staple.

  • Appetizer Salads
    • Appetizer Salads $4.99

      Lettuce, cheese, carrots, tomatoes, and onions with Mexican vinaigrette.

    • Baby Greens Salad $4.99

      Served with low fat chile ranch or thyme vinaigrette.

    • Caesar Salad $4.99

      Slightly spicy version of the classic.

    • Small Pancho Salad $4.99

    • Large Pancho Salad $7.99

  • Panchos Favorite Sides
    • Refried Beans $2.99

    • BBQ Beans $2.99

    • Black Beans $2.99

    • Black Bean and Corn Relish $2.99

    • Bean Salad $2.99

    • Seasoned Waffle Fries $3.98

    • Shoestring French Fries $2.99

    • Sweet Potato Fries $3.98

    • Mashed Potatoes $2.99

    • Green Chili Mashed $2.99

    • Sweet Plantains $4.98

    • Macaroni and Cheese $2.99

    • Spanish Rice $2.99

    • Western Rice $2.99

    • Baby Greens Salad $2.99

    • Guacamole $4.98

    • Caesar Salad $2.99

    • Fresh Avocado Slices $4.98

    • Spinach and Veggies $2.99

    • Grilled Vegetables $2.99

  • Quesadillas
    • Just Cheese Quesadilla $7.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Roasted Shrimp Quesadilla $13.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Chorizo Potato Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Cheese Burger Quesadilla $12.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • BBQ Skirt Steak Quesadilla $13.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Portabella Mushroom Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Cheddar and Mashed Quesadilla $9.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • BBQ Beef Quesadilla $12.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Grilled Chicken Quesadilla $12.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Shredded Chicken Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla.

    • Pork Carnitas Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Spinach Veggie Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Avocado Tomato Quesadilla $11.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla $13.99

      Made in a toasted flour tortilla....corn, habanero, or whole wheat tortilla available upon request.

    • The Cuban Quesadilla $13.99

      Pulled pork, ham, pickles and yellow mustard in a toasted habanero tortilla. Flour, whole wheat, or corn tortilla available on request.

    • California Quesadilla $12.99

      Portabella mushrooms, avocado, sun-dried tomatoes, and Monterey Jack cheese. Made in a toasted pesto tortilla.

  • Nachos
    • Classic Cheese Nachos $8.99

      A platter of corn tortilla chips with three types of melted cheese, mild red sauce, jalapeno slices, refried beans and sour cream.

    • Ranchers Nachos $11.99

      Beef or veggie chili, ranchera sauce, guacamole, and sour cream. A platter of corn tortilla chips with three types of melted cheese and served in choice of Panchos styles.

    • Garden Nachos $11.99

      Avocado, onion, jalapeno, salsa, olives, tomatoes, and sour cream. A platter of corn tortilla chips with three types of melted cheese and served in choice of Panchos styles.

    • Ultimate Nachos $14.99

      Grilled steak and chicken, black and refried beans, tomatoes, onions, olives, green and red sauces, sour cream, and guacamole. A platter of corn tortilla chips with three types of melted cheese and served in choice of Panchos styles.

    • Nacho Bar $9.99

      Corn chips topped with queso sauce, melted cheese, and choice of toppings.

  • Panchos Specialties
    Served with 2 side dishes.
    • Bandito Burrito $21.99

      Grilled chicken breast, black beans, cheese, spicy green chile sauce inside a large flour tortilla, sour cream, and guacamole.

    • Enchilada Pie $19.99

      Layers of corn tortillas, ancho enchilada gravy, pulled chicken, corn, black beans, and cheese baked.

    • Chile Relleno $19.99

      Fire roasted poblano chili peppers stuffed with ground beef, chorizo, and a cooling yogurt chipotle sauce.

    • Grilled Vegetable Burrito $17.99

      Spinach, mushrooms, veggies with refried beans, salsa, cheese inside a pesto tortilla, sour cream, and guacamole.

    • Pancho's Classic Super Burrito $19.99

      Shredded chicken or ground beef, refried or black beans, onions, and cheese rolled in a flour tortilla. Topped with ranchera sauce or spicy green chile sauce with sour cream and guacamole.

    • Pancho's Classic Chimichanga $19.99

      A golden crispy burrito without beans inside.

    • Pancho's Macaroni and Cheese Carnitas $19.99

      Shredded chicken, roasted corn, and poblano chilies in a spicy cheddar cheese sauce.

    • Enchiladas Primo $24.99

      BBQ skirt steak in soft flour tortillas smothered with mild ranchera, spicy green sauces, and Monterey Jack cheese.

    • Colorado Enchiladas $21.99

      Grilled chicken and avocado inside soft flour tortillas topped with melted cheese, mild ranchera sauce, and sprinkled with cilantro.

    • Spinach and Veggie Enchiladas $19.99

      Corn tortillas filled with spinach, mushrooms, and grilled veggies. Topped with mild ranchera sauce or classic ancho gravy and melted cheese.

    • Chicken and Shrimp Jambalaya $25.99

      Red rice cooked with ground chorizo sausage, poblano chilies, boneless chicken, and tender shrimp.

    • Enchiladas Garcia $21.99

      Grilled chicken and portabella mushrooms inside soft corn tortillas. Topped with Monterey Jack and spicy green chile sauce.

    • Enchiladas en Mole $21.99

      Served with a spicy sauce of chilies and chocolate in soft corn tortillas. Topped with melted Monterey Jack cheese.

    • Tacos al Carbon $19.99

      Grilled flour tortillas stuffed with either BBQ skirt steak & fresh avocado or BBQ chicken and caramelized onions.

    • Burgers $16.99

      8 oz. of ground beef. Served wrapped in a flour or whole wheat tortilla or on a soft roll.

    • Pancho's Meatloaf $21.99

      Homemade chorizo, ground beef, and Pancho's seasonings, with a touch of bacon and served with ancho gravy.

  • Seafood
    • Santa Fe Grilled Shrimp $25.99

      Succulent shrimp seasoned in new Mexico style shallot and herb butter.

    • Cornbreaded Shrimp $25.99

      Served with creamy garlic and spicy BBQ dipping sauces.

    • Shrimp Margarita $25.99

      Sauteed with garlic, sweet lime juice, and a hint of gold tequila.

    • Mexicali Shrimp $25.99

      A mildly-spicy classic Mexican dish. Shrimp sauteed in a garlic vegetable puree.

    • Shrimp Acapulco $26.99

      Crispy fried shrimp smothered in mild ranchera and spicy green sauces. Topped with melted Monterey Jack cheese.

    • California Fish Tacos $22.99

      Tender strips prepared in soft corn tortillas, lettuce wraps, or soft flour tortillas.

    • Cajun Spiced Catfish Broiled with Fresh Tomato Salsa $22.99

    • Broiled Spicy Tortilla Crusted Tilapia with Mango Salsa $22.99

    • Yucatan Baked Catfish with Lime Cilantro Corn Crumb $22.99

    • Southern Fried Catfish Fillet $22.99

      Crispy with fresh mango salsa.

  • Famous Fajitas
    • Grilled Chicken Fajita $21.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Mixed Vegetable Fajita $20.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Portabella Mushroom Fajita $20.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Grilled Hanger Steak Fajita $23.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Grilled Hanger Steak Fajita $21.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Combo Fajita $22.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Skirt Steak Combo Fajita $24.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • BBQ Skirt Steak Fajita $26.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Roasted Shrimp Fajita $24.99

      Served with refried beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pico de gallo, and warm flour tortillas.

    • Beyond 'Burger' Fajita $23.99

      Vegetarian beef fajita. Served with our traditional fajita garnish, peppers, onions and homemade marinade...

  • Steak Chicken Ribs and BBQ
    • Cattleman's BBQ Skirt Steak $28.99

      Grilled and served sliced in garlic barbecue sauce.

    • Desperado's Chicken $21.99

      BBQ boneless breast topped with three types of melted cheese.

    • BBQ Pork Chops $22.99

      3 sweet, juicy grilled pork chops glazed with honey BBQ sauce.

    • 1/2 Chicken $19.99

      Grilled in choice of sauces.

    • Margarita Chicken $19.99

      Strips of grilled chicken sauteed with garlic, sweet lime juice, triple sec, and a hint of gold tequila.

    • BBQ Chicken and Ribs Combo $25.99

      1/2 rack of baby backs with choice of white or dark meat chicken.

    • Cheyenne Chicken Lettuce Wraps $19.99

      Garlic and cilantro marinated breast slices with avocado, sweet red pepper puree, and drizzled with spicy chipotle BBQ sauce.

    • Spicy Poblano Chicken $22.99

      Grilled boneless breast topped with fire roasted poblanos, red peppers, and portabellas. Finished with green chile sauce and melted cheese.

    • Chicken Diablo $21.99

      Strips of grilled chicken sauteed with spicy smoked jalapeno salsa and cilantro.

    • Cowboy Combo $29.99

      1/2 rack of baby backs paired with choice of 6 Santa Fe grilled or 6 corn breaded shrimp.

    • Baby Back Ribs $29.99

      A full rack.

  • Mexican Combos
    • Create Your Own Combinations $18.99

  • Young Adult Menu
    Served with 1 of Panchos sides.
    • YA Desperado's Chicken $11.99

    • YA Sliced Grilled Chicken Breast $11.99

    • YA Steak Quesadilla $11.99

    • YA Colorado Enchilada $11.99

    • YA Quarter BBQ Chicken $11.99

    • YA 1/2 Rack Baby Back Ribs $16.98

    • YA Popcorn Shrimp $16.98

    • YA Sliced Skirt Steak $16.98

  • Kids Menu
    Served with one of Panchos sides.
    • Kids Hamburger $8.99

    • Kids Cheeseburger $8.99

    • Kids Chicken Fingers $8.99

    • Kids Beef Hot Dog $8.99

    • Kids Tacos $8.99

    • Kids Burrito $8.99

    • Kids Macaroni and Cheese $8.99

    • Kids Cheese Quesadilla $8.99

    • Kids Chicken Quesadilla $8.99

    • Kids Enchilada $8.99

  • Pancho's Mini Desserts
    Homemade from scratch, individual serving.
    • Tiramisu $2.5

    • S'mores $2.5

    • Mint Brownie $2.5

    • Cookies and Cream $2.5

    • Key Lime Pie $2.5

    • Classic Flan $2.5

    • Triple Chocolate $2.5

    • Strawberry Cheesecake $2.5

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.