Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Garden City
  • Baked by Melissa

What is Seamless

Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.

Next

Why use Seamless

Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.

Previous
Start your order

Baked by Melissa

(646) 666-8911

We make ordering easy. Learn more

Google map
  • 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530
  • No cuisines specified

  • Seamless.com
  • Baked by Melissa

  • (646) 666-8911

    We make ordering easy.

  • Menu
  • Limited Edition
    • Emily In Paris 12-Pack $22.00

      "Oui, we brought back cupcarons to celebrate the season premiere of Emily in Paris! Taste two new flavors inspired by the City of Lights and two inspired by la dolce vita, just in time for your viewing party. C’est très chic, if you ask us. Flavors Included 3 x Chocolate Rose 3 x Rainbow Cookie 3 x Caffè Caramel 3 x Strawberry Crêpe This pack contains nuts."

    • Emily In Paris 25-Pack $41.00

      "Oui, we brought back cupcarons to celebrate the season premiere of Emily in Paris! Taste two new flavors inspired by the City of Lights and two inspired by la dolce vita, just in time for your viewing party. C’est très chic, if you ask us. Flavors Included 7 x Chocolate Rose 6 x Rainbow Cookie 6 x Caffè Caramel 6 x Strawberry Crêpe This pack contains nuts."

    • Holiday Cheer 25-Pack $41.00

      "Limited-edition holiday flavors inspired by nostalgic desserts—sugar cookies, hot cocoa, chocolate candy, and more. May your cookie swap and holiday parties be merry & bite-size. Flavors Included 7 x Brookie 6 x Vanilla Fluff 6 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 6 x Snowcap"

    • Festival of Bites 25-Pack $41.00

      "Celebrate eight craaaaazy nights with holiday flavors inspired by nostalgic desserts, like chocolate babka, chocolate candy, and hot cocoa. The perfect treat after lighting the menorah. Flavors Included 7 x Caramel Cake Batter 6 x Marshmallow Hot Cocoa 6 x Snowcap 6 x Chocolate Babka"

    • Chrismukkah Cupcake 50-Pack $74.00

      "Flavors Included 24 x Snowcap 14 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 14 x Caramel Cake Batter 12 x Marshmallow Hot Cocoa 12 x Vanilla Fluff 12 x Brookie 12 x Chocolate Babka"

    • Holiday Party Cupcake 100-Pack $139.00

      "Create a holiday dessert table packed with 16 incredible flavors inspired by nostalgic desserts, like sugar cookies and hot cocoa. Holiday hosting has never been easier. Flavors Included: 12 x Snowcap 10 x Vanilla Fluff 10 x Marshmallow Hot Cocoa 10 x Brookie 7 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 7 x Caramel Cake Batter 6 x Chocolate Babka 6 x Chocolate Cookie Cheesecake 4 x Tie-Dye 4 x Cookie & Cream 4 x Peanut Butter & Jelly 4 x Cookie Dough 4 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 4 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 4 x Red Velvet 4 x Mint Cookie"

    • Christmas Gift Box 25-Pack $49.00

      Choice of 25-Pack paired with our red Christmas Gift Box.

    • Holiday Gift Box 25-Pack $49.00

      Choice of 25-Pack paired with our blue Holiday Gift Box.

    • New York Holiday Gift Box 25-Pack $49.00

      Choice of 25-Pack paired with our NYC Holiday Gift Box.

    • Merry & Bright 6-Box $18.00

      1 x Red Holiday 6-Box. Flavors included: 1 x Vanilla Fluff 1 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 1 x Brookie 1 x Snowcap 1 x White Chocolate Hot Cocoa 1 x Caramel Cake Batter Wrapped in a red holiday gift box."

    • Let It Snow 6-Box $18.00

      "1 x Blue Holiday 6-Box. Flavors included: 1 x Vanilla Fluff 1 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 1 x Brookie 1 x Snowcap 1 x White Chocolate Hot Cocoa 1 x Caramel Cake Batter Wrapped in a blue holiday gift box."

    • Stocking Stuffers Cupcakes 6-Pack (Bundle of 4) $64.00

      "Good things come in small packages. These little gifts make everyone happy, with six unique flavors—each made entirely by hand—in every box. Bundle includes a mix of Festival of Bites & Holiday Cheer flavors. Each 6 Pack includes: 1 x Vanilla Fluff 1 x Christmas Sugar Cookie 1 x Brookie 1 x Snowcap 1 x White Chocolate Hot Cocoa 1 x Caramel Cake Batter"

  • Paw Patrol
    • Paw Patrol 25-Pack $46.00

      "It’s paw-ty time! This 25-Pack features four limited-edition flavors inspired by Chase, Skye, Marshall, and Rubble, wrapped in a PAW Patrol sleeve. Flavors Included 7 x Chase is on the Case Cookies & Cream 6 x Skye's Cookie Dough Takeoff 6 x Marshall's Blazing Tie Dye Chocolate Blast 6 x Rubble on the Double S'more ©️2025 &TM Spin Master Ltd."

    • Paw Patrol 6-Pack (Bundle of 4) $45.00

      "Treat time is on a roll! This bundle includes four 6-Packs, each with a unique sleeve for Chase, Skye, Marshall, and Rubble. Each 6-Pack includes: 2 x Skye's Cookie Dough Takeoff 2 x Chase is on the Case Cookies & Cream 1 x Marshall's Blazing Tie Dye Chocolate Blast 1 x Rubble on the Double S'more ©️2025 &TM Spin Master Ltd."

    • Paw Patrol 50-Pack $84.00

      "2 x Paw Patrol 25-Packs Flavors Included 14 x Chase is on the Case Cookies & Cream 12 x Skye's Cookie Dough Takeoff 12 x Marshall's Blazing Tie Dye Chocolate Blast 12 x Rubble on the Double S'more ©️2025 &TM Spin Master Ltd."

    • Paw Patrol 100-Pack $145.00

      "4 x Paw Patrol 25-Packs Flavors Included 28 x Chase is on the Case Cookies & Cream 24 x Skye's Cookie Dough Takeoff 24 x Marshall's Blazing Tie Dye Chocolate Blast 24 x Rubble on the Double S'more ©️2025 &TM Spin Master Ltd."

    • Paw Patrol 6-Pack $15.00

      " Flavors Included: 2 x Skye's Cookie Dough Takeoff 2 x Chase is on the Case Cookies & Cream 1 x Marshall's Blazing Tie Dye Chocolate Blast 1 x Rubble on the Double S'more + your choice of character sleeve! ©️2025 &TM Spin Master Ltd."

  • Cupcakes
    • Latest and Greatest Cupcakes $41.00

      "Our best-seller! This cupcake pack is our go-to sampler for dessert lovers looking to try a little bit of everything. THE LATEST: our 3 seasonal cupcakes plus our monthly Mini of the Month! THE GREATEST: our 8 must-have original flavors! Flavors Included 2 x Tie-Dye 2 x Cookie & Cream 2 x PB&J (contains nuts) 2 x Cookie Dough 2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 2 x Red Velvet 2 x Mint Cookie 9 x Fudge Brownie 8 x Pumpkin Pie 8 x Cinnamon 3 x Cookies & Milk"

    • The O.G. Cupcakes $41.00

      Stick to the classics with our eight original cupcake flavors that have been around since day one. 25 cupcakes baked to fluffy perfection, hand-stuffed, iced and topped with magical ingredients like semi-sweet chocolate chips, minty cookie butter and real Oreo® cookies. Flavors Included 4 x Tie-Dye 3 x Cookie & Cream 3 x Peanut Butter & Jelly 3 x Cookie Dough 3 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 3 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 3 x Red Velvet 3 x Mint Cookie

    • The Party Safe O.G. Cupcakes $41.00

      The Party Safe Original Greats, no nut flavors included*. Includes seven of our most-loved signature flavors, all iced by hand & topped with ingredients like Oreo® cookie pieces and semi-sweet chocolate chips, chosen to compliment each magical bite. *These cupcakes do not contain peanuts. However, all of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, and other allergens. *All of our products are baked in a kitchen where nut ingredients are used. Flavors Included 4 x Tie-Dye 4 x Cookie & Cream 4 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 4 x Red Velvet 3 x Cookie Dough 3 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 3 x Mint Cookie

    • Tie-Dye Cupcake 12-Pack $22.00

      Melissa's Tie-Dye cupcakes are utterly simple and hypnotizingly delicious. Try the famous vanilla tie-dye cupcake, iced with smooth and creamy vanilla icing and dusted with magical rainbow sugar crystals. Flavors Included 12 x Tie Dye

    • Party Safe OG 6-Pack $14.25

      Melissa's Tie-Dye cupcakes are utterly simple and hypnotizingly delicious. Try the famous vanilla tie-dye cupcake, iced with smooth and creamy vanilla icing and dusted with magical rainbow sugar crystals. Flavors Included 12 x Tie Dye

  • Pick Your Own
    • Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack $46.00

      All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 25 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month. "Your choice of: Tie-Dye Cookie & Cream PB&J (contains nuts) Cookie Dough Triple Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Chip Pancake Red Velvet Mint Cookie Mini of the Month: Christmas Sugar Cookie For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you.

    • Pick Your Flavors 12-Pack $24.50

      All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 12 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month. "Your choice of: Tie-Dye Cookie & Cream PB&J (contains nuts) Cookie Dough Triple Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Chip Pancake Red Velvet Mint Cookie Mini of the Month: Christmas Sugar Cookie For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you.

    • Pick Your Flavors 6-Pack $15.25

      All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 6 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month. "Your choice of: Tie-Dye Cookie & Cream PB&J (contains nuts) Cookie Dough Triple Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Chip Pancake Red Velvet Mint Cookie Mini of the Month: Christmas Sugar Cookie For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you.

  • Birthdays
    The best birthday gifts are the ones you can eat!
    • Electric Tie Dye Layer Cake (serves 8-12) $69.00

      *Stored frozen for transit. Please bring to room temp 1 hour before serving.* This cake will take your birthday celebration to the next level. Made with 3 layers of Melissa's signature Electric Vanilla Tie-Dye Cake, loads of vanilla buttercream icing, and tie-dye cake crumble topping. It's everything you know and love about Baked by Melissa, packed into a cake! Serving Suggestion: Serves 8 - 12 people.

    • Happy Birthday Cupcakes & Candles $49.95

      Wish them a Happy Birthday with cupcakes & candles! This sweet gift comes fully equipped with 25 handcrafted, mini cupcakes in 12 flavors and our ‘Happy Birthday’ candle set! Cupcake flavors include our ever-changing Mini of the Month, 3 seasonal cupcake flavors and all 8 of Melissa's Original Greats. Flavors Included 2 x Tie-Dye 2 x Cookie & Cream 2 x PB&J (contains nuts) 2 x Cookie Dough 2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 2 x Red Velvet 2 x Mint Cookie 2 x Brookie 2 x Vanilla Fluff 2 x Marshmallow Hot Cocoa 3 x Snowball (contains coconut)

    • Groovy Birthday Gift Box 25-Pack $51.00

      The sweetest birthday gifts come in small packages! And you have options—this gift is best if you're looking for more variety! Choose one 25-Pack from any of the below assortments to send in our groovy Happy Birthday gift box. BEST FOR GIFTING A SPECIALTY ASSORTMENT!

    • The Birthday 50-Pack Gift Box $84.00

      Choose 2 assortment packs to fill your groovy birthday gift box! The best birthday present to send to celebrate any friend or family, near and far!

  • Speciality
    • Vegan Latest & Greatest $54.00

      Our best-selling cupcake assortment goes VEGAN! Curated by Melissa herself, the Vegan Latest & Greatest is your one-stop-shop for every vegan cupcake flavor on the menu. Each assortment includes 25 vegan cupcakes featuring six vegan cupcake flavors all handcrafted using the most delicious dairy-free vegan ingredients. Flavors Included 5 x Vegan Strawberry 4 x Vegan Peanut Butter (contains nuts) 4 x Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip 4 x Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip 4 x Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut 4 x Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun *Vegan cupcakes contain coconut. Peanut Butter flavor also contains peanuts.

    • The Oh My Gluten Free Cupcakes $54.00

      Oh my, gluten free! Six wheatless, handcrafted gluten-free flavors that are fantastically rich and sweet. Now with NEW flavors, including Cookies & Cream, Marshmallow, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Caramel. All of our gluten free cupcakes & macarons are made in a separate facility. Flavors Included 5 x Gluten Free Tie-Dye 4 x Gluten Free Red Velvet 4 x Gluten Free Marshmallow 4 x Gluten Free Cookies & Cream 4 x Gluten Free Cookie Dough 4 x Gluten Free Chocolate Caramel

    • The Mac 12-Pack $30.50

      Double-stuffed, bite-size macarons. Our six melt-in-your-mouth flavors are handcrafted with ingredients like dark chocolate, sea salt, hand-whipped Philadelphia cream cheese and more. PS. Macarons are made with almond flour, so they're naturally gluten free! *All macarons are made with almond flour. Flavors Included 2 x Sugar Cookie 2 x Double Chocolate 2 x Red Velvet 2 x Cookie Dough 2 x Snickerdoodle 2 x Salted Caramel

    • Vegan 12-Pack $25.00

      "Flavors Included 2 x Vegan Strawberry 2 x Vegan Peanut Butter (contains nuts) 2 x Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip 2 x Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip 2 x Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut 2 x Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun"

    • OMGF 12-Pack $25.00

      "Flavors Included 2 x GF Tie Dye 2 x GF Red Velvet 2 x GF Marshmallow 2 x GF Cookie Dough 2 x GF Cookies & Cream 2 x GF Chocolate Caramel"

  • Parties
    • Latest & Greatest Cupcakes 100-Pack $139.00

      A 100 bite-size cupcake sampler of 12 unique, hand-crafted cupcake flavors. Our most-loved originals, the ever-changing delicious Mini of the Month, and new seasonal flavors. The perfect party pack for your next celebration! Flavors Included 8 x Tie-Dye 8 x Cookie & Cream 8 x PB&J (contains nuts) 8 x Cookie Dough 8 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 8 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 8 x Red Velvet 8 x Mint Cookie 8 x Brookie 8 x Vanilla Fluff 8 x Marshmallow Hot Cocoa 12 x Snowball (contains coconut)

    • Party Safe Original Greats Cupcakes 100-Pack $139.00

      The sweetest way to celebrate every occasion, no nut flavors included*. Includes seven of our most-loved original flavors, that are fit for classrooms and birthday parties alike. Whether they’re craving a little Cookies & Cream or going for classic Tie-Dye, there are plenty more where that came from. *These cupcakes do not contain peanuts. However, all of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, and other allergens. Flavors Included 16 x Tie-Dye 16 x Cookie & Cream 16 x Triple Chocolate Fudge 16 x Red Velvet 16 x Cookie Dough 12 x Chocolate Chip Pancake 12 x Mint Cookie

    • Pick Your Flavors 100-Pack $144.00

      Perfect for your next party! Choose 100 of your favorite bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month. Your choice of: Tie-Dye Cookie & Cream PB&J (contains nuts) Cookie Dough Triple Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Chip Pancake Red Velvet Mint Cookie Mini of the Month: Christmas Sugar Cookie For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you.

  • Beverages & Add-Ons
    • Gold Happy Birthday Candles $7.95

    • Rainbow Happy Birthday Candles $6.00

    • Rainbow Stick Candles $3.00

    • Birthday Card $6.00

    • Birthday Gift Bag $3.00

    • Fiji Water (16.9 oz) $4.00

    • Sparkling Water (11 oz) $4.00

    • Fruit Punch (6 oz) $6.00

  • In-Store Special
    • Single $2.00

    • PYF 6-Pack $11.25

    • PYF 12-Pack $21.50

    • Pre-Pack 6-Pack $10.25

    • Pre-Pack 12-Pack $19.00

    • PYF 25-Pack $42.00

    • PYF 50-Pack $75.00

    • PYF 100-Pack $140.00

    • Pre-Pack 25-Pack $37.00

    • Pre-Pack 50-Pack $70.00

    • Pre-Pack 100-Pack $135.00

    • Gift Box $8.00

    • Vegan/GF 25-Pack $44.00

    • Mac 12-Pack $27.50

    • Vegan/GF 50-Pack $84.00

    • Vegan/GF 100-Pack $188.00

Menu for Baked by Melissa provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.