• New York
  • Bayport
  • Grey Horse Tavern

Grey Horse Tavern

(631) 472-1868
  • 291 Bayport Ave, Bayport, NY 11705
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • $$$$$
(631) 472-1868
  • Lunch
  • Brunch
  • Dinner
  • Snacks & Starters
    • Daily Soup $5

    • Fried Pickle $6

      Sriracha aioi

    • Maryland Lump Crab Cakes $15

      Old bay remoulade, lemon

    • Spicy Duck Confit Wontons $12

      Scallion & cream cheese, sambal sauce, local honey

    • Crispy Calamari $14

      Peppadew peppers, black olives, scallions, oregano, garlic-parmasan aioli

    • Fresh Burrata $14

      Olive tapenade, arugula pesto, grilled ciabatta

    • Quick Pickle Platter $10

      Green beans, cauliflower, red beets & baby carrots

  • Salads
    Add to any salad: Roasted chicken $6, fried chicken $7, marinated steak $9, marinated portobellos $5
    • North Fork Farmstand $7

      Baby greens, radish, carrot, cucumber, pickled beets, red onion, crispy potatoes & merlot vinaigrette

    • Pear Salad $7

      Baby greens & frisee, red pears, toasted pistachios, local honey balsamic vinaigrette

    • H. Club Salad $19

      Romaine, red cabbage, farm fresh egg, fruitwood bacon, cheddar, carrots, avocado, cherry tomatoes, roasted garlic-scallion dressing, bell & evans buttermilk fried chicken, garlic croutons

  • Classics
    Sides - Choose fries or house made slaw. Add $2 for green salad, organic broccolini or jicama salad. Extras - fries $5, house made slaw $3, organic broccolini $7, jicama salad $7
    • Crock of Mer's Mac & Cheese $9

      Gouda, cheddar, parmesan & goat cheeses, toasted shallot crumbs. Add bacon $2, mushrooms $1, berkshire pulled pork $3

    • Fish & Chips $19

      Ale battered local flounder, house made tartar, hand cut fries, coleslaw

    • Tavern Burger $19

      Meyer's all natural burger, sweet roll. W/ choice of side. Add $1 each - cheddar, swiss, blue, american, gouda, mushrooms, onions. Add $2 each - avocado, bacon marmalade, fruit wood double cut bacon

    • Quinoa & Red Bean Burger $14

      Sweet pickled slaw and chipotle mayo., onion poppyseed roll, choice of side.

    • Spinach & Artichoke Grilled Cheese $12

      Swiss, gouda, parmesan & garlic. w/ choice of side.

    • Bell & Evans Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich $15

      Cheddar, bacon marmalade, green tomatoes, hot honey, onion-poppyseed roll. choice of side

    • Berkshire Pulled Pork Sandwich $14

      Tavern BBQ sauce, house made slaw. onion-poppyseed roll, choice of side.

    • BLT & Avocado $12

      Fruitwood smoked double cut bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo, toasted whole grain bread, choice of side

  • Sunday Brunch Menu
    • Scottish Smoked Salmon & Bagel $12

      Scallion cream cheese, mixed greens, capers, sliced tomato & red onion served on a grilled everything or whole wheat bagel

    • Miss Amy's Fresh Biscuits & Sausage Gravy $10

      Add an egg your way $2

    • Fried Chicken & Waffles $16

      Bell & evans buttermilk fried chicken, brown butter waffle, whipped butter, organic maple syrup

    • The Egg Sandwich $12

      Griddled texas toast, two farm fresh eggs, cheddar, home fries, bacon or sausage

    • Tavern Breakfast $14

      2 Farm fresh eggs, choose berkshire pork sausage or fruitwood bacon, home fries, toasted whole bread

    • Mountain of Spuds $14

      A heaping plate of home fries topped with crispy bacon & melted cheddar, finished with two farm fresh eggs

    • Frittata & Green Salad $10

      Add $1 each - onion, mushrooms, tomato, spinach, potato, swiss, cheddar, gouda. Add $2 each - fruit wood bacon or housemade berkshire pork sausage $2 each

    • Classic Eggs Benedict $14

      2 Farm fresh poached eggs, black forest ham, hollandaise sauce, griddled whole grain ciabatta, green salad

    • Crabcake Benedict $18

      Classic eggs benedict with a crab cake

    • Banana & Brioche French Toast $12

      Fresh banana, organic maple syrup, miss amy's chocolate ganache and whipped butter

    • BLTA & E $14

      Grilled whole grain ciabatta, fruitwood bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, sunnyside up egg, french fries

    • Quinoa & Red Bean Burger $14

      Sweet pickled slaw and chipotle mayo, french fries

    • Tavern Burger $12

      Add $1 each - cheddar, swiss, gouda, blue, american, mushrooms, caramelized onions. Add $2 each - avocado, bacon, bacon marmalade.

  • Sides
    • Organic Steel Cut Oats $8

    • Fresh Fruit $8

    • Almonds $8

    • Organic Maple Syrup $8

    • Housemade Berkshire Pork Sausage $4

    • Fruitwood Double Cut Bacon $4

      Add an egg $2, all egg whites $3

  • Starters
    • Daily Soup $5

    • Quick Pickle Platter $10

      Green beans, cauliflower, red beets & baby carrots

    • Clams au Gratin $16

      With warm baguette

    • Spicy Duck Confit Wontons $12

      Scallion, cream cheese, sambal sauce, local honey

    • Fried Pickles $6

      Sriracha aioli

    • Crispy Calamari $14

      Peppadew peppers, black olives, scallions, oregano, garlic-parm aioli

    • Fresh Burrata $14

      Olive tapenade, arugula pesto, grilled ciabatta

    • Maryland Lump Crab Cakes $15

      Old bay remoulade, lemon

  • Salads
    Add to any salad - Roasted chicken $6, fried chicken $7, marinated steaK $9, or marinated portobellos $5
    • North Fork Farmstand $7

      Baby greens, radish, carrot, cucumber, pickled beets, red onion, crispy potatoes, merlot vinaigrette

    • Pear Salad $7

      Baby greens & frisee, red pears, toasted pistachios, local honey balsamic vinaigrette

    • H. Club Salad $19

      Romaine, red cabbage, grated farm fresh egg, fruitwood bacon, cheddar, carrots, avocado, cherry tomatoes, roasted garlic-scallion dressing, bell & evans buttermilk fried chicken, garlic croutons

  • Classics
    Sides - Choose hand cut fries or house made slaw add $2 for green salad, organic broccolini, jicama salad
    • Crock of Mer's Mac & Cheese $9

      Gouda, cheddar, parmesan & goat cheeses, toasted shallot crumbs. Add bacon $2, add mushrooms $1, add berkshire pulled pork $3

    • Fish & Chips $19

      Ale battered local flounder, house made tartar, hand cut fries & coleslaw

    • Tavern Burger $12

      Classic meyer's all natural burger, sweet roll, w/ choice of side. Add $1 /each - cheddar, swiss, blue, american, gouda, mushrooms, onions. Add $2/each - avocado, bacon marmalade, fruitwood double cut bacon.

    • Quinoa & Red Bean Burger $14

      Sweet pickled slaw, chipotle mayo, onion poppy seed roll w/ choice of side

    • Spinach & Artichoke Grilled Cheese $12

      Swiss, gouda, parmesan, garlic w/ choice of side

    • Bell & Evans Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich $15

      Cheddar, bacon marmalade, green tomatoes, hot honey, onion poppy seed roll choice of side

  • Supper
    Extras - fries $5, house made slaw $3, organic broccolini $7, jicama salad $7
    • Toasted Potato & Parmesan Gnocchi $26

      Bell & evans roasted chicken, pancetta, organic broccolini, garlic, brown butter and house made ricotta

    • Marinated Meyer's Natural 12oz Strip Steak $34

      Sauteed organic broccolini, sour cream-chive baked potato

    • Asparagus & Prosciutto Bucatini $24

      Wild mushrooms, spring garlic, prosciutto, parmesan and a touch of cream

    • Berkshire Pulled Pork $28

      Crispy polenta & jicama salad with citrus, mint cream, pomegranate molasses, pumpkin & sunflower seeds

    • Idaho Rainbow Trout $26

      Butter toasted homefries, herb roasted wild mushrooms, horseradish creme fraiche

    • Crab & Sweet Pea Risotto $24

      Tomato-espelette vinegar, fresh pea shoots

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.