Allmenus.com
  • New York
  • Bayport
  • The Fish Store

What is Grubhub

Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.

Next

Why use Grubhub

Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.

Previous
Start your order

The Fish Store

(631) 472-3018

We make ordering easy. Learn more

Google map
  • 836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY 11705
  • Restaurant website
  • American ,  Sandwiches ,  Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • The Fish Store

  • (631) 472-3018

    We make ordering easy.

  • Menu
  • Soup By The Cup Or Pint
    • New England Clam Chowder Soup $3.50

    • Lobster Bisque Soup $7.00

    • Seafood Bisque Soup $3.50

    • Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup $3.50

  • Fried Dinners
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Fish and Chips $11.99

    • Squid $10.99

    • Haddock $11.99

    • Chicken Fingers $9.99

    • Flounder Fil $12.99

    • Shrimp $12.99

    • Oysters $13.99

    • Fish Cakes $8.99

    • Clam Strips $8.99

    • Stuffed Flounder Fil $15.99

    • Crab Cakes (Old Bay) $8.99

    • Cajun Catfish $12.99

    • Sea Scallops $15.99

    • Spinach Stuffed Flounder Fil $15.99

    • Catfish $11.99

    • Buffalo Shrimp $11.99

    • Soft Shell Crabs $11.99

    • Bay Scallops $11.99

    • Cod $12.99

  • Fried Combo Dinners
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Bucket Of Steamers $16.00

      3 lbs. Seved in a white wine garlic sauce.

    • Shellfish Medley $12.99

      Shrimp, clam strips and bay scallops.

    • Sauteed Dinners $11.99

      Maryland style jumbo lump crab cakes (real blue claw meat).

    • Bucket Of Fish $14.99

      Choice of 3 (with fries, cole slaw, tartarand cocktail sauce) cod-haddock-catfish-cajun catfish-fish cakes-clam strips-buffalo shrimp.

    • Sauteed Dinners A $11.99

      Soft shell crabs sauteed with wine and seasoning.

    • Fisherman's Platter $13.99

      Shrimp, oysters, bay scallops, clam strips and flounder.

    • Bucket Of Mussels $13.00

      3 lbs. Served in a white wine garlic sauce or red sauce.

    • Hat Trick $12.99

      Shrimp, bay scallops and flounder.

    • Lobster Roll $11.99

      Real lobster salad on a toasted new England bun.

  • Broiled/Grilled Dinners
    All broiled dinners are cooked with butter, lemon, & white wine. Lemon butter dill, house marinade, mom's marinade, lemon butter herb, ginger teriyaki, cajun, caribbean, honey horseradish mustard or blackening.
    • Grouper $11.99

    • Stuffed Shrimp $12.99

      Broiled only.

    • Stuffed Flounder Broiled $14.99

      With seafood stuffing or with spinach and feta cheese (broiled only).

    • Tilapia $10.99

    • Catfish $11.99

    • Salmon Fillet $12.99

    • Mako $12.99

    • Mahi-Mahi $12.99

    • Shrimp $12.99

    • Wild Salmon $15.99

    • Orange Roughy $12.99

    • Red Snapper $11.99

    • Cajun Catfish $12.99

    • Flounder Fillet $13.99

      Broiled only.

    • Tuna $13.99

    • Bay Scallops $12.99

      Broiled only.

    • Cod $13.99

    • Basa $10.99

    • Shrimp Scampi $13.99

      Broiled only.

    • Sea Scallops $16.99

    • Swordfish Broiled $13.99

    • Chilean Sea Bass $16.99

  • Side Orders
    • Linguine with Marinara $4.99

    • Stuffed Mushrooms $6.99

    • Shrimp Cocktail $12.99

    • House Salad $5.99

    • Buffalo Shrimp $8.99

    • Calamari Squid $7.99

    • French Fries Large $2.99

    • Curly Fries $3.99

    • 1 Piece Stuffed Crab $2.50

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.99

    • French Fries Jumbo $4.99

    • Sweet Potato Fries $3.99

    • 4 Pieces Crab Cakes $6.99

    • Zucchini Sticks $3.99

    • Clam Strips $5.99

    • 3 Pieces Stuffed Clams $2.25

    • Onion Rings $3.99

  • On The Half Shell
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Little or Top Necks On 1/2 Shell $5.00

    • 1 Dozen Steamed Little or Top Necks $12.00

  • Whole Lobster Dinners
    Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 2 lb $36.99

    • 1 1/4 lb $20.99

    • 1 1/2- 1 3/4 lb $25.99

  • Lobster Tail Dinners
    Choice of one tail or two tails. Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 18 oz. Tail Dinner $19.99

    • 16 oz. Tail Dinner $16.99

  • Crab Leg Dinners
    Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 1 lb. Snow Crab Legs $19.99

    • 1 lb. King Crab Legs $32.99

  • Pasta Dinners Over Linguine
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Clam Sauce Red or White $12.99

    • Shrimp Parmigiana $15.99

    • Crispy Calamari Delight $14.99

    • Chicken Parmigiana $13.99

    • Mussels Marinara Red or In White Garlic Sauce $11.99

    • Linguine Shrimp Scampi $14.99

    • Shellfish Marinara Red Sauce or In A White Garlic Sauce $15.99

  • Sandwiches
    Choice of white or wheat bun. Comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, cole slaw and fries.
    • Soft Shell Crab Sandwich $12.99

      Seasonal.

    • Crab Cake Old Bay Sandwich $8.99

    • Flounder Fil Sandwich $9.99

  • Party Platters - Hot Appetizer Platter
    • Platter $29.99

      Onion rings, zucchini sticks, mozzarella sticks, fish cakes, crab cakes, clam strips, cocktail sauce, tartar sauce.

  • Cold Shrimp Platters
    With lemon, cocktail sauce, crab meat & garnish.
    • 5lb $80.00

    • 3lb $50.00

    • 2lb $35.00

    • 4lb $65.00

  • Florida Stone Crab Claw Platter
    Caught, cooked and shipped to us same day. Cracked florida stone crab claws on a platter served with drawn butter, the fish stores stone crab mustard, lemon & kale.
    • 5lb Tray $85.00

    • 3lb Tray $55.00

    • 2lb Tray $40.00

    • 4lb Tray $70.00

  • Lobster Bakes
    Prepared ready to cook lobster bakes in 2 pots 1-1/4 lb. Lobster, 10-clams, 1 lb mussels, 1 lb steamers, corn on the cob or baked potato.
    • Lobster Bakes $31.99

Menu for The Fish Store provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.