• New York
  • Bayport
  • The Fish Store

The Fish Store

(631) 472-3018
  • 836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY 11705
  • Website
  • American ,  Sandwiches ,  Seafood
  • $$$$$
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Soup By The Cup Or Pint
    • New England Clam Chowder Soup $3.5

    • Lobster Bisque Soup $7

    • Seafood Bisque Soup $3.5

    • Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup $3.5

  • Fried Dinners
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Fish and Chips $11.99

    • Squid $10.99

    • Haddock $11.99

    • Chicken Fingers $9.99

    • Flounder Fil $12.99

    • Shrimp $12.99

    • Oysters $13.99

    • Fish Cakes $8.99

    • Clam Strips $8.99

    • Stuffed Flounder Fil $15.99

    • Crab Cakes (Old Bay) $8.99

    • Cajun Catfish $12.99

    • Sea Scallops $15.99

    • Spinach Stuffed Flounder Fil $15.99

    • Catfish $11.99

    • Buffalo Shrimp $11.99

    • Soft Shell Crabs $11.99

    • Bay Scallops $11.99

    • Cod $12.99

  • Fried Combo Dinners
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Bucket Of Steamers $16

      3 lbs. Seved in a white wine garlic sauce.

    • Shellfish Medley $12.99

      Shrimp, clam strips and bay scallops.

    • Sauteed Dinners $11.99

      Maryland style jumbo lump crab cakes (real blue claw meat).

    • Bucket Of Fish $14.99

      Choice of 3 (with fries, cole slaw, tartarand cocktail sauce) cod-haddock-catfish-cajun catfish-fish cakes-clam strips-buffalo shrimp.

    • Sauteed Dinners A $11.99

      Soft shell crabs sauteed with wine and seasoning.

    • Fisherman's Platter $13.99

      Shrimp, oysters, bay scallops, clam strips and flounder.

    • Bucket Of Mussels $13

      3 lbs. Served in a white wine garlic sauce or red sauce.

    • Hat Trick $12.99

      Shrimp, bay scallops and flounder.

    • Lobster Roll $11.99

      Real lobster salad on a toasted new England bun.

  • Broiled/Grilled Dinners
    All broiled dinners are cooked with butter, lemon, & white wine. Lemon butter dill, house marinade, mom's marinade, lemon butter herb, ginger teriyaki, cajun, caribbean, honey horseradish mustard or blackening.
    • Grouper $11.99

    • Stuffed Shrimp $12.99

      Broiled only.

    • Stuffed Flounder Broiled $14.99

      With seafood stuffing or with spinach and feta cheese (broiled only).

    • Tilapia $10.99

    • Catfish $11.99

    • Salmon Fillet $12.99

    • Mako $12.99

    • Mahi-Mahi $12.99

    • Shrimp $12.99

    • Wild Salmon $15.99

    • Orange Roughy $12.99

    • Red Snapper $11.99

    • Cajun Catfish $12.99

    • Flounder Fillet $13.99

      Broiled only.

    • Tuna $13.99

    • Bay Scallops $12.99

      Broiled only.

    • Cod $13.99

    • Basa $10.99

    • Shrimp Scampi $13.99

      Broiled only.

    • Sea Scallops $16.99

    • Swordfish Broiled $13.99

    • Chilean Sea Bass $16.99

  • Side Orders
    • Linguine with Marinara $4.99

    • Stuffed Mushrooms $6.99

    • Shrimp Cocktail $12.99

    • House Salad $5.99

    • Buffalo Shrimp $8.99

    • Calamari Squid $7.99

    • French Fries Large $2.99

    • Curly Fries $3.99

    • 1 Piece Stuffed Crab $2.5

    • Mozzarella Sticks $5.99

    • French Fries Jumbo $4.99

    • Sweet Potato Fries $3.99

    • 4 Pieces Crab Cakes $6.99

    • Zucchini Sticks $3.99

    • Clam Strips $5.99

    • 3 Pieces Stuffed Clams $2.25

    • Onion Rings $3.99

  • On The Half Shell
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Little or Top Necks On 1/2 Shell $5

    • 1 Dozen Steamed Little or Top Necks $12

  • Whole Lobster Dinners
    Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 2 lb $36.99

    • 1 1/4 lb $20.99

    • 1 1/2- 1 3/4 lb $25.99

  • Lobster Tail Dinners
    Choice of one tail or two tails. Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 18 oz. Tail Dinner $19.99

    • 16 oz. Tail Dinner $16.99

  • Crab Leg Dinners
    Served with cole slaw, lemon, butter & choice of fries, rice or baked potato.
    • 1 lb. Snow Crab Legs $19.99

    • 1 lb. King Crab Legs $32.99

  • Pasta Dinners Over Linguine
    All dinners served with cole slaw, tartar sauce, lemon. Also your choice of fries, rice or baked potato. All product fried is in 0 % trans fat vegetable oil.
    • Clam Sauce Red or White $12.99

    • Shrimp Parmigiana $15.99

    • Crispy Calamari Delight $14.99

    • Chicken Parmigiana $13.99

    • Mussels Marinara Red or In White Garlic Sauce $11.99

    • Linguine Shrimp Scampi $14.99

    • Shellfish Marinara Red Sauce or In A White Garlic Sauce $15.99

  • Sandwiches
    Choice of white or wheat bun. Comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, cole slaw and fries.
    • Soft Shell Crab Sandwich $12.99

      Seasonal.

    • Crab Cake Old Bay Sandwich $8.99

    • Flounder Fil Sandwich $9.99

  • Party Platters - Hot Appetizer Platter
    • Platter $29.99

      Onion rings, zucchini sticks, mozzarella sticks, fish cakes, crab cakes, clam strips, cocktail sauce, tartar sauce.

  • Cold Shrimp Platters
    With lemon, cocktail sauce, crab meat & garnish.
    • 5lb $80

    • 3lb $50

    • 2lb $35

    • 4lb $65

  • Florida Stone Crab Claw Platter
    Caught, cooked and shipped to us same day. Cracked florida stone crab claws on a platter served with drawn butter, the fish stores stone crab mustard, lemon & kale.
    • 5lb Tray $85

    • 3lb Tray $55

    • 2lb Tray $40

    • 4lb Tray $70

  • Lobster Bakes
    Prepared ready to cook lobster bakes in 2 pots 1-1/4 lb. Lobster, 10-clams, 1 lb mussels, 1 lb steamers, corn on the cob or baked potato.
    • Lobster Bakes $31.99

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.