• New York
  • Batavia
  • Settler's Restaurant

Settler's Restaurant

(585) 343-7443
  • 353 W Main St, Batavia, NY 14020
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • $$$$$
(585) 343-7443
  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Eggs 'N Things
    Substitute hash browns for $0.50, extrasubstitute egg beaters or egg whites for S1.00 extra substitute italian sausage or turkey sausage $1.00
    • Eggs Only $0.99

    • With Home Fries & Toast $3.49

    • Home Fries & Sausage, Bacon or Ham & Toast $4.49

    • With Toast & Jelly $2.49

    • Sausage, Bacon or Ham & Toast $3.99

  • Omelettes
    All omelettes are made with 3 extra large eggs andare served with potatoes, toast & jelly. Cheese choices: american, cheddar or mozzarella make any omelette a scrambler for $1.00 extra sub 2pancakes instead of toast for $1.00substutute italian sausage or turkey sausage $1.00 extra substitute egg beaters or egg whites for $1.00 extra. Substitute hash browns for$0.50 extra
    • Cheese Lovers Omelette $6.49

      American, cheddar, mozzarella

    • Ham & Cheese Omelette $5.99

    • Western Omelette $6.99

      With cheese

    • Greek Country Omelette $6.99

      Feta cheese, tomato and spinach

    • Meat Lovers' Omelette $7.99

      Stuffed with ham, bacon, sausage, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses

    • Mushroom & Cheese Omelette $6.99

    • Old Country Omelette $7.99

      Turkey, spinach, Swiss and tomato

    • Asparagus Omelette $6.99

      Prepared with fresh asparagus and topped with hollandaise sauce

    • Vegetable Omelette $7.49

      Asparagus, broccoli, tomato, peppers, onions and mushrooms

    • Steak Omelette $7.99

      Sirloin steak, sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese

    • Philly Steak Omelette $7.99

      Shaved steak, sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms, with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses

    • Broccoli & Cheese Omelette $6.99

    • Godfather Omelette $7.99

      Italian sausage, sauteed peppers, onions and mushrooms, with mozzarella cheese

    • "Everything" Omelette $8.49

      Our meat lovers omelette with the addition of peppers, onion and tomato

  • French Toast
    Waffles, pancakes & french toast served with syrup and butteradd. Add bacon, sausage or ham $1.00
    • French Toast $3.99

    • L.A. French Toast $4.99

    • Italian French Toast $4.49

  • Waffles
    Waffles, pancakes & french toast served with syrup and butter. Add bacon, sausage or ham $1.00
    • Belgian Waffle $4.99

      With syrupadd fresh blueberries, raspberries,strawberries or black raspberries for $0.50 eachadd mixedberries $1.00, add ice cream $1.00 extra

  • Pancakes
    Waffles, pancakes & french toast served with syrup and butter. Add bacon, sausage or ham $1.00
    • Pancakes $3.99

    • Specialty Pancakes $4.49

      Add bananas, chocolate chips or M & M's

  • Baked Goods
    Cream cheese, peanut butter or honey add $0.49 each
    • Bagel $1.99

    • Hard Roll $1.79

    • Assorted Muffins $2.99

    • Toast $1.49

      Texas, raisin, sourdough, white, italian, 12 grain, english muffin, rye or whole wheat

    • Grilled Pita Bread $1.99

    • Assorted Danish $3.99

    • Gluten-free Rye Bread $2.49

  • Breakfast Specials
    Substitute italian sausage or turkey sausage $1.00 extrasubstitute egg beaters or egg whites for $1.00extrasub 2 pancakes instead of toast for $1.00substitute hash browns for $0.50 extra
    • Pancake Special $5.99

      Two pancakes, two eggs, two bacon, and one sausage patty

    • Fruit Plate (Seasonal) $6.99

      With cottage cheese

    • Sausage & Gravy $5.99

      Over light and fluffy biscuits 1/2 Order $4.99

    • Corned Beef Hash & Eggs $6.99

      Two eggs, any style with corned beef hash, home fries and toast

    • Steak & Eggs $7.49

      With home fries and toast 6 oz, Sirloin 12 oz. NY Strip Steak $12.99

    • Breakfast Wrap $7.49

      Choice of meat: bacon, sausage or ham with scrambled eggs, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses in a garlic herb wrap, with home fries. Add a second meat for $1.00 more

    • Breakfast Melt $6.49

      2 scrambled eggs, american cheese, choice of 1 meat, bacon, ham, sausage patty, choice of bread (hard roll, bagel, english muffin, grilled sourdough or pita. Served with home fries

    • Old Fashioned Oatmeal $2.99

      Piping hot, served with milk Cup $2.49. Add raisins or bananas included. Add mixed berries $1.00

    • 1 Breakfast $6.49

      Two eggs, two pancakes, 1 sausage patty, and home fries

    • Chicken Fried Steak $6.99

      With two eggs, toast and home fries

    • Souvlaki Breakfast $7.49

      Marinated chicken or beef souvlaki cooked with onions and peppers, served with two eggs any style, home fries, tzatziki sauce and toast

    • Pork Chop & Eggs $7.49

      Grilled pork chop, 2 eggs any style, home fries and toast

    • Breakfast Quesadilla $7.99

      crambled eggs, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, peppers, onions, tomato, and choice of one meat wrapped in a tortilla shell. Served with home fries and a side of salsa and sour cream

  • Eggs Benedict Specials
    • Traditional Eggs Benedict $7.49

      2 Poached eggs with Canadian bacon on and English Muffin topped with Hollandaise sauce, served with home fries

    • Crab Cakes Benedict $8.99

      Toasted English Muffin topped with spinach, 2 poached eggs with two maryland style crab cakes and hollandaise sauce, served with home fries

    • Corned Beef Hash Benedict $8.99

      English Muffin topped with corned beef hash, 2 poached eggs and Hollandaise sauce, served with home fries

    • Eggs Florentine $7.49

      Toasted English Muffin topped with spinach, two poached eggs, Hollandaise sauce and served with home fries

    • Southern Benedict $8.99

      Grilled biscuits topped with sausage patties, 2 scrambled eggs and sausage gravy, served with home fries

    • Oscar Benedict $8.99

      2 poached eggs topped with asparagus, crab meat and Hollandaise sauce over an english muffin, served with home fries

  • Sides
    • Sides $2.49

    • Bacon (3) or Sausage Patty (2) $2.49

    • Corned Beef Hash $3.49

    • Fruit Cup $3.99

    • Hash Browns $2.99

    • Sliced Ham $2.49

    • Sausage Gravy $2.99

      Cup

  • Kid's Korner
    10 Years old and under all kid's meals come with choice of small juice or mil
    • Short Stack of Pancakes (2) $3.49

      Add bananas, chocolate chips, M & M's $1.00

    • Egg & Toast $2.99

      With 2 bacon or 1 sausage

    • Waffle (1) $2.99

    • Pancake & Meat $3.49

      With 2 bacon or 1 sausage

  • Beverages
    • Hot Tea $1.79

      Any flavor

    • Juice $1.79

      O.J., tomato, apple, grapefruit

    • Hot Chocolate $1.99

      with whipped cream

    • Milk $1.99

      White or chocolate

    • Coffee $1.79

    • Soft Drinks $1.99

      Pepsi products free refills

  • Wraps & Pitas
    Wrap choice: garlic, jalapeno cheddar, plain. All wraps or pitas are served with potato chips and a pickle. Add fries $0.99, add fries, cup of soup, and coleslaw $1.99
    • Buffalo Chicken $7.49

      Chicken fingers with cheddar cheese and bacon dressed with bleu cheese dressing and hot sauce.

    • Chicken or Beef Souvlaki $7.49

      Dressed with feta cheese, onions, and tzatziki sauce

    • Steak & Three Cheese $7.49

      Shaved steak tossed with sauteed peppers and onions, topped with cheddar, mozzarella and American cheeses

    • Bacon Cheeseburger $7.49

      Dressed with onions and bacon

    • Chicken Cordon Bleu $7.49

      Filet of chicken breast topped with ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo

    • Cold Cut Wrap or Pita $6.99

      Turkey, roast beef, ham, tuna salad, or chicken salad with choice of cheese, tomato, lettuce, and mayo

  • Sandwiches
    All sandwiches are served with potato chips and a pickle. Add fries $0.99, add fries, cup of soup, and coleslaw $1.99
    • Zwiegles Red Hot $3.99

    • Zwiegles Red Hot $4.99

    • Deli Sandwiches $4.99

      Choose from turkey, ham, roast beef, tuna salad, BLT, or chicken salad. Served on white bread with lettuce and mayo. Make any sandwich a Club for $6.99

    • Grilled Cheese $4.49

      With American or Swiss, wth ham or bacon $4.99

    • Western Sandwich $4.49

      With cheese

  • Lighter Fare
    • Ground Beef Patty $6.99

      Char broiled and garnished with peach halves, a scoop of cottage cheese, sliced tomato, and vegetable

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $6.99

      Grilled chicken breast over a bend of spring mix lettuce with parmesan cheese, croutons, and bacon bits with caesar dressing

    • Chef Salad $6.49

      Salad greens topped with julienne of ham, turkey, Swiss and American cheese, sliced tomato, and a hard boiled egg with choice of dressing

    • Greek Chicken Salad $6.99

      Greek salad topped with chunks of chicken souvlaki served with our house dressing and choice of garlic or pita bread

  • Specialty Sandwiches
    All sandwiches are served with potato chips and a pickle. Add fries $0.99. Add fries, cup of soup, and coleslaw $1.99
    • Crunchy Chicken Melt $7.49

      Chicken fingers on grilled Texas toast with cheddar cheese, bacon, and tomatoes

    • Steak Sandwich $7.49

      6 oz. sirloin steak served on a grilled hoagie roll with sauteed peppers and onions

    • Settler's Beef on Weck $7.49

      Choice top sirloin thinly sliced served on a kimmelweck roll

    • Mr. Reuben $7.49

      Thinly sliced corned beef or turkey smothered with tasty Swiss cheese and sauerkraut served on grilled rye bread

    • French Dip-It $6.99

      Thin slices of freshly roasted USDA choice beef dipped in natural juices and served on a hoagie roll

    • The Beef Lover $7.49

      Shaved top sirloin beef served on a grilled hoagie roll smothered with cheese, peppers, and onions

    • Chicken Finger Sub $7.99

      On a sub roll with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo

    • Settler's Chicken Supreme $6.99

      Chicken breast on a soft Kaiser roll dressed with Swiss cheese and bacon

    • Grilled Tuna $7.49

      Served with melted American cheese and tomato on grilled rye bread

    • Hot Turkey or Beef $6.99

      With gravy on white bread

    • Turkey Melt $6.99

      Served on grilled sourdough with American cheese, tomato, and bacon

    • Chicken Souvlaki Melt $6.99

      On grilled Texas toast with feta cheese, tomatoes, bacon, and tzatziki sauce

    • Italian Sausage $7.49

      1/4 lb. chopped italian style sausage on a hoagie roll with fried peppers and onions

  • Burger Specialties
    All 6 oz. steak burgers are served with a pickle and fries. Add cup of soup and coleslaw $1.99
    • Bleu Moon Burger $7.49

      6 oz. steak burger topped with mushrooms, bleu cheese, and lettuce

    • All American $6.99

      Dressed bacon cheeseburger

    • Pepper Jack Burger $6.99

      6 oz. steak burger topped with jalapenos and pepper jack cheese

    • Western Burger $6.99

      6 oz. steak burger topped with bacon, onion straws, BBQ sauce, and cheddar

    • Patty Melt $6.99

      1/4 lb. burger on grilled rye with Swiss cheese, fried mushrooms, onions, and bacon

    • Settler Melt $7.49

      1/2 lb. burger topped with mozzarella, mushrooms, onions, and bacon, served on grilled sourdough

    • Settler Burger $7.49

      1/2 lb. burger topped with mozzarella cheese, sauteed mushrooms and onions with bacon

    • Sky Burger $7.99

      Two 6 oz. steakburgers dressed with bacon & cheese

  • Side Dishes
    • Cup of Soup $2.49

    • Potato or Macaroni Salad $1.99

      Seasonal

    • Hash Browns $1.99

    • Apple Sauce $1.99

    • Potato Choice $1.99

    • Side Salad $2.99

    • Garlic Bread $1.49

    • Bowl of Soup $2.99

    • Onion Rings $2.49

    • Cottage Cheese $1.99

    • Fresh Fruit Plate $2.99

    • Vegetable $1.49

    • Cole Slaw $1.49

  • Lunch Specials
    Soup & Sandwich
    • Fish sandwich topped with lettuce. Potato chips, cup of soup, coleslaw $8.49 no roll & no lettuce $7.99

    • Club Special $7.99

      Tuna on rye. Dressed with american cheese. Potato chips, cup of soup, coleslaw

    • Crab Cake Melt $8.99

      2 Crab cakes on grilled sourdough, topped with canadian bacon, thousand island, & swiss cheese. Served with potato chips, coleslaw & cup of soup

    • Greek Burger $8.99

      6oz Steak burger on a grilled bagel, dressed with feta, bacon, tomato and Spinach. Served with potato chips, coleslaw, & a cup of soup

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad $8.99

      Crisp mixed greens topped with buffalo chicken fingers, tomatoes, cheddar, & crumble bleu. Served with celery sticks, Cup of soup

    • Meat lovers Submarine $8.99

      Thinly sliced turkey, roast beef, & ham on a toasted sub roll with lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese, & mayo. Served with potato chips, cup of soup, coleslaw

  • Entrees
    Served with soup of the day or a salad, potato, bread and butter
    • Pork Chops $10.49

      2 delicious center cut grilled chops with applesauce

    • N.Y. Strip Steak $13.99

      Tasty, tender, 12 oz. strip steak cooked to order, topped with sauteed mushrooms, and onions

    • Chicken Fingers (5) $9.99

    • Baby Beef Liver $8.99

      Generous portion of the best baby beef liver in the area. Cooked tasty and tender, topped with fried onions, peppers, and bacon

    • Roast Turkey Dinner $8.99

      Fresh roasted turkey breast over stuffing with gravy

    • Fried Chicken $9.99

      4 delicious, golden brown pieces of the finest quality chicken, fried light and crisp

    • Souvlaki Dinner $9.99

      Marinated beef or chicken served over rice with a Greek salad, house dressing and choice of garlic or pita bread

    • Settler's Chopped Steak $9.49

      Made from lean flavorful beef ground and chopped cooked to order with sauteed fried onions and peppers with brown gravy

    • Baked Meatloaf $8.99

      Try our own oven baked meatloaf lightly seasoned and served with brown gravy

    • Smothered Chicken $10.99

      Two 5 oz. chicken breasts topped with sauteed peppers, onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese

  • Pasta
    Served with soup of the day or a salad, potato, bread and butter
    • Italian Platter $11.99

      Portion of lasagna, spaghetti, one meatball, and Italian sausage

    • Pasta $8.99

      Spaghetti or Rigatoni topped with our homemade sauce and 2 meatballs or 1 Italian sausage

    • Lasagna $9.99

      Layers of noodles with red sauce, ricotta, and parmesan cheese, ground beef, and Italian seasonings

    • Fresh Chicken or Veal Parmesan $10.99

      Breaded chicken breast or veal medallion topped with mozzarella cheese and italian style sauce, served with choice of pasta

  • Seafood
    Served with soup of the day or a salad, potato, bread and butter
    • Fish Fry $10.99

      Large portion of deep water fish filet lightly breaded.

    • Shrimp Basket $8.99

      Over twenty lightly breaded shrimp fried golden brown, served with cocktail or tartar sauce

  • Kid's Corner
    10 Years Old and Under. All Kid's Meals come with choice of small juice or milk
    • Egg & Toast $2.99

      With 2 bacon or 1 sausage

    • Short Stack of Pancakes (2) $3.49

      Add bananas, chocolate chips, M & M's $1.00

    • Turkey Dinner $4.99

      Turkey, mashed potatoes, corn, and gravy

    • Chicken Fingers $5.99

      Two chicken fingers with French fries

    • Hot Dog $3.99

      Served with fries

    • Pancake & Meat $3.49

      With 2 bacon or 1 sausage

    • Waffle (1) $2.99

    • Spaghetti $4.99

      Includes one meatball, bread, and butter

    • Hamburger & Fries $4.99

      Served with cheese $5.49

    • Grilled Cheese $3.99

      Served with fries

  • Specials
    • Fish Fry Dinner $10.99

      Beer battered and deep fried golden brown, or broiled, cajun, breaded, italian broiled, peppers, onions, sauce, mozz cheese. Choice of potato, coleslaw, cup soup or salad

    • Fishermans Platter $11.99

      Breaded flounder, shrimp, & scallops. Served with choice of potato, cup of soup, salad

    • Macaroni & Cheese $9.99

      Homemade served with a cup of soup & toss salad

    • Fettuccini Alfredo $13.99

      Alfredo served over fettuccin, salad and cup of soup $10.99. Add chicken $11.99. Add chicken & broccoli $12.99. seafood alfredo add crab, shrimp, scallops

    • Breaded Shrimp Basket -OR- Clam Strip Dinner $9.99

      Choice of potato, cup of soup, side salad

    • Fresh Veal or Chicken Parmesan $11.99

      Breaded & Fried. Choice of pasta. Cup of soup, toss salad

    • Homemade Lasagna $10.99

      Homemade. Served with toss salad & a cup of soup

    • 12oz Cajun Grilled Strip Steak $14.99

      12oz NY Strip Steak with Cajun Spices. Topped with Caramelized Onions & Crumble Bleu Cheese. Served with a choice of potato, cup of soup, & toss salad

    • Spaghetti Or Rigaton $9.99

      2. Meatballs or 1. Italian Sausage. Homemade Sauce. Salad, Cup of Soup

  • Homemade Soups
    • Minestrone

    • New England Clam Chowder

    • Homemade Chili

    • Chicken Noodle

    • Hamburger Noodle

  • Desserts
    • Ice Cream Sundae $2.99

    • Pie $2.99

      A la Mode $3.99

    • Milkshake $3.99

      Ask server for selection or flavor

    • Rice Pudding $1.99

      With whipped cream $2.29

    • Hot Fudge Sundae $3.49

    • Dish of Ice Cream $2.49

    • Strawberry Shortcake $3.59

      In season with ice cream $3.99

    • Cheesecake $2.99

      With strawberries $3.49

  • Beverages
    • Soft Drinks $1.99

      Pepsi, diet pepsi, loganberry, sierra mist, mug root beer, dr. pepper, mountain dew, free refills

    • Milk $1.99

      Available in white or chocolate

    • Juice $1.79

      O.J., tomato, apple, grapefruit, lemonade

    • Hot Chocolate $1.69

      Served with whipped cream

    • Hot Tea $1.49

      Any flavor

    • Iced Tea $1.69

      Available in regular or raspberry

    • Coffee $1.49

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.