• New York
  • Amherst
  • Black & Blue Steak & Crab

Black & Blue Steak & Crab

(716) 839-2525
  • 5493 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14221
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American ,  Steak
(716) 839-2525
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    • Oysters on the Half Shell $2.75

      Each ask your server for today's selection

    • Large Oyster Sampler (8 Pieces) $19.95

    • Small Oyster Sampler (4 Pieces) $10.95

    • Seafood Platter $79.95

      Serves $4.00 assorted fresh, chilled seafood

    • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $13.5

      Poached and chilled with a spicy citrus cocktail sauce

    • B&B Shrimp $9.95

      Crispy fried rock shrimp tossed with a sweet & spicy thai chili glaze

    • Blue Crab Cocktail $12.5

      Lump crab meat served chilled with a house dipping sauce

    • Tuna Tartare $13.95

      Seasoned, diced yellowfin tuna with cucumber slaw & crispy rock shrimp

    • Potato Croquettes $7.95

      Chorizo, piquillo peppers and pepper jack cheese with a tamarind BBQ sauce

    • Crab Cake $16.95

      Colossal and jumbo lump blue crab cake, pan seared with an avocado lime aioli

    • Kobe Meatballs $10.95

      Slow roasted kobe beef with caramelized onions and a roasted garlic cream sauce

    • Fried Calamari $9.95

      With watercress, cilantro, cashews, sweet & spicy ponzu and sesame tempura crisps

    • Crab & Lobster Fondue $12.95

      Sweet crab & maine lobster, parmigiano reggiano cheese and toasted pita chips

    • Steak Tartare $13.95

      Diced tenderloin with onion, garlic, capers, horseradish aioli, truffle oil and panko crusted soft boiled egg

  • Soups and Salads
    • Maryland She-Crab Soup $8.95

    • Lobster Bisque $9.95

    • Caesar Salad $8.5

      Hearts of romaine, garlic croutons and fresh shaved parmesan in a classic dressing

    • Mixed Greens $7.5

      Mesclun greens and cornbread croutons tossed in a white balsamic vinaigrette

    • Beefsteak Tomato Salad $8.5

      Quartered and tossed in a sweet basil vinaigrette with fresh mozzarella and red onion

    • Chop Salad $8.5

      Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, blue cheese, bacon and toasted chick peas in a sweet & sour vinaigrette

    • Black & Blue Salad $14.95

      Seasoned beef tenderloin tips over baby spinach with grilled onions, oven dried tomatoes and crispy bacon croutons in a bacon blue cheese viniagrette

  • Fish
    • Black Grouper $29.95

      Line caught black grouper with roasted artichokes, cipollini onions, kalamata olives, blistered tomatoes, scallion pesto and black garlic vinaigrette

    • Red Snapper $32.95

      Line caught red snapper, quinoa pilaf with currants, baby arugula and golden beets over a butternut squash puree, finished with crispy pickled shallots

    • Ahi Tuna $31.95

      Filet mignon of hawaiian yellow fin tuna seared over a gingered potato salad, soy glazed carrots and sugar snap peas

    • Atlantic Salmon $28.95

      Crispy pan seared over a cauliflower and potato puree with fennel & spinach confit

  • Shellfish
    • Seared Sea Scallops $32.95

      Jumbo scallops with a pomegranate glaze over grilled vegetable risotto

    • Lump Maryland Blue Crab $29.95

      De shelled, lump crab steamed and served with an herb infused butter and mustard aioli with your choice of side

    • Alaskan King Crab Legs $41.95

      Served pre cracked with your choice of side

    • Live Maine Lobster $39.95

      Comparable to a 1½ lb lobster de shelled, steamed & served with drawn butter comes with your choice of side

    • Whole Live Maine Lobster $49.95

      2¼ lb steamed lobster, pre cracked and served with drawn butter & lemon comes with your choice of side

    • North Atlantic Lobster Tail $59.95

      Broiled jumbo 18oz cold water tail served with drawn butter and your choice of side

  • House Specialties
    • Short Ribs $29.95

      Slow braised beef shortrib, onion rings and blue cheese mashed potatoes

    • Roasted Chicken $19.95

      Oven roasted herb encrusted half chicken with a seared potato cake, green beans & red onion

    • Roasted Piquillo Peppers $18.95

      Stuffed with saffron rice and a three grain saute with a balsamic glaze

  • Steaks and Chops
    Comes with your choice of one side & one sauce. Sauces: Red wine demi glace, horseradish cream, gorgonzola cream, b&b steak sauce, bearnaise, black truffle butter. Steak temp guide: Blue: Very red cool center, medium rare: Red warm center, medium: Pink hot center, medium well: Dull pink center, well: Broiled throughout
    • Center Cut Sirloin (9 oz) $26.95

    • N.Y. Strip (12 oz) $32.95

    • N.Y. Strip (16 oz) $39.95

    • Filet Mignon (8 oz) $33.95

    • Filet Mignon (12 oz) $47.95

    • Kansas City Strip (14 oz) $36.95

    • Ribeye (14 oz) $39.95

    • Porterhouse (20 oz) $46.95

    • Bone-In Cowboy Ribeye (21 oz) $48.95

    • Lamb Chops (12 oz) $34.95

  • Addons
    • Jumbo Shrimp $6.5

    • Lump Blue Crab (4 oz) $10.5

    • Maine Lobster Tail (3 oz) $13.95

    • Alaskan King Crab Legs (8 oz) $17.95

    • Jumbo Lobster Tail (18 oz) $52.95

  • Steakhouse Specialties
    • Steak Au Poivre $36.95

      12 oz NY strip steak with a brandy & black peppercorn sauce, hash brown rosti cake and green beans

    • Steak Arabica $28.95

      Coffee & cocoa rubbed 9 oz center cut sirloin, sweet potato dumpling and sauteed spinach

    • Steak Garlic $36.95

      12 oz NY strip with sweet whole roasted garlic, minced garlic butter, button mushrooms and a crispy chorizo & pepper jack potato cake

    • Surf & Turf $34.95

      9 oz center cut sirloin & pan-seared sea scallops with a lemon butter sauce, asparagus and vegetable risotto

  • Sides
    • Garlic Mashed Potatoes $6.5

    • Shoe String Fries $6.5

    • White Cheddar Fries $6.5

    • Sweet Potato Dumplings $6.5

    • Vidalia Onion Rings $6.5

    • Roasted Button Mushrooms $6.5

    • Grilled Asparagus $6.5

    • Creamy Spinach $6.5

    • Green Beans $6.5

    • Orzo Mac & Cheese $6.5

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.