• New Jersey
  • Toms River
  • Old Time Tavern

Old Time Tavern

(732) 349-8778
  • North Main St., Toms River, NJ 08753
  • Website
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American
(732) 349-8778
  • Dinner
  • Soups & Starters
    our tantalizing selection of soups and starters is meant to be shared amongst friends.
    • Boneless Buffalo Wings $5.99

      chicken strips basted in hot sauce with celery sticks and bleu cheese dip

    • Spinach & Artichoke Dip $5.99

      with tri-color tortilla chips for dipping

    • Mozzarella Tower $5.99

      stacked with roasted pepper, sliced tomato, fresh basil and garlic olive oil

    • Navajo Nachos $6.99

      crisp tortilla chips layered with spicy chili, picante cheese sauce, tomatoes, scallions, black olives and jalapeno peppers served with a side of sour cream

    • The "OTT" Cheesy Combo $9.99

      cheesy bacon skins, mozzarella sticks, cheddar broccoli bites, and cream cheese jalapeno poppers served with sour cream and zesty marinara dipping sauce

    • Crab Stuffed Mushrooms $6.99

      silver dollar mushrooms baked with our seasoned crab stuffing and champagne cream

    • Fried Calamari $7.99

      golden fried in lightly seasoned flour served with zesty marinara sauce

    • Buffalo Calamari $8.99

      tossed in hot sauce with crumbled bleu cheese

    • Shrimp Cocktail $6.99

      chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce, crackers and lemon

    • Fresh Whole Mussels $7.99

      simmered in your choice of scampi, marinara, or spicy fra diavolo sauces

    • Shrimp Luciano $8.99

      a quartet of smoked mozzarella stuffed shrimp baked in a crisp bacon wrapper laced with champagne cream

    • Clams Casino $6.99

      a half dozen top neck clams baked with onions, peppers and bacon

    • Chef's Soup of the Day $1.99

      a piping hot cup of our tantalizing soup enjoy a crockful for just 2.99

    • Baked Onion Soup $3.99

      a crock of homemade onion soup baked with mozzarella cheese

  • Special Occasions
    oruvate or semi-private dining complete packages for lunch & dinner parties business meetings & seminars weddings, showers, anniversaries, & engagement parties parties from 20 to 180 people
    • Special Occasions $0

  • Butcher Block
    served with your choice of creamy coleslaw, french fries, or seasoned mashed potatoes
    • Prime Rib Sandwich $9.99

      sliced prime rib grilled with melted cheddar cheese and onion rings on a toasted garlic roll

    • Grilled Vegetable Panini $7.99

      marinated eggplant with roasted red pepper, sliced tomato and fresh mozzarella cheese grilled on onion focaccia bread

    • Chicken Ranchero Wrap $8.5

      grilled BBQ chicken with cheddar-jack cheese, ranch dressing, shredded lettuce and tomato in a garlic-herb tortilla wrapper

    • Tavern Rueben $9.5

      steamed corned beef with sauerkraut, russian dressing and swiss cheese on toasted rye

    • Turkey Club $9.5

      fresh roasted turkey with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise double decker on white toast

    • California Chicken $7.99

      flame-grilled marinated chicken breast with lettuce, tomato and red onion on a kaiser roll

    • "Philly" Cheese Steak $8.5

      shaved steak sauteed with onions and melted american cheese on a toasted torpedo roll

  • Black Angus Burgers
    served on a kaiser roll with lettuce and tomato your choice of French fries, coleslaw, or seasoned mashed potatoes
    • Classic Burger $7.99

      an 8ounce certified black angus beef patty grilled to your preference

    • Build Your Own Burger Toppings $0

      sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers (each, any tow, or all three) cheeses: american, cheddar, swiss, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, bleu cheese. add $1.00 each

    • Old Time Favorite Topping Combinations $0

      backyard BBQ-bacon-cheese mushroom-cheddar-melt bruschetta mozzarella add $ 2.00 each

  • Fresh Salads
    with our compleiments enjoy a cup of our chef's daily soup selections while we prepare your sandwich, burger, or salad
    • Southwest Chicken $9.99

      crisp tortilla shell filled with mixed greens, olives, tomatoes, scallions, cheddar-jack cheese, and sliced spicy chicken breast & our salsa dressing

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar $8.99

      grilled marinated chicken breast sliced over classic caesar salad

    • Chicken Waldorf Salad $9.99

      chicken breast tossed with raisins, walnuts and apples in our chef's creamy dressing on a bed of lettuce

    • Tuscany Balsamic Salad $8.99

      roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and artichoke hearts over mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette

  • Chef's Choice
    • Grilled Asian Chicken $12.99

      sliced marinated chicken tossed with sesame seared vegetables in a teriyaki glaze over asian noodles

    • Baked Salmon Riviera $14.99

      fresh atlantic salmon fillet served on a bed of seasoned spinach with classic beurre blanc

    • Shrimp & Scallops Sicily $15.99

      sweet gulf shrimp and deep sea scallops with julienne roasted peppers baked in fresh tarragon butter

    • Chicken Portobello Bruschetta $13.99

      topped with sliced portobello and diced tomato in garlic wine sauce over fresh sauteed spinach

    • Caribbean Mahi Mahi $14.99

      pan seared in a lightly seasoned coating with fresh pineapple-mango salsa served over rice pilaf

    • Tavern Mixed Grill $15.99

      center cut loin lamb chop, boneless chicken breast, and tender pork chop over garlic mashed potatoes drizzled with balsamic demiglace

  • From The Grill
    served with chef's vegetable and your choice of french fries, rice pilaf, roasted, seasoned mashed or baked potatoes
    • 24 oz Porterhouse Steak $27.99

      the best of both steaks.. sirloin and tenderloin all on one bone served sizzling with onion rings

    • 16 oz. T- Bone Steak $19.99

      hand rubbed with our robust seasoning

    • 10 oz. New York Strip $15.99

      genuine boneless strip steak cut from the loin

    • Filet Mignon $19.99

      tender and juicy center cut beef tenderloin

    • Petit Filet $15.99

      a lighter cut of our filet mignon

    • Great Steak Additions Sauteed Onions or Mushrooms or Both $1.5

    • Great Steak Additions Golden Fried Onion Rings $2.5

    • Great Steak Additions Broiled 4 ounce Lobster $9

  • Seafood
    served with chef's vegetable and your choice of french fries, rice pilaf, seasoned mashed, roasted or baked potatoes (unless otherwise specified)
    • Shrimp Scampi $15.99

      eight jumbo shrimp simmered in garlic wine sauce

    • Fried Shrimp $13.99

      half dozen hand breaded shrimp golden fried with cocktail sauce and lemon wedge

    • Stuffed Shrimp $16.99

      fantail shrimp baked with seasoned lump crab stuffing over lobster sauce

    • Maryland Style Crab Cakes $14.99

      golden fried maryland style crab cakes served over lobster sauce

    • Fillet of Flounder $14.99

      fresh flounder fillets oven broiled with tartar sauce and lemon wedge

    • Stuffed Flounder $16.99

      oven baked atlantic flounder fillets wrapped around maryland style crab stuffing

  • Neptune's Jewels
    • Twin Lobster Tails $21.99

      twin 4 ounce oven broiled lobster tails served with lemon and drawn butter add crabmeat stuffing for 27.99

    • Broiled Combination $18.99

      stuffed shrimp, sea scallops, flounder fillet, and clams casino add a lobster tail for 27.99

  • Old Time Favorites
    all dinner entrees include your choice of our bottomless bowl of freshly tossed caesar or garden salad
    • Chicken Francaise $14.99

      twin egg dipped chicken breasts pan seared in lemon wine sauce served over angel hair pasta

    • Yankee Pot Roast $12.99

      old fashioned pot roast simmered in gravy served with applesauce and potato pancake

    • Oven Roast Turkey $12.99

      sliced over cornbread stuffing with gravy, cranberry sauce and mashed potatoes

    • Pork Chops $12.99

      twin center cut loin chops flame broiled with a side of applesauce and mashed potatoes

    • Chicken Parmigiana $13.99

      smothered in marinara and mozzarella cheese served with a generous platter of spaghetti

    • Cheese Ravioli $9.99

      ricotta cheese stuffed ravioli simmered in our light marinara sauce

    • Spaghetti & Meatballs $9.99

      a steaming bowl of spaghetti and homemade meatballs with our light marinara sauce.

  • Monday Prime Rib Night
    • Slow Roasted Prime Rib $13.99

    • Shrimp Cocktail Trio $1.99

  • Tuesday Italian Night
    • Italian Specialties $10.99

    • Wine Glass Specials $1.99

  • Wednesday Night BBQ
    • Chicken & Ribs $12.99

    • Draft Beer Specials $1.99

  • Friday Night Lobsterfest
    • Steamed Lobster $15.99

    • Maine Lobster Bake $21.99

  • Thursday Night Seafest
    • Seafood Specialties $10.99

    • Clam Half Shell Trio $1.99

  • Family Fare Ott Favorites
    our complete family fare meals are served with fresh rolls and butter a cup of soup or fruit cocktail, tossed salad, house dessert and coffee
    • Fish & Chips $10.99

      beer batter cod fillets with tartar sauce & fries

    • Sauteed Calves Liver $10.99

      served with crisp bacon, onions and seasoned mashed potatoes

    • Chicken Francaise $11.99

      egg dipped chicken breast pan seared lemon wine sauce over angel hair pasta

    • Chicken Parmigiana $11.99

      served with a side of spaghetti marinara

    • Oven Roast Turkey $11.99

      sliced over cornbread stuffing with gravy, cranberry sauce and mashed potatoes.

    • Yankee Pot Roast $11.99

      served with applesauce & potato pancake

    • Broiled Salmon Fillet $13.99

      served with vegetable and potato

    • Twin Baby Lamb Chops $13.99

      twin 4oz center cut loin lamb chops grilled with mint jelly, vegetable and potato

  • Family Fare Today's Choice
    our complete family fare meals are served with fresh rolls and butter a cup of soup or fruit cocktail, tossed salad, house dessert and coffee
    • Old Time Tavern Meatloaf $8.99

      served with mushroom gravy, chef's vegetables and mashed potatoes

    • Rigatoni & Broccoli $9.99

      tossed with sweet italian sausage in a fresh basil-garlic white wine sauce

    • Jumbo Stuffed Shells ala Pesto $9.99

      stuffed with ricotta cheese simmered in a fresh basil pesto sauce

    • Stuffed Roast Half Chicken $9.99

      oven roasted with cornbread stuffing, natural gravy chef's vegetable and mashed potatoes

    • Beef Tenderloin Tips Burgundy $10.99

      sauteed with mushrooms in a burgundy wine sauce over fettuccini pasta

    • Jaeger Schnitzel $12.99

      breaded veal cutlet in mushroom sauce with red cabbage and seasoned mashed potatoes

    • Flounder Bruschetta $13.99

      baked with diced tomato, fresh garlic, and basil over seasoned spinach and roasted potatoes

    • Coquille "Scallops" St Jacques $13.99

      baked in a champagne mushroom cream sauce with chef's vegetable and rice pilaf

  • Sandwich & Salads
    enjoy a complimentary cup of our daily soup selections while we prepare your sandwich or salad
    • Buffalo Chicken Caesar Salad $8.99

      spicy buffalo chicken pieces on a bed of classic caesar salad

    • Chicken Cheese Steak Sandwich $8.99

      grilled chicken with peppers, onions, cheddar-jack cheese on a toasted roll

    • Steak Fajita Wrap $8.99

      sliced sirloin with cheddar-jack cheese, peppers & onions, lettuce and tomato in a garlic- herb tortilla wrapper

    • Lemon Pepper Ahi Tuna $9.99

      petit ahi tuna steak grilled with lemon pepper seasonings on a bed of fresh baby greens with cucumbers, grape tomatoes, and raspberry vinaigrette

  • Drink Specials
    • Apple'n Oranges $5.75

      applejack, stoli o, apple-orange juice, splash of grenadine

    • Jersey Peach $5.75

      vodka, peach schnapps, sour apple, cran-orange juice

    • Heineken Light Bottles $4.75

      import flavor with a lot less calories

  • Great Starters
    • Asian BBQ Wings $6.99

      chicken strips laced with cusabi sauce over asian noodles

    • Trifecta Combo $7.99

      clams casino, shrimp luciano and crab stuffed new zealand mussels

    • Fried Macaroni And Cheese $4.99

      in a crispy batter with marinara sauce

  • Chef's Suggestions
    enjoy a cup of our daily soup selections or a tossed garden greens or a classic caesar salad
    • Stuffed Pork Chops $13.99

      stuffed with a apple-raisin stuffing with natural gravy and garlic mashed potatoes

    • Beef Bistro Braciole $13.99

      top sirloin of beef stuffed with roasted pepper, asparagus, portobello mushrooms and fresh mozzarella topped with port wine demiglace over mashed potatoes

    • Peachy Chicken $12.99

      sauteed chicken breast with fresh peaches in a lightly brandy sauce, chef's vegetable and roasted potatoes

    • Blackened Tilapia Fillet $14.99

      pan seared in a cajun spicy cream sauce served over red beans and rice with mango salsa

    • Grilled Lemon Pepper Tuna $16.99

      grilled to perfection served with pickled ginger over mix baby green dressed with toasted sesame vinaigrett

    • Roast Prime Rib $18.99

      served with horseradish sauce, vegetable and choice of potato

    • Baby Back Ribs $17.99

      a full rack of tender baby back ribs basted with tangy barbecue sauce served with coleslaw and french fries potatoes

    • Veal Scaloppini Mariano $15.99

      sauteed with sundried tomatoes, scallions and shiitake mushrooms in chardonnay cream sauce over fettuccini pasta

    • Blue Cheese Crusted Genuine Angus $17.99

      a eight ounce seasoned flat iron steak grilled in a port wine demiglace served with vegetable and sweet potato fries

    • Portobello 24 Ounce Porterhouse Steak $27.99

      smothered with caramelized onions and portobello mushrooms served with chef's vegetable and roasted potatoes

  • Finishing Touches
    • Cognac Pumpkin Cheesecake $4.99

      topped with fresh whipped cream drizzled with white chocolate

    • Peach Melba $3.99

      premium vanilla ice cream topped with raspberry sauce, sliced peaches and whipped cream

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.