Allmenus.com
  • New Jersey
  • Somerville
  • Blue Sheep Bake Shop

What is Grubhub

Through online ordering, we connect hungry people with the best local restaurants. Explore restaurants near you to find what you love.

Next

Why use Grubhub

Order popular dishes from a variety of restaurants. Get your order delivered or pick it up.

Previous
Start your order

Blue Sheep Bake Shop

(908) 393-1824

We make ordering easy. Learn more

Google map
  • 9 Division St Ste 13, Somerville, NJ 08876
  • No cuisines specified

  • Grubhub.com
  • Blue Sheep Bake Shop

  • (908) 393-1824

    We make ordering easy.

  • Menu
  • Artisan Ice Cream - Milkshakes - Belgian Waffles
    • Ice Cream - Choose Scoops, Pints or Milkshakes!

      A delectable scoop of pure indulgence, the ultimate delight for ice cream enthusiasts! Choose scoops, pints, or shakes! You can add a cone or toppings which will be packaged separately.

    • Waffle Cone $0.50

      Choose from wafer, sugar, or DIPPED cones! This is packaged separately from the ice cream.

    • Belgian Liege Dessert Waffles $4.95

      Warm, golden-brown waffle with a delicately crisp exterior! As you sink your teeth into its soft, doughy center, you discover pockets of caramelized pearl sugar, creating a symphony of sweetness with each mouthful. Garnished with confectioner's sugar if no toppings are selected.

    • Beligian Liege Waffles & Ice Cream $4.95

      Warm, golden-brown waffle with a delicately crisp exterior! As you sink your teeth into its soft, doughy center, you discover pockets of caramelized pearl sugar, creating a symphony of sweetness with each mouthful. Add ice cream & toppings!

  • Gourmet Cupcakes
    • Death By Chocolate Cupcake $3.95

      Chocolate cake, dipped in ganache, finished with milk chocolate swiss buttercream.

    • Peanut Butter Cupcake (Stuffed!) $4.50

      Moist chocolate cake dipped in chocolate ganache, filled with peanut butter sauce, and frosted in peanut butter Swiss buttercream.

    • Birthday Cake Cupcake $3.95

      Funfetti cake topped with our signature creamy vanilla buttercream and rainbow sprinkles

    • Oreo Cupcake $3.95

      Fluffy Oreo cake frosted in Oreo buttercream and topped with crushed Oreos.

    • Pina Colada $4.50

      With its coconut cake, tangy pineapple filling, pina colada frosting, and a coating of shredded coconut, this cupcake is a true tropical paradise in dessert form.

    • Champagne & Strawberries Cupcake $4.50

      Champagne cake topped with sweet strawberry buttercream frosting!

    • Red Velvet Cupcake $3.95

      Smooth, buttermilk red velvet cake frosted in cream cheese frosting. Garnishes may vary slightly.

    • S'mores Cupcake - STUFFED $4.25

      Our delicious chocolate cake FILLED with graham butter, dipped in chocolate ganache, topped with fluff buttercream!

    • Carrot Cake Cupcake $3.95

      Carrot Cake, topped with Cream Cheese Frosting

    • Salted Caramel - STUFFED $4.25

      Our signature vanilla cake filled with house made caramel, topped with caramel swiss buttercream.

    • 90's Breakfast $3.95

      White cake baked with Fruity Pebbles, topped with strawberry buttercream and a mini pop tart.

    • Apple Crisp Cupcake $4.50

      Fresh apples and fall spices come together for this seasonal specialty, topped with creamy caramel buttercream!

    • Toasted Banana S'mores $4.50

    • Banoffee (STUFFED!) $4.50

      Moist banana cake studded with mini chocolate chips, filled with house made caramel, dipped in chocolate ganache, and topped with mascarpone buttercream that tastes like whipped cream!

    • Biscoff Cookie Butter Cupcake - STUFFED $4.50

      This mouthwatering cookie butter cupcake is loaded with crushed Biscoff cookies then stuffed with Biscoff cookie butter and topped with Biscoff cookie butter buttercream - it's out of this world!

    • Boston Cream (STUFFED!) $4.50

      Soft vanilla sponge cake, filled with vanilla pudding, topped with vanilla buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache.

    • Cake Batter $3.50

      Fluffy funfetti cake topped with cake batter buttercream and rainbow non pereils!

    • Chocolate Eclair $4.50

      Vanilla cake STUFFED with chocolate pudding, frosted in our signature vanilla buttercream, then rolled in éclair crunch!

    • Cinnabun Cupcakes $3.95

      This amazing cupcake is loaded with cinnamon and brown sugar swirl and frosted with cinnamon buttercream. This is a house favorite!

    • Cinnamon Roll $3.95

      Cinnamon brown sugar cake with a cinnamon brown sugar swirl and cinnamon buttercream frosting. This is a seasonal house favorite!

    • Coconut Cream Pie $4.50

      Coconut cake filled with coconut cream, then topped in coconut buttercream!

    • Birthday Cookie Dough (Stuffed!) $4.50

      Birthday cake filled with cookie dough, then topped with cookie dough buttercream and even MORE cookie dough!

    • Ferrero Roche - STUFFED!!! $4.95

      Our signature chocolate cake filled with Nutella, dipped in ganache, frosted with Nutella buttercream, rolled in hazelnuts, topped with a Ferrero Roche!

    • Guinness Stuffed $4.50

      Guinness cake stuffed with jameson cream and frosted in caramel buttercream.

    • Hot Cocoa $3.95

      Rich chocolate cake dipped in chocolate ganache, topped with marshmallow buttercream and rolled in chocolate curls!

    • Irish Coffee Cupcake $4.50

      Bailey's Irish Cream cake filled with espresso buttercream, dipped in ganache, topped with Bailey's Irish Cream buttercream, chocolate curls, ganache, and a chocolate garnish.

    • Irish Cream $4.50

      Irish cream cake stuffed with homemade caramel and frosted in Irish cream buttercream.

    • Jack Daniels Cupcake - STUFFED $4.95

      Rich chocolate Jack Daniel's cake STUFFED with our home-made caramel and topped with caramel buttercream.

    • Lava Cake $4.25

      Rich chocolate cake dipped in chocolate ganache, frosted in whipped ganache!

    • Lavender Lemon (Stuffed!) $4.50

      Lavender scented cake filled with lemon pudding, topped with lemon buttercream!

    • Lemon Blueberry $4.50

      Lemon cake, blueberry filling, topped with sweet and tangy lemon buttercream!

    • Lucky Charms Cupcake $3.50

      Fruity cereal cake topped with creamy vanilla buttercream and garnished with rainbow sprinkles and Lucky Charms cereal.

    • Mocha Cappucino Cupcake - STUFFED $4.50

      Chocolate cake filled with vanilla cream, dipped in ganache, frosted in espresso buttercream and garnished with white chocolate curls, chocolate ganache, and a molded chocolate piece.

    • Reese's PB Oreo Cupcake $4.50

      LIMITED RELEASE! Our decadent chocolate cake with chunks of peanut butter Oreo's folded in the batter, then dipped in ganache, frosted in Reese's peanut butter Oreo buttercream and topped with a peanut butter cake bite!

    • Samoa Cupcakes $4.50

      Coconut cream filled chocolate cake that's dipped in chocolate ganache & frosted with caramel buttercream then topped with toasted coconut, caramel, & ganache!

    • Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake - STUFFED $4.50

    • Oreo Party $4.50

      Oreo cake filled with cake batter, vanilla frosting, rainbow sprinkles!

    • Pumpkin Oreo $4.25

      This cake is loaded with crushed pumpkin Oreos, then topped with pumpkin Oreo buttercream!

    • NEW!!! Pumpkin Spice Latte Cupcakes $3.95

      Our signature pumpkin spice cupcake frosted in espresso pumpkin spice Swiss buttercream frosting.

    • Tiramisu- STUFFED $4.95

      Vanilla sponge cake soaked in amaretto & espresso, frosted with mascarpone frosting (tasted like whipped cream!) and topped with a lady finger dipped in chocolate.

    • Gluten Free Vanilla $4.25

      Gluten free vanilla cake with vanilla icing

    • Gingerbread Latte Cupcake $4.50

    • Hostess Cupcake $3.75

      Moist, rich chocolate sponge is generously filled with a lusciously creamy center, then expertly dipped in a velvety ganache, adding a luxurious depth to the chocolate experience. To top it off, it's adorned with beautifully piped buttercream stars.

    • Peanut Butter Honey Comb Crunch Cupcake $4.00

      Experience the ultimate indulgence with our Peanut Butter Honey Comb Crunch Cupcake – a delectable masterpiece crafted for the discerning sweet tooth! Rich, moist peanut butter cake, each bite infused with the unique texture and sweetness of honey comb crunch. Crowned with a swirl of silky-smooth peanut butter Swiss buttercream. Perfect for peanut butter lovers, dessert enthusiasts, or as a special treat for any occasion, our Peanut Butter Honey Comb Crunch Cupcake is an irresistible delight that promises a sensory journey of taste and texture. Order now and savor the unparalleled blend of peanut butter richness and the sweet, crunchy allure of honey co

    • Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Cupcake $4.00

      A moist and zesty lemon cake base, baked with fresh blueberries to create a delightful burst of natural sweetness in every bite. Atop this luscious cake sits a creamy cream cheese frosting, dusted with lemon zest and skillfully swirled to perfection. Order now and treat your taste buds to this exquisite culinary creation!

    • Gluten Free Chocolate Cupcake $4.25

      Our gluten chocolate cake recipe frosted in creamy chocolate swiss buttercream frosting.

    • Gluten Free Funfetti Cupcake $4.25

      Our gluten free vanilla cake recipe with gluten free sprinkles and vanilla swiss buttercream frosting.

    • Pistachio Cannoli Cupcake $3.95

      Delicious pistachio cake, chock full of nuts and filled with homemade cannoli cream filling. Wow your guests at the birthday party with these amazing cupcakes!

    • Snickers Stuffed Cupcake $4.25

      Indulge your senses with our new SNICKERS cupcakes! This rich chocolate cake features a gooey caramel-peanut filling, dipped in silky chocolate ganache, and crowned with Reese's peanut butter buttercream.

    • Toasted Banana S'mores Cupcake $3.95

      Savor the bliss of our Toasted Banana S'mores Cupcakes - a heavenly bite of banana cake, rich graham butter center, chocolate ganache coating, and a topping of toasted marshmallow buttercream. Perfect for any festivity!

    • Lavender Honey Cupcake $3.75

    • Blood Orange Cannoli Mimosa $3.95

      Savor the fusion of tradition and citrus with our Blood Orange Cannoli Cupcake, featuring a blood orange scented cake, cannoli cream filling, and champagne frosting. 

    • Coconut Key Lime $4.00

    • Guava Cupcake- STUFFED $4.00

    • Coconut Guava Cupcake $4.00

    • Matcha Ginger Bliss Cupcake $3.95

      Matcha cake with ginger buttercream

    • Gluten Free Vanilla Raspberry $4.00

      Our gluten free vanilla cake recipe filled with raspberry preserve and frosted in raspberry swiss buttercream frosting.

    • Black Forest Cupcake - STUFFED $4.25

    • Gluten Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake $4.50

    • Mexican Hot Chocolate Cupcake $4.00

    • Almond Raspberry Cupcake- STUFFED $4.50

    • Cookie Butter Stuffed $4.25

    • Dulce De Leche- STUFFED $4.50

    • Chocolate Churro Cupcake - STUFFED $4.25

    • Apple Chai Stuffed $4.25

    • Nutty Pumpkin $3.50

    • Gluten Free Vanilla Chocolate $4.50

    • Snickers stuffed cupcake $4.25

    • pumpkin cheesecake $4.00

    • Honey Almond $4.00

    • Mocha $4.25

    • Bailey's Hot Coco $4.50

    • Santa's Milk and Cookies- STUFFED $4.25

    • Christmas Cookie Crunch $3.95

    • Pistachio Cherry - STUFFED $4.25

      Pistachio flavored cake with a cherry filling, topped with pistachio buttercream and white chocolate curls.

    • Love Potion #9 - STUFFED! $4.25

      Rich chocolate cake filled with raspberry compote, dipped in silky ganache and topped with a swirl of raspberry Swiss meringue buttercream.

    • Chocolate Covered Strawberry $3.75

      Fresh strawberry cupcake dipped in chocolate ganache, frosted in strawberry Swiss buttercream.

    • Love You Latte $4.25

    • Bailey's Mudslide $4.50

    • Bailey's Irish Cream $3.95

    • Guinness Beer $4.50

    • Lemon Poppy $4.25

      Lemon cake baked with poppy seed, a lemon filling, and topped with lemon buttercream and poppy seeds

    • Caramel Chai $3.95

      Chai cake with a caramel buttercream.

    • Chocolate Pistachio $4.95

      Chocolate cake filled with pistachio ganache, topped with pistachio buttercream

    • Strawberry Fields $3.75

    • Rocky Road Stuffed $4.25

    • Lavender Honey Blueberry (Stuffed) $4.25

    • Le-Mond Royale $4.25

    • Miss Strawberry Crumble $4.50

    • Little Lemon Lunatic $4.50

    • Chocolate Churro- STUFFED $4.25

    • Coconut Raspberry- STUFFED $4.25

    • Gluten Free Oreo $4.25

    • Champagne Strawberry $4.25

    • Selena Gomez Oreo Cupcake $4.50

    • Italian Rainbow Cupcake $4.75

      Almond cake, raspberry filling, ganache frosting, rolled in sprinkles and topped with a slice of Italian rainbow cake!

    • The Versailles Cupcake $4.75

      Pistachio cake base with raspberry filling Pistachio buttercream frosting with honey drizzle Garnished with chopped pistachios

    • Pumpkin Cinnamon Roll $4.50

  • French Macaron Collections
    • Raspberry Macaron $2.75

      Raspberry Swiss buttercream & raspberry preserve layered between two raspberry macaron shells.

    • Strawberry Macaron $2.75

      Light pink macaron shells filled with strawberry Swiss buttercream.

    • Lemon Raspberry Macaron $2.75

    • Pistachio Macaron $2.75

      Lime green macaron shells stuffed with pistachio buttercream.

    • Irish Whiskey Macaron $2.50

    • Cookies & Cream Macaron $2.75

      Blue macaron shell filled with oreo Swiss buttercream.

    • Lavender Chai Macaron $2.75

      Lavender colored macarons filled with chai cream.

    • Death By Chocolate Macaron $2.75

      Rich chocolate ganache sandwiched between two chocolate macaron cookies.

    • Nutella Macaron $2.75

      Chocolate macaron shell with Nutella AND Nutella buttercream filling.

    • Vanilla Macaron $2.75

      Natural macaron shell with creamy vanilla buttercream filling.

    • Birthday Cake Macaron $2.75

      Birthday cake flavored Swiss buttercream sandwiched between 2 vanilla macaron shells.

    • Macaron Classics Collection $15.95

      A classic mix of birthday cake, death by chocolate, crème Brulee, strawberry, raspberry, and Oreo. If you want a different mix leave us a note in the comments and we'll do our best to accomodate.

    • Macaron Surprise Me Collection $15.95

      Pricing is for six macarons, bakers choice! Don't worry - we'll pick good ones! (because they're ALL GOOD!)

    • Guava Macaron $2.50

    • Creme Brulee Macaron $2.75

      Two vanilla macaron cookies filled with caramel and lightly bruleed.

    • Banana Peanut Butter Macaron $2.50

      Two lemon macaron cookies filled with Swiss lemon swiss buttercream and tangy raspberry preserve.

    • Pecan Pie Macaron $2.50

    • Peanut Butter Macaroon $2.75

      Reese's peanut butter filled French macarons

    • Biscoff Cookie Butter Macaron $2.50

    • Honey Fig $2.50

    • Pumpkin Espresso $2.50

    • Ube Macaron $2.50

  • Cupcake Collections
    • The Classics - (Birthday Cake, Oreo, Reese's, Death by Chocolate, Red Velvet, & Carrot Cake) $24.00

      Pricing is for 6 cupcakes. A classic mix of birthday cake, oreo, chocolate peanut butter, death by chocolate, red velvet, and champagne and strawberries.

    • Chocolate Lovers Cupcake Collection $24.00

      Pricing is for 6 cupcakes. Add to cart to order more! A mix of all the chocolate flavors we're offering on the menu (usually 2 of each!)

  • Cookies
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies $2.25

      Just like mom used to make - but we have a secret ingredient!

    • Dark Chocolate Pistachio with Smoked Sea Salt $2.50

      This cookie is loaded with chocolate chunks and pistachios then topped with smoked sea salt - it's a MUST TRY!

    • Birth-YAY! $2.50

      Our famous cake batter cookie, studded with sprinkles and white chocolate chips

    • Giant Reese's Stuffed Cookie $6.50

      Giant Reese's peanut butter cookie loaded with Reese's pieces and STUFFED with an entire Reese's peanut butter cup!

    • Bomba Chocolate Chip $5.50

      This massive cookie is PACKED with chocolate chips!

    • Bake At Home Cookies $12.00

      Box of 6 bake at home cookies, bake from frozen at 350 for 8-12 minutes in conventional oven.

    • Double Chocolate $2.50

    • Lemon Crinkle Cookie $2.25

      Fresh lemony cookie with a sugar crumble coating!

    • Cookie Bento Box $14.00

      Six pack of our signature cookies in assorted flavors.

    • German Chocolate Stuffed Cookie $6.50

      This giant chocolate cookie is STUFFED with classic German chocolate filling, and loaded with pecans & caramel chips.

    • Birth-YAY Stuffed Cookie $6.50

      Our birth-yay cookie stuffed with an italian rainbow cookie and white chocolate chips!

    • Twix Cookie $2.50

      Creamy salted caramel cookie dough, loaded with chocolate chips, mini chocolate chips, caramel chips and Twix bars!

    • Giant Ganache Stuffed Cookie $6.50

      Our delicious giant chocolate chip cookie filled with rich and creamy chocolate ganache!

    • Triple Chocolate Suffed Cookie $6.50

      Triple chocolate cookie dough loaded with chocolate chips and white chocolate chips stuffed with ganache!

    • Red Velvet Oreo Cookies $2.50

      Our signature red velvet cookie studded with oreo cookie pieces and white chocolate chips!

    • Sugar Cookie $2.50

    • Raspberry Stuffed Dark Chocolate Pistachio $5.95

      This cookie is loaded with chocolate chunks and pistachios then stuffed with raspberry and topped with smoked sea salt.

    • Oatmeal Cookie $2.50

    • Peanut Butter Cookie Chaos $6.50

    • Gingerbread Cookie $1.95

    • Snickerdoodle Cookie $1.95

    • Shamrock Shake Cookie $5.50

    • Salted Caramel Cookie $2.50

    • Churro Cookie- STUFFED $4.50

    • Unicorn Magic $4.50

    • Nutella Dream $4.50

    • Dubai Pistachio Stuffed $4.50

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.50

  • Brownies & Dessert Bars
    • STUFFED Nutella Brownies $5.95

      Our decadent brownie but with a twist - STUFFED with Nutella!

    • STUFFED Caramel Brownies $5.95

      Our decadent brownie with a twist - STUFFED with caramel!

    • Death By Chocolate Brownie $5.25

      Our amazing fudge brownie recipe layered with with chocolate ganache, chocolate curls, and chocolate pearls!

    • Reese's Peanut Butter Brownie $5.25

      Reese's peanut butter cups folded into our fudge brownie recipe, then layers of Reese's peanut butter ganache and chocolate ganache are poured over top!

    • Magic Bars $5.25

      Once you taste these delicious dessert bars you'll understand why they're called Magic Bars. Layers of graham, butterscotch, chocolate, coconut, and pecans held together with condensed milk and baked together to fuse a flavor so unbelievable - it must be magic!

    • Cookie Butter Dream Bars $5.25

      Biscoff cookie crust filled with cookie butter cream cheese and topped with cookie butter and Biscoff cookies!

    • Turtle Bro-Nuts $4.95

      Mouthwatering brownie batter dipped in caramel ganache, topped with pecans and coconut

    • King Kandy Bro-Nuts $4.95

      Mouthwatering brownie batter dipped in chocolate ganache an topped with candy!

    • Pumpkin Brownie Bro-Nuts $4.95

      Mouthwatering pumpkin spice brownie batter dipped in caramel ganache, topped with cinnamon chocolate chips and ganache.

    • Raspberry Bars $5.25

      Pair these deliciously sweet and tart raspberry dessert bars with vanilla ice cream for the ultimate treat!

    • S'mores Cookie Bar $5.25

      A cookie bar with a graham cracker crust, loaded with Hershey bars and marshmallows, then drizzled in chocolate ganache.

    • Killer Kit Kat STUFFED Brownie $5.95

      Our amazingly decadent brownie generously stuffed with a Kit Kat chocolate bar, adding an irresistible crunch and a burst of creamy chocolate to every bite.

    • Italian Rainbow Cookie Bar $4.25

    • Oreo Stuffed Brownie $5.95

    • Dirty Chai Blondie $4.95

    • Snickerdoodle Blondie $4.25

    • Chocolate Italian Rainbow Cookie Bar $4.25

    • Cocoa Caramel Italian Cookie Bar $4.25

    • Snickers Stuffed Brownie $5.95

    • Lemon Blueberry Bundt Cake $5.00

    • Lava Bundt Cake $5.95

    • Peppermint Patty Brownie $5.95

    • Coconut Dream Bar $4.95

    • cinnabon Bundt $4.95

    • pecan bar $4.95

    • Cookie Dough Stuffed Brownie $5.95

    • Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake $5.95

    • Caramel Stuffed Brownie $5.95

    • Biscoff Cheesecake Bar $5.95

    • Nutella Brookie Bliss Bomb $6.50

    • Dubai Pistachio Brownie $5.95

    • Cinnamon Irish Whiskey Bundt $4.95

    • Cookie Butter Stuffed Brownie $5.95

    • Pineapple Rum Express Bundt Cake $5.95

    • Peanut Butter Brownie $5.95

  • Gifts
    • Birthday Bento Box $19.95

      Birthday bento box with our most popular flavors. The gift box contains 2 cupcakes (1 birthday cake & 1 chocolate, 3 macarons (birthday cake, raspberry, and chocolate), and a fudge brownie!

    • Mother's Day Bento Box $24.95

      This special box was made just for mom! It features 2 specially decorated cupcakes, 3 macarons, and a ganache brownie.

    • Gift $25.00

      A great add on when sending a gift!

    • Gift $25.00

      A great add on when sending a gift!

    • Mini Ice Cream Cake $19.50

      Send a 4" mini ice cream cake to that special someone complete with a personalized message! Classic vanilla and chocolate ice cream layers with our famous crunch filling.

    • Cupcake Gift Box $49.95

      Send your well wishes with a dozen of our gourmet cupcakes!

  • Whoopie Pies
    • The Classic Whoopie Pie $2.95

      Fluffy marshmallow buttercream sandwich between two mounds of whoopie pie batter!

    • Strawberry Whoopie Pie $2.95

      Our creamy strawberry buttercream slathered between two chocolate whoopie pie mounds !

    • Stuffed Caramel Whoopie Pie $2.95

      This whoopie pie stands out from the crowd for sure - it has not one, but TWO fillings! A ring of caramel buttercream which is also filled with our homemade caramel sauce.

    • STUFFED Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Whoopie Pie $2.95

      We start with two whoopie pie mounds and fill it with Reese's peanut butter sauce and Reese's peanut butter buttercream.

    • STUFFED Caramel Whoopie Pie $2.95

      Our home made caramel is stuffed between caramel buttercream and two mounds of chocolate whoopie pies!

Menu for Blue Sheep Bake Shop provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Notice of Financial Incentive
©2023 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.