Baldwin Pizzeria
(973) 335-7731

We make ordering easy.

Slices
- Plain Slice $2.76
- Extra Cheese Slice $4.43
- Pepperoni Slice $3.87
- Mushroom Slice $3.87
- Onion Slice $3.87
- Sausage Slice $3.87
- Hawaiian Slice $4.43
- Margherita Slice $4.43
- Veggie Slice $4.43
- Meatlovers Slice $4.43
- Sicilian Slice $3.32
- Chicken Parm Slice $4.43
- BBQ Chicken Slice $4.43
- Buffalo Chicken Slice $4.43
- Specialty Slice $4.43
- Thai Chicken Slice $4.43
- Deep Dish $4.70

Pizza
- 10" PC $9.43
- 14" MC $15.33
- 16" LC $17.69
- 18" XLC $21.23
- Sicilian $22.41
- Gluten Free Pizza 12" $16.51
- Cauliflower Crust 10" $15.33
- Grandma Sicilian $25.95
- Pizza Shells $5.90
- Dessert Pizza $27.13
- 10" Vegan $11.79
- 14" Vegan $19.46
- 16" Vegan $25.95
- 18" Vegan $28.31
- Sicilian Vegan $28.31
- Drunken Grandma Sicilian $28.31

Beverages
- Spring Water $2.36
- 12 oz Can of Soda $1.77
- 20 oz Bottle of Soda $2.95
- 2 Liter Soda $4.43
- Arizona $1.17
- Gatorade $3.04
- Snapple $3.04
- Pure Leaf Lemon $3.04
- Pure Leaf Unsweetened $3.04
- Pure Leaf Sweet $3.04
- Push Drink $2.76
- Push Tea $3.54
- Chu Chi $3.54

Appetizers "Hot"
- 10 Wings $15.33
- Mozzarella Sticks $9.43
- Fried Calamari $14.15
- Jalapeños Poppers $9.43
- Zucchini Sticks $9.43
- Mussels $14.15
- Chicken Fingers $11.79
- Chicken Fingers W/ Fries $14.15
- Quesadilas $12.97
- Loaded Nachos $12.97
- Sampler $14.15
- Garlic Bread $5.89
- Garlic Bread W/ Cheese $7.07
- Breaded Mushrooms $9.43
- Potato Skins $14.15
- Onion Rings $9.43
- Eggplant Rollatini $12.97
- Cheese Riceball $4.71
- Beef RiceBalls $5.89

Appetizers "Cold"
- Bruschetta On Toast $10.61
- Cold Antipasto Appetizer $12.97
- Italian Appetizer $12.97

Side Orders
- French Fries $5.89
- French Fries /Cheese $7.07
- Buffalo Fries $9.43
- French Fries W/ Cheese And Brown Gravy $10.61
- Sweet Potato Fries $8.25
- Pizza Fries $9.43
- Grilled Chicken Side Order $8.25
- Breaded Chicken Side Order $8.25
- Garlic Knots (6) W/sauce $4.43
- Sautéed Spinach $10.61
- Sautéed Broccoli $10.61
- Meatballs Side Order $7.07
- Sausage Side Order $7.07
- Large Pizza Dough $5.90
- Sautéed Broccoli Rabe $10.61
- Side Of Hot Dogs $5.89
- Drunken Fries $11.79
- Sliders(3) $11.79
- Slider $3.87
- Pizza Fries $9.43
- Eggplant Parm $11.79
- Meatball Parm $11.79
- Chicken Parm $11.79

Hot Sandwiches
- The Standard Sub $12.97
- The Baldwin Sub $14.15
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub $14.15
- Meatball Parmigiana Sub $14.15
- Meatball Sub -No Cheese $12.97
- The Big Show Sub $14.15
- The Nunn Zinger Sub $14.15
- Chicken Cutlet W/ LTBR Sub $14.15
- Breaded Chicken Sub $14.15
- Chicken Francese Sub $14.15
- Chicken Francese Sub/Fresh Mozzarella $15.33
- Chicken Milanese Sub $14.15
- Breaded Buffalo Chicken Sub $14.15
- Chicken Vodka Sub $15.33
- Eggplant Parmigiana Sub $14.15
- Sausage Parmigiana Sub $14.15
- Veal Parmigiana Sub $15.33
- Shrimp Parmigiana Sub $15.33
- Italian Hot Dog $14.15
- Sausage Pepper & Onion Sub $14.15
- Potato Pepper & Egg Sub $12.97

CheeseSteak
- Steak Sub - No Cheese $11.79
- Cheesesteak Sub $12.97
- The Classic Cheesesteak Sub $14.15
- Chicken Cheesesteak Sub $14.15
- The Western Cheesesteak Sub $14.15
- The Texas Cheesesteak Sub $14.15
- Italian Cheesesteak Sub $14.15

Cold Sandwiches
- The Original Italian Sub $12.97
- The Baldwin Italian Sub $14.15
- Turkey Sub $12.97
- Tuna Melt Sub $14.15
- Tuna Sub $12.97
- Fresh Mozzarella Sub $12.97
- Prosciutto Sub $14.15

Panini
- Monte Cristo Panini $14.15
- The Chipotle Chicken Panini $14.15
- Chicken Spring Mix Panini $14.15
- Tuscan Panini $14.15

Wraps
- Grilled Chicken Wrap $11.20
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.79
- Chicken Cutlet Wrap $12.97
- Cheesesteak Wrap $12.97
- Grilled Veggie Wrap $11.79
- Antipasto Wrap $11.79
- Santa Fe Wrap $12.97
- Tuna Wrap $11.79
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap $11.79
- Florentine Wrap $11.79
- Godfather Wrap $12.97
- BBQ Chicken Wrap $11.79
- Chicken Parmigiana Wrap $11.79
- Grilled Shrimp Wrap $14.15

Salad
- House Salad
- Caesar Salad
- Spicy Buffalo Chicken Salad
- Chef Salad
- Tuna Salad
- Antipasto Salad
- Godfather Salad
- Cobb Salad
- Caprina Salad $14.15
- Caprina Salad W/ Chicken $17.69
- Mango Blackened Chicken Salad $17.69
- Bistro Salad $17.69
- Bistro Salad (Shrimp) $18.87
- Taco Salad $17.69
- Grilled Shrimp Salad $17.69
- Baby Spinach Salad $14.15
- Baby Spinach Salad (Chicken) $18.87
- Small House Salad $9.43
- Tilapia Salad $17.69

Soup
- Pasta Fagioli $8.25
- Minestrone $8.25
- Escarole & Bean $8.25
- Chicken Noodle $8.25
- Tortellini en Brodo $8.25
- Stracciatelle $8.25
- Chili $8.25
- Extra Bread $1.18
- Seafood Soup $11.79

Chicken Dinners
- Chicken Parmigiana $18.87
- Chicken Primavera $18.87
- Chicken Marsala $18.87
- Chicken Francese $21.23
- Chicken Sorrentino $18.87
- Chicken Saltimbocca $18.87
- Chicken Pizzaiola $18.87
- Chicken Principese $18.87
- Chicken Florentina $18.87
- Chicken Piccata $18.87
- Chicken Cacciatore $18.87
- Chicken Arrabiata $18.87
- Chicken Alfredo $18.87

Veal Dinners
- Veal Parmigiana $21.23
- Veal Primavera $22.41
- Veal Marsala $22.41
- Veal Francese $23.59
- Veal Sorrentino $22.41
- Veal Saltimbocca $22.41
- Veal Pizzaiola $22.41
- Veal Principesa $22.41
- Veal Florentina $22.41
- Veal Piccata $22.41
- Veal Arrabiata $22.41
- Veal Alfredo $22.41

Seafood Dinners
- Shrimp Parmigiana $22.41
- Shrimp Scampi $23.59
- Shrimp Francese $23.59
- Shrimp Fra Diavolo $23.59
- Shrimp Primavera $24.77
- Mussels Marinara $22.41
- Calamari Marinara $22.41
- Seafood Combo $27.13
- Tilapia Francese/Scampi $23.59

Oven Baked
- Baked Ziti $15.33
- Stuffed Shells $15.33
- Lasagna $15.33
- Manicotti $15.33
- Meat Sauce/Vodka Or Alfredo Sauce $5.90
- Baked Ravioli $18.87

Eggplant Dinners
- Eggplant Parmigiana $17.69
- Eggplant Rollatini $18.87

Gourmet Sauces
- Tomato Sauce $12.97
- Butter Sauce $12.97
- Bolognese Sauce $16.51
- Marinara Sauce $14.15
- Primavera Sauce $17.69
- Carbonara Sauce $17.69
- Fresh Clam Sauce $17.69
- Sausage Peppers & Onion Sauce $17.69
- Meatballs $16.51
- Sausage $16.51
- Garlic & Olive Oil Sauce $15.33
- Broccoli Garlic & Olive Oil Sauce $17.69
- Pesto Sauce $17.69
- Alfredo $17.69
- Bolognese With Meatballs $21.23
- Bolognese With Sausage $21.23

Pasta Specialties
- Tortellini Alfredo $17.69
- Fettuccini Alfredo $17.69
- Gnocchi In Tomato Sauce $15.33
- Gnocchi In Bolognese Sauce $18.87
- Cheese Ravioli In Tomato Sauce $15.33
- Baked Ravioli $18.87
- Cheese Ravioli In Bolognese Sauce $18.87
- Spinach Ravioli In Tomato Sauce $17.69
- Spinach Ravioli In Bolognese Sauce $21.23
- Cavateli Broccoli Garlic & Olive Oil $17.69
- Penne Vodka $17.69
- Stuffed Rigatoni $18.87

Baldwin Specialties
- Calzone $11.79
- Veggie Calzone $15.33
- Meat Lovers Calzone $15.33
- Homemade Empanadas $3.53
- Stromboli $11.79
- Buffalo Chicken Roll $11.79
- Sausage Pepper & Onion Roll $11.79
- Chicken Roll $11.79
- Eggplant Roll $11.79
- Spinach Roll $11.79
- Broccoli Roll $11.79
- Additional Topping $1.77
- Extra Sauce $1.18

New Platters
- Baldwin Platter $17.69
- Shrimp Platter $20.05
- Chicken Rollatini $18.87
- Grilled Veggie Platter $17.69

Dessert
- Cannoli $4.71
- Zeppole (10) $6.49
- Cheese Cake $5.89
- Chocolate Cake $5.89
- Ice Cream $2.95
- Ice Cream Cup $3.53
- Tiramisu $5.89
- Fried Oreos (4 In One Order) $5.89
- Funnel Cake $5.89
- Brownie Cheesecake $7.07

Specials
- #1 - Cajun Heat Fries $7.99
  
  Crispy cajun seasoned fries, served with chipotle mayo.
- #2 - Hot Honey Chicken Vodka Hero $13.99
  
  Crispy chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, vodka sauce, hot honey. Served with fries.
- #3 - Garden Caprese Sub $10.99
  
  Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, arugula, balsamic glaze. Served with chips.
- #4 - Pepperoni Pizza Melt Panini $12.99
  
  Shredded mozzarella, pepperoni, house-made tomato sauce, pressed panini style. Served with fries.
- #5 - Spicy Rigatoni alla Vodka $13.99
  
  Creamy Vodka Sauce with a kick. Served with bread.

Burgers
- Classic Cheeseburger $12.98
- Veggie Cheeseburger $12.98
- Classic burger $12.98
- #1 Jalapeno Burger $12.98
- #2 Pepper jack Burger $12.98
- #3 Desayuno Burger $12.98
- #4 Texas Burger $12.98
- #5 Spicy Mushroom Burger $12.98

Specialty Burgers
- #1 Jalapeno Burger $12.98
- #2 Pepper jack Burger $12.98
- #3 Desayuno Burger $12.98
- #4 Texas Burger $12.98
- #5 Spicy Mushroom Burger $12.98

Catering
- Small Tray Godfather Salad $53.10
- Large Tray Godfather Salad $88.50
- Small Tray Penne With Tomato Sauce $41.30
- Large Tray Penne With Tomato Sauce $70.80
- Small Tray Baked Ziti $47.20
- Large Tray Baked Ziti $76.70
- Small Tray Ziti Bolognese $53.10
- Large Tray Ziti Bolognese $88.50
- Small Tray Stuffed Shells $53.10
- Large Tray Stuffed Shells $88.50
- Small Tray Manicotti $53.10
- Large Tray Manicotti $88.50
- Small Tray Lasagna $53.10
- Large Tray Lasagna $100.30
- Small Tray Spinach Lasagna $53.10
- Large Tray Spinach Lasagna $100.30
- Small Tray Eggplant Parm $59.00
- Large Tray Eggplant Parm $94.40
- Small Tray Eggplant Rollatini $59.00
- Large Tray Eggplant Rollatini $100.30
- Small Tray Cavatelli Broccoli $47.20
- Large Tray Cavatelli Broccoli $88.50
- Small Tray Penne Vodka $59.00
- Large Tray Penne Vodka $100.30
- Small Tray Pasta With Shrimp And Garlic $76.70
- Large Tray Pasta With Shrimp And Garlic $129.80
- Small Tray Shrimp Marinara $76.70
- Large Tray Shrimp Marinara $129.80
- Small Tray Shrimp Fra Diavolo $76.70
- Large Tray Shrimp Fra Diavolo $129.80
- Small Tray Shrimp Scampi $76.70
- Large Tray Shrimp Scampi $129.80
- Small Tray Shrimp Francese $76.70
- Large Tray Shrimp Francese $129.80
- Small Tray Shrimp Parm $76.70
- Large Tray Shrimp Parm $129.80
- Small Tray Mussels Marinara $47.20
- Large Tray Mussels Marinara $129.80
- Small Fried Calamari $53.10
- Large Tray Fried Calamri $94.40
- Small Tray Chicken $59.00
- Large Tray Chicken $106.20
- Small Tray Chicken Sorrentino $64.90
- Large Tray Chicken Sorrentino $112.10
- Small Tray Chicken Saltimbocca $64.90
- Large Tray Chicken Saltimbocca $112.10
- Large Tray Chicke Fingers $88.50
- Small Tray Chicken Cacciatore $64.90
- Large Tray Chicken Cacciatore $112.10
- Small Tray Chicken Fingers $47.20
- Small Tray Wings $53.10
- Large Tray Wings $94.40
- Small Tray Veal Parm $64.90
- Large Tray Veal Parm $118.00
- Small Tray Veal Saltimbocca $70.80
- Large Tray Veal Saltimbocca $129.80
- Small Tray Sausage And Peppers $53.10
- Large Tray Sausage And Peppers $100.30
- Small Tray Meatballs With Sauce $59.00
- Large Tray Meatballs With Sauce $100.30
- Small Tray Sausage With Sauce $59.00
- Large Tray Sausage With Sauce $100.30
- Small Tray Cold Antipasto Salad $53.10
- Large Tray Cold Antipasto Salad $94.40
- Small Tray Regular Tossed Salad $35.40
- Large Tray Regular Tossed Salad $59.00
- Small Tray Caesar Salad $41.30
- Large Tray Caesar Salad $64.90
- Small Tray Empanads $59.00
- Large Tray Empanadas $100.30
- Small Tray Loaded Potato Skins $53.10
- Large Tray Loaded Potato Skins $94.40
- Small Tray Italian Bread $17.70
- Large Tray Italian Bread $29.50
- Small Tray Garlic Knots $23.60
- Large Tray Garlic Knots $47.20

Specialty Sauces
- Small Tomato Sauce $7.07
- Large Tomato Sauce $11.79
- Small Specialty Sauce $9.43
- Large Specialty Sauce $14.15

The Baldwin Family Deal
- The Baldwin Family Deal $53.09

Coupons
- Pizza +Wings And A 2 Liter $31.85
- 2 Pizzas+Knots+Mozz Stixs+ A 2 Liter Soda $47.19

Menu for Baldwin Pizzeria provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

What is Grubhub

Why use Grubhub

Baldwin Pizzeria