For Starters
- Loaded Nachos $11.50
  
  Crispy nacho chips with cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, onions, peppers, tomato & black olives. Served with sides of sour cream, sarah's salsa and guacamole. Add burger or chicken $1.50
- 1/2 Loaded Nachos $9.50
- Hot Nachos $9.40
  
  Crisp nacho chips w/ cheddar and mozzarella cheeses served w/ sour cream & sarah's salsa
- 1/2 Hot Nachos $7.50
  
  Crisp nacho chips w/ cheddar and mozzarella cheeses served w/ sour cream & sarah's salsa
- Toasted Nacho Chips $5.30
  
  Served w/ sarah's salsa
- Toasted Nacho Chips w/ Guacamole $6.50
  
  Served w/ sarah's salsa
- Garlic Bread $5.30
  
  Fresh baked bread topped with garlic butter, cheddar & mozzarella served hot w/ side of sauce
- Baked Potato Skins $6.50
  
  With bacon and cheddar. Served with side of sour cream
- Quesadilla $8.50
  
  A 12" flour tortilla stuffed with loads of cheddar, baked till golden brown & served with Sarah's salsa & sour cream. Add meat $1.50, veggie $0.50
- Oven Fries and Gravy $5.00
  
  Oven fries served with a side of beef gravy
- Steamed Mussels $11.00
  
  In garlic, tomato, herbs & wine served with crusty bread & lemon
- Sarah's Crab Cakes $10.80
  
  Two homemade crab cakes grilled and served on a bed of crispy greens w/ sides of homemade tartar sauce & lemon

The Chef

Choice of our homemade dressings: house vinaigrette, fat free raspberry vinaigrette, ranch, blue cheese, parmesan pepper, thousand island. Goat cheese or feta cheese available $1.00
- Assortment of Mixed Greens and Seasonal Vegetables $7.30+
  
  Topped w/ sliced cheddar and Swiss, choice of one; ham, pepperoni, chicken, turkey or anchovies, a boiled egg, and served w/ garlic bread
- Beef & Blue Salad $9.30+
  
  Grilled sliced prime beef topped on a mixed green salad w/ seasonal vegetables, crumbled blue cheese, bacon & garlic bread.
- Garden $4.70+
  
  Crisp lettuce w/ seasonal vegetables & sprouts, served w/ garlic bread
- Spinach $4.70+
  
  With crisp seasonal vegetables & sprouts, served w/ garlic bread
- Boothbay Harbor Crab Cobb Salad $10.50+
  
  Mixed greens & crisp seasonal veggies topped w/ blue cheese crumbles garnished w/ two grilled crab cakes, crisp bacon, boiled egg, garlic bread & lemon slice. Smaller size w/ one grilled crab cake
- Taco Salad $8.00+
  
  A crispy nacho chip framed salad with lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, peppers, red on ions & cheddar with your choice of hamburger, chicken, steak or turkey. Topped with sour cream, salsa and guacamole.
- Greek $7.30+
  
  Spinach, red onions, peppers, cucumbers, greek olives, tomatoes, feta cheese & pepperoncini, served w/ garlic bread
- Caesar Salad $6.00+
  
  Romaine lettuce tossed with our home made caesar dressing, carrots, cabbage, croutons & shredded parmesan cheese.
- Sarah's Seasonal Salad $7.50+
  
  Tender greens, seasonal berries, toasted walnuts, goat cheese crumbles
- Sarah's Cobb Salad $10.50
  
  With assorted mixed greens and seasonal vegetables topped w/ sliced turkey, bacon, boiled egg & crumbled blue cheese. Served w/ garlic bread
- Cup of Chowder $3.99
- Soup with your Salad $3.99

Whaleboat

Our version of a calzone, your choice of white or wheat, with mozzarella and cheddar, baked till golden brown. Served w/ pizza sauce on request $0.75
- The Captains Cut $10.00
  
  Steak, sauteed onion, bacon, mushrooms, tomatoes, cheddar & mozzarella
- Greek $9.50
  
  Spinach, tomato, red onion, greek olives, feta, pepperoncini, mozzarella & vinaigrette
- Crows Nest $9.25
  
  Spinach, tomato, red onion, sprouts, mush rooms, cheddar, mozzarella & vinaigrette
- The Bunk $8.50
  
  Your choice of pepperoni or ham with cheddar & mozzarella
- Sunken Treasure $9.50
  
  Spinach, tomato, mushrooms, broccoli, pesto, mozzarella & cheddar
- Harbor Master $9.50
  
  Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss, mozzarella & spicy brown mustard
- Helmsman $9.25
  
  Your choice of turkey or bacon with tomato, spinach, mozzarella & cheddar
- The Deck Hand $9.50
  
  Hamburger, sauteed onions, tomatoes, bacon, cheddar & mozzarella
- Haddock Boat $14.95
  
  Lemon butter baked haddock, spinach, tomato, mozzarella and cheddar
- Build Your Own Boat $8.75
  
  Includes: 1 meat & 2 veggies, cheddar and mozzarella
- The Lobster Trap
  
  Maine lobster meat, spinach, tomato, cheddar & mozzarella

The Matey

A dough blanket wrapped around your choice of filling including cheddar and mozzarella and baked till golden brown. A smaller version of any above whaleboat for $1.00 less
- The Cabin Girl $8.50
  
  Sarah's original classic, spinach, tomato, red onion, mushrooms, sprouts, sour cream, mozzarella & cheddar cheese wrapped in a dough blanket & baked till golden brown
- The Yard Arm $8.00
  
  Sarah's original classic w/ a natural casing frank, bacon, cheddar & mozzarella wrapped in a dough blanket & baked till golden brown

Sarah's Famous Fresh Dough Pizza

Topped w/ our pizza, barbecue or garlic sauce, a blend of cheeses and your choice of toppings on a white, wheat or 10"gluten free crust $2.00. Toppings: red onions, black olives, tomatoes, peppers, mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, pineapple, jalapenos, garlic, sprouts 9" $1.00, 12" $1.50, 15" $2.00. Add cheese 9" $1.50, 12" $3.00, 15" $4.00.

Sarah's Roll Ups

12" White or wheat tortilla served w/ chips and pickle
- Chicken Caesar $8.50
  
  Romaine lettuce, roasted chicken, shredded parmesan, cheddar cheese, caesar dressing
- Roasted Lemon Pepper Chicken Salad $8.25
  
  Tomatoes, lettuce & cheddar cheese. Add bacon for $1.50
- BLT w/ Cheddar $8.35
- Veggie $8.50
  
  With spinach, tomato, peppers, red onion, sprouts, mushrooms & cheddar
- Choice of Ham or Roast Turkey Deluxe $9.00
  
  With bacon, tomatoes, red onion, lettuce & cheddar
- Steak Loaded $9.00
  
  Thinly sliced prime steak with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheddar

Sarah's Fresh Catch
- Haddock Melt $11.00
  
  Baked in a lemon parsley butter on a bulky bun served hot w/ cheddar w/ sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, lemon, chips and pickle
- Haddock Matey $11.00
  
  Baked in a lemon parsley butter, wrapped w/ mozzarella & cheddar, spinach & tomato in a fresh dough blanket. Baked till golden brown & served w/ homemade tartar sauce, lemon
- Baked Haddock $13.00
  
  Filet on sliced tomatoes, topped w/ Swiss and baked casserole style. Served w/ a mixed green salad, tartar sauce & lemon
- Haddock Wrap $15.50
  
  A 12" flour tortilla wrapped around fresh lemon baked haddock, spinach, tomato & cheddar cheese. Baked till golden brown & served w/ Sarah's salsa, sour cream, guacamole & lemon
- Crab Cake Burger $13.50
  
  Two grilled crab cakes topped w/ swiss cheese on a grilled bun w/ sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle & lemon
- Haddock Crab Deluxe $14.00
  
  Fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter, topped w/ a grilled crab cake & cheddar cheese on a grilled bun .Served w/ sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle & lemon
- Parmesan Haddock $12.00
  
  Fresh haddock oven fried in a parmesan breading on your choice of bun. Served w/ sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle & lemon
- Haddock Club $12.50
  
  Fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter topped with bacon , Swiss, lettuce and tomato on a grilled bun with sides of homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle and lemon
- Pesto Haddock $12.50
  
  Fresh haddock baked in a lemon butter topped with pesto sauce and swiss cheese on a grilled bun with sides of lettuce, tomato, homemade tartar sauce, chips, pickle and lemon

Sarah's Fresh Oven Baked Sandwiches

Served with chips and pickle on your choice of bun, french bread or sliced bread gluten free $2.00. Served grilled unless specified
- Roasted Lemon Pepper Chicken Salad $8.25
  
  With lettuce & tomato
- Steak $9.00
  
  Thinly sliced steak, mushrooms, sauteed onions, mozzarella & cheddar cheese
- Reuben, Slow Cooked Corned Beef $9.00
  
  Thinly sliced, sauerkraut, thousand island, mozzarella and Swiss
- Ham $8.25
  
  Cheddar & mozzarella cheese
- 1/2 Sandwich w/ Cup of Soup $8.25
  
  Sliced bread or french bread
- Turkey $8.95
  
  Peppers, tomatoes, sauteed onion, bacon, lettuce, mozzarella & cheddar cheese
- Grilled American Cheese $7.50
  
  With tomatoes on sliced bread
- BLT $8.35
  
  No cheese can substitute spinach instead of lettuce
- Greek $9.00
  
  With spinach, red onion, peppers, tomatoes, Greek olives, pepperoncini, mozzarella and Feta
- Veggie $8.50
  
  Spinach, tomatoes, red onion, mushrooms, peppers, sprouts mozzarella & cheddar cheese
- Steak Loaded Steak Sub $9.50
  
  Thinly sliced steak w/ grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms & Swiss

Sarah's Farmhouse Specials
- Steamed Mussels $14.00
  
  With tomato, wine and garlic served crusty bread
- Oven Fried Parmesan Crusted Haddock $14.00
- Seafood Trio Haddock $24.00
  
  Baked in a lemon butter with 4 lobster claws and topped with a grilled crab cake

Specialty Pizzas

6oz. Sirloin Burgers

Served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and chips. Swiss, blue cheese, cheddar, bacon, feta, pesto, American cheese, guacamole or goat cheese $1.50 ea. grilled onions, mushrooms, red onions, pineapple jalapenos, peppers or tomato $0.50. Choice of fresh baked buns gluten free buns additional charge: $2.00
- Turkey Burger $8.25
- Veggie Burger $8.25

Main Menu
- Sarah's Maine Lobster
- The Lobster Roll
  
  White or wheat of the day our famous grilled roll stuffed w/ maine lobster meat gently tossed with fine diced celery, mayo, salt and pepper and a bit of lettuce served with chips and pickle. Plain lobster meat and drawn butter $2.50 additional
- Fresh Mixed Garden or Spinach
  
  Salad topped w/ lobster salad served with garlic bread
- Lobster Wrap or Quesadilla
  
  A 12" flour tortilla filled w/ fresh lobster meat, spinach, tomato & cheddar, baked till golden brown & served w/ Sarah's salsa, sour cream, guacamole
- Lobster Grilled Cheese
  
  On sliced bread with tomatoes, maine lobster meat and swiss cheese w/ sides of chips & pickle
- Lobster Salad Club
  
  Lettuce, tomato, bacon, cheddar and lobster salad on your choice of a grilled bun or sliced bread w/ sides of chips & pickle
- Lobster Trap
  
  Maine lobster meat, spinach, tomato, cheddar & mozzarella cooked calzone style

Sarah's Sides
- Potato Salad $1.95
- Coleslaw $1.95
- Mashed Potatoes and Gravy $2.95
- Oven Fries $2.95
- Macaroni and Cheese $2.95
- Demi Salad Homemade Applesauce $2.95
- Butternut Squash $2.95
- Cup of Soup $3.99

Beverages
- Pepsi $2.20
- Diet Pepsi $2.20
- Sierra Mist $2.20
- Mug $2.20
- Mountain Dew $2.20
- Ginger Ale $2.20
- Sarah Pomegranate $4.00
- Sarah Lemonade $4.00
- Blueberry Lemonade $4.00
- Bottled Water $1.95
- Carbonated Poland Spring Water $1.95
- Capt. Eli's Root Beer $2.95
- Blueberry Soda $2.95
- Ginger Beer $2.95
- Medium Milk $2.00
- Large Milk $2.75
- Chocolate Milk (Md) $2.50
- Chocolate Milk (Lg) $3.00
- Hot Chocolate with Real Whipped Cream $2.25
- Fresh Coffee Columbian $1.75
- Decaffeinated $1.75
- Iced Coffee $2.00
- Tea $1.75
- Sarah's Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $2.20
- Orange (Md) $2.00
- Orange (Lg) $3.00
- Cranberry (Lg) $3.00
- Cranberry (Md) $2.00
- Apple (Md) $2.00
- Apple (Lg) $3.00
- Blueberry (Lg) $3.00
- Blueberry (Md) $2.00

Menu for Sarah's Cafe provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.