Butterfingers
(219) 836-4202

We make ordering easy.

Salads
- Red Bliss Potato Salad $6.50
- Fresh Fruit Salad $7.25
- Ham Salad $7.95
- Tuna Salad $8.75
- Macaroni Salad $6.25
- Spinach Pasta $6.50
- Seafood Pasta $8.75
- Chicken Almond $9.25
- Oriental Chicken $7.95
- Pasta Primavera $6.95
- Garden Vegetable $6.95
- Chicken Pasta $7.95
- New Potato $6.50
- Turkey, Cheese with Red Grapes $8.25
- Tomato, Cucumber, and Red Onion $6.25
- Sesame Bow Ties with Chicken $7.95
- Bow Ties $7.95
  
  With asparagus and sun-dried tomatoes.
- Napa Cabbage Slaw $6.25
- Broccoli Cranberry $6.50
- Pasta Shells $6.95
  
  With mozzarella and basil.
- Greek Salad $7.95
- Cucumber Dill $6.25
- Cranberry Orange Couscous $7.95
- Orzo with Lemon and Feta $7.95

Entrees
- Chicken Breast $8.25
  
  With sour cream and breadcrumbs.
- Stuffed Red Peppers $7.25
- Honey Baked Chicken Breast $8.25
- Spinach Ravioli $8.25
- Pork Tenderloin $9.50
  
  With apricot mustard.
- Vegetable Lasagna $8.25
- BBQ Beef $8.95
- Penne Pasta $6.75
  
  With meatballs.
- Italian Sausage $8.25
  
  With roasted vegetables.

Garden Salads
- Green Salad $3.95
  
  Meat, cheese, and toppings can be chosen from the sandwich.

Sandwiches
- Mini Croissant $3.95
- Bread $3.95
- Pretzel Bun $3.95
- Large Croissant $5.95
- Large Bread $5.95
- Large Wrap $5.95
- Large Pretzel Bun $5.95
- Tomato Basil, Garlic Pesto, and Honey Wheat $5.95

Box and Bag Lunches
- Large Sandwich $11.95
  
  Side of pasta, side of fruit, 2 cookies or 1 brownie. Box lunch
- Large Wrap $11.95
  
  Side of pasta, side of fruit, 2 cookies or 1 brownie. Box lunch

Breads and Croissants
- Butter Croissants $0.69
- Bread Loaves Include $2.85
  
  Vienna, cracked wheat, rye, dill, and seven-grain.
- Filled Croissants $2.50
  
  Almond, chocolate, maple pecan, vanilla hazelnut, cream cheese, strawberry and blueberry cream cheese.

Quiche
- Quiche $3.35
  
  Types Lorraine, broccoli and cheddar, spinach and feta, bacon, ham and cheddar, vegetable, broccoli red pepper.

Sweet Trays
- Brownie Bar Trays $30.00
  
  12 inches 48 pieces, 16 inches 96 pieces.
- Cookie Trays $33.00
  
  12 inches 4 dozen cookies, 16 inches 6 dozen cookies
- Cookie and Brownie Trays $34.00
  
  12 inches 3 dozen cookies and 4 brownies cut in quarters, 16 inches 4 dozen cookies and 10 brownies cut in quarters.
- Chocolate Dipped Strawberries $38.50

Cakes
- Carrot Cake $22.50
- Apple Bavarian Cake $22.50
- German Chocolate $21.50
- Double Chocolate Mousse Cake $24.50
- Sour Cream Fudge Cake $21.50
- Strawberry Cream Cake $21.95
- Lemon Raspberry Cake $22.50
- Raspberry Pound Cake $18.95
- Amaretto Pound Cake $18.95
- Devils Food Chocolate Chip Cake $18.95
- Raspberry Fudge Cake $31.95
- Banana Cake $22.50
- Hazelnut Buttercream Cake $21.95
- Red Velvet Cake $19.95
- Cherry White Chocolate Mousse Cake $22.50
- Vanilla Layer Cake with Coconut $22.50
- Raspberry White Chocolate Cake $22.50

Cheesecakes
- Sour Cream Cheesecake $24.95
- Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake $24.95
- Marble Cheesecake $24.50

Celebration Cakes
- Carrot Cake $36.00
- German Chocolate $38.00
- Raspberry Fudge $52.00
- Banana $36.00
- Red Velvet $34.00
- Vanilla Layer $23.50
- Butterfingers Sheet Cake $50.00

Brownies and Bars
- Fudge Walnut $2.50
- Double Fudge $2.50
- Cream Cheese $2.50
- Souffle $2.50
- Iced Truffle $2.50
- Blueberry Cream Cheese Bars $2.50
- Raspberry Cream Cheese Bars $2.50
- Strawberry Cream Cheese Bars $2.50
- Cashew Butterscotch $2.50
- Chocolate Hazelnut $2.50

Cookies
- Chocolate Chip $0.65
- M&M Chocolate Chip $0.65
- Oatmeal Raisin $0.65
- Peanut Butter Chunk $0.65
- Double Chocolate $0.65
- Dried Cranberry White Chocolate Chip $0.65
- Oatmeal Butterscotch $0.65
- Cashew Vanilla Chip $0.65
- Cashew Milk Chocolate Chip $0.65
- Peanut Butter $0.65
- Mint Cocoa Crispy $0.65

Small Desserts
- Cupcakes $3.50
  
  Banana, coconut, cherry, chocolate cream-filled, vanilla, lemon, red velvet, caramel, strawberry, blueberry, confetti.
- Mini Cupcakes $2.50

Menu for Butterfingers provided by Allmenus.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes. Check with this restaurant for current pricing and menu information. A listing on Allmenus.com does not necessarily reflect our affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of Allmenus.com. Please tell us by clicking here if you know that any of the information shown is incorrect. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

What is Grubhub

Why use Grubhub

Butterfingers