• Indiana
  • Fishers
  • Nancy Pizza

Nancy Pizza

(317) 594-6400
  • 8938 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037
  • Own this business? Learn more about offering online ordering to your diners.

  • American ,  Pizza
(317) 594-6400
  • Menu
  • Appetizers
    all appetizers are baked not fried
    • Garlic Bread $0

    • Tomato Bread $0

    • Pizza Bread $0

    • Italian Bread Sticks $0

    • Spicy Potato Wedges $0

    • Mozzarella Sticks $0

    • Jalapeno Peppers $0

    • Onion Rings $0

    • Zucchini $0

    • Appetizer Sampler $0

    • Focaccia $0

    • BBQ and Spicy Chicken Wings $0

  • Sandwiches
    • Roasted Italian Beef Sandwich $0

    • Italian Meatball Sandwich $0

    • Italian Sausage Sandwich $0

    • 'Godfather' Sandwich $0

      roasted Italian beef and melted mozzarella served on our homemade garlic bread

    • 'Godmother' Sandwich. $0

      oven baked breaded chicken breast with red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese served on our homemade garlic breaded

    • Sorrento Sandwich $0

      roasted Italian beef topped with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, melted mozzarella cheese and creamy garlic sauce

    • Chicken Club $0

      oven baked breaded chicken breast, bacon, melted mozzarella cheese lettuce, tomato and creamy garlic sauce served on our

  • Salads
    • Small Garden Salad $0

    • Large Garden Salad $0

    • Large Garbage Salad $0

      lettuce mixed with pepperoni, cunadian bacon, cheese, black olives, green olives and a variety of fresh vegetables (add skinless cuhed chicken breast to all three)

  • Dinners
    • Nancy's Fettuccine Alfredo $0

      first place winner of the Chicago fribune pasta challenge, a creamy mixture of parmesan cheese, fresh cream and butter

    • Chicken Tetrazzini $0

      breast of chicken, spaghetti and fresh mushrooms sauce in a rich cream sauce, with mozzarella cheese

    • Baked Mostaeeioli $0

      our homemade marinara sauce combined with mostaccioli covered with mozzarella cheese

    • Naney's Homemade Ravioli $0

      large homemade ligg noodles stuffed with your choice of meat cheese, or mix and match and six, topped with our homemade marinara sauce

    • Mostaccioli or Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce Chicken or Zucchini Parmesan $0

      lightly breaded oven baked chicken breast or zucchini on a bed of mostaccioli or spaghetti, topped with our home-made marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese

    • Lasagna of Milan $0

      layers of egg noodles stuffed with four cheese, baked in our homemade marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese

    • Lasagna of Florence $0

      layers of egg noodles stuffed with four cheeses, baked with Spinach in fresh cream, tomatoes and mozzarella cheese

  • Thin Crust Pizza
    your choice of ingredients in the following sizes
    • Your Choice of Ingredients in the Following Sizes $0

      small 10' serves 1-2, medium 12' serves 2-3, large 14' serves 3-4, x-large 16' serves 4-5, family size 18' serves 5-6

  • Naney's Thin Signature Pizzas
    available in all sizes
    • Summer Garden Pizza $0

      roasted garlic, fresh basil and tomato

    • Vegitini $0

      broccoli, roasted garlic, mushroom and tomato

    • Unele Tony Special Pizza $0

      sausage, pepperoni, green pepper and onions

    • A Lot a Meat Pizza $0

      Sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni and bacon

    • BBQ Chicken Pizza $0

      BBQ sauce, chicken breast, onions and fesh bacon

    • Nancy's Original Buffalo Wing Pizza $0

      chicken breast marinated in a zesty buffalo wing sauce topped with cheese and fresh celery served with side of blue cheese dressing

    • Hawaiian Pizza $0

      BBQ sauce, Canadian bacon and pineapple

    • Rocco's Party Pizza $0

      sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and onions

    • Nancy's Taco Pizza $0

      nancy's original salsa sauce topped with topped with chopped meatball and cheese served with lettuce, tomato and dorico chips, served with a side of sour cream and salsa

  • Nancy's Take and Bake Pizzas
    • Nancy's Take and Bake Pizzas $0

      we make it, you bake it, available in medium 13' and x-large 17

  • Stuffed Pizza
    • Stuffed Pizza $0

      small 4-slices serves 2-3, medium 6-slices serves 3-4, large 8-slices serves 4-5

  • Nancy's Stuffed Signature Pizzas
    available in small, medium, large
    • Chicken Caeeiatore Pizza $0

      chicken breast, mushrooms, green peppers and onions

    • Rocco's Party Pizza $0

      sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and onions

    • Zia Melina $0

      chicken, basil and broccoli

    • A Lot a Meat Stuffed Pizza $0

      sausage Canadian bacon, pepperoni and bacon

    • Nana's Special $0

      spinach and mushroom

    • Uncle Carl's Favorite $0

      pepperoni and 1 lot giardiniera

  • Selection of Pizza Ingredients
    • Italian Sausage $0

    • Fresh Mushrooms $0

    • Chopped Meatball $0

    • Fresh Green $0

    • Peppers $0

    • Canadian Bacon $0

    • Fresh Onions $0

    • Fresh Bacon $0

    • Roasted Garlic $0

    • Pepperoni $0

    • Black Olives $0

    • Chicken $0

      chicken counts as 2 ingredients

    • Green Olives $0

    • Broccoli $0

    • Sliced Tomatoes $0

    • Fresh Basil $0

    • Spinach $0

    • Pineapple $0

    • Hot Giardinera $0

    • Roast Beef $0

    • Imported Anchovies $0

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.