• Illinois
  • Chicago
  • Replay Andersonville

Replay Andersonville

(773) 654-1369
  • 5358 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60640
  • Grubhub.com
  • Menu
  • Specials & Seasonal Offerings
    Specials & other seasonal items!
    • Chicken and Sausage Gumbo $14.24

      Andouille sausage, chicken, red & green bell peppers, carrots, okra, rice, side of toasted sourdough bread

    • Roll of Toilet Paper $0.95

      1 roll of 2 PLY toilet paper!!

    • Smoked Chicken Thighs Dinner for Two $30

      Boneless smoked Chicken Thighs Hen of the wood mushrooms, bok choy, mustard gremolata, crispy potatoes. Choice of Caeser or Mixed Green Dinner Salad

    • Meatloaf Dinner (feeds 4) $40

      Hickory smoked meatloaf, homemade mashed potatoes, bourbon gravy. Choice of dinner salad for 4 people

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich $13.95

      Slow-cooked pulled pork, with tangy BBQ sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of side!

    • Family Pulled Pork Meal $40

      Slow-cooked pulled pork, 4 homemade biscuits, Coleslaw, and Fries or Tater Tots (feeds 4)

    • Easter Ham Dinner $20

      Sliced Ham, Roasted Potatoes, Asparagus

    • Easter Lamb Dinner $20

      Rack of lamb, chimichurri sauce, roasted potatoes

    • Replay Cobb Salad $13.95

      Romaine, Green Onions, Avocado, Tomato, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Hard Boiled Egg, Chicken. Served with Ranch Dressing.

    • Beef Tip Special $16

      10oz beef tip with garlic mash potatoes, sautéed spinach and garlic demi glace

    • Thanksgiving Dinner $28

      Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner - options for salad, main course and dessert. Served with Butternut Squash Soup

    • Thanksgiving Dinner for Two $50

      A traditional Thanksgiving dinner for two people!

    • Tomato Bisque $10

      Bowl of creamy tomato bisque topped with EVO and crispy basil. Served with a half grilled cheese sandwich

    • Beef Chili $10

      Bowl of our traditional beef chili with beans, corn and peppers topped with sour cream, green onions, and cheddar. Served with side of corn tortilla chips.

    • King's Cake Bread Pudding $14.24

      Challah bread, dulce de leche, sprinkles, vanilla ice cream. Available now through Feb 17th

  • Shareables
    • Wisconsin Cheese Curds $15.54

      Battered, fried and garnished with pickled red onion, and served with ranch dipping sauce.

    • Fried Dill Pickles $15.54

      Panko breaded fried pickle chips, chipotle buttermilk ranch dressing.

    • Crispy Cauliflower $15.54

      Deep fried, rice-flour coated cauliflower, spicy curry, and pickle salad.

    • Game-Time Nachos $19.44

      Pepper jack cheese, guacamole, roasted tomato salsa, pico de gallo, pickled peppers and sour cream. Substitute tater tots at no charge, add protein for an additional charge.

    • Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls $18.14

      3 crispy egg rolls filled with smoked chicken, blue cheese and Buffalo sauce. Served with blue cheese or buttermilk ranch.

    • Replay Chicken Wings $19.44

      8 pieces. Tossed in Buffalo, BBQ, or our signature hot honey mustard sauce. Served with celery sticks and your choice of buttermilk ranch dressing or blue cheese dressing.

    • Chicken Tenders $19.44

      Choose a sauce: ranch, BBQ, Buffalo sauce, hot honey mustard, bourbon BBQ, or garlic aioli.

    • Pan Seared Brussels Sprouts $15.54

      Sofrito aioli, balsamic reduction, Parmesan cheese.

    • Toasted Chickpea Hummus $8.95

      Roasted poblano, chickpea and caper chutney with grilled pita bread, fresh jicama and celery.

    • Curried Deviled Eggs $6.95

    • Chipotle Spinach, Kale and Feta Cheese Empanadas $8.95

      Homemade.

    • Beef and Chihuahua Cheese Empanadas $8.95

      Homemade.

    • Crispy Pork Belly $10.95

      Spicy Asian glaze, topped with pineapple and Poblano relish.

    • Heirloom Tomato Gazpacho $5.95

      Summer blend garnished with sweet watermelon, mint herb oil and heirloom cherry tomatoes.

    • BBQ Brisket Sliders $10.95

      Slow cooked and smoked. Tossed in bourbon BBQ sauce and topped with coleslaw.

    • Andersonville Swedish Meatballs $7.95

      Traditional Swedish style pork and beef meatballs.

    • Today's Seasonal Soup $4.5

      Please contact restaurant for today's selection.

    • Italian Meatballs $8.95

      Pork and beef meatballs served with spicy marinara sauce, topped with Parmesan cheese.

    • Spinach and Artichoke Dip $9.95

      Served with lightly fried pita chips.

    • Roasted Red Pepper Hummus $9.95

      Served with celery and grilled pita bread

    • Duck Empanadas $8.95

      Duck, guajillo chili, chihuahua cheeseê

    • Baked Mac and Cheese $22.04

      Andersonville's best mac and cheese! Cavatappi noodles with smoked gouda, fontina cheese, and smoked applewood bacon; baked au gratin with panko crumbles.

    • BBQ Blitz Flatbread $19.44

      Bourbon BBQ, chicken, mozzarella, pickled red onions

  • Wraps and Salads
    Add protein for an additional charge.
    • Apple and Cranberry Salad $18.13

      Fresh spring mix, honey crisp apple, dried cranberries, blue cheese crumbles and candied walnuts tossed in honey-yuzu vinaigrette.

    • ** Seasonal Harvest Glow Salad $19.44

      Roasted sweet potato and cauliflower mixed with crunchy candied walnuts, quinoa and mixed greens tossed in a spicy honey vinaigrette

    • Chicken Pesto Wrap $23.33

      Grilled chicken breast, baby spinach, fresh Parmesan cheese, homemade pesto. Served with choice of side.

    • Buffalo $23.33

      Romaine, celery, carrots, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, buttermilk ranch or blue cheese, choice of protein tossed in buffalo sauce (+2.6 for steak)

    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $23.33

      Grilled chicken breast tossed in Buffalo sauce with your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing, lettuce and tomato. Served with choice of side.

    • Cobb $18.13

      Romaine, green onions, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, blue cheese, buttermilk ranch

    • Replay Cobb Wrap $18.13

      Vegetarian cobb with romaine, green onions, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, bleu cheese, ranch dressing. Served with choice of side.

    • Kohlrabi and Fennel Appetizer Salad $5.5

      Ginger maple dressing with mixed greens, Honeycrisp apple and candied walnuts.

    • Kohlrabi and Fennel Entree Salad $11.95

      Ginger maple dressing with mixed greens, Honeycrisp apple and candied walnuts.

    • Lime-Grilled Shrimp Salad $13.95

      Romaine, arugula, avocado, cilantro, pickled peppers, jicama, queso fresco, tortilla chips and citrus vinaigrette.

    • Beet Salad

      Spring mix, baby arugula, roasted beets, green beans, shiitake mushrooms, tomato, toasted almonds and shaved avalon cheese tossed with shallot vinegar.

    • Caesar $18.13

      Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, brioche croutons, homemade Caesar dressing.

    • Caesar Wrap $18.13

      Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, brioche croutons, homemade Caesar dressing. Served with choice of side.

    • Santa Fe $18.13

      Romaine lettuce, fresh corn, black beans, queso fresco, tortilla strips and tomato with a spicy peanut cilantro vinaigrette.

    • Small Mixed Green Salad $5.95

      Cherry tomato, cucumber, mixed greens and balsamic vinaigrette.

    • Bourbon BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad $13.95

      Avocado, tomato, grilled corn, black beans, cucumber and romaine lettuce tossed with bourbon BBQ ranch dressing and topped with crispy onion strings.

    • Fennel and Daikon Radish Salad

      Baby arugula, shaved fennel, daikon radish, candied pecans, tomatoes, red onions and pomegranate seeds tossed with pomegranate dressing.

    • Shrimp Salad $13.95

      Romaine, arugula, avocado, cilantro, pickled peppers, jicama, queso fresco, tortilla chips, tossed in a citrus vinaigrette and topped with grilled shrimp.

    • Bok Choy Salad $12.95

      Bok Choy leaves, Brussels Sprouts, Arugula, Candied Pistachios, Lemon Vinaigrette

    • Replay Farmer's Salad $13.95

      Farm Greens, Watermelon, Grapes, Tomatoes, Pepitas, Almonds, Dried Goji Berries, Feta Cheese, Sherry Vinaigrette, Pomegranate Gastrique

    • Santa Fe Wrap $18.13

      Romaine lettuce, fresh corn, black beans, queso fresco, tortilla strips and tomato with a spicy peanut cilantro vinaigrette. Served with choice of side.

    • Strawberry Fields Salad $18.13

      Quinoa, spinach, strawberries, candied walnuts, cherry tomato, pickled red onion, goat cheese crumbles, balsamic vinaigrette

    • Seasonal Apple Cranberry Salad $19.44

      Mixed greens, honey crisp apples, dried cranberries, pickled red onions, candied walnuts and bleu cheese, tossed in a honey-yuzu vinaigrette

    • Mediterranean $13.95

      Romaine, house-made pesto, chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, red onion, olives, feta

  • Tacos and Quesadillas
    Add a side of guacamole for an additional charge.
    • Birria Beef Quesatacos $20.74

      Slow-cooked savory Mexican-style beef tacos with Chihuahua cheese crust, pickled red onions, and cilantro with a side of consume and lime.

    • Birria Beef Quesadilla $20.74

      Slow-cooked savory Mexican-style beef with Chihuahua cheese and salsa verde.

    • Chicken Quesadilla $22.04

      Grilled chicken, poblano peppers, and pepper jack cheese. Served with roasted salsa and sour cream.

    • Kickin' Shrimp Tacos $20.74

      Romaine, house-made pesto, chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, red onion, olives, feta

    • Cauli-Crunch Tacos $20.74

      Romaine, house-made pesto, chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, red onion, olives, feta

  • Burgers
    Burgers include your choice of hand-cut fries or tater tots. Add-ons and substitutions are available for an additional charge.
    • ** Seasonal Bonfire Burger $23.34

      8oz beef patty with candied sweet potato rings, melted smoked gouda, marshmallow fluff, arugula, and pickled red onion on a buttery bun

    • Build-A-Burger $19.43

      8 oz. patty topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles and served on a fresh buttery bun.

    • Jalapeno Bacon Burger $23.34

      8 oz patty, queso fresco, bacon, arugula, tomato, jalapeño, pickled red onion, pretzel bun

    • NEW Figgy Wonderland Burger $23.34

      8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty, Brie cheese, caramelized onions, arugula and fig jam on a buttery bun.

    • Double Smash Burger $24.64

      Two quarter-pound patties, applewood-smoked bacon, American cheese, caramelized onions, tomato, arugula, fried pickles, brioche bun

    • Bourbon Burger $23.34

      8 oz patty, blue cheese, bourbon BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, pretzel bun

    • Hawaiian Burger $15.95

      8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty, applewood smoked ham, provolone cheese, caramelized onions and our house made grilled pineapple relish on a pretzel bun

    • Impossible Burger Deluxe $24.64

      Impossible™ patty, smoked tomato aioli, avocado, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, brioche bun

    • NEW Berry-licious Burger $23.34

      8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty on a buttery bun with strawberry jam, baby arugula, ricotta cheese

    • Seasonal Figgy Wonderland Burger $23.34

      8 oz beef patty, melted brie cheese, caramelized onions, arugula and fig spread on a buttery bun

  • Sandwiches
    Include your choice of hand-cut fries or tater tots.
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $22.04

      Grilled marinated chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles, fresh buttery bun.

    • Chicken Sandwich $20.74

      Chicken (grilled, blackened, or crispy), chipotle buttermilk ranch, arugula, tomato, pickles, brioche bun

    • Cubano $23.34

      Braised pork shoulder, smoked ham, applewood-smoked bacon, Monterey Jack, pickles, mustard aioli, pickled peppers, griddled telera bread

    • Steak Sandwich $26.64

      Flat iron steak, arugula, grilled onion, pesto, garlic aioli, French baguette

    • Reuben $23.34

      House-braised corned beef, Swiss, caraway sauerkraut, Russian dressing, grilled rye

    • BLT $18.14

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli, toasted white bread

    • Roasted Mushroom Sandwich $13.95

      Roasted hen of the woods and oyster mushrooms, pickled onions, mixed lettuce greens, truffle aioli with shallots and garlic on French bread

    • Replay Banh Mi Sandwich $14.95

      Grilled shrimp, smoked meatloaf, crunchy vegetable slaw, lime dressing basil and mint

  • Sides
    • Hand-Cut French Fries $7.74

    • Tater Tots $7.74

    • Fresh Fruit Salad $3.95

    • Homemade Mashed Potatoes with Bourbon Gravy $2.95

    • Brussel Sprouts - side $7.74

    • Sweet Potato Fries $7.74

    • Side Mixed Green Salad $7.74

      Mixed green salad with tomatoes and cucumber. Comes with side of balsamic dressing

    • Mashed Potatoes $3.95

      Homemade garlic mashed potatoes with bourbon gravy

    • Extra Sauce

    • Side of Guacamole $4.55

    • Side of Tortilla Chips $5.14

    • Side of Avocado $4.55

    • Chips and Salsa $7

      Crunchy tortilla chips with side of house roasted tomato salsa

  • House-Made Desserts
    Come with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream.
    • Seasonal - Very Berry Bread Pudding $14.24

      House-made apple bread pudding made with Challah bread, Served with berry compote, bourbon caramel, candied walnuts, and vanilla ice cream

    • Seasonal Figgy Bread Pudding $14.24

      Challah bread, fig spread, dried figs, drizzled with orange-fig syrup, topped with vanilla ice cream and candied walnuts

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet $15.54

      30 minutes bake time. Chocolate chip cookie baked in cast iron skillet, topped with vanilla ice cream and bourbon caramel.

    • Brownie Sundae $14.24

      Warm brownie with Ghirardelli chocolate chips, served with chocolate sauce, vanilla ice cream and whipped cream

    • Vanilla Ice Cream $6.5

      3 scoops of vanilla ice cream

    • ** Seasonal Pumpkin Bread Pudding $14.24

      Challah bread with pumpkin and spice topped with ice cream, candied walnuts and a Bourbon syrup

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Restaurant Center
  • Contact Us
  • Chain Restaurants
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • CA Privacy Notice
©2021 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.